Member Reviews

What a fun little retelling! T. Kingfisher just does not miss! I loved to watch Toadling turn the story of Sleeping Beauty on its head. A very fun and very quick read

Was this review helpful?

Thornhedge is a short but sweet reimagining of sleeping beauty, but with a more sinister twist. Toadling, our main character, guards a tower, and the sleeping princess within, for a very good reason.
I absolutely loved this story. My only complaint is that I wish this story were longer. The world-building, the characters, the magic...I want more!


Thanks to Netgalley for an ARC in exchange for this honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was given the privilege of reading the ARC of Thornhedge from Tor Publishing Group and NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.

I absolutely adored this retelling of sleeping beauty. T. Kingfisher delivered a whimsical and magical read. I wish I could gobble up more stories about Toadlings adventures!

I usually gravitate to T. Kingfisher horror reads. But this fantasy novel made me want to dive in to her whole catalog.

Was this review helpful?

Thornhedge is a brilliant reimagining of the classic Sleeping Beauty fairytale that brings a whole new perspective to the story. This book is the ideal example of T. Kingfisher and her writing: equal parts horror, fantasy, and romance blended beautifully into a short story.

Was this review helpful?

There is just something about T. Kingfisher's works that always draw me in. Ever since I read The Hollow Places, I have loved near everything from this author.

Thornhedge was no exception. This play on Sleeping Beauty was intriguing and so very good. This story was amazing with its subversion of tropes. I love the way she works with fairytales - they feel so real and fresh. She is someone that I trust to write and craft characters that I love.

This was the prefect length for this fairytale and I loved every minute of it!

Thank you to Netgalley and Tor for the arc!

Was this review helpful?

***Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC!***

This was an extremely cute and sweet retelling of Sleeping Beauty!

But it left me wanting more. I kept waiting for there to be a progression of some sort, either by character development, relationship development between the hero and Toadling, etc, but it never came. It seemed as though it was building up to one, but then the last chapter and the epilogue happened and to me the entire novella seemed to fall flat and end anticlimactically and disappointingly. I think part of this issue may be from it being a novella in the first place, but the rest of the story had the perfect arc you would expect from a fairy tale retelling, but nothing was ever done with it, and instead of a finished arc, it felt a but like a plummet from where the climax should have been. The ending felt really rushed and devoid of emotion because of this, and I wanted much more from Toadling and the hero. Because of all of this, in the end the story seems really forgettable (and I admit time passed today and I completely forgot I had to come back and write a review for this book! It was as if the minute I finished it, it left my mind).

So, I really did enjoy the story, but I think I would have preferred it as a longer novel. I adored the characters, but I wanted more from them as a result. Still, I would recommend the book if you are looking for a short and sweet fairy tale! Just don't go into it expecting anything revolutionary, I suppose.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great and entertaining novella. Quick and easy to follow with excellent character development even with the short timeline.

We stay out with Toadling, a supernatural being guarding a tower over centuries of time. She eventually meets a knight who has heard of the tower and comes to investigate. Totaling eventually tells the night the story of the tower and the girl that sleeps within. It is not what you would expect. Yet, it is completely original and unique for a "girl trapped in a tower story". I found it to be a really refreshing, if not dark retelling of sleeping beauty.

I would definitely recommend this book and I honestly wish I had been longer because I enjoy the story so much I would've liked to have delved deeper.

Was this review helpful?

Short and whimsical with just a hint of faerie cruelty. While this was not my favorite from T. Kingfisher I did still enjoy it. Poor Toadling was taken and switched with a changling moments after she was born. Raised by lesser water folk, then trained by the higher courts of faerie to stand protector over the changeling left in her place. Through events she ends up standing guard over the child for centuries protecting the world from her.

Was this review helpful?

A deeply imaginative and engaging retelling of Sleeping Beauty. I was hooked from the start, and read it all in one sitting.

Was this review helpful?

This was cute! I enjoyed this spin on Sleeping Beauty. I did find it a bit anticlimactic, but still liked the ending. It's a pretty lighthearted read.

Was this review helpful?

ARC received by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

T, Kingfisher's takes on fairytales have become one of my favorite books. This one is another for the list of books that I have come to love. The characters were all understandable and I could see why they took the actions they did. I don't want to get into too much because this is a short story, and I don't want to spoil anything. The only thing I do wish this book had been longer. I would have loved to see more of these characters and their lives.

Was this review helpful?

*The publisher provided me with an ARC of this novella in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Fairy tale retellings are all the rage these days, and no one does them better than T. Kingfisher.

A retelling of Sleeping Beauty that drastically deviates from its source material, Thornhedge is a delightfully dark novella that poses the question - what is Sleeping Beauty was put to sleep for good reasons? What results is a book that has many of the features that you would expect from a Sleeping Beauty retelling - a sleeping princess locked away in a tower, a strapping young prince trying to save her, a dangerous protective wall of thorns, and a kind fairy over-looking our fairy maiden. Readers quickly figure out, however, that this is not the traditional version of the story they have seen many times over.

The main character of Thornhedge is the fairy-being herself, Toadling. Toadling was a character that I was instantly drawn to, as she demonstrated by empathetic thoughtfulness and determined strength in a manner that felt genuine and lived in. The novella is written in a non-linear format in which we consistently jump back and forth between the modern day (where princes and knights are trying to save the princess) and Toadling's past, where we learn about the tragic events that have lead to the current "Sleeping Beauty in the tower situation". We feel every single on of Toadling's sacrifices, and the ethical choices that she doesn't want to make but is forced to make. As the novella unfurls, Kingfisher applies many layers to Toadling, as she tries to define her own strength in the world without losing all of her sweet humanity.

