Member Reviews

4.5⭐️
Annie has always been the quiet good girl, but is looking to shed that reputation in favor of more authentically expressing herself. Despite her efforts though, her dates haven’t been interested in forming the emotional connection she needs. When Will Griffin returns to Rome, Kentucky to provide security for Amelia Rose, Annie has found the perfect person to give her some lessons. Will doesn’t believe in love, but Annie is too sweet to resist, but the lines of their arrangement quickly start to blur.

My favorite Sarah Adams book so far! Will and Annie are so swoon-worthy and I loved their chemistry and banter! Our tattooed, ex-military, emotionally unattached bodyguard is such an affectionate, tenderhearted sweetie who can communicate 😍 I love his dynamic with Annie and I loved that their relationship was one that supported each other as individuals and as a couple.

This is the perfect heartwarming, closed door romance loaded with tension to add to your TBR!

You’ll Find —
Good Girl/Bad Boy
Small Town
Fake Dating
Dating Lessons

Thank you NetGalley, Dell Books, and Sarah Adams for the gifted digital review copy!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Random House for the ARC of " Practice Makes Perfect". I adored" When in Rome" and have been anxiously awaiting this novel! The story follows Annie, the introvert of three sisters and Will, her future sister in laws bodyguard as they explore a flirtation under the guise of dating classes. I enjoyed the premise of this book, but it felt way too cliche for me and too predictable.

Was this review helpful?

Annie is seen by everyone as the sweet, innocent friend that would never swear and needs to be protected at all costs. The youngest child, she never knew her parents like her siblings did. So, to not add to their pain Annie hid her feelings and put on a happy smile. She played the part of the innocent little sister and was even called “Angel Annie” by her sisters.

When Annie has yet another disastrous date, this time witnessed by none other than Will Griffin— the sexy, bad boy bodyguard of her soon-to-be sister-in-law. Amelia sets the two up, suggesting Will can tutor Annie through her awkwardness on dates. The two have an instant chemistry— but Annie wants to marry, and Will doesn’t believe in love. Slowly, these seemingly polar opposites tear down the others walls and realize they have more in common than meets the eye.

Man I wish I picked this up sooner. I swear Annie Walker is ME. I need a Will Griffin in my life, for real.

read if you like:
• Sarah Adams books
• romance reads
• small town romance
• good girl/bad boy trope
• “fake” dating trope (kinda?)
• Audrey Hepburn

Was this review helpful?

Best RomCom of the year!!! I feel the same way reading Sarah Adams’ books as I do watching Nancy Meyers’ movies… they are comfy, cozy, and absolutely delightful. Practice Makes Perfect is bad guy/good girl, practice dating, small town romance ~perfection~

This is a closed door romance with tons of chemistry (steamy but not spicy) BUT you can read an open door scene of their time in Paris if you sign up for Sarah Adams’ newsletter!

Thank you NetGalley for this eARC in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Sarah Adams is my go-to author when I'm looking for a feel-good rom-com. In her latest, sweet, introverted Annie Walker is looking for love, but she is really bad at dating. When Will, aka Buzzfeed's hottest bodyguard, comes to town to work with Annie's friend, she enlists his help as a dating coach. It's an adorable love story with a relatable protagonist. I loved returning to the world of When in Rome. More, please!

Was this review helpful?

I had such high hopes for this book because I liked When In Rome and I loved the premise of it but unfortunately, I thought Annie seem too childish and it got old fast. I felt she could’ve still been innocent and kind and tender without seeming totally naive and over the top childish. I could not find the excitement or desire to pick up this book and read it so unfortunately this one was not for me.

Was this review helpful?

Sarah Adams did it again! She has created this sweet, Gilmore Girls-esque world that is positively swoonworthy. This book was full of sweetness and desire - a great compliment to When In Rome!

Was this review helpful?

This is a good book. The two main characters are Annie and Will. Annie owns a flower shop. Will is a bodyguard. There is an instant attraction. Will has volunteered to help Annie learn to date. But it backfires on both of them. They start to fall in love.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Random House for the ARC!

Five stars for Practice Makes Perfect!

What a great summer read. This is how I like my small town romance! It had the perfect amount of angst with a female main character that I just completely loved. The story between Annie & Will was perfectly swoony. I can’t wait to revisit Rome for the next book (which I hope will be Maddie’s book 🤞).

Was this review helpful?

I hadn’t realized how much I adore small town romances until I read, Practice Makes Perfect (When in Rome book 2) by Sarah Adams. In the first book, When in Rome, there is an unexpected coupling of Amelia (think Taylor Swift) and Noah (The local pie baker). They are in the background of this book but it focuses on Annie (flower shop owner and Noah’s sister) and Will (Amelia’s bodyguard). When Annie is trying to have her perfectly ever after with one straight laced dweeb after another Will steps in to rock her dating world with his sexy lessons and has Amelia thinking the bad boy is just what the doctor ordered to help her live her best life. Throw in some tattoos, pickup trucks, along with some pirate romance books, and this was a perfect read.

