Member Reviews

“Keep silver in your pockets,
Walk with dirt in your shoes, …
Stay away from the hickories,
Stay away from the trees”

My thanks to Crooked Lane Books for an eARC via NetGalley of ‘The Woods Are Waiting’ by Katherine Greene.

I am always drawn to novels featuring woodlands as while I love trees and woods, they also provide the perfect setting for tales of folk horror. I

Cheyenne Ashby has returned to the town of Blue Cliff, Virginia in the shadow of the Appalachian Mountains, after receiving an urgent call from the local police chief about her mother’s increasingly eccentric behaviour. Constance Ashby had been raised seeped in the customs and generational superstitions linked to a local legend of an evil entity that haunts the forest: the Hickory Man. Cheyenne had sought to escape from Constance’s influence but now has been drawn back.

Five years ago when Cheyenne left, three local children went missing and their bodies were later found in the woods. Yet it was a man named Jasper Clinton, who was convicted of these heinous crimes rather than a mythical entity. Recently Jasper’s conviction has been overturned and he was released. Now another child has gone missing and the townspeople are up in arms.

Cheyenne and her former school friends, Natalie and Jackson, are determined to uncover the truth, little realising how dangerous seeking answers could prove. At the heart of the mystery is who or what is living in the woods?

Overall, I found ‘The Woods Are Waiting’ quite creepy and exactly what I would expect from the premise. It proved an atmospheric and engaging read and I felt that it was a promising debut. I will be looking forward to news of her future projects.

Was this review helpful?

This didn't work for me. The story moved very slowly and I quickly became bored. Eventually, it did pick up the pace but that was more than halfway through and by that time I wasn't interested or invested at all.

Was this review helpful?

The Woods Are Waiting by Katherine Green
Rating: 3 stars
Pub Date: 7/11

This story revolves around Cheyenne Ashby, a young woman who escaped her hometown to evade its dark history. Raised by her eccentric mother, Constance, amidst the haunting woods and their unsettling legends, Cheyenne is all too familiar with the town's deep-rooted superstitions. When another child goes missing, Cheyenne and her childhood friend Natalie embark on a journey to uncover the truth and expose the town's dangerous secrets.

Though this book wasn't my usual genre and was slightly creepier than I anticipated, I found myself engrossed in its atmospheric prose. Greene expertly captures the palpable tension, making the woods come alive and sending shivers down my spine. The pacing is swift, propelling the narrative forward and heightening the sense of unease with every turn of the page.

The characters, particularly Cheyenne and Natalie, are well-developed and relatable. Their determination to confront the horrors of their town and face their own fears adds depth to the story. Additionally, the author weaves a compelling mystery, gradually revealing the tangled web of secrets that have haunted Blue Cliff for years.

While The Woods Are Waiting pushed the boundaries of my comfort zone, I appreciate Katherine Greene's skill in crafting an unsettling and gripping tale. Fans of atmospheric thrillers will find themselves drawn into this dark descent into a town's horrifying past, where evil lurks within the waiting woods.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for my advanced copy in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Reading Between the Wines book review #77/115 for 2023:
Rating: 4 🍷 🍷 🍷 🍷
Book: The Woods are Waiting
Author: Katherine Green
RELEASES on July 11, 2023!!! Happy Publication Day!

Sipping thoughts: The Woods are Waiting is such a spooky read. Brimming with ghost-like, evil, demonic, cultish superstitions, you will be on the edge of your seat trying to figure out what is happening to the kids in Blue Cliff. What I was expecting is nowhere near what happened but oh was it satisfying. I really enjoyed this read! If you don’t make this your summer read, you have to put it on your Halloween/Fall reads.

Cheers and thank you to @NetGalley and @CrookedLaneBooks for an advanced copy of @TheWoodsAreWaiting.
#TheWoodsAreWaiting #KatherineGreen #CrookedLaneBooks #NetGalley #advancedreadercopy #ARC #Kindle #Booksofinstagram #readersofinstagram #bookstagram #nicoles_bookcellar #bookworm #bookdragon #booknerd #booklover #bookstagrammer #bookaholic #bookreview #bookreviewer #IHaveNoShelfControl #ReadingBetweenTheWines #fiction #thriller #suspense #mystery #MysteryAndThrillers #GeneralFictionAdult

Was this review helpful?

