Member Reviews

Olivia meets Zach while on vacation on the Amalfi coast and after 6 weeks, they get engaged. Zach’s parents Amy and Troy were best friends with June as she was engaged to Troy but Amy became pregnant with Zach and unfortunately June severed both relationships.



Olivia, June’s daughter & Zach, Troy’s son are now engaged to be married making all of them in-laws. The twists and turns in this book have made me laugh & cry. I love all the characters especially Olivia and Zach.



I love Ms. Fenton & Ms. Steinke’s works & I highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Liz Fenton & Lisa Steinke - Forever Hold Your Peace.

Olivia and Zach have fallen hopelessly, madly and deeply in love. It’s a whirlwind romance, but the pair are smitten and plan to marry.
When they bring their parents together for the first time, it all goes a bit wrong, as it transpires that their mothers, June and Amy, already know each other. And despite once being friends, they haven’t spoken for over 20 years. There seems to be no love lost between the pair.

What happened for June and Amy to fall out so spectacularly all those years ago?
And when all those secrets do come tumbling out. What will that mean for Olivia and Zach?

I loved the premise of this book. The plot sounded intriguing and fun.

Olivia and Zach are clearly so in love and meant to be together. They are very sweet.
Amy and June turn into a proper pair of Mom-Zillas. But ultimately their hearts are in the right place.

I thoroughly enjoyed #ForeverHoldYourPeace. It’s a story that engaged me from the start. It’s warm hearted, funny, emotional, at times sad, but overall a fabulous read.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

With thanks to Netgalley and Alcove Press for a digital arc of this title.

Was this review helpful?

This was different than others written by these others…more of a rom com. Though o was surprised by the change in genre I still enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

This was a sweet novel that read really, really quickly. I wanted more in the middle! But I appreciated the stories about forgiveness and friendship.

Was this review helpful?

This started out with a very original story line that captivated my interest. I kept turning the pages until the wedding planning started. At that point, each detail of the wedding was described - I started skimming this part. The relationships during the wedding planned seemed very immature and a bit much for me. I didn't care for the characters lying to each other and expecting forgiveness.

The ending was wrapped up in a perfectly neat bow - not very realistic and disappointing after such a great start.

Was this review helpful?

Life can be complex and messy sometimes. This is very true for Olivia and Zack. Meeting each other and falling in love in beautiful Italy they return home to share the happy news with their families. What they didn’t know was the drama this would unleash. They didn’t know their parents parents have a complicated history with each other.

Liz Fenton & Lisa Steinke have created a story in the vein of Elin Hilderbrand; rich families, country clubs and mystery. I found it interesting. I wanted to learn the whole story but similarly wanted the book to end.
I would have liked more character development to understand them better.
As usual, I am certain many will really like this book. It is just not for me. Many thanks to NetGalley and Alcove Press for the opportunity to read the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was a Hallmark movie love story and I really enjoyed it. There was love, romance, friendship, mother-daughter relationships. It was very sweet. I enjoyed the characters and their stories. I liked the past and present colliding. There were a few moments that dragged on or I wished they were slightly different - maybe less predictable, maybe more exciting - but overall a nice read.

Thank you NetGalley and Alcove Press for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for this e-arc in exchange for my honest review! I really enjoyed this read since it focused on the parents of the newly engaged couple and their past history rather than the younger couple’s love story. Theme of family, healing, moving forward were present as the adults needed to work through their complicated pasts to support their adult children in reaching their happily ever after. Full of comedy, drama, and overall fun, this was a sweet read I enjoyed thoroughly.

Was this review helpful?

After a whirlwind vacation romance, June’s daughter and Amy’s son are engaged. The problem? June and Amy have a very complicated history - involving the father of the groom.

After reading a lot of romances in a row, this was a good change of pace. I liked the audiobook.

Was this review helpful?

