What a lovely book.
This book is well written. The characters are well developed.
In places, it is a bit dense. It was a slow read

This book is a little hard to review. It is something any history buff would like, especially those who like the 1600s and how women were accused of witchcraft, not to mention how easily anyone could get accused of anything. I liked the concept of it all but was left sort of disappointed. On the one hand, it was really good yet on the other, not good at all. More like the last bit was mindless. This is hard to say without spoilers.

The story has every emotion there is. I had to stop reading every little bit because my heart was being ripped out thinking about this poor woman and how she was treated. Plus the other prisoners. Then what happened to them. It would've been horrifying to live in those days. The book is hard to hold your interest during most of it because it's a lot of the same thing over and over. Just someone else's miserable treatment and life all gloom and doom. And we have Goodcole come to minister to everyone and to get a conession from Sawyer. He is also writing a pamphlet about her. I didnt like his character at all. He was so miserable. He was in his profession for all the wrong reasons but maybe mainly because he was scared. Life didn't go the way he had wanted after all. But he learned a lot from Sawyer. He learned more about the true meaning of the Bible and faith than he ever taught anyone in church. This is not a religious preachy book. But in this setting of history church was a big part. Toward the end I came to like Goodcole's character more. The whole story was kind of dry and depressing.

What disappointed me was mainly the ending. I didn't expect unicorns and fairy dust but I also didn't expect the last few pages to take a turn onto the yellow brick road then just end like it did. I can see the message behind it but don't like how it got there. All this time and effort then just a lot of fluff with no real climax like there should've been. If I'd known that, I wouldn't have read it. It's like the author didnt even try. I give it 3 stars because the history part was really good. And I'm not even a big historical type reader. Sorry to rant.

Thank you to NetGalley and the author/publisher for my copy

It is a well written novel, with punchy dialogue that rings true, and the descriptive writing brings the scenes to life.

King James I of England (VI of Scotland) dismissed witchcraft ae trickery and yet he feared it so much thousands of women would be put to death. Not as well known as the Pendle Witch Trials, a decade earlier, this novel looks again at the life and death of Elizabeth Sawyer, the Witch of Edmonton.
This is a gripping story, authentic, believable and poignant. Newgate Prison and Tyburn are brought vividly to life; the sights, sounds and smells of 1621 permeate every page.
The author has the potential to become the next C.J. Sansom, Hilary Mantel or Andrew Taylor in the crowded field of historical fiction.

THE WONDERFUL DISCOVERY of ELIZABETH SAWYER by Jonathan Vischer

It’s 1621, prison chaplain, Henry Goodcole is assigned to meet with condemned Newgate prisoner Elizabeth Sawyer in order to get her final confession.

Elizabeth Sawyer’s story is a tragic one, but it is not surprising given the time and place in history. Being a woman back then (and even these days) is being in a constant battle with the views of the church and its members. One “wrong” move or word spoken out of turn and a woman is branded a whore or witch or deemed insane.

Overall, I really want to like this book because I’m all about witches and history, but it just didn’t hold my interest. I do wish this was told through Elizabeth’s perspective instead. For a debut novel, it is solid but it didn’t meet my expectations.


Rating: 3/5 ⭐️
Release Date: 09.27.22
#TheWonderfulDiscoveryofElizabethSawyer #JonathanVischer

ARC courtesy of @NetGalley & #TheBookGuild

This was an interesting and very well written story. I don’t want to give any spoilers but I’d recommend this to anyone who enjoys gothic style women’s fiction.

A true gem of a read. The Wonderful Discovery of Elizabeth Sawyer reminds us of the terrible fate that women have suffered at the hands of the church since the beginning of time. Seen as unclean, the bringers of sin, held in the clutch of satan-they are easy scapegoats for all of the ills of the world. The church (both catholic and Protestant) regularly subjected women to horrible punishments. Speaking out against injustice could brand you a witch. Be raped and be branded a whore. Become pregnant out of wedlock, you’re ruined. Be on the wrong side of the ruling church power of the day and you may find yourself burned alive. Wash your clothes wrong, anger a neighbor, have land someone in power wanted, lose a child to miscarriage, be present when someone dies-these are all things that have gotten women killed and accused of witchcraft.

What I took most from this book is that while we’ve made progress, we are only one pendulum swing from going backwards.

A story that is far too true in the history of women. Don’t skip this book.

Your typical story of a man not having empathy for a woman until he realizes his daughter...is also a woman... yeah.

I was going to give it 2 stars because the writing style is okay, but I just couldn't. This was not for me. I was SO BORED. I read a few reviews that the second half of the book picks up a bit, but I disagree. The last 15% was alright, although I did not like the ending either. I felt from the description that this had such promise! But for me, it fell short. 1 star.

Thank you to netgalley & the publisher for this free arc.

This was a quick read, easy to follow and very interesting. I did think that the book was about Elizabeth Sawyer but really it is about the chaplain. It's his version of the events. It's more focused on how he is feeling and what is going on around him.