In a Nutshell: A slowburn mystery set in the Appalachian region of Virginia. Great atmosphere, poorly-sketched characters, repetitive writing, below-average suspense, disappointing resolution.

Story Synopsis:
Blue Cliff is a town steeped in superstition, as residents believe that the local hickory woods are haunted. It is also infamous as the town where three children were found dead in the woods five years ago. Jasper Clinton was convicted for his crimes almost immediately, but now another child has gone missing.
Cheyenne Ashby left her hometown of Blue Cliff to escape its dark history and her superstitious mother. But with her mother’s health on the decline, their old family friend and police chief asks Cheyenne to return.
Her childhood friend Natalie is no longer on speaking terms with her. But when reality starts becoming more bizarre, Cheyenne and Natalie realise that they must team up to save the missing boy, even if it means confronting the being who lives in the woods.
The story comes to us in the first person perspectives of Cheyenne and Natalie.

Bookish Yays:
💐 Loved the use of the location. The hickory woods create a nice atmospheric setting, further enhanced by the small town culture.
💐 Enjoyed the way superstitions were used to amp up the tension.
💐 A gorgeous cover with a matching title. Loved the vibes generated by the cover pic.

Bookish Mixed Bags:
🌹 The character sketching of Cheyenne and Natalie. I liked how they were strong women who didn’t shy away from tough talk or tough decisions or even tough actions. It was a refreshing change to see such women at the helm of a contemporary mystery rather than the usual whiny protagonists we encounter. At the same time, there were certain things in their situation that were impossible to accept. Natalie’s blindness to her fiancé’s attitude towards her was too farfetched to believe. Then again, her pov is mostly useless and more focussed on her personal issues than on the central mystery. Her character development had a lot of wasted potential.

Bookish Nays:
🌵 Sloooooooooow. Nothing much happens until the second half. And even then, only a little happens. Basically, the book contains a whole load of talk and hardly any action.
🌵 The above-mentioned talk is also quite repetitive, with the same situations and comments being brought up again and again in the first half.
🌵 Several characters were infuriating, chief of whom being Natalie’s fiancé Hunter. Unlikeable characters aren’t a problem, but when they are unlikeable as well as unidimensional, it’s tough to enjoy the book.
🌵 Cheyenne and Natalie are both given first person voices, but there is nothing to distinguish them by as the writing in both perspectives sounds the same. It would have been better if Natalie had been written in third person to create a distinction between the two leads.
🌵 Several events in the plot feel quite flat and brushed aside without proper resolution. The reason for Cheyenne’s rushing away from Blue Cliff five years ago seems flimsy, and her return is almost instant without much stress. The resolution of her broken relationship with Natalie is also pretty conflict-free. The silence of some townspeople over certain key events is also unrealistic.
🌵 Even worse than the above half-baked portrayals is the lack of logic in the people and the plot. Kids have disappeared in threes for centuries and yet there is no deeper investigation by any higher authority? A suspect has been convicted for the latest triple murder five years back, and this relaxes everyone, without wondering how the earlier kids died? So many deaths of little ones, and people still willingly stay in this nondescript with their families carrying just cornhusk dolls and silver coins for protection? There seems to be not an iota of common sense in the townspeople.
🌵 The final 20% of the book comprises mostly of an extended infodump scene with the villain and some other characters. It killed the little enjoyment I had had until that point. I know cosy mysteries often end with an infodump full of reveals, but 20% is just too much. It didn’t help that the reveal was utterly disappointing and farfetched.
🌵 Guessing the villain’s identity is a cakewalk. Honestly, you don’t even need to be an avid mystery reader. If you pay careful attention to the character names, you will guess the identity of the culprit instantaneously. This is the biggest shortcoming of the book because no mystery should be so easy to resolve.
🌵 What was the point of the last sentence of the book? A cliffhanger just for the sake of it? To disprove everything that occurred till then?


All in all, I had high hopes from this one because of that interesting premise. But the poor pacing and the repetition were dampeners. Atmosphere alone can’t sustain a book. Moreover, a mystery novel is only as good as its ending, and the ending of this one is so tiresome that my rating, which was around 3 stars until the 80% mark, slid down by a whole star.
This is a debut work, and jointly written by two authors under a combined pen name. Their imagination is certainly in the right place, and more writing experience will hopefully help iron out plot holes as were present this one.
Well, whom do I recommend this book to? I don’t know. Maybe you will like it better if you have more patience with slow and action-free and somewhat predictable cosy mysteries set in a small town.
2 stars.