Was this review helpful?

*This book was sent to me via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*

I was so excited to get this eBook as I loved the 1st in this series. I wasn't let down by this one at all..

This author is great with catching you within the 1st chapter & nailed the Fake Dating with this book!! Which is crazy because it's also a bodyguard romance, what more can you ask for?!?! You don't want to put the book down as you want to know what is going to happen next. From the moment I first read Will and Annie chat, their chemistry was sizzling & came across as genuine. The two, especially Annie are hilarious. I laughed out loud more than once. But also there were a few tears that fell as well. I truly hope that there will be more in this series because I will be there & ready to read the next.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 ⭐️ I picked up this book and finished it in one day. As crazy as my life has been, it was the un-put-down-able escape that I needed at exactly the right moment!

For me, I liked this one better than When in Rome, and I think a big reason was I just related to Annie so well, and Will was the perfect mix of soft-hearted bad boy. These two characters were vastly different, but in all the best ways. I loved so much how they complemented one another, well done Sarah Adams! The chemistry and sizzle were oh so perfectly done. 🔥

Annie was a great mix of the good, shy girl who wants to branch out and figure out who she really is. She is tired of the box everyone has put her in, but she’s scared to step out of it.

As an innate people pleaser/quiet girl myself, I feel like I went through a lot of the same transitions as she did in my 20s. I related to her on so many levels. It can be hard to build that inner confidence, and I loved loved loved watching her find it.

If I had one complaint, it seemed at times her good girl persona was painted in a slightly less than positive light, at least coming from her family with the teasing. I loved how Will appreciated that side of her though. ❤️

Will is the rough around the edges, commitment phobic, tough guy that I gravitate towards in novels. I love layers and seeing them uncovered one by one. Will had so many, and it was wonderful seeing Annie soften and truly “see” him.

I can’t wait to return to Rome, Kentucky!!!

Also, don’t miss the bonus content Sarah recently released for this book!! Head to her page and subscribe for her newsletter to get it!

Was this review helpful?

Rating: I liked it

I thoroughly enjoyed When in Rome and Noah became one of my top book boyfriends (I can’t even do a top 10 anymore because there's just too many that belong on that list) but anyway - this isn’t a review about WIR.

First, let me start by saying I absolutely adore the cover. I love the pinks and flowers.

There was so much hype about this book and I seriously didn’t hear a single bad thing - everyone was convinced I would love Will and Annie. Now, don’t get me wrong - I did like them, but they didn’t wow me.

PMP was a little too light and fluffy for me - and definitely too cheesy. Unfortunately, I just wasn’t in a Hallmark-y mood when I picked this one up.

I’m going to start off with the characters - I absolutely loved Will and Annie together. At first it came across as opposites attract, but I don’t know if I believed that toward the end. Will just pulled out the real Annie that was buried and hiding inside her.

I didn’t get the introvert/shy vibes from Annie, which would have been fine had we not been reminded about it almost every chapter. She very rarely came across that way to me. Sure she had an awkward first date and didn’t know what to say, but it was just a bad date. I also didn’t understand why everyone thought Will was so dangerous. He always seemed sweet to me and I wasn’t sure why the town was picking on him and rooting for him to not be with Angel Annie.

I like the dating coach trope, but it was a little underwhelming. I didn’t really feel like he was coaching her through anything and it was randomly brought in throughout the book just as a reminder it was happening.

I really liked the chemistry between Will and Annie - although this book is closed door, it didn’t really feel like it. I could’ve done with a little less “I’m a 30 year old virgin and there's a half-naked man in my room” talk, though.

I did really like that Annie stood up for herself at the end of the book and that her sister’s didn’t make a big stink over it. Love a good supportive family (who all secretly read a different type of romance).

If you’re looking for something super charming and Hallmark-y, or a good palate-cleanser book, then this is definitely the one for you.

Read if you like:
Good girl/Bad boy trope
Small town setting
Dating Coach/Lessons
He falls first
Friends to lovers
Closed door (but lots of heat)

Was this review helpful?

Read if you enjoy:
- Closed Door Romance
- Fake Dating
- Opposites Attract
- Bodyguard (MMC) and Flowershop Owner (FMC)
- Pirate Smut Reader (FMC)
- Dual POV
- Small Town Vibes
- COMMUNICATION!

Rating: 4.5⭐️

I simply loved everything about this book! What a fun and quick-paced book filled with lovable characters and opinionated small-town nosy found family haha.

