Member Reviews

What could have been really timely and thought provoking fell flat. I am. not the audience for this. I love all of the reviews with their “because it was the 90s” excuses. As a person diagnosed bipolar in the 90s, I can tell you that this was not the excuse for the writing that people are making it out to be.

Was this review helpful?

•Description•
Private School
Bullying
Depression

•Rating•
⭐⭐⭐ 3 stars
Not for me, but might be for you.

•Similar Recommended Reads•
The Gifted School
Luckiest Girl Alive
Wilder Girls

Was this review helpful?

Sarah Taylor is accepted into the St. Ambrose School for Girls on scholarship - one she didn’t even apply for, but her single mother did. Sarah is from a poor, small town and suffers from bipolar disorder - her mother thought the school might be exactly what Sarah needs to turn her life around. But St. Ambrose has a pecking order with Sarah at the bottom and Greta at the top. Greta immediately sees the potential in bullying Sarah and she is relentless. What unfolds over the course of the first semester is gut wrenching and astounding: an attractive and married RA who seemingly flirts with the girls, a friendship between opposites and a murder. How could any of this end well?

Super quick and enthralling read. My only issue with this novel is its treatment of bipolar. My dad is bipolar and has been for 30 years, so I have been in close contact. I know that it manifests differently in different people, but this didn’t quite fit with what I know of the illness and I struggled because of that.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to like this book. Ultimately, I didn’t hate it; I didn’t love it. I don’t think I was prepared for the heaviness of this story. Sarah hasn’t had an easy life. She’s had to fight her mental illness every day. She’s given the opportunity to attend St. Ambrose and life there isn’t all rainbows and sunshine. But this self-proclaimed loner does make a friend. I did enjoy seeing Sarah open up and start a friendship. I also liked how as things progressed, it opened Sarah’s eyes to her mother and changed her opinion of her. This book definitely had some twists I didn’t see coming and I still wanted to know how things ended.

Was this review helpful?

This was a title I was very interested in reading. I'm always up for a good "mean girls" gothic sort of story and The St. Ambrose School for Girls has all the elements -- rich mean girls, resident advisors with lots of temptations in front of them and history behind them, and the girls who don't fit in. The story is told from the perspective of one of those girls. Sarah Taylor isn't like most of the rich girls attending the school. She's there on a scholarship that she didn't apply for, and she has a serious mental illness. She has a target on her back before her bags are in her room.

Greta Stanhope is the mean girl to eclipse all mean girls. She just isn't mean -- she revels in the destruction she causes. She's also in the beautiful girl clique, where jealousy and passive aggressive behavior are currency. And there's Strots -- or Ellen Strotsberry, Sarah's athlete roommate. I really liked Strots. She had her own demons to deal with but still managed to look out for Sarah when she needed someone.

The story is told from the point of view of Sarah Taylor. Much of the first half is devoted to a very thought-provoking, sometimes harrowing and often very emotional expose on what it is like living with multiple health issues, including bipolar disorder at the age of fifteen. The author does a good job of showing Sarah's life through her eyes with sensitivity even when it was difficult to read. This part of the story is not for the faint of heart. Sarah's unique perspective had me holding my breath at times as Sarah navigated her illness and her enemies around her. The rich girls do their usual sort of pranks on Sarah, but things gradually escalate, especially after Sarah starts connecting the dots between her rich tormentors and Nick Hollis, the gorgeous male resident advisor on their floor.

As Sarah continues to deal with both her illness and all of the aspects of being at the new school, Greta and her group of mean girls turn up the heat on everyone, even each other. While the first part of the book was more slow burn and getting to know the characters from Sarah's viewpoint, the second half of the book heats up with some fairly predictable and awful actions.

Overall, The St. Ambrose School for Girls is a sensitive story of mental illness wrapped around a bit of a whodunit. While the first half takes it's time establishing Sarah's viewpoint, the second half is a taut mystery that gradually builds in intensity. There is a payoff at the end and it left me questioning, wondering, and thinking about everything I just read. This is a perfect book for a book club discussion, especially if you want to talk about ethics. To tell you the truth, I'm gobsmacked about that ending in a good way as I love it when a story has me thinking about it long after I finished reading and that was The St. Ambrose School for Girls.

Was this review helpful?