My thanks to NetGalley, Crooked Lane Books for the DRC, and Dreamscape Media for the ALC of “The Woods are Waiting”. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book. Sorry this didn’t work out better.

Was this review helpful?

This was dark, creepy, and atmospheric! I absolutely loved the way the author set the stage for this book.

I was able to predict the ending, but I didn’t find that it took away from my enjoyment of the book at all. I will also say that there were enough red herrings that I wasn’t always 100% sure I was correct about who the perpetrator was.

I definitely recommend this one to anyone who loves thrillers!

I received a free eARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

What a delightful spooky-forest-of-doom read!! Seriously you guys, this is brilliant. And a debut novel too? I'm amazed.

I love books that are mostly or partially set in forests because that will never not be creepy. There's so many things that go bump in the night so it's easy to imagine how living next to something like that might make people feel. And especially with the Hickory Man legends they all grew up with.

So basically this is a town where kids go missing, always, seemingly in threes. It's been happening for hundreds of years and no one really knows why, except of course that it must be because of the Hickory Man.

Cheyenne's family has always lived in the woods, and they're sort of the town's protectors. She gets called home when another kid goes missing and gets wrapped up in a mystery for the ages.

We follow her PoV, but also her former best friend Natalie's as well. The two PoVs balanced each other out. I initially wasn't sure if I wanted anyone other than Cheyenne to tell the story, but Natalie won me over pretty fast. Her PoV was just as interesting as Cheyenne's.

What I liked most about this book is the atmosphere and the small town superstitions that got passed down from generation to generation. Why do they carry silver coins or put dirt in their shoes? To protect them from the evil lurking in the trees, duh. I love that.

And the salt, herbs, poppets, crystals, rituals, all of that was interesting to read about and helped build up the spook factor.

There was even a little romance thrown in, with Cheyenne and her first boyfriend Jack. He's very much like a puppy, and I liked the two of them together.

I did guess some things, but I didn't let myself speculate too much, I just went with the flow and it worked well for me. I had a good time.

Until the very end I wasn't sure if the Hickory Man was real or not and after finishing this...ALL I'M GONNA SAY IS THAT THERE ARE ABSOLUTELY SPOOKY THINGS IN THE APPALACHIAN MOUNTAINS OKAY. AND IF YOU HEAR ANYTHING CALLING OUT YOUR NAME FROM THE FOREST NO, YOU DO NOT.

I can't wait to see what these authors (yes, there's 2) put out next. And if they set it in Appalachia again, well, I'll come running.

*Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for providing me with an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review*

Was this review helpful?

This mystery/suspense follows Cheyenne Ashby as she returns home to Blue Cliff, Virginia after being away for 5 years. She grew up with her eccentric mother in the woods - the woods where local legend the Hickory Man is said to wait and kidnap children. Only five years ago, it wasn't the Hickory Man who murdered three children but a man named Jasper Clinton. Now, Jasper is released due to new evidence coming to light, another child goes missing from Blue Cliff, and Cheyenne's mother is becoming obsessive with her superstitions and protection rituals. When Cheyenne reconnects with her friend, Natalie, the two are determined to find out what is truly happening to the children of Blue Cliff.

TW/CW: kidnapping, death of a child,

This was a fantastically creepy read. The small town Appalachia setting combined with a great supernatural undercurrent really worked well together to create a great atmosphere for the entire book. The town of Blue Cliff is a mix of people who outwardly believe in the superstitions, those who pretend they don't but believe behind closed doors, and outsiders who don't believe at all. This creates a really great dynamic and fuel for tension as more children go missing. There's a constant push/pull between the superstitions and reality as the people of Blue Cliff try to figure out what is happening to their town.

The Hickory Man legend was really well developed and did a lot of work in the story. I did a quick search to see if this was a well-known Appalachian legend but didn't find anything so I believe Greene created it. We get a really great backstory through some flashbacks that show how entwined the Hickory Man and Blue Cliff are. Layered on top, we have Cheyenne's family of the Ashbys being charged as the town's protectors - a role which her mother takes very seriously. I loved the details of the nursery rhyme that the children chant and adults follow to protect the children from the Hickory Man. When I was reading, I could almost hear the creepy children singing this rhyme and I loved it. The Hickory Man wasn't just a background story to our characters, he is a real legend and Greene used that to her full advantage throughout this read.

