Member Reviews

Thank you to Netgally and Ava Morgan for approving this Arc.


Are you looking for the perfect book for the beginning of your Spooky season?

Then I have the book for you.

The Witches of Bone Hill is about two sisters that have been estranged from each other and the rest of their family for some time, but our brought back together by the death of an aunt.

They find out they have inherited the mansion where the family has resided for centuries, the only problem is that they must stay in order to gain the inheritance from the aunt they never met.

Cordelia Bone has no other option but to stay, her slimy ex-husband cheated on her and has left her with a debt she must repay or the ones she cares about will be in harms way.

Eustace is eager to have a home to stay in, learn more about their family, and learn about the mystery of their mothers murder from whence they were younger.

Then there is the handsome but grouchy groundskeeper with tattoos that Cordelia must avoid because her track record with men has not been good, and a man with hellfire on his knuckles can't be trustworthy.

I can't sing this book's praises enough! This was marketed as horror, but I felt it was more gothic horror or fantasy with elements of horror. This story is more about finding your roots and coming back to them.

The villain was pretty obvious but at the same time there was a twist to my theory, so that was a pleasant surprise.

This book has everything!

The magic, the sisterhood, the ghosts, the romance, mystery, and elements of horror.

I always love stories where the ghosts aren't the bad guys but are just trying to help the MCs solve the mystery and uncover the truth of what happened to them and to right the wrongs of their past.

All these themes this book felt very Practical Magic meets Crimson Peak.

I do also want to add that there are some scenes that depict animal abuse and horror. If you don't want to read about that type of thing then maybe this might be a bit too dark for you.

For me I was OK, but I definitely cried during one of the scenes at the end especially, but understood why it was necessary.

4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

This book definitely has a bit of a slow start, but that is completely forgotten once you get halfway through because shit really hits the fan quick! There is so much mystery and intrigue in this book, I was surprised a few times and did not see the end coming.

I really liked our lead character Cordelia and her sister, though I do kind of wish we could have read from her perspective too. The book follows Cordelia, a middle aged woman with painful headaches and a pain in the ass (ex) husband who finds herself at Bone Hill.

I also loved Gordon and thought their romance was a perfect balance to the other tensions rising within the book.

The setting is wild because it’s basically a haunted house where stuff is just always going sideways! Every detail is so spooky and specific, it really lures you in.

The magic system wasn’t overly complicated and the lore really unfolds nicely throughout the book because we are learning along with the sisters.

Overall, I really enjoyed this book and it definitely got me hype for Halloween and the fall season! I highly recommend to anyone who’s into magic, witches, paranormal/supernatural mysteries and/or fantasies!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a wild ride and such a fun way to kick off spooky season! It combines two of my favorite seasonal themes - witches and haunted houses. But don’t let the cutesy, whimsical cover fool you - this is 𝘯𝘰𝘵 what I would call a cozy read! The magic leans more towards the sinister side of the supernatural, with darker elements like murder, curses, and vengeful spirits.

Cordelia and Eustace are sisters who have been estranged for 5 years when they are brought back together by the death of their mysterious aunt, who has left them her magnificent Victorian manor. They know nothing about the house or its long history in their family because their late mother kept them away from it.

When they arrive at Bone Hill they discover a cast of strange characters - an elderly attorney who is keeping secrets about their cryptic family history, a sexy, tattooed groundskeeper who seems mysteriously attached to the house, ghostly relatives who want revenge on the sisters, and a shadowy figure that’s been stalking the Bone women for decades. Cordelia and Eustace know they must uncover the truth about their family, and themselves, once and for all - but to do it they must work together and face an unknown darkness that threatens their lives and their legacy.

While this one started off a bit slow, after the first 30% it really gets going! I loved the sisters and how they complimented each other. The writing is very descriptive and the creepy clues kept me turning the pages as they work together to unravel secrets, decode ancient symbols and rituals, and discover their own powers. If you love ghosts, they show up right away and are an eerie, lingering presence throughout the book. Trigger warning for graphic animal cruelty (this was a tough one for me, but it wasn’t gratuitous and served a purpose in the overall plot).

