Member Reviews
I really enjoyed this book. I learned a lot about the history of mooncakes, and the love story was sweet.The characters were loveable, and i really rooted for the MC.
While there are many things to love about this book from the mooncakes, to the corgi, to the actual hilarity from chaotic families, to the pure adorableness of the relationship, I just found this book wasn't for me.
I thought this was a really cute book, just like the cover!
I feel like you get exactly what you expect from this book, in the best way!
It was an optimistic, sweet, fake dating book. Dylan and Theo are just so cute together!
These two were so complimentary to each other. Theo is an extrovert. Dylan an introvert, which makes for such a fun dynamic! I say again it was a super cute LGBTQ+ YA book.
Additionally, I thought that the exploration of the Chinese culture was so intriguing! I think the author did a really good job of including the culture in the values, morals, traditions, and food. (LOL) I just really loved how wholesome this story was.
Received an e-arc from the publisher through netgalley!!! Absolute joy of a read—the story was perfectly well done but what got me fully and wholeheartedly was the bits of Singaporean American culture hidden inside. From the food names to the asian grocery stores, Sher Lee captured not just the nuance of being queer and a person of color, but also the inherent relationship between a singaporean and food as well :).
Although easily predicable, the story flowed beautifully and was all around a fun read (and an absolutely perfect YA)! Would recommend endlessly for anyone to read.
This one was so adorably fluffy! I picked it up purely because of the cover, and I have no regrets. The entire thing was a pure boost of serotonin!
My favorite thing about this was definitely the family aspects. Dylan's entire family was so cute. I loved watching them support each other, and how unfailing that support was. I also loved how quickly they embraced Theo. Even when Dylan wasn't quite sure of his feelings, his family was, and it was adorable.
As for the relationship between Dylan and Theo, I really enjoyed it too. I do wish we'd gotten a bit more content with them together as a couple, but that's a minor complaint. They had amazing banter and chemistry, and their will-they/won't-they game was fun.
I already know this cover is going to be featured on Bookstagram constantly, it's that pretty. So, do yourself a favor and pick up the book when you see it. You won't regret it!
Thanks to Netgalley for providing a free copy in exchange for an honest review!
Huge thank you to Sher Lee, Randomhouse and Netgalley for allowing me to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
This book is just TOO sweet. I can’t. My heart is full to bursting. These boys, these families, I am in so much love.
This has been described as Heartstopper meets Crazy Rich Asians and, honestly, that’s so, so true.
Dylan and Theo are far too adorable together. I was rooting for them from the first moment they met, all the way through until the end. They balanced each other so well, and I loved that Dylan not only reminded Theo what was important, but helped him connect with his mother and their shared heritage.
I loved the supporting cast, too. All of them were so fun and vibrant and brimming with life, all in such different ways, and I loved seeing them all come together towards the end.
I also really enjoyed learning about Chinese culture. This book has so much history and information woven throughout and I enjoyed it so much. Also, now I’m craving xiao long bao!
I can’t recommend this book enough!
This story was fun from the start - two teenage boys coming of age in a complicated city where money and station instantly highlight their differences. If you are looking for a sweet story of two new friends falling in love, this one is for you! This was an easy read to fall right into as the main characters had chemistry from the start. I would call this trope heavy in a good way.
When I first started reading I had no idea that this was a YA romance. But still this book was a good read for me. The main reason I don't like YA anymore is because of the character development. I didn't expected much from it but it was great.
Everything was well executed and this is a good one time read. The characters were amazing too but I wished that Theo's father and his aunt would have stop fighting.
The characters are so cute and the romance is so fast-paced. It reads like a c drama!!! Sher Lee is a clever writing and I felt something for every character in this book. Well done!
“有缘千里来相会,无缘对面不相逢”
An LGBTQ YA novel written by a Singaporean, featuring a male protagonist with a Singaporean heritage and background? YES, please!
Dylan Tang is a high school boy who lives with his aunt and helps out in her Chinese takeout in Brooklyn after his mother’s passing. Hoping to save his aunt’s struggling business and in memory of his mother, Dylan wants to win a mooncake-making competition. While running a delivery, he meets Theo Summers, the son of a business magnate. Though charmed by Theo’s smiles and personality, their worlds are poles apart. But as they spend more time together and Dylan gets dragged into rich-people problems, will they be able to overcome all odds and also save his aunt’s business?
