I think this book and series will find a wonderful audience of readers who will rank this as an instant favorite. Am I one of them? Yes and no.

Unfortunately, it took me two tries to get into this book. The opening with Yagrin felt a bit bland to me, which is really unfortunate because he ends up being such an interesting character. Once I got past that to Quell’s chapter, things picked up a lot, but I found myself wishing there was a little bit more clarity on how the world and magic system worked. I think there is something really great there, but it felt like I was missing a huge backstory.

Once I felt invested in the story, I really enjoyed it. I think some readers may be put off by how much is going on in this book, but I enjoyed the complexity. You have an almost debutante society of magic families full of secrets, wealth, and danger. Then you have your heroine, dropped into this world after being completely isolated from it and raised in a very different way. It’s a familiar setup, but the author still managed to make it feel fresh and mysterious. There is also an enemies to lovers storyline with little to no spice, which is always a fun addition to a story like this.

Overall, I feel really split about this book. I didn’t love it as much as I wanted to, but I liked it enough to read the next book and see how the story changes and matures.

*Big thanks to J. Elle, Penguin Group, and NetGalley for providing me with an e-book copy in exchange for honest review*

This story is targeted at a much younger audience than me. Trying to keep track of the characters and their flawed psyches has given me a headache. Sorry, I see some people loved it......it's just not for me.

House of Marionne had great potential, between the dark academia and magical societies, but ultimately it didn’t deliver. Told from two points of view, Quell Marionne, the daughter of a headmistress in a magical order, felt immature and difficult to connect with. The alternating point of view started strong but quickly lost momentum, leaving the plot rushed and underdeveloped.

The setting, with its school surrounded by a mysterious forest, was atmospheric, and the friendship between Quell and Abby brought much-needed warmth. However, the lack of world-building and explanation of the magic system made it hard to fully engage with the story. The romance subplot felt unnecessary and lacked chemistry, while the final chapters—when the pace picked up—showed the potential the book never fully realized. While the concept had promise, the end result was choppy, leaving the reader craving a more cohesive narrative.

I absolutely loved this story! The boarding house, the magic, the politics, it all worked so incredibly well. Such an intriguing and binge worthy story. I found characters I loved, and characters I wanted to strangle, but it made it that much more enjoyable to read with that dynamic. Also did not see that twist coming at the end! Wow!!

This was a nominee for 2023 Goodreads choice awards but that's not shocking because I really enjoyed this book. Secret society? assassins? magic? dark academia? The potential with the love interest did not feel real at all. I love the fantasy and magic with the debutante balls. Thank you so much for the publisher and Netgalley for letting me read this and the author for writing it. I can't wait to see what else this author has in store for us!

House of Marionne by J. Elle is a wild, magical ride that pulls you into a world of secrets, power, and drama. The story follows a girl named Zay, who lives in a world where magic is everything. She’s from a powerful family, the Marionnes, but she’s not exactly in their good graces. Zay has to navigate family loyalty, dangerous rivals, and a bunch of hidden truths while figuring out who she really is and what kind of power she has.

What I loved about this book is how full of twists and turns it is. Just when you think you know what’s going to happen, something crazy comes up, and you’re like, “Wait, what?!” The magic system is super interesting, and Zay is such a strong character who grows a lot throughout the book. The world-building is cool too, with all these magical houses and politics going on.

The pacing is quick, and the tension between characters keeps things exciting. The romance is there, but it doesn’t overpower the main plot, which I liked. It’s more about Zay’s journey and what she has to do to survive in her cutthroat world.

House of Marionne is a spellbinding tale of magic, love, and intrigue—captivating from start to finish!