While this one made me a bit uncomfortable at times with its darker elements, it was also full of hope, healing, sisterhood, a bit of romance, and the power of family bonds and legacies. I definitely recommend it if you’re looking for a witchy, haunted house story that will give you thrills and chills!

Thank you St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?

The Witches of Bone Hill by Ava Morgyn is at the same time super creepy AND unputdownable. Thank you to @netgalley and @stmartinspress for the ARC. This book is available today. If you like fantasy that tips pretty heavily towards horror, scoop this up for your fall TBR. There’s even a little romance mixed in!I could not read it before bed, but also kept thinking about it when I wasn’t reading it.

This is the story of two estranged sisters who learn that they are Nordic witches. They get a call that a great aunt they never met has died and they must travel to a small town in Connecticut to deal with the estate. And when they arrive they realize that there is nothing simple or innocent about their aunt’s Victorian mansion or the family secrets kept within the walls.

Excellent writing, definitely spooky–a win for Fall reading. And I did love the ending.

Was this review helpful?

First off this cover is amazing! This book gave me charmed vibes which made me feel all nostalgic! With the house and family being so important it locked me in for the long haul!! I felt things alongside these characters and kept going back for more. This book will leave you saying just one more chapter over and over again until you are done and you didn’t even realize you made it that far in the book. It is a build and then everything just starts happening so if you are a person who doesn’t like that I will tell you it is worth the build up.

Was this review helpful?

This story follows two sisters who travel to Connecticut to deal with the estate of their great aunt. Once there, the sisters start to uncover family secrets.
This book is a fantasy with some romance and mystery elements. Overall, I enjoyed the story. I loved the thriller and mystery aspects of the books and it kept me wanting more at times. However, I did find it dragged at times, making it difficult for me to fully get into it. It started to pick up in the last few chapters of the book and had me booked. I felt that the climax and ending felt too quick to wrap everything up, although it was very action packed! As for the characters, I had a hard time connecting with them. Still a spooky read perfect for Halloween time!

Was this review helpful?

Two sisters, each with their own problems, come together to accept a large inheritance from an unknown aunt. However, they get much more than wealth. The Bone sisters’ mother ran away from her wealthy family at a young age to the hard-scrabble life that was all the family memories that the two sisters had. Learning their history is the real gift from their dead aunt. But it is not as straightforward as the women expected. There are dark forces at work here. Will The Witches of Bone Hill be able to accept their family burdens? Will they survive long enough to appreciate their family’s unusual legacy?

Atmosphere, atmosphere, atmosphere! The overstuffed, maybe even overwrought, prose sets the creepy scene. The adjectives outnumber the verbs by ten to one. The entire plot reminds me of the Victorian era Mary Roberts Rinehart “had-she-but-known” gothic novels of my youth. Think Rebecca or Wuthering Heights if you are more familiar with old movies. This style is not necessarily bad, but it does slow down the book’s pacing to a crawl.

Whether you like the book’s writing style and pacing or not, the conclusion is definitely not to be missed. I loved the surprising end of The Witches of Bone Hill, which brings my rating up to 4 stars.

Thanks to St. Martin’s Griffin and NetGalley for a digital review copy of the book.

Was this review helpful?

If you only read one book for spooky season, this book needs to be your choice! It has everything I could want in a witchy read plus some. I went into this one thinking it would be more light hearted and the typical sisters-finding-out-they-have-powers read and I was definitely wrong. This one was far more creepy than I gave it credit for! I got serious The Haunting of Hill House vibes!

I loved all the characters, the setting of Bone Hill, the overall plot, the romance, and all the twists and turns. I basically just loved everything about this book. The hauntings were pretty creepy and gave me chills when I read at night. I will say, there is one part that animal lovers won't be thrilled about, so read the trigger warnings prior to picking this one up.

All in all, this was a total gem of a book! I give it an easy 5/5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

The Witches of Bone Hill has a little bit of everything for spooky season. There is romance, a haunted inheritance, witchcraft, magical realism, family mysteries, and sisterly bonding.

