Member Reviews
Creative premise and a well told story, I found myself interested in how it would play out. Kuang creates a sympathetic character in June Hayward - despite her flaws and questionable judgement. The plagiarism story has an added element of interest because of the racial aspect. I thought this was a clever idea and was well implemented. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it!
When aspiring hit novelist June watches her successful author friend Athena die, she makes a spur of the moment decision that snowballs into an avalanche of theft and plagiarism.
This novel holds up a mirror to the entire seedy underbelly of the publishing world. And not just the publishing world, but the roles that authors and readers play within that mess as well. Honestly, after reading Kuang's <u>Yellowface</u>, I feel somewhat dirty leaving a review at all! But Kuang judiciously holds up a mirror to every single one of her audience members. Those that cannot stomach this novel simply don't have the gall for tough and eye-opening conversations about sexism, racism, or privilege. Or maybe it's the fact that they simply cannot handle the face in the mirror and take the self-critique on the chin? Because at the end of the day this novel forces everyone to self-examine, and that can sometimes prove a daunting task. Though if you put in the effort and stick with this novel to the end, I think you'll find the story quite rewarding indeed.
Kuang's voice is so strong. The whole story is carefully structured and Lasser did an incredible job voicing an unlikable character. Listening to it increased the cringe factor to a 100%.
What happens when you steal a manuscript from a dead author? Who's going to know? This is the tale of Juniper and her rise to stardom in the publishing world...even though she didn't really write the book she's gaining fame for. I ended up listening to this one and am glad I did. While June is completely unlikeable, you end up feeling bad for her and the series of horrible decisions she makes. Lots of commentary on who gets to tell who's stories, it was an eye-opening read. Late to the party on this one, but glad I caught up.
Such a fascinating read that we have here. I thought it was thought provoking to have a white main character do all those terrible actions. I also enjoyed how both characters were completely flawed and realistic. I think it’s amazing that RF Kuang was able to write about this controversial topic with a brilliant narrative and compelling story.
Thank you to netgalley for providing an e-galley for review. Yellowface tackles some big issues, without feeling overblown or heavy handed. Juniper Song was friends/frenemies with Athena Liu and was there the night Athena passed away. June/Juniper takes a previously unknown work in progress of Athena's, finishes it and promotes it as her own. Other than the act of stealing anther person's intellectual property, major issues arise with this action. The book is about Chinese laborers in World War 1. Juniper is white. Questions arise about cultural appropriation, whether authors can write about other lived experiences, since that is their job, racism, online bullying and the consequences of actions. It was immensely readable with characters that are unlikable, turning to likable, making relatable decisions.
I read this in one sitting. A scathing portrayal of the publishing world and their quest to highlight minority authors… but not too many ,the authors trying desperately to stay relevant , and the impact social media has on the publishing industry as well as the world in general. This book was quite the departure from Kuang’s historical fantasy books and shows the amazing breadth of her talent. I love all her work and if as June does she reads Goodreads reviews- you are brilliant!
Thanks Netgalley for the ARC - my opinions are my own.
RF Kuang never misses and this expose on modern publishing is haunting. It makes you think. It makes you cry. It makes you wonder.
I went into this one not knowing what it was about, but that it was loved by many. I really enjoyed this book, but it fell a little flat for me. I felt like the buildup was a little slow and the ending wasn’t quite what I was hoping for.
I did enjoy Yellowface, but with all the hype I was hoping for a little bit more.
R. F. Kuang is a tried and true academic. At only twenty-six, Kuang has studied at prestigious institutions such as Georgetown, Oxford, Cambridge, and most recently Yale. She’s a Marshall Scholar with four best-selling novels already under her belt. Her passion for her studies is clear in the way she chooses to incorporate them into her novels. Kuang is a high-fantasy writer known for using the fantastical to examine historical events. Her debut series, The Poppy War Trilogy, draws many parallels to the Second Sino-Japanese War and the Chinese Civil War. Her first stand-alone, Babel: Or the Necessity of Violence: An Arcane History of the Oxford Translators' Revolution, focuses on the consequences of the Industrial Revolution. Historical Fantasy has long been considered the center of Kuang’s brand, which is why it was a surprise to many when she announced that her upcoming novel, Yellowface, would be a literary thriller. Nonetheless, the announcement was met with much excitement. Many readers, including myself, were curious to see how Kuang would transition to a new genre. Yellowface is set to release May 16th, 2023, but I was lucky enough to receive an advanced reader copy from Harper Collins earlier this month. I didn’t intend to, but I ended up reading the book in one sitting. Once I finished I was left with many thoughts, unfortunately, none of them are good.
