Member Reviews

Love books by Arnaldur Indriadson. Nice clean plot liines. Takes you through the crime and solution as if you were right there with the characters. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I love this series! This second entry with retired detective Konrad held by attention throughout.

The main character is a retired police detective who keeps his nose in the game while trying to determine the killer of his father years ago. While aiding a friend of his late wife he finds himself pulled into a sleazy, dark situation which may bring unwanted answers to his questions. Plus a cold case with undertows of the supernatural.

Bring on the next one!

Was this review helpful?

My interest in this book was twofold: (1) I was eager to get a behind-the-scenes look at Icelandic culture and geography to get a fuller picture of this isolated island and ‘experience’ a bit of what I’d missed on our short visit and (2) I’d heard Arnaldur Indriðason was THE Scandanavian writer of crime fiction and I wanted to see why he was so popular.

I was disappointed.

Why?
✔️swearing
✔️overuse of commas
✔️stilted flow of sentences slowed my reading/comprehension
✔️inability to maintain my interest
✔️unappealing main character; extremely moody and overly introspective
✔️rambling narrative; unclear direction and slow development

Things I liked:
✔️the sense of place is excellent
✔️he wrote about a place he knows well and it shows
✔️intricate mystery
✔️unique cast of characters
✔️the succinct style; no over-explaining shows faith in his readers

I wish I’d known that I was starting on book two! I wonder if I would have struggled less if I’d had some of Detective Konrad’s backstory or if I’d have understood his outlook a bit better. I would disagree that this can be read as a stand-alone. I discovered that Konrad has been a character in multiple books and wonder if the author feels that he doesn’t need to give readers any backstory.

I was so in awe of the uniqueness of Reykjavik when we visited that I was oblivious to the darker side of the isolation - drug and alcohol abuse. Arnaldur Indriðason definitely paints a heartbreaking view of his beloved homeland and the real struggle for many of the Icelandic youth.

Please don’t let my disappointment influence your reading options. The author obviously has a dedicated following who, for the past 24 years on November 1st, look forward to his new publication. My curiosity is satisfied.

I was gifted this copy by St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.

Was this review helpful?

I really like the vibe of this book, very ominous and almost supernatural. The description and cover really do it justice. I was flying through the book every page had me hooked. And Konrad, what an interesting character. Great mystery thiller, solid 4/5.

Was this review helpful?