For me, this was a quick and enjoyable read. The plot moved quickly and there was plenty of action to keep the pages turning. I really enjoyed the background on the ghosts and previous matriarchs of the Bone mansion and thought the magic itself stemming from Nordic lore was a new and unique twist that I had not previously encountered before. That being said, I had an issue with a few of the plot points. The first was the entire storyline revolving Cordelia's ex-husband and the mob. To me, it was completely unnecessary and didn't really make much sense. I also wish the romance between Cordelia and Gordon didn't feel so forced. I though there could have been more interactions between the two of them that would push them together as lovers instead of just simply him looking hot and them being in the same room together.

Overall, if you like books by Alice Hoffman or Jennifer McMahon, The Witches of Bone Hill will definitely be up your alley. For many, it will have just the right amount of spooky magic and a pretty tame romance that could easily be read and enjoyed by anyone from teens to more senior adults who don't appreciate a lot of spice.

Thank you to NetGalley, Ava Morgyn, and St. Martin's Press for an Advanced Readers's Copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Witches of Bone Hill is a captivating and enigmatic novel that seamlessly blends mystery, magic, and family drama. Morgyn's skillful storytelling and well-crafted characters make this a must-read for fans of supernatural mysteries with a touch of family drama. Prepare to be entranced by the secrets of Bone Hill and the journey of two sisters discovering their hidden powers and the truth that binds them to their family's legacy.

The strength of Morgyn's storytelling lies in her ability to create a vivid sense of atmosphere. The old Victorian mansion and the crypt exude an eerie and haunting ambiance, making them almost characters in their own right. The characters, including the sisters, are well-developed, each harboring their own secrets and personal struggles.

You must pick up a copy tomorrow, September 26, 2023. Thank you NetGalley, St. Martin Press, and SMP Influencers for this advanced reader's copy.

Was this review helpful?

Close your eyes, Cordelia, her mother would say. Don’t look at them. But more importantly, Never, ever speak to them.

The Witches of Bone Hill is a perfect story for the Halloween season with it's Gothic tone, supernatural mystery, and two sisters on their own trying to figure out and survive their family history and legacy. Told all from younger sister Cordelia's point-of-view, readers come into her life as it's completely falling apart. Her soon to be ex-husband has cleaned out her bank accounts and is currently destroying her credit as he gallivants around with her former assistant, that she caught in flagrante delicto with her husband in the kitchen. As she's trying to sell her house to stay ahead of the creditors, receiving a note from a bookie threatening that she is now on the hook for her husband's fifty grand owed, Cordelia receives a phone call from her sister Eustace, who she hasn't talked to in five years. It seems the great aunt that they have never met has passed away and left them her estate, which includes a house called Bone Hill.

This place, with its gothic sensibility and family history, might hold the only answers she could hope to find about who and what their mother was, why she left, and what happened to her.

Right away the story sets the tone as the sisters are driven up to the old Victorian looking home, with it's gables, turrets, and antiques. Once inside, they discover a picture of women standing in a circle and one in the middle levitating, along with a pentagram looking shape on the floor of one of the rooms. I could feel the spookiness already creeping in and when Cordelia looks up the stairs and sees a woman in black dress and white hair, I knew the chills where on the way. Cordelia and Eustace's mom always kept them on the road, never settling for too long and never talked about her family. The sisters are confused as the home and antiques seem to point to the family having money and they start to wonder why their mother kept them from it. Cordelia sees this as an opportunity to sell and get the money she needs to pay everyone off but the estate lawyer, who claims to come from generations that have served her family, tells the sisters that they must stay at the house, as there is a contingency against them selling. The will obviously is a way to keep the sisters at the house and while it generally worked, the contingency talk later on got a bit messy and I felt myself just having to go along with it.

What concerned her more was the hulking groundskeeper and his bedroom eyes, the things he wasn’t saying more than the things he was, the effect he had on her. Men like that didn’t roll out of the womb covered in ink and defiance— they were damaged somewhere along the way. And Cordelia hated to admit just how much she yearned to know what his damage was.

