Member Reviews

I did not enjoy this one as much. The fact that the stories are a lot longer kinda erases the punches the previous stories had and sometimes makes it feel a bit dragged (one could argue it's good horror skills to work dread throughout, but it's just not my favorite kind of horror).
At that point in my reading journey of Orochi, reading the last two stories, I'm well acquainted with the style, characters and themes, so I guess it would take a bit more to impress me, since the initial charm (which I adored) has come and gone a little bit.
Overall this selection of stories just wasn't for me. The themes about revenge and war are just not what I usually like. If I wasn't reading the whole trilogy and had fallen just on this book alone I probably wouldn't have read just because I would know right away that this is not the kind of story I usually connect with.
Anyway, I'm glad I read it, I know that these stories, originally written in the 50's, have been pillars and foundation to the horror manga genres, so I'm glad to have added them to my general culture. I can definitely see their influence in the work of other mangakas.

Was this review helpful?

Good gravy. This series started out well - the first volume was pretty good, if a bit confusing, but it started to lose its mojo in the second volume, and then this happened. The first story, "Stage", was a convoluted long game revenge story that was full of stuff that made no sense and convenient plot devices. It annoyed me so much! "Combat," the second story, was better, but harsh and gut-punching; it recalls the Battle of Guadalcanal during WWII, and while I believe the story in the book is fictional, I'm sure it had real-life inspiration. This story has some disturbing stuff in it, and I recommend caution to sensitive readers.
This is not one I'd recommend to someone just looking for something to read, this one feels more like a book to complete a fan's collection.

#OrochiThePerfectEditionVol3 #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Orochi Perfect Edition Volume Three sees Orochi observing what happens to two different young men.

Orochi Perfect Edition Volume Three
Written by: Kazuo Umezz
Publisher: Shogakukan
English Publisher: VIZ Media
Release Date: November 15, 2022

This volume contains two stories, with the first one being 130 pages and the second story running for 223 pages. While this may seem to be rather long page counts, the stories that are presented needed to run for these longer lengths in order for Umezz to tell them effectively.

The first story, “Stage,” sees Orochi coming upon a traffic accident. A three-year-old boy named Yuichi wanders out of his house in order to see his father after he gets off work. As Yuichi is crossing the street at a green light, a car suddenly races through, and Yuichi’s father jumps in the way and is hit by the car. While Yuichi’s father is able to get up and walk away, his head later hurts, but he doesn’t go to see a doctor. Yuichi’s father dies overnight, and Yuichi says the driver of the car was “The Morning Man,” a host on a children’s television program that he watches.

The reader gets to see through Orochi’s eyes as Yuichi is taken to the trial of Shingo Tanabe, the man in question. Unfortunately, due to his age, Yuichi’s testimony isn’t taken seriously and Shingo is found not guilty since Yuichi was the only eyewitness to the accident.

We see Yuichi isn’t able to let go of this situation, and as he grows up, he becomes short-tempered and gloomy. After actively avoiding entertainment for several years, Yuichi suddenly starts demanding a transistor radio, a record player, and records. After he acquires these things, he becomes a fan of a singer named Hideji Hanada. By the end of middle school, Yuichi decides he wants to pursue a singing career and runs off to Tokyo to try to become a student of Hideji Hanada… and Yuichi ends up wreaking havoc in Hideji’s life.

For the most part during the story, Orochi is simply an observer. However, there was one point when Yuichi was as a child where she stepped in and stopped a group of boys from picking on him. But later in the story, Orochi is unable to intervene and stop what ultimately happens by the end.

While I did enjoy “Stage,” I admit that I figured out the basic idea of the twist of this story shortly after Yuichi becomes a fan of Hideji Hanada. However, I hadn’t figured out all the specifics of the twist. In that regard, I was slightly disappointed at figuring out the twist of the story that early on. At least the story itself was compelling enough that I found I still wanted to keep reading in order to find out how exactly Yuichi would pull off what I was suspecting he was up to.

“Combat” introduces a junior high school student named Tadashi Okabe, who admires his father for being so nice to everyone but questions why his father’s personality is the way it is. Orochi overhears an essay he wrote about his father being read out loud in class, and she develops an interest in Tadashi and his family. The essay grabbed her interest enough that she decides to starts observing the family.

One day, Tadashi is approached by a man that’s missing an arm and a leg, and the man asks Tadashi to deliver something to his father. Out of curiosity, Tadashi opens up the package and finds a human skull inside, which he refuses to give to his father. Another time, Tadashi’s little sister has something that she tries to keep hidden from Tadashi. But it turns out to be a grenade, which goes off as she trips. Fortunately, both Tadashi and his sister survive, and Tadashi realizes the man from earlier must have given his sister the grenade. When Tadashi has another encounter with the man, he learns something about his father from the time he served in the war, and Tadashi finds himself becoming conflicted.

