Quirky and eccentric was what I was hoping for, and I got half of that. While It was fun to see tarot explored, the second half of the story dragged and got a bit boring for me.

While I enjoyed the premise of this book, it seemed to not quite know what kind of story it wanted to tell. Each element thrown in felt more like a checklist rather than a needed plot point. I could also never tell if the psychic elements wanted to be portrayed as real or as a good hoax. The story moved very slowly through more than half of the book, and the ending seemed to shove everything together.

This is good for a debut. I would read more by the author, but I didn't love this one. I thought the premise was good, but it was a little too police-y for me, and I wanted more from the ending.

I received an advance copy. All thoughts are my own.

DNF. Stopped at 25%. Had no idea what was going on. The plot was all over the place and I didn't get it.

Play the Fool is a debut novel by Lina Chern. The premise of this story was really good and I enjoyed the main characters but I feel there were so many characters it was sometimes confusing. The book also dragged in places but was fast paced in others. Overall, decent but I would like to have seen a little more in this book.

For a debut novel this book is great. It has the potential to move into a series while operating just fine as a stand alone novel. I love it.

There were times when I struggled to relate and it was definitely difficult to keep up with our FMC as she is all over the place and that my friends is very relatable for me.

I found the case itself to be predictable, but as this genre and style are my wheelhouse, that isn’t saying much. The journey to get to the end is great though and I feel like that’s what matters.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ebook copy of this one! It’s worth the read and I can’t wait to see what this author does next!

This was a good quick read! The strength of this book is really the characters. Honestly if each character had their own short "day-in-the-life" story, I would read it! They were all so unique and interesting, even the characters we didn't spend that much time with, like the police officer with all the kids for example.

The plot was fine and drug on in some places with lengthy descriptions places and Katie's thoughts. I started to pick up on a pattern where the first half of a chapter was descriptions and the last half would ramp up with dialogue and plot to ensure the chapters ended with "suspense."

Overall a great idea to interweave the mystics of a psychic reader with the logistics of a crime drama.

Thanks to Lina Chern, Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine, Bantam and Netgally for the opportunity to read this ARC.

This book has a great female lead character. The murder mystery was interesting but not exciting. It is definitely a character driven story, I prefer a plot driven story that keeps me on the edge of my seat. I didn't feel that with this one. There seemed to be no urgency in resolving the mystery. This is a preference thing. If you enjoy a strong female lead in a character driven story, this may be for you,

Katie True is jumping from one dead-end job to the next, trying to keep a low profile with her overbearing family that's always hoping she'll live up to her potential.
She's currently selling tchotchkes in the mall and reading tarot while her friend Marley works in a clothing store across the way...

until a man stumbles into Katie's shop with a photo of Marley with a gunshot wound.

Katie has to use her street smarts and cunning to solve Marley's murder while asking herself if she ever truly knew her friend at all.

This was a fun murder mystery with faint rom-com vibes that would translate well to the screen! While there's plenty of things that happen that require a strong suspension of disbelief, I went along for the ride because I understood it's a lighthearted story here to entertain and that's what it did!

Thanks to Bantam and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review. Play the Fool was released on March 28, 2023.

I wasn’t sold on this when I first started reading it. The writing style was a bit different than what I was used to, and I wasn’t sure how I felt about the main character, Katie. She’s kind of stuck in her life and seemed a little world weary. I wasn’t sure if we could trust her as a narrator. But as I continued to read, I got used to the writing and the world and I ended up having a pretty good time with it.

The characters and their relationships were what really drove the story for me. The mystery wasn’t that difficult to figure out and the reveal at the end was a bit predictable. But I loved seeing Katie with her brother, who is neurodivergent. And the relationship between Katie and Jamie, the cop who gets involved, was really fun.

Thank you to NetGalley, Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine/Bantam, and Lina Chern for an e-arc of Play the Fool in exchange for an honest review.

This was a fun read. I tend to like any book that involves tarot cards, so that was a bonus. Had the language been "cleaner" I would have called this a cozy mystery. The strong female protagonist carries the story well. Katie and her brother Owen are both interesting and likeable characters. Jamie is also a good character. The characters all seem to fit together well to create a slightly odd but good group for solving the mystery. An enjoyable read

The premise of this book sounded interesting, but the writing style is a bit distracting at times and I couldn't suspend disbelief enough to stay interested in the mystery.

Thanks to Ballentine and Netgalley for this advanced copy!