Written in first person from Dylan’s POV, I absolutely loved how the Singaporean Chinese culture and heritage was brought out in the story - the food (chye tow kway, hokkien mee…), calling unrelated people ‘auntie’ and ‘uncle’, the seventh lunar month... To be able to see a representation of things so familiar to me in a book is such a delight. The story of Chang’e and Houyi was beautifully woven into the story, consistent with the theme of Mid-Autumn, along with historical facts about how the custom of eating mooncakes originated back in ancient China.
The romance between Dylan and Theo was adorable - from their disastrous first meeting, to a budding attraction, fake-dating and all that palpable flirtatious tension, to finally getting together despite your typical Asian drama romance obstacle. I also found both characters to be well developed, with Dylan a little more so than Theo.
The theme of family shone brightly in this story - Dylan with his loving aunt and cousins, and Theo’s crazily complicated one.
The writing is strong and the story flows smoothly. I enjoyed the humour and Dylan’s punny T-shirts! I had such a wonderful time with this debut novel and can’t wait to read more from Sher Lee! 4.5/5 stars
An adorable read that was quick and easy to get through. You root for all the characters from start to finish
cute, wholesome story about two boys from two different society worlds. I'm a sucker for fake dating with one bed trope.
i love the history behind Chinese culture references and the bond between theo & dylan. the book to me had too many characters and slow at times. the author derailed in some parts of the book, which was unnecessary, where it could've focused more on the moon cake contest. I think they were trying to build up a story leading to moon cake contest and perhaps build some angst, but fell short in chapter of contest. also wish author kept out k-pop references especially since it was heavy on chinese culture references.
overall a great debut novel for author.
Fake Dates and Mooncakes is a book that I've been excited to read for months. I will always gobble up any queer story that features the fake dating trope. The beautiful cover made my excitement skyrocket, so when I received an ARC, I was completely ready to dive into the story.
I think the Crazy Rich Asian's comparison really fits this book. I felt a similar energy throughout, and the wedding was definitely my favourite portion of the novel. We've all had to show up to a family function we didn't really want to go to, and dragging someone along with you to share in the pain is part of the fun. Dylan and Theo had some really fun moments during the wedding. Terri's meltdown by the water? I died. The insane dynamics of rich families will never cease to amaze me. I felt for Dylan as he struggled to navigate an infuriatingly strange new world.
The representation was wonderful and the author truly built realistic queer characters. This book will fall perfectly into the hands of queer teenagers, and we love to see it! Dylan and Theo's relationship was completely wholesome. They were adorable and I loved following their romance. Theo really was Dylan's knight in shining armour, and I loved how devoted he was to wooing the protagonist. This book was the epitome of light and heartwarming. Delicate queer love as its finest!
I have always wanted a Corgi so I was incredibly jealous of Dylan's little companion.
I personally do not see the Heartstopper comparison. I think a lot of achillean books are being compared to Heartstopper simply because... they feature two young queer protagonists. I wish the marketing of queer books would consider that it's really not necessary to compare titles to popular queer books to entice readers.
The writing was really strong, but there were a few themes that I felt could have been explored more, particularly grief. I felt like I was often being told about what the characters had lost, but never shown. For this reason, I struggled to fully connect with the characters. A few moments were brushed over that could have been expanded for the benefit of developing the characters. I felt like Dylan had a real purpose and drive, he knew what he wanted and knew what to do to achieve his dreams. I think Theo lacked the same drive. I wasn't sure what his purpose was beyond being Dylan's love interest. The secondary characters and their families really brightened the atmosphere. I adored Dylan's aunt, and loved Theo's crazy family so much that I wish we spent more time with them. There were some really great descriptions of food that were very detailed. Food descriptions in books have never really enticed me but I enjoyed learning about mooncakes. I was highly anticipating the baking competition and wish that portion had been expanded.
I really hope this book finds a place on many young readers shelves. I love that more queer love stories featuring teen boys are being published. I would have screamed and foamed at the mouth over this book when I was fifteen. If you're a parent of a queer kid, or know one, gift them a copy of this book!
Thank you to the author & Random House Children's for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
4.5/5 A delicious and quick read! The description of the dishes and mooncakes was mouthwatering and the romance was heartwarming. This will be a great beach read. The characters were easy to root for and felt complex. The ending was a little rushed but everything came together just like it should in this genre.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
THIS BOOK IS A WORK OF ART‼️
Thank you so much to Sher Lee and the publishers for providing me with an eARC in exchange for a review!