I really enjoyed the characters and their relationships were so complex. Small towns are a favorite setting of mine for this exact reason. Everyone knows everyone and that can be useful but also can cause tension when suspicion turns inward and the townsfolk turn on one another. The chapters alternate between following Cheyenne and Natalie and it was interesting to see the difference in their lives. They were friends since they were little, but when Cheyenne left suddenly five years ago, their lives took very different paths. The comparison between Cheyenne, who is now treated as a bit of an outsider, and Natalie, who is now engaged to the mayor's son, is really fascinating.

I thought the solution to the mystery came together really well and tied together a lot of the details we got throughout the story. My favorite element to these folk horror/superstition mysteries is finding out if the supernatural entity is real or if someone is using it as a cover for their crimes. I did see a post on Twitter comparing this read to a specific movie that did spoil the general ending a bit but I didn't guess the exact details so it was still a fun read figuring out what is really going on in this small town. I did find the main story ended a little quickly for my liking, but we do get an epilogue so we are able to see a bit of the aftermath of the ending reveal which I always appreciate.

Overall, this was a great, creepy, folk horror read that really paid off on the premise. The small town setting and legend of the Hickory Man were really used to their utmost potential and really heightened this story.

Thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the ARC. Publication date is July 11, 2023.

Was this review helpful?

I love the lore around the Appalachian Mountains so this was a fun read for me. The spooky vibes were off the charts and I liked the big reveal at the end of who the murderer was. The characters were interesting and I really enjoyed the plot.

Was this review helpful?

**Spoilers ahead**

This book started off so promising. I started reading and thought oh, this is going to be fun! Only it quickly started to get tedious and I finished it just to see what would happen (the ending didn't help things).

This is the story of a town in the woods where children go missing every few years, always three at a time. Cheyenne, one of our points of view, is the daughter of the "crazy lady" who lives in the woods. The lady who is doing everything she can to protect the town from the Hickory Man, the local legend of the monster that lives in the woods. Cheyenne left town as soon as she could without a backward glance, leaving everyone behind without a word. Only now someone has contacted her to let her know her mom isn't doing very well and she might want to check up on her. So this is the first time in 5 years she has come back.

When she left she left her bff's Natalie and Jack behind. The second point of view we get is Natalies and...she is engaged to her high school boyfriend who is really verbally abusive though no one ever mentions that. I did not understand why she put up with him and even when she broke up she still never really reflected on exactly how toxic he was. Or I should say when he broke up with her and she decided not to go back to him when he came crawling back. I just...him and his family were awful so it didn't make sense why anyone in town really liked them. Oh well.

So with Cheyenne back and a new kid missing there is a lot of worry and anxiety in town. Cheyenne always thought the old superstitions were bs and she gets so angry any time anyone brings up something like that. Like it couldn't possibly be true. And while in the end it was people murdering children there was still the hint of otherworldy something going on. It was obvious that some of the townspeople were in on whatever was happening, but the end was really disappointing. I really expected more of the town to be in on it, more people knowing what is going on instead of basically 2 people. So...and the whole bad guy explaining everything in the end was not so great.

Now besides the ending not working for me and being disappointing the other main issue was the characters themselves. Especially Cheyenne. She was almost cartoonish for me. They oftentimes didn't read like real people. The conversations were off and I don't know it didn't work for me. So that is why it was sliding downhill, but I was hoping for some cool monster in the woods only to be let down by that as well. The end kind of leaves it open to there might actually be something there, but eh.

Thanks to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for an advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't impressed with this debut thriller. The characters lacked depth and seemed overly stereotypical of small town residents. The story moved at an even pace but the outcome was predictable. Sorry, I can't recommend this one.

Thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for an advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

Cheyenne left Blue Cliff and never planned to return. But when she gets the call that her eccentric mother isn’t doing well, Cheyenne packs up her life and heads back home.

Blue Cliff is a place of tragedy. Many times over many years, children have gone missing and then been found dead. Superstitions fly rampant, especially as another child goes missing. Cheyanne, her childhood best friend, and her first love must figure out what is truly going on, before another child disappears.