Highschool senior, Raquell Janae Marionne called Quell has toushana that grows inside her like a curse. The Draguns are assassins tasked with hunting anyone suspected of possessing this magic. She seeks refuge with her only remaining family—her grandmother who is headmistress of House Marionne of the Order of Highest Mysteries. Receiving information requiring moving so often from her mother that she is hunted by the Draguns, because of the toushana. She gets a crash course in magical history, aristocracy, and political intrigue she receives. Latin terms and old European courtship traditions are woven into a magical finishing school tucked away in an alternative New Orleans with a population cued as racially diverse. Quell finds the debutante life both risky and rewarding as she struggles to control her toushana. There is the dangerously alluring Jordan, a young, brooding Dragun. There is growing tension between the two as Quell masters enviable abilities before her Cotillion debut. As secrets both magical and political are revealed, she learns that even the Marionnes have skeletons in their closets. Will she be able to get Jordento help her?

The novel is rich with magic throughout this fantasy. This novel has drawn me into the series after reading this first volume. It includes the House of Marionne specialties, map, and house histories which facilitates the story. I enjoyed the whole fantasy. The author has written threads of loneliness, love, and pride to compose an intriguing story of a loyal girl wanting for a place to belong. There are unexpected plot twists. It is a good beginning fr this series.

This book just wasn't it for me. It felt bland and unoriginal, which is unfortunate because I feel like this book was hyped up a lot. I ended up not finishing it.

This book was so interesting. It was like a magical high society but in a school setting. The magic system confused me a little initially. Quell and Jordan are the MCs and I wasn't sure about either at first. Their relationship seemed to develop a bit quickly. I did enjoy the magical school world building and would like more of that.

Quell has to run away and hide at her grandma's home when her magic starts to be out of control. Also this magic is supposedly evil but they don't really explain why it's evil. Unless I missed it. There's also a want to be shadow daddy called Jordan but he's kind of forgetable. He's also a dragon.

House of Marionne by J. Elle is the first book in the house of Marionne series.
 
Quell has dark magic that is called Toushana and means a death sentence in her world. She views magic as a curse and very negatively and she moves from place to place to keep hidden. Her mother did everything for her and it was quite sad to see how she was almost forgotten in the later part of the book.
 
The beginning of this book was very promising and suspenseful and Quell must survive. She was very strong but as soon as she’s in the House of Marionne all of that was forgotten and it went downhill. She is made into the perfect Marionne heir and that includes being perfect in everything and it all happens effortlessly. That was so unrealistic and Quell believes whatever they tell her, and it seemed like she lost all her characteristics. The house and all the characters stayed flat, and it was a lot of mindless conversations and thoughts. I couldn’t connect to any character and with every page I got bored more and more. The balls and tea parties were okay for networking but didn’t really have a purpose and it got boring easily. The story had a lot of potential, but everything stayed flat and only scratched the surface and that wasn’t good enough for me. And the romance was nonexistent as well and Jordan always stayed a side character, and he wasn't really a love interest to me.
 
Unfortunately, House of Marionne wasn’t for me at all and it’s one of the worst books I’ve read this year. 2 stars.
 
(Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with an arc.)

3.5 stars.

So, this book wasn't particularly unique, but it was quite enjoyable, nevertheless. At least to me. I saw one bad review saying this was like Barbie Princess Charm School meets City of Bones and Shadow and Bone, and honestly... ngl, I feel the same way - only the first S&B book, tho, yk, with the whole magic school type thing and a bunch of drama? - except I like it. There was literally a scene or two that felt straight out of Barbie, but that is fine, I am not docking anything for that. :)

SPOILERS


The romance was also nothing new, and I feel like the whole thing with Jordan trying to kill her after he finds out about her toushana - which is forbidden dark magic - and then telling her he loves her a few days later could have been handled a bit better... I mean, even if it weren't for the whole trying to kill her thing, I would think they were going a bit far with saying they loved each other. But I'm used to that at this point.

I sort of called that Octus was Yagrin. I wasn't sure, but I considered it a possibility. Also, I totally called that <spoiler>he and Jordan were brothers</spoiler> about halfway through the book. No complaints on that count tho. Sibling relationships in book are the best, whether they're strong healthy relationships, or... well... Anyway, I would like to get to see more of them as brothers in the next book, but who knows how likely that is.