Along with the estate lawyer that will have you wanting to keep your eye on him and his nephew that acts like a chauffeur, there is the groundskeeper, Gordon, who makes you want to keep your eye on him for a different reason. Adding in some romance, Gordon is a former rock star who's mother worked on the estate as a maid and then had her own mysterious death. Gordon seems to be working there as a way to grieve and maybe find out what really happened to her. Cordelia and him have some instant attraction and then it becomes what all does Gordon know and can Cordelia trust him. Since I was mostly here for the chills, I really enjoyed this little romance additive but it's definitely not the star of the show. Cordelia and Eustace trying to figure out their family history and the supernatural elements are the spotlight and they delivered.

When she opened her eyes again, she read the answer in the mirror before her, her heart icing over. In the blood dripped and spattered across the opposite wall, righted only by the reversal of its reflection, one gruesome, gut-twisting word had formed.
Witch.

The first half of this book had me thinking this would be a five star because I love Gothic mystery and this had the setting and the tone but the second half meandered a little too much and then, along with the contingency, some threads got a bit too disheveled in trying to keep the mystery alive. Cordelia and Eustace's family history was fascinating and I liked how it brought in an unexpected element of old Norse history with the supernatural. I thought the villain of the piece was pretty obvious and then when we got the whys, they had gotten too lost in stretching the story out for a little too long. The whole mob, owing money to the bookie thread really seemed unneeded to me and shared some of that messiness I was talking about, it could have been removed in favor of streamlining, cleaning up the story; Cordelia already had enough reasons to be desperate for money.

“I am what lies behind,” the woman said. “And I am what lies ahead. Hella of the Bones. Speaker for the dead. I wield the Seidr.” She drew near to Cordelia , placing a finger between her breasts. “And you are of my vӧlur.”

Cordelia and Eustace's relationship added some heart to the story, with the sisters coming together again after the five years of estrangement and Eustace had her own magical journey. While most of the tone of this was Gothic, the second half and ending did bring in some horror elements, there was very descriptive scenes of animal cruelty and general blood and gore. The magical lore created, ghosts, and human relationships all made this a spooky seasonal read that I highly recommend.

“Don’t you want to know?”
“If we’re witches?”

Was this review helpful?

This book is a perfect read to give all of the Fall vibes! There is family, drama, mystery and witches! The setting and atmosphere in this book added a dimension to the spookiness of the story. I wanted to keep reading to find out what was going on and to solve the mystery of their family secrets. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for an advanced copy! All thoughts and opinions are my own!

Was this review helpful?

I picked this book up because I like stories about witches. This was an intriguing tale of two sisters who inherit not only a house from a great aunt they didn't know, but a family history mired in secret rituals and magic.

Description:
Cordelia Bone's meticulously crafted life and career in Dallas are crashing down around her thanks to a philandering husband with criminal debts.

When her older, carefree sister, Eustace—a cannabis grower in Boulder, calls to inform her the great aunt they never met has died and they must travel to a small town in Connecticut to deal with the estate, she sees an opportunity to unload the house and save herself.

But once there, the sisters learn they are getting much more than they bargained for. The Victorian mansion they stand to inherit is bound in a dynasty trust controlled by their late aunt's aging attorney who insists they inhabit the house and retain it but keeps them in the dark about the peculiar rituals of their ancestors. Not to mention a sexy, tattooed groundskeeper with a shrouded past who refuses to leave the carriage house and a crypt full of dead relatives looming at the property line.

As both women grapple with their current predicament, they come face to face with a haunting family secret, the truth of what happened to their mother, and the enemy that's been stalking them from the shadows for generations. In a twisting torrent of terror and blood, the sisters must uncover the power within them to heal their fractured relationship, reverse their mysteriously declining health, and claim the lineage they wanted to escape but now must embrace if they are to survive at Bone Hill.

My Thoughts:
What began as an inheritance and hopes for a new beginning descended into a fight for survival as Cordelia and Eustace unravel the family secrets and try to overcome the malevolence that come with their inheritance. The story became very tense at times as the sisters faced threats. The house was full of dark secrets. The bone rituals were interesting and kind of creepy. There was some humor in the book though. I liked the characters and their desire to become part of the community (if they could ever leave the grounds of Bone Hill). I would recommend to anyone who likes witchy stories.