Olivia meets Zach on a trip to Italy and they become engaged after knowing each other only a few months. Both their parents are worried they're rushing into and decide to meet for brunch to hopefully convince Olivia and Zach to wait. Olivia's mom June arrives late and finds out that Zach's parents are her ex best friend Amy and ex fiance Troy. Neither Olivia nor Zach knew about their parents connection, but their parent's history threatens to end their engagement. As June and Amy try and work together to help their children plan the wedding, they also have to come to terms with their past history and see if there's any reconciliation to be had. Overall, a story about love and second chances, Though the book starts out with Olivia and Zach's perspective, more of the focus is on the parent's relationship and the effect the past has on them. There's a lot of miscommunication and jumping to conclusions, but most of that is addressed by the end of the book.

Was this review helpful?

What a fun story! I really enjoyed the characters in the story and how they were intertwined. Olivia & Zack met & fell in love in Positano and then came home to California to prep for their quick wedding. When June, Olivia’s Mum, walks into the parents’ brunch & realizes the two people she feels ruined her life at one time are going to be in her family the story just ramped up. The themes of forgiveness and moving forward from the past were so beautifully played out in this book. I thought June & her Mom Elaine making up & talking past their issues was great. June & Amy regained their friendship and June & Troy get to explore what their relationship might look like. I feel like June was the big winner in this story.
The parade scene was one of my favourites and I’m so glad the “we ducked up” group was successful.

Thanks to NetGalley & Alcove Press for a copy of this book in exchange for my review.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun read. Two young people fall in love in Italy. (Thanks Lisa and Liz for your vacation posts that brought it all to life for me) Both sets of parents are not thrilled with the idea of them being engaged after a just a few months. At a brunch to get both sets of parents together, we find out there was a rather sordid past between them. Olivia's mom June was once engaged to Zack's dad but her best friend Amy slept with him one drunken night and got pregnant with Zack and that sent them on a trajectory of anger and sadness that had stayed with, especially June, all these years.

A little white lie separates the couple and the parents are all going to have to work together to bring them back together. It is a great ride and speaking of rides, a Rose Parade float may play a part. I can so picture this in a Hallmark movie!

You can't go wrong with a book from Liz and Lisa.

Thanks to Netgalley and Alcove Press for a copy for review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the Publisher for this Advanced Readers Copy of Forever Hold Your Peace by Liz Fenton & Lisa Steinke!

Was this review helpful?

June and Amy are not thrilled when their young (but grown, mind you) children come home from a trip abroad with the news that they are engaged. June thought she was close to Olivia, but bungles it when her daughter reveals the engagement, creating distance between them. Amy and Zach have been close since she divorced his father when Zach was a toddler, and no girlfriend has ever measured up to Amy's standards. She cannot believe that Zach didn't tell her about the engagement until coming home. But nothing beats June or Amy's surprise when the parents meet for the first time, and the two women realize that they know each other: they were once best friends in college, but a shocking event broke up their friendship for life. June and Amy are horrified to realize their kids are getting married, but try to shift the focus to breaking up Zach and Olivia's rapid engagement.

I had assumed this was a thriller, as per the authors' usual MO. It's not, but it's still a really captivating read. There is drama supreme here with the parents' saga! Some of the characters are quite annoying (I'm looking at you, Amy). Still, I couldn't help but keep reading. It's a silly story but a quick read. No character felt particularly fleshed out, but I felt engaged by June and Amy's story. The book is really just as much about the older characters as the young, even if it opens on Zach and Olivia's whirlwind romance.

There's a bit of romance thrown in here (beyond our young couple) and the ending is fairly cute. I do hate the trope of lying and miscommunication, though--I sure wish that happened a little less here.

Was this review helpful?

I've read almost all of these ladies novels, and will continue to do so after this one! I really enjoyed this contemporary romance. It was such a fun ride watching as a young couple gets engaged, and then what follows, where you get to see perspectives from the couple, as well as each set of their parents. There are wild secrets that I didn't see coming, so if you can go into this book mostly blind, I highly recommend doing so!