END SPOILERS

There were some plot twists that I didn't call too, tho. And overall, I just found this really enjoyable for some reason. *shrugs* Anyway, I suppose I'll be reading book 2 at some point.

Unfortunately this one fell a little flat for me. It felt like there was not as much plot development as I wanted. I ended up DNFing about halfway through.

Dark academia with more promise than payoff. Every now and then when I'm reading these books, I feel like I'm reading fanfiction - decent quality, but sometimes wild mood swings and plot points that feel insufficiently developed. It's an easy read, but not necessarily a worthwhile read. And honestly, the romance in this book drives me up the wall (and gets worse in the second novel).

Also, I'm supposed to think the main character is in danger all the time but I never actually think she's in danger - the states feel low, even when I'm told they're high.

But for what it's worth, I'll probably end up reading the series through because I'm so confused about where it's going, and I want to know the answers. So there's that.

I really wanted to love this book but I think it just wasn’t for me. Dark Academia is very hit or miss for me and unfortunately this one was a miss.

This book was starting to read. I enjoyed the world development. The way the author just created all of the magic and mystery and suspense. Really enjoyed the Caswell. The main female was the one that really captured my attention while reading. I enjoyed the growth of the revelations that she had to over come and see you in this book, and I also enjoyed the story lines and how they kind of convergent and divergent at different times to add element to the plot that were either shocking or surprising.

This was a really cool start to a series. When it came out I did make a display for it, which sold well. I was recommending it to fans of The Selection!

Thank you so much to NetGalley for the ARC I received of House of Marionne!
What an amazing read - it has everything I was currently looking for in a read, dark academia, enemies to lovers. The main female character is fierce and I love her for that. The writing in this book is excellent and I cannot wait to see where the next book takes us to.

I really tried to like this book. It feels like it has aspects to be a good original story, but many of the prose this novel had going for it fell flat by the end. For a book of this length, especially the start of a trilogy, it feels like most of the events could have been summed up to make the book just about half its length. Quell and Jordan, the two main characters are about as on the nose for stereotypes as it goes for a romance fantasy series. The girl who discovers a magical world where she is an heir and the brooding bad boy in said world who acts like he hates her until they randomly fall in love. I thought the romance would make a turn for the better since the tension established, to begin with, wasn't the worst, yet it really fell flat when they both decided to randomly admit they love each other after barely any development towards their relationship. Mixing this with the fact that the two are some of the most unoriginal characters I've seen, to the point where it could even be called plagiarized, it made the romance completely unenjoyable, which is not what you want for a series being marketed as a romance series.
Along with this, I feel like we don't get nearly as much romance between Quell and Jordan as there should have been for this being a romance series. Not that I wasn't more from these two bland characters, but we spend so much filler time in Quell's shoes learning about our side characters who are even more bland than Quell, that I felt like I forgot this was supposed to be romance. There is barely any plot development. For some stories, this could work if the worldbuilding is done in a complex and intriguing way, but I feel like we learn so little about the world and magic system that I ended up more confused than anything else. We learn about Quell and her Toushana but are only told about the other magics, the ones that are normal for the characters in this world to have and bind with. We are only once shown another magic in action, which is such a shame because I was super interested in learning more about them.
This book did have two redeeming qualities which is why I have it two stars. Although the characters are bland and the world is severely underdeveloped, J. Elles's prose while telling us about these boring things slapped. I feel like she could write action scenes as well as intense moments so well with this skill, but alas we see none of this in House of Marionne. The second thing I enjoyed was only the last chapter when we saw the plot finally move. I do think it was an engaging hook to set up for the next novel with a few plot twists I did not see coming, but it is not enough to sell me on the second book unfortunately.
All in all, 2/5 stars.