Thanks to St Martin's Press through Netgalley for an advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

This was so much more than I thought it was going to be. There was mystery, horror, drama and romance. I love all of these things. Combined in this one book made the story so so good. I did not want to put it down. I wanted to know all the things. I loved the sisters. I cried for Marvel. That hurt my heart. I would read more in this world if I could. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the arc in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Cordelia Bone has a secret, as in “I see dead people,” kind of secret. When her whole life blows up and she is drowning in chaos of her ex husbands making her estranged sister, Eustace, reaches out. Right when she needs it the most it appears she has caught a break and a possible windfall of an inheritance is just within her grasp. The only catch is she is going to have to learn some truths about herself and her family that she has spend the majority of her life trying not to face. The Bone sisters make their way to the family estate and finally learn about the legacy and powers they are destined to inherit. Or would be at least if mysterious forces weren’t trying to keep them away.. A murder mystery, family origins and hunky tattooed groundskeeper join the mix in the delightful and suspenseful witchy mystery. The only downside is that the stores eventually has to end. This reader would love to hear more about the Bone sisters of Bone Hill!

Thank you so much Net Galley and Ava Morgyn for the opportunity to read this and leave an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The Witches of Bone Hill by Ava Morgan was a great story about two sisters who were estranged for a period of time, but forced into a reunion due to the passing of their aunt. Quickly, they realized how much they missed each other and how without the other, there was a void for each of them. Each of the sisters have different feelings about their new situation, but also, are discovering new abilities, as they learn more about their ancestry and how their family are what their mother wanted to protect them from - the fact that they are witches.

Overall, I really enjoyed this story and watching as both Cordelia and Eustace come to terms with the information they have learned. And of course, what is any good story without a bit of suspense? The Witches of Bone Hill gives you everything you want in a book about witches and didn't disappoint me and my expectations of the book. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to review an advance reader copy of this story.

Was this review helpful?

Cordelia’s life is falling apart. Her husband has cheated on her and racked up tons of debt in her name. She is about to lose it all. Then she is notified of her great aunt passing away in a small Connecticut town. She and her estranged sister head up there to take care of her aunt’s estate. Little do they know…a family secret is looming!

This story is a little bit of everything…family drama, murder, secrets, ghosts, and of course, witches. I enjoy how this tale manipulates the reader. There were times I was afraid it was about to be a horror book, then it twisted again.

I fell for both Cordelia and her sister Eustace. Both of these ladies are so different. And their interactions with each other is classic sibling love!

Need a good witching tale for Halloween season…THIS IS IT! Grab your copy today.

I received this novel from the publisher for a honest review

Was this review helpful?

Overall: Special thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.


Content warnings: gore

Rep: sister bonds

Thoughts
Neutral thoughts:

...This was a weird book for me 🤔. And I didn't really enjoy it. I've seen a lot of reviewers compare this to Alice Hoffman and she's not an author that I have enjoyed; but if you have enjoyed Hoffman's work then I would give this a try.

I thought that the writing was fine, but I kept getting confused about what was happening. One minute the character (Cordelia) is doing one thing and then all of the sudden by the 4 sentence she's in a completely different part of the house or she's having a conversation with someone who I didn't even know was in the room. It honestly just felt like whiplash and it kept taking me out of the story.

This is a debut novel so I am giving the author some wiggle room, but this unfortunately was not my fave 😭

Was this review helpful?

DNFed this one. It just wasn’t what I expected. The writing was good, but the pace was very slow. I wanted something either a little more fun or a little more spooky. The author was trying to build the atmosphere in the beginning, but I just wasn’t feeling the spooky, creepy vibe of the house.

You may enjoy this one if you’re…
- looking for a Halloween read
- into descriptive writing
- wanting a slower paced book
- into mysterious families and their secrets

Thank you to St. Martin’s Griffin for my eARC of this book in exchange for my honest thoughts!

Was this review helpful?

I was interested in The Witches of Bone Hill for several reasons - the description sounded interesting and I thought it had a cute spooky season cover!

In this novel, we meet two sisters who inherit the Bone Family estate, but it comes with many strings attached - moving to the property, etc.

I wanted to love this book, but it just never hooked me. I read 80% of the book without feeling a connection with the characters or the story, so I set it aside and haven't gone back to finish it completely.

Was this review helpful?