I loved the multiple POVs, as well as the backstories that were told about the parents. I'm so removed from the wedding scene, that I found it very entertaining to hear about things that are now "in" and other traditions that are "out." This was very entertaining, and a great summer read! Definitely a must add to your TBR list if the subject interests you.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 rounded up.
Olivia and Zack are young and in love, after meeting only six weeks ago abroad in Italy. They get engaged and while their families at first have the expected hesitation of - "its so fast! are you sure?" - it becomes more than that. A weekend brunch is planned for the families to meet and everyone realizes that they aren't quite strangers. This is a light, almost funny at times rom-com without much depth but kept the pages turning. It was the perfect read for me right now to get my mind off things. Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for an early release e-copy in exchange for my honest opinion. Forever Hold Your Peace is now available.

Was this review helpful?

This reminds me of an 80s romcom movie. It's a wedding-centered comedy of errors that's over-the-top and a little bit corny but still really entertaining. Suspend disbelief and enjoy the ride!

Thanks to Alcove Press for the copy to review.

Was this review helpful?

Olivia and Zack both recently graduated college and each went on a trip to Italy. They met there and after a whirlwind romance, they are engaged! It’s a funny coincidence that they met in Italy, but actually live in California only 30 min apart. It’s fate!

When they decide to get their parents together to meet, everyone is nervous. But it’s not until the two moms see each other that we understand- June and Amy were best friends that had a massive fight and ended their friendship. They haven’t seen each other since the big blowup. And now they will be forced to see each other at family events?

There’s a lot that goes on with planning a wedding and especially on short notice as well as playing the mothers game with who wants to do what for the big day. This was just such a fun and enjoyable read. I could easily see this book being made into a movie.

Thank you so much to @alcovebooks and @lisaandliz for my gifted ebook. Forever Hold Your Peace is out now.

Was this review helpful?

Forever Hold Your Peace is the latest release from Liz Fenton and Lisa Steinke. This novel features two families bonded over a couple of lifetimes and through two generations of love, loss, betrayal and reconnection.

We follow Zach and Olivia, two college graduates who met while on vacation in Italy. Their whirlwind romance leads them to an unexpected,, but fated proposal. When they re-enter everyday life and introduce their future partner to their fairly shocked parents, there are more connections than the two could ever have imagined, and the history is complex and fraught with hurt and heartache. Can the parents move past it to support these two young lovers?

Zach’s mother is clearly a mom-zilla and used to having absolute control over her son. She takes a bit of getting used to. This story has drama, complicated family dynamics, broken relationships and the strength and passion of young love. This story covers the topics of empty-nesting and letting your adult children take control of their own lives. It’s about making peace with your past and the power of forgiveness. There are elements that will frustrate you, parts that will make you laugh, and those that will make you smile. Forever Hold Your Peace is an apt title and a quick, engrossing summer read, and a second chance story that you’ll definitely want to pick up.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a nice change of pace after all the heavy, dark, suspenseful, and true crime books that I like to read. Forever Hold Your Peace by Liz Fenton and Lisa Steinke. This is contemporary women’s fiction with a premise I loved. It would make a fun movie and while I read it, I could see the scenes so clearly playing out as if on the screen!

When their newly engaged kids ask all four divorced parents to meet each other over brunch, everyone RSVPs yes–secretly hoping someone at the table will get to the bottom of the bottomless mimosas fast enough to say what they’re all thinking: that this engagement, coming after a whirlwind romance between two people barely out of college, is too much too soon.

But at that brunch it’s not the impulsive couple’s decisions that end up under the microscope, as it turns out June, mother of the bride, and Amy, mother of the groom, certainly do know each other–they’re ex-best-friends who haven’t spoken since their explosive falling out more than twenty-five years ago. Reeling from their unwanted reunion and eager to shift the spotlight off their past as decades-old secrets and rivalries come to light, the two moms battle it out for the prize of Most Enthusiastic About This Wedding.

But when their history—and their present-day shenanigans—threaten to crack the foundations of the happy couple’s future, June and Amy find themselves becoming unexpected allies in an all-hands-on-deck effort to get their kids (and themselves) a happily-ever-after two generations in the making.

This is out now!

Was this review helpful?