It was a good book and it is very well researched and written. The imagery was there and it was like I could picture it all in my head. I enjoyed it very much and would read this author again.

I really wanted to like this story, as anything with witches in it normally has my heart, but unfortunately I just couldn't engage with it like I wanted to....

The story follows Henry Goodcole, chaplain of a prison, who has to listen to final confessions of prisoners in the hopes that they will beg forgiveness from God. He is due to do this for the imprisoned witch, Elizabeth Sawyer. She confesses to selling her soul to the Devil in order to save the soul of her unborn child and she is hung as punishment for her crimes.

I found the first half of this book to be difficult to digest. There was a lot less focus on witchcraft than I anticipated, and more focus on Goodcole's fear of God and his own battles with how he sees and understands Sawyer. The second half of the book was much more captivating for me, as a subplot is unearthed regarding young women being shipped off to other countries with the promise of a new life as a bride. The story requires attention and the vocabulary is demanding, definitely not literature for the faint hearted.

Overall, for a debut novel, this was definitely good. Personally, it just didn't align with my expectations regarding the storyline itself. However, I would be very interested to read any further works published by this author.

Thank you to NetGalley for a copy of this in exchange for honest review

Based on a true story I was drawn right in.There was much to think about the struggles of women during that time the superstitions .A short but interesting story.#netgalley #bookguild.

Henry Goodcole, cleric & ordinary of Newgate Prison visits convicted witch Elizabeth Sawyer held in ‘Limbo’ the depths of Newgate prison. She tells him 3 stories in his attempts to get her confession before her arranged hanging.
We also learn of the ships the London company are preparing to sail to Nova Britannia along with women promised a new & exciting life as brides.
Based on true events I found this a fascinating read.

I really wanted to like this book, and in parts I did, but as others have pointed out in their feedback, the use of he said, she said is very jarring after a while. It's a really interesting subject with so much potential, it's just hard to get past the first few chapters unfortunately. I'll pick it back up at a later date and hopefully be able to get into it then.

The book had a very interesting topic but I just could not get into the writing style at all. Constant use of the word he says etc really put me off my stride and I couldn't get into it as much as I should have, also the book didn't go in the direction I enjoyed, over all not for me.

I really wanted to like this book but could not engage with the story. I loved the idea but found the first section somewhat dull and repetitive. From then on I ended up skim reading and therefore felt unsatisfied. Not the fault of the writer, it just didn't click for me

*Many thanks to Jonathan Vischer, The Book Guild, and NetGalley for arc in exchange for my honest review.*
The novel revolves around a woman, Elizabeth Sawyer, who in 1621 is held in Newgate and who is believed to be a witch. The ordinary, Henry Goodcole, a layman who due to some circumstances was not ordained, dreams of having his own parish, is ordered to get her confession. The story of Sawyer's life changes his own in ways he was unable to predictr before meeting Elizabeth.
The novel has superbly detailed descriptions of London and the life the those imprisoned, for whatever reasons. I may guess the print copy may have a map which helps move around the 1early 17th century London. Also, a very interesting subplot is the historic, well-documented idea of English maids, so-called Jamestown Brides, to be sent overseas to find husbands among English settlers in Virginia.
The read is not an easy one despite being relatively short. It requires concentration on the vocabulary and language as the writing style is demanding.
if this is a debut novel, it is a good one.

I went into this thinking the book would be about one thing and it went in a direction I didn't expect and was overall left unimpressed.

This novel packs a punch from the start straight to the action of Henry Goodcole meeting Elizabeth Sawyer on in the darkness of Newgate prison. The writing explores faith, and assumptions of people of all standings around witchcraft. There is meticulous research about so many topics and I learned so much historically. The writing allows for strong visuals, I was transported back in time throughout.
There are many themes that are explored in this book, and it is an engaging read if you are interested in this particular era of history.
My only thought about improvement was that the book would have been better if it ended without as much reflection. I didn’t feel as though the last 60 pages or so added to the story. Despite this, I enjoyed this most in depth read and appreciated learning what it must have been like to live in the early 1600s

I must admit that I did not enjoy this novel because of the writing style which greatly disturbed my reading. The author uses the verb "says" for the dialogues so much and what seems like always that it renders the writing very clumsy and irritating. The storyline was interesting but I was not very taken by the plot.
I received a complimentary ARC of this novel from NetGalley and I am leaving voluntarily an honest review.

Many "witch" stories begin with first-hand accounts of how they had turned their neighbour's milk sour or consorted with the devil, however "The Wonderful Discovery of Elizabeth Sawyer" by Jonathan Vischer cuts straight to 7 days before she is hanged. Goodcole, Ordinary at Newgate is tasked with extracting her confession but instead Sawyer tells him 3 stories about her life. He becomes wrapped up in her case and investigates the facts. Based on a true story, this book is slow to gain my interest but I was involved in the plot and Goodcole's descent into madness (or bewitching?) by the end.