Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Klune has done it again. Another great cast of characters and a story that will pull at every heart string you have. Perfection.

If you haven't read Klune yet, you should. Read ALL of them because he is truly talented.

Was this review helpful?

As a fun of TJ Klune's previous works, I was disappointed with this one. The first few robot sex jokes were funny but then it got old quickly. I loved Nurse Ratchet but everyone else was annoying.

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge fan of TJ Klune's House of the Cerulean Sea and Under the Whispering Door. I have loved the fantasy, the sweet, charming characters, unique settings, and the heartwarming messages. This book, however, might have been a little too far out for me. There were definitely parts that won me over like the quirky, goofy characters, the themes of love, and the interesting setting. The rest of it, however, left me scratching my head and questioning where in the world this story could go next.

This story begins with a not so quite man who is handed a baby by parents under duress. He takes in the boy, Victor, raising him in the strange but charming home he has crafted full of additions, annexes, and bridges in the woods. The boy grows to be a resourceful, inventive young man who lives his days under the love of his father who we now know is an extremely advanced form of AI, Giovanni, and his charming and hilarious friends, Nurse Ratched (a revamped and improved nurse bot) and Rambo (a refurbished rumba vacuum). The story is marked by strange, sexual, goofy banter lobed back and forth between the characters. Everything is turned upside down when Victor, Nurse Ratched, and Rambo find a discarded AI being in the trash heap. There are underlying signs of Vic's attraction to the bot and the three secretly carry him away to begin building him a heart, like the one Gio crafted for himself.

When Vic infuses the heart with a bit of his blood, the being comes to life and we learn that HAP remembers nothing from his previous "life" and he quickly learns, gains emotional intelligence, and is added to this family unit. Little do they know, that upon receiving the blood of a human, the authority is notified and comes in search of the source of this blood. The convoluted, bizarre, and surprising journey that ensues will keep you turning pages.

This story is masterfully written. I can see the profound way that Klune flipped the classic Pinnochio story, in that the father is the "toy" and the "son" is the human teaching love and emotion. I also see wonderful allusions to The Wizard of Oz and can understand the deep messaging that Klune hopes to convey to readers. It just wasn't the story for me.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Tor Publishing Group for this Advanced Reading Copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Another wonderful book by TJ Klune. I loved the characters and wish I could have my own Rambo! The story itself was a little drawn out for me, but the characters more than made up for it! I received an advanced readers copy and all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Inspired by Carlo Collodi's "The Adventures of Pinocchio". with a darker twist, a bit of Frankenstein, Wall-E, and Swiss Family Robinson, this is a futuristic tale of what happens when Robots and Humans clash. From the amazing TJ Klune who brought us The House in the Cerulean Sea and Under the Whispering Door, comes this amazing look into why humans are wonderful... for all their faults.

In the middle of a forest, with nothing for miles, lives an odd little family. An android who goes by Gio, a sociopath nurse machine, an adorable vacuum, and... a human boy - Victor Lawson. One day Vic finds an android labelled "HAP," who he takes back home and repairs. After his father, Gio, discovers him though, Vic learns that there is a very dark history between them - a history that involved hunting and killing humans.

When the robots are accidentally alerted to their location, Gio is captured and taken back to his old lab in the City of Electric Dreams. In order to save him, Vic must travel further than he ever has, and much further than he ever imagined, to rescue Gio before he is decommissioned - or even reprogrammed. Along the way, Vic has to deal with growing feelings for Hap - along with everything else he learns along the way.

I have to say, I always wanted a Roomba, After hearing Klune's story on how he came up with the idea of this book, and reading it myself, I really want one to put pincers, googly eyes and a mouth, and name it Rambo. He was my favorite character! I'm not sure I've ever related to robots in the way that Klune made me do in this book - from Nurse Ratched to Rambo, to robots we only see in passing, it was amazing to see them personified so well. And probably terrifying in realty to consider.