As I’m writing this review I’m still crying happy tears 🥹 this book is everything I hope for in a ya contemporary romance: heartwarming, cute, funny, and pensive all at once. Throughout the story, I fell in love with so many characters, especially Dylan and Theo who are so freaking adorable I could read 5 more books about them🫶🏼
One of my favorite things about this novel is that its pacing is consistent and engaging. It was so hard for me to put this book down because I NEEDED to know how it ended‼️ I also really appreciated how vivid and realistic all the characters, but especially Dylan’s family felt. Another highlight of this book is the details about the food, especially the Mooncakes!! I can tell a lot of thought and time went into perfecting this story, and it definitely paid off.
Heartwarming, cute, and funny this book is everything I look for in a romance!!
I love this book! The plot is sweet, but also very emotional, tackling issues such as learning about your culture, dealing with racism, falling in love when you belong in different social circles, grief and friendship!
Dylan has a very strong family circle, who he has a loving and supportive relationship. This is seen mainly with Megan, his cousin who's always trying to push him out of his comfort zone, and Aunt Jade, who took him in and raised him as her own. We also have the contrast between Dylan's small and caring family vs Theo's huge and sometimes fake family.
Theo is a great character! I loved seeing him fall in love with Dylan and be ready to do whatever he needed. He tried his best to help Dylan win the contest and to support him through everything.
I really enjoyed Dylan and Theo's relationship, they went through some complicated issues, but managed to work everything out!
The best part of course is Dylan's work to win the Mooncake competiton, with his family recipe. He tries to reconnect with his mother and his grandparents, by recreating their recipe and winning the money to save his aunt's restaurant!
It also features an important topic: sometimes pushing your child to be perfect, will actually exhaust them mentally to a point where they cannot enjoy life anymore.
The How to Train Your Dragons Theme songs playing at the wedding was the best thing I've ever read!
I definetely reccomend this book for those who are looking for a sweet wholesome book!
TW:mentions of death, alcoholism, car crash, racism, abandonment.
4.5⭐️ - this book was just cozy and adorable! I loved the MCs, the family vibes are amazing, and the food descriptions had me salivating throughout the book! I fully enjoyed and would recommend it!
Thank you to Netgalley for the e-ARC!
Goddamn this book had a hold on me. It's been a long time since I've stayed up WAY too late to finish a book and this one broke that dryspell. It was by no means a heavy book and it lived up to the title of "light and fluffy" and honestly, I was here for it. I loved Dylan and Theo and immediately they were my OTP. And Clover. I was here for Clover. Cause, CORGI HOW COULD YOU NOT? Such a smart girl!
Seriously though, this book was so sweet my teeth practically rotted. My dentist thanks you Sher Lee. I loved the characters (some more than others), I loved the emotions, and I loved the highlight on Chinese and Singaporean culture. POC!! And lowkey, Theo. Can he be anymore perfect?
Okay okay before I start this review I simply must say this: *screaming* THIS WAS SO CUTE!!
Fake Dates and Mooncakes is a wonderful and heartwarming YA contemporary romance full of epic humor (I laughed out loud so many times and highlighted so many hilarious quotes - also the ones that will stick with me for forever, but that's a whole different discussion), amazing characters, and a love story for the ages!
Dylan and Theo come from completely different worlds - Dylan is a son of a Singaporean immigrant, living with his aunt and cousins in a tiny apartment above the family take out restaurant (intermission - I would give EVERYTHING to eat aunt Jade's food at least once ahhh), and Theo is basically a dynasty type kid, with all the material goods and more money than he could ever spend (but maybe lacking in the familial warmth and love department) - but they fit together like two pieces of a puzzle. As soon as they met (for the second time) the sparks flew and as their fake dating at a family wedding plan starts to unfold, you know that these two are destined. It was just THAT cute.
Without spoiling too much, this book will bring you all the fake dating goodness (with the only one bed trope included!!), some more serious conversations (about mental health, loss and grief, financial struggles, etc), lots of family love and remembrance, and most of all characters that will burrow into your heart for all eternity. Also you WILL be hungry all the time while reading this book and once you are done you will for sure be googling the closest Singaporean/Chinese restaurant, just a fair warning.
Dylan and Theo forever, basically! I can't wait for my physical copy to arrive so I can reread it again (and maybe listen to the audiobook as well while I'm at it) and experience all the cuteness, heartbreak, and joy all over again!!
Received this ARC via NetGalley
This was super cute! If you want a feel-good, guaranteed HEA, this is it. The dynamic between the characters was adorable and had a good amount of (teen-like) angst. They also had mature conversations which I think are advanced for teens but I think aspirational for those who are at the age.
I also appreciated how the author addressed race and how the characters honored their culture.