St. Ambrose School for Girls by Jessica Ward an intense psychological thriller. It is a dark and twisty story filled with many devastating secrets. This author has so many sensitive subjects in this one but I loved the way they were handled. Filled with mystery, murder, bullying and mental illness. The characters are well developed with many flaws. You will love them or you won’t. Ms. Wards descriptions are captivating. There is a shocking turn of events that will blow your mind. This is a great summer read for those who love a great thriller!

Thank you NetGalley, Simon and Schuster and Jessica Ward for this suspenseful story to read and review.
#netgalley #simonandschuster. #jessicaward
#stambroseschoolforgirls. #arc

Was this review helpful?

I’ve sat on my review for a few days, letting my thoughts about ST AMBROSE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS settle in. I can say this: Sarah’s story will stay with you for a while.

Jessica Ward (aka JR Ward) has written a literary novel, so unlike anything else I’ve ever read from her-and I’ve read just about all of her books. It’s Sarah, the novel’s main character, and her experiences with bipolar disorder that lingers, much more than the plot (which is fantastic reading) or the other characters from the book (who are kind of one-dimensional, which serves a purpose). Instead, it’s Sarah’s inner monologue that tells a good portion of this story that’s left an imprint on my brain.

While touted as a Young Adult, “Heathers meets The Secret History in a thrilling coming-of-age novel” ST AMBROSE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS is, at its heart, a story about a young woman navigating the choppy waters of bipolar disorder. When Sarah arrives at St. Ambrose we meet a young woman who lives in her head without any true connections, to include her mother. Ward slowly brings Sarah into focus, which at times was difficult to read as someone who suffers from bipolar, though not to the extent as Sarah.

Early on we meet a cast of characters that could exist in any high school: the mean girl and her entourage, the athlete who is brusque but tolerates Sarah, the handsome resident advisor, and the quirky English teacher. Ward uses these characters to bolster Sarah’s journey and she creates a list of suspects for something that hasn’t happened yet, but we know will happen. This kept me reading and looking over my shoulder.

The key to this literary thriller is Sarah’s unreliable narration. As she observes all these characters and slowly starts to interact with them, questions about validity run wild. Sarah even questions herself and this reader jumped on the bandwagon with enthusiasm. I loved how ST AMBROSE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS made me question EVERYTHING.

But, I also read ST AMBROSE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS with some concerns. First, despite most of the characters being high school age, I would not consider this a Young Adult novel. Sarah’s mental illness is not for the faint of heart. There are chapters about suicide, to include details on how one could take their own life. A good portion of the novel feels hopeless as Sarah feels her way through bullying and loneliness. Sarah’s crush on her resident advisor is familiar territory, my high school days spent with many a crush on someone way too old for me, yet the possibility of statutory rape is at least suggested in the pages of ST AMBROSE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Finally, I found the ending problematic and again, not appropriate for younger readers.

ST AMBROSE SCHOOL FOR GIRLS is a book that I would recommend but with trigger warnings for suicide, hurting yourself, intense bullying, and statutory rape. It kept me on the edge of my seat and sympathetic to a troubled young woman who makes questionable decisions in her desire to fit in. 4 stars.

Was this review helpful?

". . . there are only two types of girls here. The ones who play sports and the ones who dress like getting a date is their sport even though there are no boys around to compete over."

It's Sarah's first year at hoity-toity St. Ambrose, and she has a dark secret. Teen queen Greta lives just across the hall, and gets her kicks by tormenting other girls. Sarah is this year's target, and the pranks are nasty. Sarah's roommate had to deal with Greta the previous year, and offers this advice, "Just don't give 'em what they're looking for and they'll get bored. They only like chew toys with the squeakers still in 'em." But her roommate has her own secret to keep hidden.

How far can things go before something really awful happens?

I wasn't sure what to expect from this one. I thought perhaps there might be something a bit more sinister going on than just a tale of mean girls, bullying, and perverts, but it turned out that was honestly enough to hold my interest. The author's characters and dialogue are both believable, and she throws in the occasional quip that made me snort, like - ."What is this, Clue, girls' school edition? Her main character, Sarah, goes off on some wild tangents, and delivers a few lengthy speculative soliloquies that I could have done without, but otherwise this was an engrossing and entertaining read.