The first chapter of the book is written in an over the top, way too cliched style. But I’m glad I pushed past that, because the rest of the book is written really well. This story is very suspenseful, with an eerie factor and a twist ending I did not see coming. I would recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

This book starts off with a particular trope laid out before you: the reluctant return to a small town where something has happened before, and a family member is still there, connecting you and that incident, and something is amiss and seems to be history repeating. I was anticipating that this book could go either way – into a horror crime with supernatural elements based on the history of the olde town of Blue Cliff, Virginia, and the Hickory Man (which reminded me of The Chestnut Man by Soren Sveistrup – go read it!!!) , or to become a heightened horror/serial killer story. The idea of the Hickory man, and the superstitions to protect you like the salt at the doorsteps, the herbs sprinkled everywhere, and the created effigies were all mesmerising and creepy. These little traditions and the general eeriness of this little Virginian town were great in shaping the location of this story.
What didn’t work were some of the characters. Cheyenne Ashby is the prodigal daughter. Her estranged bestie Natalie and her fiancé Hunter seem like trivial characters. Cheyenne’s ex flame, Jack didn’t add a lot of depth to the story, and the reconnection between Natalie, Cheyenne and Jack seemed a little to quick for me. Possibly as a set up for what was to come. The points of view from Cheyenne and Natalie provide a split-personality narrative, and end up meshing together into the same narrative, possibly to strengthen the history between the two women. I think a deeper story like between them based on the history of the town could have really punched the story up to another level. It also became too easy to spot the villain and for a potential serial killer on the loose, this is where I was anticipating at less predictable and more shocking link between the town, the Ashby family, and the Blue Cliff woods.

Was this review helpful?

🪙🪙🪙.5
“The Woods are Waiting” is an eerie whodunnit that takes place in a small town at the foothills of the Appalachians. Blue Cliff gives off a hillbilly vibe. With its strange residents and peculiar traditions and superstitions, the town has a sense of halted-time years ago.

BOOK QUOTE:
“Keep silver in your pockets,
Walk with dirt in your shoes,
Or he’ll poke your eyeballs from their sockets,
And boil your bones in stew.
Stay away from the hickories,
Stay away from the trees,
Don’t sing, don’t shout, don’t run about,
Or he’ll never let you leave.
Watch out for his rough fingers,
His eyes as red as blood,
Whisper a prayer, you’ll need them there,
As he pulls you into the mud.”

Children are warned to stay out of Ashby Woods because of The Hickory Man. For years, children have gone missing and been found murdered in the woods. Some town folk believe in the local legend while others blame an outsider. The Clinton family moved into the area with their son Jasper who never fit in. Jasper was convicted of several murders but his conviction was overturned after serving several years.

Cheyenne, Natalie, and Jackson find themselves in a sticky situation when they stumble across evidence of town secrets. This is when the story becomes intense and suspenseful. I had my suspicions pretty early in the book and I was correct. Just a hunch due to hints the authors dropped.

I would compare this story to Alex North and Soren Sveistrup. You might want to give it a try if you enjoyed their work. It’s filled with generations of superstitions and traditions. A slow and steady pace at the beginning fills readers in on the backstory until it gets closer to the conclusion and picks up speed.

Sincere thanks to Crooked Lane Books for providing this Gifted ARC through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

#TheWoodsareWaiting #netgalley #crookedlanebooks #PengiunRandomHouse #giftedARC #justfinished #debutthriller #Superstition #Tradition #ad #honestreview #thrillerfriendsunite #mysteryandthrills #thrillerobsessedbookishclub #newrelease #igbookreels #thriller #suspense #mystery #lovetoread #bookworms #lovebooks #lovetoreadbooks #fortheloveofbooks #booknerd #bookreviewer #booksbooksandmorebooks #instabook #readaholic

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

This book was not bad. Set in the mountains of Appalachia a small town has a booger man living in the woods. The author sets up "the Hickory Man" so well. It was sooo creepy and I totally could see his booger butt coming out of the woods at times.

The police chief of the small town calls Cheyenne and tells her that another kid in her town is missing and her mom is not doing well. Well this small town has the secrets. Groups of three...kids taken then found murdered.
Cheyenne's mom believes that she and her family line have to keep the town safe by practicing some witchy ways.