This was an interesting mystery, seemingly driven by tarot, but also possibly about the drug trade and the cop is Jewish AND cute?? It felt like this book was trying to do too much sometime, but I will say that Katie, the main character, felt well-formed and her life felt robustly described. But I almost didn't care about the central mystery and the ending, while not totally obvious to me, left me feeling a bit meh.

Lina Chern’s debut mystery “Play the Fool” operates on many levels, some that are quite strong, others not so much. The positives first. Chern is a fabulous writer, and does a great job creating believable characters who are likable despite (and even because of) their imperfections. The main character, Katie True, works at the dying Deerpath Mall at a Russian knickknack store and her best friend Marley works at the goth boutique across from her. Even though they had only known each other for two months, Katie considered them to be “rare specimens of some exotic breed of loser.” Although she is truly skilled at reading tarot cards with her mind, her grifter Aunt Rosie taught her to “don’t read the cards, read the person,” and Katie does that very well too. After seeing evidence that Marley has been murdered, Katie takes on the investigation on her own initially, before teaming up with a police investigator who appears to be equally lost and friendless, but also equally clever.

The problem with the novel lies in the plot, which is not particularly mysterious, and seems to have no purpose in the end but to reveal who many of the characters really are (i.e., we get to see who is “playing the fool”). If that is the real mystery then the novel succeeds on many levels. Otherwise, a tighter and more well-developed plot is needed for this to really be considered a mystery. 4.0 out of 5 stars for great writing and characters. I look forward to a sequel!

Thanks to the publisher and to NetGalley for providing me with a complimentary advanced readers copy of this book.

‘Play the Fool’ is an upbeat, funny, and clever whodunnit filled to the brim with quirky but likable characters, tarot lore, and fun mystery tropes. While not the twisty thriller advertised, if you like the edgier end of cozy mysteries, love the tarot, or just want to unwind from true physiological thrillers without getting too far away from the genre, this quick, fun lil debut might be for you!

Thanks very much to Lina Chern, Netgalley, and Random House Publishing for an advanced e-galley in exchange for an honest review.

THIS COVER is everything! I was immediately drawn in by the cover and a book about tarot cards struck me as unique and enticing.
Kate was a relatable, likeable character. She is “lost” in life, unable to focus on a career path and navigating family dynamics. Her character growth is lacking, but I don’t think this was intended to be a character driven novel. She spirals into searching for a missing friend, which kept the storyline moving forward at all times.
This was such a fun, cozy mystery with a tarot card element. I do wish we seen more of the character coming into herself given the nature of it being a rather less complex mystery. ANYWAY! The author's writing is rather casual but sprinkles in a lot of humor throughout. Really a great “palate cleanser” read!

I was pleasantly surprised by this book. I kept thinking I would just continue to put it off, but I decided to read it over a weekend and found myself getting sucked into the story and the mystery. I definitely didn't predict how the story would end up, but I really liked it. I wish there had been a little more romance between the FMC and the cop, but I'm sure the author is probably leaving that open for future books. Overall, a pretty decent mystery read.

Katie is not doing well, least successful of all of her siblings, friendless, and a dead end job, the one thing she's truly good at is reading tarot cards. Unexpectedly she meets fellow mall worker Marley, self assured, interesting and mysterious, they become friends over lunches. So when Katie accidently uncovers Marley's death while trying to fake a psychic reading, Katie can't help herself to try and find out who killed her only friend.

This was a bit of a slow start for me, but overall I really enjoyed this murder/mystery. I found it engaging and surprisingly funny at times. While it was a slow start, once I got into it I did not want to put it down.

Thank you NetGalley and Bantam for allowing me a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

This book feels like the cover doesn't totally match the vibe yet somehow it perfectly fits the vibe. It was an okay book. I probably wouldn't recommend it to anyone but I would tell someone not to read it if they picked it up.

This is a tough book to review because I can't really explain why I didn't like it as much as I expected to.

On paper, I am absolutely the ideal audience for this: I love fun mystery novels, quirky characters, tarot, a story with fairly low stakes. And yet, this just wasn't the romp I was hoping it'd be.

I struggled to get through it (it took me nearly two months to read). Whenever I would put it down, it took effort to pick it back up, and the only motivation I had to keep going in the last third or so was to find out if my suspicions were correct. They mostly were, but even that wasn't satisfying because the book itself felt so long. I didn't like any of the characters, and their decisions and quirks were more confusing to me than endearing. It also read really young at times, not quite YA, but not really adult either.

I'm curious to check out what this author writes in the future because there were moments throughout that felt light and interesting. I wonder if this just wasn't the right book at the right time for me to fully enjoy.

It pains me to give this such a low rating because I have to assume this book has an audience, I'm just not entirely sure who that audience might be.