Member Reviews

Lovable, irreverent, bright. I adored both Gwen and Art and their not-love so much. This was a riotous adventure with well-rounded characters, amusing side plots and friends, and a completely fascinating medieval setting. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This book took me on a delightful rollercoaster of emotions with its quirky characters and charming storytelling.

Characters? Gwen and Art were like a breath of fresh air. Their banter and individual quirks made them incredibly relatable. The supporting cast added depth, contributing to the overall charm of the narrative.

Plot? The plot had me hooked from the start. The exploration of friendship, self-discovery, and navigating the ups and downs of teenage life was beautifully done. Lex Croucher weaved an authentic tale with a perfect blend of humour and heartfelt moments.

Writing style? Lex's writing style was a standout. It was witty, engaging, and had a unique voice that resonated with the story's theme. The pacing kept me turning the pages, and the narrative flowed seamlessly.

Romance? The exploration of the "are they or aren't they" dynamic between Gwen and Art was both frustrating and utterly charming. It added a layer of tension that kept me invested in their journey, and the resolution felt satisfyingly genuine.

Ending? The ending was heartwarming and left me with a sense of contentment. It tied up the main threads of the story while leaving room for the characters to continue growing beyond the final page.

Overall vibes? This book radiated warmth and authenticity. It's the kind of story that makes you reminisce about your teenage years, complete with awkward moments, genuine friendships, and the rollercoaster of emotions that come with it.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so worth the wait! The characters were amazing! They were so fleshed out and wonderful that you couldn't help falling in love with them!! Not to mention the little bit of King Arthur lore sprinkled throughout!! A must read!

Was this review helpful?

Coming from someone who loves all things Camelot, this was such a fun and unique take on the Arthurian legend! This historical romcom twists the story we know, focusing on two queer teens whose preexisting betrothal and natural disdain of the other causes them plenty of issues.

Gwen and Art’s friendship was delightful to behold and their banter had me giggling. The entire cast of secondary characters was just as charming and I wish we’d gotten to see a bit more of them. The queer representation in this novel was utterly enchanting and it was wholesome to watch these characters blunder around as they discovered their individual paths to happiness.

While the beginning of this story fully gripped me, I felt that there was a tonal shift towards the end of the book that came on abruptly. The lighthearted nature gave way to a seriousness I wasn’t expecting. After that, the ending felt a bit rushed and I wish we had seen a little bit more of the aftermath.

Thank you to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for providing me with a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

A super cute YA that is a great twist on some very famous characters! I fell in love with this story and everyone in it; I think it's a must read, even if you don't typically pick up YA.

Was this review helpful?

I liked how this novel isn't a direct take on the classic Arthur and Guinevere story but rather takes inspiration from that tale. It was also interesting to have an LGBTQIA+ take on a love story we all know (or at least think we do). The humor and wit were spot on and I found myself laughing out loud through much of the book. I would totally recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley & Wednesday Books for the e-ARC of Gwen & Art Are Not in Love!

This romcom has an enemies to friendship component that I was way more invested in than the romance. But it is Queer and we love to see it!! I definitely recommend to those who like romance, historical fiction and Sir Arthur retellings!

Was this review helpful?

What a joy of a book! I have a particular penchant for the Knights of the Round Table and all things Camelot, so I welcome adaptations with open arms. This one is so fun and incredibly clever, and really just delightful all around. The characters you think are so familiar are turned completely on their heads, and the story veers wildly away from what you already know, but in the most delightful ways. Pick this one up if you like smiling while reading!

Was this review helpful?

Things I liked about the book;
🩷 Dual POV
🩷Loosley based on Arthurian inspiration
🩷 LGBTQ+ medieval rom-com
🩷 Self-Discovery
🩷Witty Banter
🩷Faking Dating as they are suppose to get married to each other but are in love with other people.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the book, this tale takes place in medieval times, which I love. The characters are warm and humorous, a perfect quote: “To be truly brave, first you must be afraid—and to be afraid, you must have something you cannot bear to lose.” This relationship story follows Gwen and Arthur, who have been betrothed since they were kids and they're not happy about it, the only thing they've had in common over the years is the ability to annoy one another. Just have to read the book.

This is 2nd or 3rd book I've read by Lex Croucher and not be disappointed. Thank you.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book even more than I thought I would! The dialog was quite witty and even made me chuckle out loud several times. The two main characters each had a distinctive voice during their lead spotlight. Watching them grow and change for the better was delightful. And each of the other four side characters were also very distinctive and lovable. Even though plot elements may have been a bit predictable as typical tropes, the journey to get through them was quite enjoyable. The plotline even avoided the typical “misunderstand and reconciliation”. In this case, most of the misunderstandings were at the beginning and watching Gwen and Art work through childhood preconceived notions was amusing. Even though the convoluted relationship resolution required *spoiler*, it did create a much more satisfactory solution than marriages to the wrong gender with lovers on the side.

I do wish that Bridget’s reluctance to remain at court as a lady/knight in waiting had been explored a bit more. I totally get it. I would not want to just be a secret tryst whenever a spare moment could be found. If I’m in a relationship with someone, I want it to be a full courtship and not share my lover with the socially accepted frontman.

We get THREE happy couples at the end, which is very nice. And the cuteness overload! I can totally see Gwen just casually flopping into Bridget’s lap while Art lounges on a bench next to a frowning Gabriel and Sydney and Agnes feed each other grapes while making moon eyes at each other.

Was this review helpful?