The wrap up was kinda lame but then the last sentence of the book kinda mad me go "oooohhh"

Booksource: Netgalley in exchange for review.

Was this review helpful?

"There was a sense of belonging that blossomed between people who had grown up together. They understood you in a way no one else could."

If you've ever felt a tug back to your hometown despite recognizing all its flaws, The Woods are Waiting is the book for you. It embodies the need to get away from small-town drama while also acknowledging the hold that town will always have over you.

The Woods are Waiting is a quick read at 288 pages. It's short length is unfortunately its downfall. Katherine Greene did such a great job setting the scene of a small town with secrets, but I wanted more back story. We are thrown into the story when Cheyenne returns from five years away. I wanted to learn more about Cheyenne, Jack, and Natalie - Their friendship was summed up so quickly! Maybe more stories about the games they played in the woods, or how Jack and Cheyenne fell in love. Even some back story on Hunter and Natalie would have been great because they seemed like a very odd couple and I'm not quite sure how they stayed together for so long.

Despite wanting more, I did really enjoy the ending which was the redeeming quality of this book. Greene did a wonderful job dropping little hints throughout the book to lead up to the big reveal so the plot twist doesn't completely blindside the reader. She left enough nuggets of information that the suspect could have been a number of people in Blue Cliffs or even the Hickory Man.

3.5 /5 stars rounded up

Was this review helpful?

Katherine Greene's (pen name of two friends in the UK) debut, THE WOODS ARE WAITING, is a creepy dark, strange twisted suspense whodunit set in rural Blue Cliff, Virginia.

Discover more about the town at the center of their upcoming book by visiting: Blue Cliff, Virginia.

Set in a small rural town in the foothills of the Appalachian mountains, Cheyenne Ashby left her hometown of Blue Cliff, Virginia, to escape the town's dark history and haunted past years ago. The Ashbys took care of the town, and in turn, the town took care of the Ashbys.

Her eccentric mother, Constance Ashby, had always been a force to be reckoned with. She scared her to death most of the time. The town calls her a witch and always performs unusual customs to keep away the evil spirits lurking in the woods.

There are childhood rhymes of killings, kidnappings, and how to stay safe near the woods. Children are innocent, beautiful, and carefree. They are loved by their parents, neighbors, and friends, with their lives full of promise and endless possibilities.

Their mothers warned them to stay away from the woods. However, children are eager to discover for themselves the evil that lay outside their homes, no matter the consequences.

Five years earlier, three missing children's bodies were found in the woods, and a man named Jasper was arrested for their brutal murders. The police chief Donald Hickman called her to let her know her mom was not doing well after a boy went missing. Cheyenne does not want to return home. She has a life, but she returns reluctantly.

Like the ones before him, Dakota Mason had ventured into the woods and never came out. Like Olivia, Michael, and Danielle, it was as if he had vanished into thin air. There were legends, superstitions, and supernatural.

However, something sinister was happening, and Cheyenne and Natalie are determined to discover the truth and uncover the town’s dangerous secrets rooted in its terrifying past.

I am not a fan of supernatural, creepy, or ghoulish. THE WOODS ARE WAITING is dark, weird, depressing, and eerie—this book was not for me.

I listened to the audio version and did not care for Angie Hickman, the narrator with the country accent, which ground on my nerves, and I could not listen past the first chapter—I had to stop and try and get through the e-book. I do not recommend the audio.

A whodunit, but I guessed the murderer straightaway. This book may be for some but not my cup of tea. In my opinion, this book was nothing like Lisa Jewell and Ruth Ware which the book description compared.

Thanks to Crooked Lane Books for an ARC and Dreamscape Media for an ALC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Blog Review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
My Rating: 3 Stars
Pub Date: July 11, 2023

Was this review helpful?

3,5 stars

Thank you #netgalley and #crookedlanebooks for my DRC!

