Member Reviews

I'm not usually one for Arthurian tales, but not only are Gwen and Art not in love, they are also not Guinevere and Arthur Pendragon. They're just teenagers saddled with their legacy, and trapped in a betrothal. And therefore, it was downright delightful! I curled up into all the happy things like sassy banter amongst a quickly cohesive collective of queer young adults, of surprisingly diverse backgrounds, with medieval shenanigans in the background. Only complaint would be the sometimes jarring anachronistic turns of phrases that would be more in line with Gen Z speak rather than the period this is supposed to be occuring in. Regardless, excited to check out more Lex Croucher!

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars rounded up!! I really love the found family trope, especially if there’s royal ties and complexion and queer relationships within it. It definitely delivered with that. My only complaint is that I felt like there was a lot of unfulfilled knowledge of what was happening outside of the main group. This didn’t create plot holes, just a less informed audience. I will say the last 100 pages blew me away. I really liked this book!!

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book as much as I thought I would. It was written in a light easy to read manner but had poignant themes. Arthur was sarcastic and hilarious, but just the right kind of mess to have on your side. I love how the characters ended up embracing their true selves at the end and stepping outside their comfort zone to share that with the rest of the kingdom. I highly recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

From what I read I really liked this book. I liked the story well enough even though it seemed to take quite a while to fully take shape. Not sure how it ended so I’m going based on what I did read. Too bad my arc ran out before I finished.

Thanks to NetGalley and the Publisher for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

Give this book to any teens that enjoy going to Renaissance Fairs/Festivals, that loved the Alanna books, legends of King Arthur, Heartstopper series, etc. It's a modern take on historical fiction with some legendary references thrown in (and tossed on their heads for fun!) Check it out!

Was this review helpful?

This is a super cute and adorable story. I always love Lex’s writing. It’s very fun and queer, borderline fantastical, and silly.

It’s still odd to be that this is out in the UK but not here in the US? Publishers make some interesting choices. Overall, a fun tale.

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5 stars!! Gwen & Art Are Not in Love by Lex Croucher easily ranks among my favourite reads of the year so far! The characters were dynamic, the romances achingly sweet, and the humour sharp. The plot was perfectly paced, never once did I find myself longing for more action; it all fell into place seamlessly.

Gwen is the princess of England, Arthur a future Lord. Betrothed since birth they are forced to spend a summer together in Camelot in preparation for their upcoming wedding. In a story of enemies to allies to friendship, the two spend the summer sneaking around and falling in love - Arthur with Gwen's brother (the future king of England) and Gwen with the kingdom's only Lady Knight.

Croucher's engaging writing style effortlessly builds the story and characters out so well that I felt an immediate attachment to each of them.

The story navigates the beautiful complexities of identity and sexuality. An important exploration of vulnerability, acceptance, and the profound ways in which the people we least expect can have the greatest impacts on our lives.

While it is definitely not a Gwen and Arthur retelling, references to Arthurian literature play a large role in the world-building of this novel, and does an excellent ode to the lore in my opinion.

Finishing this book left me with a deep longing for more, I beg of Lex Croucher for a sequel

Was this review helpful?

This book had me at “God, I hope she stabs me” because sword lesbians are my favouriteeeee 🥰

I’ve been seeing this book all over bookstagram and I was ecstatic to receive the ARC from St. Martin’s Press via NetGalley!

Personally, I was a big fan of Arthur and Sidney’s friendship throughout the entire story, it reminded me a little of Arthur and Merlin from the show. 🥹 Gwen wasn’t my absolute favourite character but her growth over the book reminded me a bit of myself so I felt very deeply for her! Personally I kept mixing up all the lords and sirs but I think it was just because I was enjoying the book so much and not paying a whole lot of attention to side characters, so totally on me.

Overall, the story was super fun to read, I had a hard time putting it down because I just wanted to keep reading! Absolutely going to be buying my own copy of this once it publishes, I can see myself reading it a few times over.

4.5/5 ✨

Was this review helpful?

I'm normally not a huge historical fiction fan, so I was worried I wasn't going to like this book even though the premise really interested me. I ended up really, really enjoying this! It was easy to get transported to that time period. I felt like I was rewatching A Knight's Tale with how vividly I could picture the setting.

All of the main characters - Gwen, Arthur, Gabriel, Bridget, and Sidney - were so loveable and easy to root for. I adored the relationship between Gabe and Art. The slow-burn friendship between Gwen and Art, though, was my favorite part. It was so sweet to see that they actually had more in common than they thought and slowly let themselves care for one another.

Truly, the only gripes I have with the book are minor things. The perspective shifts every chapter, alternating between Gwen and Arthur. But at one point in the book, it doesn't alternate and there are two chapters in a row from one character's perspective. It threw me off just a tad. Also, I was slightly disappointed that the book ended without including Gabe's speech. I think it would've been nice to see him conquer that task and show something monumental that the book was building up to.

All in all, I really loved this book and can't wait to buy a copy once it's published!

Was this review helpful?