I was able to see Klune at a release party for the book. The first thing he did was ask if he made us cry. Resounding yeses all around. He also spoke as to why found family is so important to him - that for the LGBTQ+ community, found families are often the only families they have. His story, and things he shared, broke my heart. But I so appreciated his honesty, and everything he stands and fights for. If you ever get a chance, absolutely go meet him in person.

Overall, this is not my favorite book by Klune I have read. Under the Whispering Door still holds that title for me. That doesn't mean it isn't absolutely excellent though. Check it out - as well as the rereleases of his Wolfsong series this summer!

Content Warnings: Destruction of Human Race, general tragedy, animal death (but not pets), and sexual content mentioned but not performed (like in an odd educational way). As always, probably things I didn't think of.

Was this review helpful?

Oh. I really really enjoyed this book. It’s impossible not to fall in love with the entire cast of characters in this story, and the dynamic between them all is perfect. The conclusion absolutely got me, and was so well executed. Points were only taken away for it feeling redundant at parts.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! This is the first book I've read from this author, but I have heard of his other works, especially "The House in the Cerulean Sea". I thought the humor throughout was delightful, and I'm a huge fan of quirky "found families" such as this story. A fun and heartwarming take on Pinocchio, I'll definitely pick up more from TJ Klune. The writing of this was also top-notch; it was just what I needed at the time of reading.

Thanks to Tor Publishing Group and NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Klune's books are amazing because they have quirky lovable characters, tremendous character growth that we can all identify with, and great found families that we all want to join. In the Lives of Puppets has all of these things. With strong Pinocchio and Wizard of Oz vibes, this takes me back to my childhood with all the whimsy. The cast of characters are amazing and I want to go live in their treehouses with them. But then their world gets turned upside down and I felt the story get less cozy in stead of more cozy. I enjoyed this one, but it wasn't my favorite Klune. It was a high bar though, so this is still pretty darn good!

Was this review helpful?

In the Lives of Puppets does what Klune is a master at - looking at humanity’s flaws and reflecting them back at us through his writing, but in the most hopeful way.

I found this to be the funniest of his books, the cast of robots alongside human Victor make for the perfect sprinklings of humor during tense moments.

Was this review helpful?

This is only my second book by TJ Klune and it will most definitely not be my last! Klune is phenomenal at world building and creates these fictional, fantastical worlds that just suck you in, with stories that take you on the most amazing adventures. In the Lives of Puppets is lifted up as a Pinnochio meets Swiss Family Robinson kind of story, but those comparisons don’t do this book justice.

I absolutely adored all the quirky, unique, and wonderful characters in this story. Victor Lawson is the anxious, asexual human in the story. He’s an inventor like his android father, Giovanni. Gio also has a heart, and he loves music and creating. But above all else, he loves his son. Vic often explores the scrap yards near their treehouse home, and since there are no other humans or robots around, he makes friends of his own. First we have Nurse Ratched, the sociopathic medial nurse robot who adds a lot of twisted humor to the story and had me laughing constantly! Then there’s Rambo, who is probably my favorite. He’s a wonderfully weird, anxious robot vacuum who loves his friends, and absolutely does not want to die. And then there’s Hap - the Hysterically Angry Puppet - who somehow, despite his designation becomes the final member of this quirky, love-filled family. This story reminds us that the best part of this messy, complicated thing called life is getting to share it with the ones we love, the ones who become our home.

This book is also a masterful story about humanity. Don’t let the fact that only one of the MC’s is actually human fool you. It’s a story about what it means to have a heart. The power of our emotional capacity as humans. Our ability to change. The importance of having the power to make our own decisions, to forge our own paths, to create our own destiny. This story is a reminder that humanity will be the cause of our own destruction. But we also have what we need to save us. All it takes is a heart. A little bravery. And a willingness to start over.

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting take on Pinocchio.

(Spoiler) I love that Gio was able to create human life (still not sure exactly how he did it) and that Vic had to spend his life hiding from the robots that annihilated the human race.

I love nurse RATCHED and Rambo. Rambo is slightly neurotic and nurse RATCHED is slightly demented but together they provide some great comic relief.