Annie is a flower shop owner in a small town where everyone knows her as the sweet and angelical Annie. She is on a mission to find her perfect soon-to-be husband where she can finally fill the void she feels inside. On the other hand, we have Will, the bodyguard (excuse me… executive protection agent (EPA) sorry Will haha IFKYK) coming to fulfill his job for a month as Amelia (Book 1) is preparing for her wedding. He knows he should stay away from Annie but Amelia has better things in mind. She sets them up after a mortifyingly bad date for Annie. She asks Will to coach Annie on how to get better on her dates and this is where sparks just fly.

The Fake dating in this story was so good. I loved the dynamic of Will and Annie and how he wanted her to shine without changing who she is. He was so supportive and gave her the means to flourish while blurring the lines himself of never falling in love. It was so sweet to see him coming to this realization after enduring his childhood traumas. The communication between was so good.

This book was adorably cute! If you want a book with lovable characters and great communication with laughable moments, give this one a try! Loved it!

“Annabell, I need you to know, I’ve fallen madly in love with you.”
“But you don’t believe in love.”
“It was easier to say I don’t believe in love, rather than admitting to myself that I was afraid I wouldn’t be loved back”

Thank you Netgalley for the ARC

Was this review helpful?

(3.5★)

Practice Makes Perfect by Sarah Adams is a small town romance that follows executive protection agent William Griffin and good girl Annabell Walker.

It was difficult for me to give this book a rating since, while I adored the plot and cliches, the characters and repeating lines were just so uninteresting.

Despite having very different personalities, Will and Annie were a lovely couple, and I loved seeing them together. I adored that Will would take photos of Annie for no other reason than that she had said she had never taken any for herself. Or the fact that, despite his cold demeanor, he genuinely cared about Annie and was driven by jealousy.

Even so, Annie was too "sunshine" for me; she didn't even swear. The characters were also amazing when they were together but dull when they were alone.

Overall, Sarah knows how to incorporate romance tropes when it comes to couples because Annie and Will were simply perfect.

*Thank you to NetGalley, Random House Publishing, and to the author, Sarah Adams, for providing me with this e-arc in exchange for an honest review.*

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adore Sarah's writing. The perfect combination of swoon, humor, and perfectly sweet angst. I thought that I wouldn't be able to love a couple more than Amelia and Noah, but Annie and Will have completely taken my entire heart. The broody bodyguard and the sunshine incarnate flower shop owner have literally consumed me. I loved this book so much that I was immediately distraught and missed the characters the moment it ended. I love the quaint, southern small town of Rome and every single one of the quirky side characters that make it so endearing. Angel Annie's character turn around was everything and more. I love that she turned into such a complete and utter take no crap strong woman who unapologetically stands up for herself. The evolution of their family dynamic was amazing and I loved every romance book reference that made me out loud giggle. 5/5 sparkling stars!

Was this review helpful?

Annie is ready for Mr. Right. She's just having a hard time finding him. After overhearing a past date call her boring, she stars to think she is the problem. All she needs is practice though, right? Enter Will. Annie's sister in law to he's bodyguard. Huge and tattooed, he's the perfect guy to help her gain some edge. It's all just practice anyway, right?

This is Sarah's best book yet! I love a good bad boy/good girl trope and this was so satisfying with so much tension! The practice dates and "tutorials" are so perfect. All the stars.

Was this review helpful?

I’ll always enjoy reading a book set in stone, Kentucky with our fav characters. But I found myself just waiting to read more about Amelia and Noah because I just loved them so much from book 1. I wasn’t as invested in Will and Anna. But I’ll read book 3 of course :)

Was this review helpful?

Practice Makes Perfect is book 2 of the When in Rome Series. It can be read as a standalone.

Annie owns a flower shop, like her flowers she bright and sunny and full of life. The only thing missing is the perfect love of her life. Will is a bodyguard that loves the freedom of his job, he has no desire to settle down or fall in love. Annie decides that shes terrible at dating and Will has been tasked with the duty to teach Annie how to date!

I devoured this book, I was immediately sucked in and I could not put it down. I laughed, I cried, I related. I text everyone I could think of that would appreciate this book as soon as I was done and told them they HAD to check it out. As a recovering/relapsing people pleaser myself I related to this book on so many levels. I also loved that I shared names with the MFC, that made the book even more fun for me.

Tropes/Content: M/F, standalone, dual POV, opposites attract, social anxiety, fake dating, people pleaser, small town setting, closed door

Thank you NetGalley and Sarah Adams for this copy of Practice Makes Perfect!

Was this review helpful?

Practice Makes Perfect is the second book in the When in Rome series by Sarah Adams. We meet the main character, Annie, in the first book and see how she is the youngest sibling. As the youngest sibling, Annie is always described as being the "good girl." Annie wants to date, but hasn't had the best luck. Her brother's fiance, a famous singer, has her bodyguard in Rome. Annie and the bodyguard, Will, have fake dating exercises to get her more comfortable dating. They start developing feelings for each other while also learning things about themselves and their wants/needs. A cute romance book that kept me reading until the end.

Was this review helpful?