Gwen and Art are not in love belongs on your bookshelf.
There is truly a character for everyone- whether you like the quiet, smart Gabriel and his worldly compassion; the bluster and (seemingly) easy swagger of Arthur; Bridget’s steel and strength; Gwen’s unabashed quick wit and take no crap attitude. There is someone for everyone to connect with, but the magic is watching four different distinct and often oppositional personalities learn to fit togethers. What begin as rivalries turn into friendships. Forever chaotic, this is a queer romance you don’t want to miss.

Mostly lighthearted and incredibly funny this book falls into my must read for queer youth shenanigans. Genuinely laugh out loud. I would love to see a sequel!
Tropes: slow burn, coming of age, fake dating.

Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

From the first page to the last, Gwen and Art Are Not in Love by Lex Croucher is some of the most fun I've had reading a novel this year. It is genuinely funny and quite literally left me laughing out loud at times. There is a barrage of witty batter and hijinx that is balanced with a captivating storyline. The quippy writing style and often mad-cap dialogue create a book that delivers its reader a great time.

The story follows the titular characters, Gwen and Art, two people with nothing in common and undisguised disdain for one another. Gwen is a goody-two-shoes that is trying desperately not to rock the boat. Aurthur is a party boy with a reputation to match. Unfortunately for them, they are betrothed and destined to marry and solidify fealty to the king, which is currently on shaky ground. Things go more than a little haywire when they discover each other's secret. However, both characters being resilient and shrewd, decide upon an alliance of sorts. But you know what they say about the best-laid plans...

Most of the characters are queer, a phenomenon usually seen in fanfiction. Rather than queerness being relegated to side characters or even a gay main character in a sea of straights, the author put LGBTQ identities at the forefront of the novel. (If anything, it turns the trope of the token gay character on its head by filling that role with the very heterosexual Sydney.) By giving the reader fun but complex characters, the author provides a relatable experience for some while challenging heteronormativity for others. Also, the ethnicity or race of the characters is never explicitly mentioned. Still, based on their descriptions, at least a couple are characters of color.

The story also weaves in themes such as friendship, loyalty, substance abuse, and agency. This, along with a cast of characters that feel fully realized, contributes to a dynamic, multilayered narrative that keeps the reader consistently engaged. The pacing is strong and even, even in the moments devoid of hilarity and hijinks. The author strikes a balance by providing heartfelt moments of character growth that feel authentic. And while the side characters distinctly fall into the category of sidekick, the pitfall of being merely plot devices is deftly avoided.

Unfortunately, Art and Gwen Are Not in Love perfect comedic timing cannot mask that the novel falls short in the realm of worldbuilding. It fails to establish a clear sense of time and place, leaving readers with a vague and unsatisfying understanding of the setting. And while the setting is not central to the storyline, the lack thereof keeps the story from being as immersive as it could have been. The lack of detail about the government based on the legendary Arthur and Guinevere feels distracting. The best way to describe it is vaguely medieval, in a world that could be our own or, more likely, a universe that runs parallel to ours. And unfortunately, a rather large plot point is the monarchy structure.

Still, the good far outweighs the bad with this one. With its queer rep, a level of depth that doesn't feel like pandering, and dynamic comedic timing, Art and Gwen Are Not in Love is a highly satisfying read. This is perfect for readers looking for a book on the lighter side with a smidgeon of action that's heavily character driven.

Thank you for NetGalley and Wednesday Books for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

it was a cute and fun read. i'm not gonna lie that I'd get into this book only for the arthurian but make it ver gay legends. but I really enjoyed my time reading this. I loved the characters, the writing, the plot was ok.

Was this review helpful?

Lex Croucher's "Gwen and Art Are Not in Love" is a charming and witty retelling of a classic love story set in a post-King Arthur era. With a delightful mix of humor, romance, and unexpected alliances, this book will captivate readers with its lovable characters and delightful shenanigans.

In this imaginative tale, we meet Arthur, a carefree Lord, and Gwendoline, a quick-witted and short-tempered princess of England. Destined to marry since birth, these two heirs despise each other, unable to find common ground on anything... except their mutual dislike. However, when circumstances force them to spend the summer together at Camelot, their lives take an unexpected turn.

As Gwen stumbles upon Arthur kissing a boy and Arthur discovers Gwen's secret crush on the kingdom's only lady knight, Bridget Leclair, the pair realizes that perhaps they can be better allies than enemies. Reluctantly forming a pact to cover for each other's secrets, their lives become entangled in a web of romance, sword-fighting, and the complexities of their intertwined destinies.

Lex Croucher's writing is infused with humor, wit, and a touch of whimsy. The author's lighthearted and engaging prose effortlessly draws readers into the world of Camelot, where centuries-old legends collide with modern-day complications. The dialogue sparkles with clever banter, and the characters come to life through their authentic voices and distinct personalities.

The dynamic between Gwen and Art is a highlight of the story, as their reluctant alliance gradually transforms into something more. The development of their relationship is nuanced and believable, allowing readers to root for their unconventional romance. Croucher skillfully balances the humor and the emotional depth, creating a heartwarming tale that explores the complexities of love, friendship, and self-discovery.