This queer romance hits the expected notes, showcasing genuine characters and emotions within the LGBTQ+ spectrum. While the plot follows familiar beats, the story's heart lies in its sincere representation of love. It might not break new ground, but the narrative resonates with authenticity. The writing keeps you hooked, although a touch more flair could enhance the experience. It's a decent choice for those seeking relatable queer love, earning three stars for capturing the essence, even if it doesn't deliver a completely unique spin. Overall, a heartfelt journey that falls within the expected lines of the genre.

Was this review helpful?

The entire premise of this one had me really excited, but after a chapter I quickly found myself not as excited.

I think overall the writing just wasn't working for me nor the age demographic which sucks. A YA like this sounded like it might have been perfect for me.

Was this review helpful?

While the dialogue can get anachronistic at times, I thoroughly enjoyed Gwen & Art Are Not in Love. More than I thought I would, to be honest. The main cast felt like fully-formed people, and I loved them all, especially Sidney. The ending does do a tonal 180 from the lighter rom-com, which some readers may not enjoy? Like there's hints throughout the novel to the political side of the plot but neither POV character is really involved in the politics until the politics takes charge of the narrative. So some may not enjoy that, but overall the story was a fun romp.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited about reading a King Arthur retelling, and while this was kind of one, it also wasn't one. This was a modern retake, as it follows kids with the same name, but generations later than King Arthur and his court. While there was a medieval setting in this book, it felt almost contemporary in the banter between the characters and how they acted sometimes. It was fun to read, but also slightly took me out of the story. Overall, an okay story, but not something I would recommend broadly or re-read.

Was this review helpful?

I’d heard rave reviews about Gwen & Art Are Not in Love before ever picking up the novel, so my expectations were pretty high going in. My expectations were met; this has to be one of my favourite YA standalones in a long time. Croucher has a gift for both humor and character dynamics, and they use both to great effect in their YA debut. I liked this novel so much that I went back and started reading their adult historical romance series, which should say something of my opinion.

Gwen and Art have detested one another since they were children—almost as long as they’ve been betrothed. Summer arrives to Camelot and brings with it an unwelcome revelation: Gwen and Art are expected to spend it together, hatred and all. But when Gwen happens to catch Art kissing another boy, and Art rummages for blackmail in the form of Gwen’s diary and crush on the only lady knight, they agree to cover for each other. Political stakes, romantic feelings, and complex relationships put their alliance to the test and put their happy endings into jeopardy.

First off: I’ve seen it described as such, but I wouldn’t call this a retelling of Arthurian myth. It draws on some key names and figures of Arthurian myth, but mostly, it reads like a YA romance novel with a medieval backdrop. That being said, it does so with great success. The characters and relationships carry this novel, buoyed by the humor that had me laughing out loud at several points throughout the novel.

What I particularly appreciate alongside the diversity and WLW/MLM solidarity in this novel is Croucher’s deft—but detectable—hand at the discussion of issues and themes I imagine to be important to young adult readers. All of the characters grapple in some way with their trauma, identity, acceptance, belonging, and self-worth, but at no point does it feel didactic or soapboxy. I think a lot of young adult readers could find themselves reflected in at least one of the characters and their struggles in this novel, and that’s a precious gift.

Overall, I enthusiastically recommend this novel if you’re looking for a heartfelt, funny, romantic romp of a time, complete with a backdrop of found family. Gwen & Art Are Not in Love is a super readable standalone worth checking out.

Thank you to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for an advance review copy. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This is a super delightful rom com that has our characters bouncing from enemies to allies. It’s YA and you will be rooting for each of the characters to have their happy ending.

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for an e-ARC of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks so much to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for access to an eARC in exchange for my honest review.

This book. This. Book. You already had me with the premise alone. Like? An LGBTQIA+ forward story using the Arthurian tales as a historical backdrop with a lowkey homage to the beginning of The Swan Princess as the background of two of the main characters? Sign me up. But it was even better than that. I spent the better part of this book kicking and screaming and giggling, cheering on all of the main characters and their friends, and just having the best time of it. This story was gripping, romantic, action-packed, silly, and had *so much heart*, which is the best way to endear a story to me for life. I can't wait to go back in the next year or so and read this again and fall in love with Art, Gwen, Bridget, Gabriel, and Sidney all over again.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was such a charming book and a great take on the story of Arthur and Guinevere (Gwendoline, in this case). What happens when the two betrothed to each other want people they shouldn’t necessarily have?

My one complaint with this book is that I thought it was too long. Cut out fifty pages, amp up the chemistry between Gwen/Bridget and Art/Gabriel, and this would have been a five-star read no problem. I think I also wanted more camaraderie between Gwen and Art, more of them working through their dislike of each other and helping one another.

I know this seems like there was a lot of this book that I didn’t like, but there were more positive things than bad. I had a really great time with it and loved the characters. I’ll definitely check out other Lex Croucher books after this one.

Was this review helpful?

Gwen & Art Are Not in Love by Lex Croucher is a ya rom-com about Arthur and Gwendoline, who are engaged. A hundred years after King Arthur's reign, his descendant Arthur could care less for his betrothed, Gwendoline and she the same. They actually hate each other. After Gwen finds Arthur kissing a boy and Arthur finds out about Gwen's own scandal the two devise a pact to cover for each other.

While I don't think Gwen & Art Are Not in Love was anything revolutionary, it was an enjoyable read. It was laugh out loud funny at times that had me grinning at the virtual pages. The romance was also sweet and had me rooting for the characters and their love interests. All in all, I think Gwen & Art Are Not in Love was a cute ya rom-com based upon the Arthurian tale.

I'd recommend Gwen & Art Are Not in Love to anyone who wants to read a quick and cute young adult rom-com set to Arthurian legend.

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for an e-ARC of this novel. All thoughts and opinions contained within this review are my own.

Was this review helpful?