The most frustrating thing about R.F. Kuang is that despite being a gifted academic she is a deeply uncurious writer. I noticed this while reading some of her other works, but nowhere has it been more obvious than in Yellowface. The problem with Kuang writing literary fiction is that there is no history for her to hide behind. She can no longer fill pages with in-depth research or flex her talent for academic writing. Instead, she has to rely on her imagination, which is shockingly lacking considering she’s a literal fantasy author. Rather than use this opportunity to move outside of her comfort zone, Kuang chooses to retreat even further in.
Unfortunately this is a DNF for me. I read the first chapter and part of the second and can already tell this will not be something I like. The death in chapter one felt very silly and wasn’t emotionally impacting at all, not to mention the main character being pretty awful which I know is intentional but is a bit over the top. The narrative and content are just not interesting to me in the slightest.
This read provides an insight into the publishing industry and the many biases and pressures that writers face throughout their careers. No one is really a good person in this and I guess, that’s the point.
I loved the back-stories of characters, situations and absoutely anything that can be traced back to its origin, so I am more than satisifed with the flurry of details within this book. This was compelling, throught provoking and easily a read I could recommend to anyone.
This is another one of those books where I was in some ways perfectly situated to appreciate it but maybe know a little too much about publishing to be the ideal audience for it?
This is a tough one to review - on the one hand RF Kuang doesn't miss in engaging story telling. On the other hand as a white girl, I find it difficult to comment on the message of the book because it isn't really a story for me.
Thanks Netgalley for giving me a copy of this title in return for an honest review!
Im having a hard time putting my thoughts on this book into words. It was without a doubt a 5 star read for me but I also hated it in so many ways.
June/Jupiter is utterly vile and her actions are despicable even with her “justifications”. I could not stop reading to see what awful thing she’d say or do next. I despised her yet couldn’t help flipping to the next page.
R.F Kuang is a phenomena writer. The pacing is perfect and the prose is capturing. I think she excels in her commentary both on racism and the publishing industry in Yellowface. I cannot recommend this book enough and I cannot wait to hand-sell this title to customers in my own store.
R.F Kuang never dissapoints. Full review on my instagram. Yellowface is a intelligent and snarky take in modern day publishing. In Portugal, it is way more discriminatory than in the US.
Thank you William Morrow for providing me an ARC in exchange for a review.
June and Anthea, who met in college, both share a passion for writing and publishing. Anthea has enjoyed a successful career as an author, while June has struggled, leading to some feelings of jealousy. Anthea, having published several books and built an illustrious career, is currently working on a new project. In a dramatic turn of events, Anthea invites June over for a drink and tragically chokes and dies in front of her. Before leaving, June impulsively takes Anthea’s latest manuscript, reading and editing it, and ultimately takes it with her.
I was completely engrossed in this book and devoured it within a few days. The story fascinated me on several levels. It offered an interesting insight into the publishing industry and June's journey moving forward. This was unlike anything I've read before.
Absolutely unhinged and enthralling read that I could not put down. The first person narrative of the deeply unlikeable protagonist made me want to pull my hair out because she is exactly the kind of white, privileged woman that we've all met before. Juniper makes awful decisions and subsequently victimizes herself after trying to pass off an Asian author's work as her own. Reading from her perspective gives you a front seat to her disturbed and twisted reasoning, such that you will start to see how good white tears can be at convincing you otherwise.
Yellowface by R.F. Kuang is a masterful commentary on race and on the authority and ownership of diaspora stories, and includes interesting insight into social media's influence on the publishing world. As an Asian reader curious about the inner drama of publishing, I enjoyed it thoroughly and would highly recommend it!
I waited too long to read this. This was a captivating, original, intriguing story that felt REAL. Who is the villain? Do I side with the villain or the MC? This is my first book by RF Kuang and I thoroughly enjoyed it from start to finish. The first person narration fully immersed me inside the thoughts of the MC and it was perfection.
Oh wow this book is such an amazing satirical look at the publishing industry. It is brimming at the seams with unlikeable characters and if it had been a movie I’d have been watching from behind a cushion as I was cringing so bad at Juniper’s behaviour at multiple points. Fascinating and horrifying in equal measure, this would make a fantastic bookclub choice as there is so much to discuss!