𝐾𝑒𝑒𝑝 𝑠𝑖𝑙𝑣𝑒𝑟 𝑖𝑛 𝑦𝑜𝑢𝑟 𝑝𝑜𝑐𝑘𝑒𝑡𝑠, 𝑊𝑎𝑙𝑘 𝑤𝑖𝑡ℎ 𝑑𝑖𝑟𝑡 𝑖𝑛 𝑦𝑜𝑢𝑟 𝑠ℎ𝑜𝑒𝑠, 𝑂𝑟 ℎ𝑒’𝑙𝑙 𝑝𝑜𝑘𝑒 𝑦𝑜𝑢𝑟 𝑒𝑦𝑒𝑏𝑎𝑙𝑙𝑠 𝑓𝑟𝑜𝑚 𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑖𝑟 𝑠𝑜𝑐𝑘𝑒𝑡𝑠, 𝐴𝑛𝑑 𝑏𝑜𝑖𝑙 𝑦𝑜𝑢𝑟 𝑏𝑜𝑛𝑒𝑠 𝑖𝑛 𝑠𝑡𝑒𝑤.

It was a slow burn, so it took me a while to get into the story. But as I got to know the characters, the story gained momentum.

Unfortunately, I felt that there was nothing noteworthy happening for most of the book, so my attention kept waning.

Cheyenne returns to her hometown after a phone call from a family friend who also happens to be the sheriff. Another child has gone missing and her mother is not taking it very well.

The history of Blue Cliff is well known to true crime lovers. For almost a century now children have gone missing, claimed by the Hickory Man in the woods surrounding them, or so the legend says.

The more recent disappearance of three children still weighs heavy on Cheyenne’s mind. Now a little boy is missing and when Cheyenne finds his body in the woods with a penny in his pocket and dirt in his shoes, the legend seems to reaffirm itself. Her mother acting very weird doesn’t seem to help.

But does the Hickory Man really exist or is he just a figment of the imagination of superstitious folk?

Although there were plenty of red herrings I did actually work out what was going on, although I couldn’t understand why!

Quite atmospheric but far too slow for my personal taste.

I would still recommend it to anyone looking for an atmospheric thriller with supernatural folklore woven into the story.

Was this review helpful?

This book gave me literal chills!

I love a thriller that flirts with the paranormal, where it's hard to tell myth and horror stories from reality. Being isolated in the middle of dense, dark woods is creepy enough already, but when you add dead children and a haunting monster of legends, the story you get is simply terrifying!

Blue Cliff, Virginia, is the town that gobbles up children. For the past centuries, dozens of children have gone missing or have turned up dead in the woods surrounding Blue Cliff. The locals blame the "Hickory Man", an evil creature of legends that supposedly lives in the woods and feeds on the young.

The narrators are Cheyenne and Natalie, two best friends who have grown apart when Cheyenne up and left the town five years ago. But now, Cheyenne is back in town: another child has gone missing and Cheyenne's mother is not doing well. I loved seeing the two ex-best friends find their way back to each other and team up, with their other best friend and Cheyenne's ex-boyfriend, to solve the case of the murdered children.

I really enjoyed this book and it totally freaked me out at times! The beginning was a bit slow, but it definitely picks up!

I really recommend this book to fans of thrillers and horror books!

Was this review helpful?

After several years, Cheyenne returns to the town where she was born and raised, and from which she run away practically without telling anyone, including her best childhood friends. While there, she learns that another child has gone missing in the woods. Children always disappeared in this neighborhood, always three of them one after another. Is there supernatural powers involved, or is it just a common human serial killer? In a town where everyone knows everyone and suspects all sorts of things, the answer to this question may not be easy.

Chey's mother is something of a local witch. Witchcraft is essential to this story and is constantly present whether in the foreground or in the background. Throughout, there is the possibility that supernatural forces may be responsible for the murders of young children in the area. The whole town has lived in superstition for centuries, and Chey's mother constantly performs her magical rituals. The townspeople seem to believe it too. In my opinion, this gives the whole story a unique character.

Two close friends, Cheyenne and Nathalie, guide us through this story. I think Natalie is a little better shaped as a character. Cheyenne, although she is the main character of the book, is not that multidimensional and I didn't always know exactly what she wants. Although it may also be because Chey herself seems lost and unsure of her place and who she actually is.

In the end, the person responsible for the evil in the area turned out to be exactly the person I had suspected from the beginning, so it was no surprise to me. At least to me it seemed obvious all along. Still, the author made a significant attempt to point out to some other potential suspects. I wasn't surprised by the villain's motives either, but I still think they fit the story.

Overall, it is a really good story about the evil that lurks in the darkness of the woods. I recommend it to people who want to feel the thrill.

Was this review helpful?