Supporting characters, such as Bridget Leclair and Gwen's royal brother, add depth to the narrative and contribute to the book's vibrant ensemble cast. The found family element in the story brings warmth and a sense of belonging, reminding readers of the importance of chosen relationships and genuine connections.

While "Gwen and Art Are Not in Love" is undoubtedly an enjoyable and entertaining read, some readers may find certain plot developments predictable, particularly if they are familiar with Arthurian legends and their associated tropes. However, Croucher's fresh and contemporary spin on the timeless tale keeps the story engaging and offers enough surprises to keep readers invested.

In conclusion, "Gwen and Art Are Not in Love" is a delightful romp through a world where legends and modern sensibilities collide. Lex Croucher's skillful storytelling, endearing characters, and witty narrative make this book a joy to read. With its blend of sword-fighting, romance, and themes of self-discovery, it's a perfect choice for those seeking a lighthearted and heartfelt adventure. Prepare to be swept away by the charm and whimsy of this enchanting tale.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.

Normally I try to be a bit more eloquent when reviewing ARCs, but here, I’ll write without frills. This book is a delight. The changes in pacing were beautifully done. The characters were engaging and so easy to fall in love with and care for. The writing was funny, and tender, and I teared up in the last pages, with the found family themes hitting me square in the chest.

I couldn’t recommend it more highly.

Was this review helpful?

This was a pretty fun read! I really enjoyed it. The story itself was predictable but I loved the romances and all the characters, the humor was there as well.
It wasn't a King Arthur retelling like I thought it would be originally but I kind of didn't mind. I liked that it was its own thing.
I'll definitely read this book again.

Was this review helpful?

I had a good time with this book overall!

It definitely took me some time to get into the book and I think having so many main characters may have contributed to that. I do think that affected the book as a whole because I felt we didn't really get enough time with either couple (and there's even a third couple!!), but on the other hand of that I did actually really enjoy the friendship between Gwen and Arthur that developed in addition to the two love stories.

Arthur is a pretty entertaining character so most of the plot is really driven by him and his shenanigans (and of course Sidney too!) And Bridget is is pretty cool overall as well because she's a fierce female knight. The thing that was really lacking for me was chemistry though. It's a YA novel so I wasn't expecting anything steamy but I felt like the chemistry was subpar when you literally compare the book to Heartstopper in the blurb. Which I again think could have been probably solved by less main characters and less love stories perhaps or just finding a way to give them each their own books. I really would've enjoyed a separate book for Sidney and Agnes especially since their entire love story is off the page.

That being said I really did enjoy the book overall, I loved all the characters and their friendships and the story was pretty compelling and had real stakes and everything. It was more historical/Arthurian than romancey but being a YA I can't complain too much.

3.5 stars rounded

Was this review helpful?

Lex Croucher writes the best historical romance. Gwen & Art Are Not in Love brings together Arthur who is a descendant of King Arthur and Gwendolyn who is the princess of England. They have been engaged since birth. Unfortunately, they do not like each other at all. Things take a complicated turn when Art is send to spend the summer with Gwen's family. It isn't long until we find out that Gwen only has eyes for Bridget LeClair a female knight and Art is caught kissing a boy. With each others secrets as leverage they reach a agreement to help each other out.

I adored this story. The author always creates a unique and fun story filled with playful moments, heartfelt feelings and action. This LGBT story is beautifully crafted and depicted. I am always excited to read Lex Croucher's books.

Thank you NetGalley and Wednesday Books for the advanced reader copy. This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun Arthurian retelling, that definitely got lots of extra bonus points for being wonderfully and thoroughly queer. I loved that we got to put a twist on all our expectations for these characters, and their relationships to one another. This book had so much humor and heart, and it's impossible not to be compelled by the story. Sometimes the shift between humor and the heavier themes caught me off guard, but I overall still really enjoyed this story.

Was this review helpful?

I've been having a hard time with YA's as of recently so this was quite the nice surprise!

The characters were all lovable but not without their faults. The bonds and relationships formed between all the characters all felt super genuine and even the minor characters still had their place in the story. Gwen and Gabriel's relationship was so sweet, I love a good sibling relationship.

I wasn't as engrossed in the actual politics of it all, but that was still only a key part in the later half of the book. It was still interesting but was not the reason I was reading the book. Would've loved a deeper look into the small bits of magic mentioned.

A fun, quick, historical read.

Was this review helpful?

This book was such a fun read! It was my first Lex Croucher novel, and I had been meaning to get into their books for a while. Gwen & Art Are Not In Love was such a fun introduction to their writing. We have Gwen and Arthur (not THOSE ones) who live in a society were some people believe in the Arthurian legends. These two have been betrothed since childhood as an alliance between their countries, but they actually hate each other. And, as it turns out, they’re both extremely gay! Watching their disdain turn to friendship and their unwilling alliance turn to being some of the most important people to each other was a beautiful storyline. I almost wish there was actually more romance between Gwen and Bridget and Art and Gabe, but I also wouldn’t have wanted any of the friendship to be removed! What a lovely book!

Was this review helpful?