Was this review helpful?

Based on the description of the novel, I was very much "in". Dark academia with a murder? Sign me up.

However, it fell completely flat. There was so much exposition and detail in the first 70% of the book that I almost DNF'd it right before things got started. We spent a lot of time living in Sarah's manic episodes and getting every last detail that it felt like a chore to get through some sections of the book. By the time the actual murder and subsequent events happened I pretty much didn't care anymore.

Unfortunately, this was just a swing and a miss for me. Excellent setting and ambiance, no real follow through.

Was this review helpful?

YA dark academia by best-selling author, J.R. Ward, writing under her new pseudonym? Sign me up!
Sarah was an unlikely candidate for the prestigious St. Ambrose School for Girls, but her mother submitted an essay of hers without her knowledge. Before she knew it, Sarah was an Ambrose girl. She doesn't fit the part due to her goth look and predilection for black. But what Sarah really wants to hide is her bi-polar diagnosis and her stints in mental hospitals. Fortunately, she makes friends with her tough-talking roommate and her RA. Unfortunately, Greta, the resident popular mean-girl, has Sarah in her crosshairs. And then there's a murder...

*Special thanks to NetGalley and Gallery Books for this e-arc.*

Was this review helpful?

While this book started off being one of my most anticipated this month, unfortunately I really did not like it. The descriptions were too much and I never had a chance to settle in with the main character or care about her.

Was this review helpful?

I'm going to start by saying this is one of my all time favorite authors. I've read and loved everything she has written under both names. However, this was a disappointing book. I loved Sarah. She was a complex character and the mental health aspect was well written. The pacing is incredibly slow. The mean girls plot was something I've read too many times to care about it. There were no surprises as it felt very predictable. I enjoyed the ending but that's about it.

Was this review helpful?

Ultimately I ended up being pretty disappointed by this one when I finished. The mental health representation made me really uncomfortable, and was our MC's only character trait. It was pretty slow paced with a non explosive ending, and for a mean girl thriller that results in murder (on the synopsis, not a spoiler), the stakes seemed so low. I think if you don’t mind a slower pace, and if you like campus novels in general, you may enjoy this one.

Was this review helpful?

While the cover and premise of this book seemed promising I unfortunately had to choose to not finish it at around 36%. This book felt disjointed and confusing to me, and once I got multiple chapters of a teenager planning their suicide in a way that didn’t feel like it was handled well, I just had to call it quits.

For being over 130 pages in, I felt like very little had happened and the momentum just wasn’t built in an impactful way either.

Truly hope that this lands for some people, but it just was not for me.

Was this review helpful?

The St Ambrose School for Girls was a miss for me. Parts of it dragged on longer than necessary and I found myself skimming to keep myself interested. It was interesting to see the inner workings of Sarah’s mind and I did like how it ended.

Was this review helpful?

This book was one big giant “who cares?” to me. This story felt overdone, unnecessarily long, and unoriginal. I didn’t like any of the characters - while I don’t know a ton about bipolar disorder, I’m not even sure if the descriptions were accurate. I wish I hadn’t wasted time on this.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book I’ve read by this author. I read in her author’s notes that this book was a departure from her normal genre. I did finish the book, but did not love it. Having said that, I did enjoy some of the characters. Sarah, struggling with bipolar disorder and starting at a new prestigious boarding school and Strots, her athletic lesbian roommate are interesting and complex. The other characters com fall flat, stereotypes of a boarding school, the mean girls clique, the hit RA, the frumpy, awkward RA, etc. the writing is over descriptive and heavy handed making for a slow read. I think that this could have been a great book, the story is there, but it needs polish.

Was this review helpful?

This book really just took me for a ride. I loved the build up, the character development, and the pacing was excellent. I felt like every character had something I didn't totally love about them and that made it interesting.

Was this review helpful?

The Secret History mixed with the Heathers.

This thrilling, chilling mystery takes place in a dark academic world where secrets aren't just devastating, they're deadly.

Fast paced and on the edge of my seat.

Was this review helpful?

This was a DNF for me, I’m afraid. I got about a third of the way in and found that I just couldn’t engage with the story or the characters. There was way too much description that didn’t advance the plot or provide anything of interest, and the characters felt too generic in their “types.” Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?