We learn in this volume that Orochi has the ability to peek into people’s minds, and she uses this ability on Tadashi’s father while he’s sleeping. She gets to see his memories of serving in the war and figures out what Tadashi learned and why he’s feeling conflicted. After Tadashi ends up in a harrowing situation with his friends, Tadashi is blamed for it. Unfortunately, Tadashi’s father believes Tadashi is to blame for the incident, and this only adds to Tadashi’s issues with his father.

When we see Orochi going into Tadashi’s father’s memories, we actually get a significant sequence that shows the reader everything that happened to Tadashi’s father in the war that led him to become the man he is. It’s obvious from what’s being said and the depiction of the war that the war in question is World War II. Being an American, I always find it fascinating to see World War II being depicted in Japanese media. I’ve grown up seeing so much of the American media’s depiction of the war, so I appreciate seeing how the Japanese depict it. But in this depiction, Umezz makes it clear just how inhumane the Japanese could act on the battlefield after running out of food and starving.

My biggest issue with “Combat” is the fact that the character design for Tadashi looks way too similar to the design for the middle school aged Yuichi in “Stage.” I kept having to remind myself that I was seeing Tadashi, not Yuichi. Outside of that nitpick, though, I thought the story in “Combat” was interesting. I especially liked seeing the parallel between what Tadashi’s father went through during the war and what Tadashi experiences during his harrowing experience with his friends. Unfortunately, we don’t truly get a definitive ending for “Combat,” and there’s a major question about Tadashi’s father that’s left unanswered. I guess Umezz wanted to let the reader fill in the blanks with their own ideas for that question, as well as for how the story could conclude.

Even with the few issues I had with Orochi Perfect Edition Volume Three, I still enjoyed both the stories in the manga. And while both the stories included here ran on the longer side, they turned out to be quicker reads than I had anticipated.

If you read the previous two volumes of Orochi Perfect Edition and enjoyed then, I think you’ll also find an appreciation for the stories in Volume Three.

Was this review helpful?

Orochi plays the role of the observer only this time around, watching as two sons across two very different stories try to reconcile their feelings about their fathers. Of the two, the longer, "Combat," is the stronger. This isn't only because "Stage" is a truly convoluted revenge story, but more due to the fact that there's something intensely recognizable about the tale of Tadashi Okabe and his dad. The senior Okabe was a soldier in WWII, and he's irrevocably scarred by his experiences, trying as best he can to redeem himself from the boy he was at the time. Tadashi, learning about his father's actions as a child in the post-war period, can't even begin to imagine that the world wasn't always as black-and-white as it appears to him, and his father's inability to really talk about what he did only makes things worse. To say that I see my father's relationship with <i>his</i> father, who was also a soldier in WWII, would be disingenuous, and Umezz gets the dynamic so right that he must be writing from experience.

While these are both still clearly horror stories, they're less about supernatural horror and more about the horror we make for ourselves. War, revenge, and other uniquely human monstrosities are the villains of the piece, and it's when we fail to recognize what humanity is capable of that we create monsters to distract from who the real demons are.

Was this review helpful?

Kazuo Umezz continues to balance social commentary and retro pulp horror with Orochi. There are two longer stories in this volume, "Stage" and "Combat." Both stories focus on a the loss of a father- figure in a young boy's life. One, is literally, a very young boy watches his father get run over by a car. As he grows, a slow burn consumes him. The other, in contrast, is more of a broken pedestal story. A boy who idolizes what a good person his father is, is forced to come to grips with maybe that isn't the case. War is hell, after all.

Was this review helpful?

This installment of Orochi presents two short stories which center on sons and fathers. The first, "Stage", is a sort of bildungsroman following a young boy on his quest for vengeance after his father's murderer walks away without punishment due to his celebrity reputation. The second, "Combat," focuses on a young boy who can't understand why his father is so nice to strangers until he learns about his military past.

I found this a yet again compelling volume in the Orochi series, particularly as I've really enjoyed the family drama of previous chapters. "Combat" is the standout to me with its examination of cyclical trauma. This has been a thrilling series to follow and Umezz lives up to his reputation as a master of psychological horror.

Was this review helpful?

This manga, compiled of two short stories, was pretty good! I didn’t find them very scary or horror like, however.
Having never read the first two volumes i’m sure i don’t understand some of the interconnected parts, but i enjoyed it nonetheless!
4/5 stars :)

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this volume, but not as much as the others in the series. I thought the first story was a bit predictable and the second was very drawn out and ended without closer. Both stories still had the signature ominous vibes and amazing artwork. I would recommend it to those who like the series and I hope there will be more.

Was this review helpful?