The book was a little slow at times but was a great read overall.

Was this review helpful?

I usually love this author's books, but In the Lives of Puppets didn't wow me the way I expected. While some characters are delightful, the plot meanders and gets lost in a quest and endless musings on humanity and connection.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher for my copy, but this wasn’t really for me. This was fine overall. Way too long for what it was, and felt very repetitive at times. The same tropes were also in your face and beat over the head all throughout the book. The humor from the sidekick characters is really what kept me going, otherwise this would have been a DNF.

Was this review helpful?

After loving the House in the Cerulean Sea and Under the Whispering Door, I was super excited to get an ARC of In the Lives of Puppets!

I loved all of the characters but especially Rambo. How can you not love Rambo? The found family as always is wonderful and the humour was fantastic.

Can we also take a moment to appreciate the cover art?

It was definitely a little slow going at parts but overall I really enjoyed it!

Thank you to Tor Books and NetGalley for this copy!

Was this review helpful?

While this book was certainly wholesome and mostly fun to read (nurse Ratched and Rambo have my heart), I was a bit disappointed.
I would recommend In the Lives of Puppets to anyone who enjoys a wholesome story with atmospheric writing, humorous dialogue, lovely (and not-so-lovely) robots with feelings, a writing style that is easy to read and a diverse cast of characters (ace rep). If you’ve read and loved other books by this author, check it out (it is, however, a bit more dark then the popular books The house in the cerulean sea and Under the whispering door).

I had high expectations, since I loved The house in the cerulean sea and Under the whispering door, and, well, In the lives of puppets wasn’t as good as I hoped it’d be.
The beginning of this book got me very excited. Nurse Ratched and Rambo and Vic are so funny together. The place they lived in was described very atmospherically and I love that. But after <spoiler> the house burned down and they began walking </spoiler>, it started to get boring. While the stakes where somewhat higher then in Thithcs and Utwd, it didn’t entertain me enough. I’m not sure why. The banter between the main characters made up for it sometimes though.
I think the romance wasn’t that good. This is probably on me, but I just found the robot-human thing a bit... uncomfortable? Even though I suppose it’s sort of the point of the book that humans and robots can be happy together? I don’t know. They still had cute moments (so much holding hands!). And ace representation!
Also, I’m not a big fan of sci-fi in general, so that’s also one of the reasons why I like this book less. The conversations between the characters are written really well though, so that was fun to read.
<spoiler> The ending was a bit cheesy in my opinion. Very predictable. But I actually didn’t mind that much, I feel like a happy ending is fitting for this book (same goes for Thithcs and Utwd. I do like happy endings sometimes). </spoiler>
I’m honestly sad, I had hoped I would be as excited about this books as I am about the others, but oh well. It was an okay book.
Thank you NetGalley!

Was this review helpful?

I've had this ARC for quite some time and I've been meaning to catch up on writing my reviews! Thank you so much to NetGalley for this ARC. It was an absolute joy to read!

Klune is one of my favorites and again he does not disappoint with In the Lives of Puppets!

Klune's writing style always feels imensely comforting to me no matter the topic matter he discusses. He brings so much humanity and heart to a little group of robots. My heart bursts with ALL the emotions. I cried many queer tears.

I've been hand-selling Klune's Under the Whispering Door since it released and each "hand-sell" always involved a very special, often emotional genuine conversation along with it. I've connected to so many strangers through his stories and I look forward to more heartfelt conversations with people when discussing In the Lives of Puppets!

5 Stars!

Was this review helpful?

I never thought I would consider a Roomba vacuum to be one of my favorite characters in a book, but here we are. TJ Klune's characters are what makes his stories shine,

The whimsical sci-fi world building, heart-warming characters, and found family embarking on an epic journey to save one of their own, all combined to make one powerful adventure that had me laughing, crying, and wanting more at the end.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my heart! A queer retelling of the fable Pinocchio? It's something only TJ Klune would think of and manage to pull off brilliantly.