The non-linear nature of the novella also means that Kingfisher gets to insert all kinds of fun mysteries and twists into the narrative. It is clear from the get that not everything is at it appears, but Kingfisher doesn't reveal her hand until the perfect moments. Once everything is revealed, the plot kicks into overdrive as it excels to the novella's climax.

The pacing of this novella is on point, which is not always something that I can say about the format. Many novellas either feel like drawn out short stories or dramatically cut down novels, but Kingfisher utilized the novella's length to its benefit. The plot moves along at a great pace, always moving toward the next "reveal", while also finding time for the quieter character moments that lets their humanity shine in these of-dark circumstances. The ending is immensely satisfying, and I cannot honestly say (as a huge compliment) that I don't need anymore of Toadling or this particular world. Their story is told - its finished. Which, in the ever of the "Marvel Cinematic Universe" and "Franchise Fever" is quite refreshing.

The other major character is "the prince", Halim. I absolutely adored that Halim was not the stereotypical prince/knight figure, but also wasn't simply a stereotypical satire of that character archetype either. Instead, he was a man who doesn't quite enjoy the princely things, but always tries to do the right thing (like saving maidens from towers). There were also just other clever changes that brought him to life amongst the deluge of princes/knight figures in fantasy, even just the detail that he was Muslim and that a lot of his actions and thoughts were filtered through that particular lens.

The exact tone of this novel is hard to pin down. There is definitely a dark and sinister aura overlying the entire thing, and individual elements seep into the horror genre. Kingfisher also tackles several darker themes and ethical quandaries, from emotional abuse to feelings of not-belong, to murder and what essentially amounts to gaslighting. But there are also some cozier elements, moments of job and brightness; in particular, the interactions between Toadling and Halim can often verge on the thoughtful and philosophical, not so unlike Becky Chamber's Monk and Robot books. For T. Kingfisher fans, I would say it is not quite as dark as What Moves the Dead, but darker than Nettle and Bone. Thornhedge embraces the dark elements of fairy tales and their origins, but does not sacrifice the light elements to make some kind of "grimdark" nihilistic point about the world.

Whether you are a long time fan of T. Kingfisher or brand new to her works, this is a perfect novella for fairy tale fans.

Concluding Thoughts: Simultaneously sinister and sweet, Thornhedge subverts the traditional Sleeping Beauty story without feelings its only point of existence is to subvert. Toadling is a wonderful protagonist who is thoughtful and kind while also demonstrating temerity and strength. Readers will be transported for a short afternoon of quickly turning the pages to see what happens next. Definitely a novella fairy tale fans should check out.

Was this review helpful?

This fairytale retelling was so beautiful. I absolutely adored Toadling. She may not be that magically gifted but she makes up for it with her kind heart. Halim was a breath of fresh air. A knight who isn’t all that great at being one, isn’t handsome, and follows mysteries he’s read in books. The two were absolutely perfect main characters for this story.

Thank you NetGalley and Tor Publishing Group for allowing me to read this in advance in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book cements it: I'm a T Kingfisher fan. It has fae that aren't pretty and are neither perfectly evil nor perfectly good. I'm really digging novellas and Thornhedge surpassed my expectations for the genre.

Was this review helpful?

This is so adorable and lovely. Just a perfect fairy tale retelling- sweet, surprising, and magical. I loved the heroine, like all of Kingfisher's heroines, and her weird found family was pitch perfect.

Was this review helpful?

Thornhedge
By T. Kingfisher

This Novella took Sleeping Beauty and turned it on its head. I really enjoyed the main character and her journey, from sweet and naive to starting to come in to her own. The descriptions were fantastic, I really got immersed into the little world. If anything, it ended too soon! I definitely need to keep reading Kingfisher.

Thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this arc in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adored this. I've read several from this author, both in the fantasy and horror genres, and was expecting this to be quirky along the lines of Nettle and Bone, but it was deeply moving and sort of sad and and also sweet and very poignant and I loved it for that. A story of a Toadling human/other and the load she carries and a hesitant knight with a large heart, for want of a better way to phrase it right now. I'm going to sit with this one longer. But know that I adore it. I loved the characters, I loved the pacing, I loved that it was sweet and sad and Toadling was dealing with her internal self-image, which was so relatable. And I love novellas! This was such a great one. I feel like this was a version of the Sleepy Beauty retelling I've really not encountered before. I liked that the author mentioned a sensitivity reader in the acknowledgments for the character of Halim, which is something I'd wondered about, and this I appreciate. I'll be recommending this to others for sure. Full review to come.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the advance reader copy!

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to both Tor Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review an early copy of Thornhedge.

Expected publication August 15, 2023

Welcome to Thornhedge, the dark reimagined fairytale where Toadling lives. She was once a human child before being taken by the fairies and replaced with a changeling fairy child. Then, a disaster left Toadling trying to make up for her error and doing the best she could, for centuries!

Enter a kind knight named Halim...

Thornbridge was an interesting novella, although I could have done without the animal cruelty.

Was this review helpful?

Toadling is not your princess in the fairytale. She is taken at birth by fairies and replaced with a changling. This changling is such a viscous child that no one can bare her. Don’t worry the princess will not get the prince, but he does meet our sweet Toadling.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Tor Books for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own. The official pub date of this novel is on August 15, 2023.

Thornhedge is a quirky and cute book that readers will easily read in one sitting because a) it’s short and b) they’ll just want to see what happens next. This is a unique little fairytale where readers will be questioning who the villain is and who the hero is throughout the story. T. Kingfisher is masterful at creating characters readers love with huge hearts and a self-deprecating humor that is endearing and relatable. I gave Thornhedge 3.5 stars because it was heartwarming and creative. As I mentioned, this is a quick little cozy read, so there isn’t a ton of depth here, but it was very enjoyable!

Was this review helpful?