In the Lives of Puppets tells the story of three robots--fatherly inventor android Giovanni Lawson, a pleasantly sadistic nurse machine, Nurse Ratched, and a small vacuum desperate for love and attention, Rambo. Victor Lawson, a human, lives there too. They're a family, hidden and safe. But he day Vic salvages and repairs an unfamiliar android labelled "HAP," he learns of a shared dark past between Hap and Gio-a past spent hunting humans.

The robots Nurse Ratched (Registered Automaton to Care, Heal, Educate and Drill) is an absolute hoot with her sarcastic wit, and little Rambo with his insecurities will win your heart. Gio is the wise and intelligent AI inventor who created the very human Victor. And HAP (Hysterically Angry Puppet) is the robot Vic brings back to life. When Gio is kidnapped and tears out his heart, the others know they must bring him back - but at what cost? To me, their adventure is akin to the Wizard of Oz, as well as Pinocchio's journey. It even reminds me of the Transformers/Terminator movies where the machines take over - or attempt to take over - the world.

This is such a warm, big-hearted story not unlike Klune's other recent books. It explores themes of the human quest for knowledge and advancement in AI technology, but at what risk. Yet it's also imbued with a sense of family and what it means to love one another.

Be sure to add this to your TBR today!

Was this review helpful?

I’m typically not a fan of the ‘cozy’fantasy’ subgenre, but Klune’s last two books, The House in the Cerulean Sea and Under the Whispering Door both hold special places in my heart for the themes they carry (read my reviews for House and Door. So Klune’s next addition to this genre was a highly anticipated read for me. Doubly so because there’s robots. Unfortunately, while the same heartwarming messages were there, they were bogged down by So. Many. Sex. Jokes.

Look. I’m not a prude. My ao3 browsing history will vouch for that. But when you have characters making the same five juvenile sex jokes, every single page, the story quickly detours from cozy fantasy with coming-of-age themes to ‘high school boys locker room. I’m aware of (although not acquainted with) Klune’s other body of work, where these kinds of jokes are significantly more prevalent. And while I’m happy for the author that he’s been able to bridge the gap between his niches, I do sincerely believe this book would have been much stronger had his editor curbed him back.

Sex jokes aside, I was surprised to find myself split on the characters. I typically love robot characters and one of my favorite themes is ‘robots reconciling the concept of being human with their lack of humanity”. Hap, the stuttering murderbot our MC Vic uncovers, is the perfect example of this. Hap additionally has to reconcile the part where he spent his past life straight-up murdering humans. Some of his scenes with Vic are incredibly powerful and moving, highlighting Klune’s strengths in playing with the reader’s emotions.

Nurse Ratched, a sadistic drilling nurse bot, and Rambo, the tragically misnamed neurotic cleaning Roomba, were easily my least two favorites. They each felt like caricatures of characters, regularly reminding the reader of their epithets with some snappy comment or joke that often derailed a more serious conversation. Not so coincidentally, these two were the instigators of the majority of the sex jokes.

For me, both the story itself and the world were mostly fine, if somewhat rushed and underdeveloped. Really, I felt the issues went hand in hand. The scope of the worldbuilding is so expansive compared to the other works and no one part felt adequately dwelled upon, except for maybe the forest tree home that Vic grows up in. As a consequence, many of the plot points feel rushed or handwaved, giving the climaxes less weight because they don’t feel as earned.

Overall, I rate this book a 2/5. I was incredibly excited for Klune’s next book, so the let down was all the more disappointing. A glut of sex jokes ruined the story for me, and I wasn’t particularly thrilled on the characters either. The overall concept was fantastic, but the execution felt subpar.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful story with bits and pieces that will remind you of other stories, yet it's so original that you'll immediately start reading it for a second time when you finish the first. The bits and pieces description fit most of the characters too, as they are robots, or android humans, whatever you want to call them. But as they interact with the sole human in the story, the bits and pieces become a whole that you'll come to recognize and care for. If I had to find a comparison, I'd say this is a hybrid Wizard of Oz. The "family" will quickly learn that there really is no place like home.

Was this review helpful?