Member Reviews

Are you ready for The Love Plot by Samantha Young? It's a contemporary romance about fake dating.

Rafferty Whitman, 33, is a veterinarian with his clinic in Manhattan, New York. His father, Greg, was a shipping magnate, and his older brother, Hugo, took over the family's company. His youngest sister, Georgina, is a computer genius. Hugo is married to Philippa, and they have an eight-year-old daughter, Charmaine.

Star Shine Meadows is a twenty-eight-year-old children's entertainer and line sitter. She has a bohemian way about her, and her main objective in life is to be happy and make others happy.

When Rafe meets Star for the first time at his niece's birthday party, he is a pompous jerk. He becomes interested when he sees that Star is a humble, secure individual who lives on her terms.

This story is laugh-out-loud funny; it reminds one to live your life, be true to yourself and not change for anyone, be happy, and love!

Was this review helpful?

The Love Plot is a fun rom-com jammed packed with smoking-hot chemistry and heart.

This was one addictive and swoony read. I do adore Samantha’s writing. She always seems to have this incredible ability to make her readers laugh and fall in love while still tackling some more challenging issues. The Love Plot is perfect for those bookworms who love fake dating, grumpy sunshine; opposites attract, and one-bed love stories. If you have read one of Samantha’s previous books, you know that her writing and stories are super easy to sink into. They always flow beautifully and move quickly enough to keep readers engaged and entertained. There is a lot of humour, spice, and some interesting family dynamics that I think readers will enjoy.

Star is a ray of sunshine, and she is just one of those characters that is just a terrific ball of sunshine. I loved hanging around with her; she had me laughing multiple times throughout this book. Star gives off this hippy, flightily unconventional vibe, and many people around her think she isn’t smart or possesses any moment of depth. But she does; she is passionate about life and often sees things more clearly than those people around her. She is smart and ambitious, but her ambition is geared towards living a life that makes her happy, which is a way of thinking that I love. Many characters in books go through a journey of growth or change, and I was worried that Samantha would try and change who Star is. Thankfully that doesn’t happen; instead, Star’s growth is linked to her ability to open her heart to the possibility of having a relationship with Rafe.

Rafe, Rafe, Rafe, is that perfect mixture of broody grumpy and adorable softness. I loved watching this man become bedazzled and befuddled by Star. She really just shakes his world, and he doesn’t know what to do with her or her outrageous antics. One of my favourite things in romance land is watching an uptight grumpy man have his world completely rocked by a bubbly loveable woman, and that is what happens here. He is just drawn to Star, and he loves her for who she is and doesn’t want her to change.

The romance between these two is delicious, and all I wanted was more Star and Rafe moments. I always find grumpy sunshine romances addictive when they are done right, and Samantha knocked this one out of the park. The chemistry between these two is on fire, and everyone can see the sparks flying between them. I ate up every heated look, brief touch, and sexual innuendo between these two. For those who love a romance with a bit of spice, then you will enjoy the second half of this book.

The Love Plot is an addictive rom-com that I plan on reading again and again.

Thank you, Berkley Publishing, for the arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book gives me victorian vibes, so if it does you... don't let it. It's not Victorian. It's modern day and just so adorable! I love a grump to sunshine story and this hits all the right notes! The family drama, on both sides is just such an added bonus to a grump and sunshine storyline! Just a solid story! Well done, again, Samantha Young!

Was this review helpful?

“The Love Plot” by Samantha Young is an exhilarating rollercoaster of emotions that delivers laughter and pure joy. The novel effortlessly captures the magnetic attraction between the carefree gig worker, Star Shine Meadows, and the initially uptight Rafe Whitman. Their fake relationship sets the stage for a heartwarming but steamy romantic comedy that beautifully explores the dynamics of opposites attracting. Amidst the tension and laughter, Rafe’s character shines as the kind of man every woman would want in their life. A delightful read that easily earns its 4-star rating.

Was this review helpful?

Swoon-worthy, sweet and sentimental. Star’s journey through her relationships- not just with Rafe, but with her friends, parents and even with work and love- was both relatable and emotional. On the page, her free spirited whimsy felt so grounded that it was easy to see why Rafe fell even when he didn’t want to.

Their grumpy-sunshine dynamic was so well reflected in the plot itself, and in Star’s own narrative. I kind of hoped they’d get a dog, but I really loved seeing her come full circle and bloom (burst? Idk, what’s the appropriate star analogy?).

The smut was exquisite and I loved it. 4 stars because I really struggled with the intensity of Pippa and Hugo’s disdain, as well as the conflict with Kendall and Roger which were never really explored. But this is likely a limit of trad publishing and if another book came out in this universe, I definitely would read it immediately.

Thank you to Samantha Young for the ARC. As always, this has not influenced the honesty of my review and simply served to allow me to reflect my own views instead of trying to fit into society’s boxes- Star would be so proud!

Was this review helpful?

What an adorable story. This grumpy vs. sunshine trope is such a fun and sexy read. The chemistry between Star and Rafe is off the charts and so is their witty banter.

Star Shine Meadows is as cute as her name indicates and she couldn’t be more opposite from Rafferty Whitman. Born to hippie parents, Star is all about being happy and free. Rafe, born into wealth, is all about family, career, and one day committing to marriage.

To get his mom and sister-in-law off his back about being single, Rafe hires Star to be his girlfriend. The ruse is going along well until it is not a ruse anymore and Star begins to change herself to fit into Rafe’s world. Star is forced to look deep into her heart, her insecurities and her upbringing. Both characters learn a lot about the importance of being yourself and not having to fit into the little boxes that society dictates.

Such a fun, witty story with a cast of great characters. The swoony grump and the free spirited beauty will steal your heart. It was everything I love in a romantic comedy

“I felt pity for anyone who was narrow-minded. It closed off so much of the beauty of the world to them.”

Many thanks to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Professional line sitter and character actor Star meets the grumpiest, elitest, and judgy Rafe at a client’s daughter’s birthday party. After another chance meeting, Rafe offers Star a deal she finds hard to refuse: fake date him for $10K per month. That’s more money her current jobs pay her. But once things get muddy and lines are blurred, could Star get over her commitment phobia to be with the one man she least expected? Rafe and Star couldn’t be any more opposite, but they do say, opposites attract.

This was just what I needed after a slow reading month last month. I was pleasantly surprised at how well the story was told from Star’s POV, the character growth of both MCs, the chemistry between the two, and the solid opposites attract trope slash fake dating romance. I loved Rafe and all his grumpy alpha-ness and how much he defended Star to his family. I definitely recommend to my fellow romance-lovers!

Was this review helpful?

I needed this kind of amusing entertainment but still a keep you grounded story. It feels energizing, especially when Star and Rafe meet. They are very different, but once they start opening up, they show a lot of support, understanding, and acceptance towards each other. Even when the road is not easy. One thing I would have loved was to get some of the chapters from his POV, especially at the beginning. But the story is still very good.

Was this review helpful?

That quote pretty sums this one up, and it is one wild and crazy ride! Rafe and Star meet when she's standing in line for her line sitting job and takes great delight in heckling the rich, handsome grump. Somehow this turns into a fake dating relationship so Rafe Whitman can get his family off his back about him dating.

His mother and sister-in-law are relentless, constantly sending woman his way who call him on the phone and show up at his veterinarian clinic with their four-legged friends who have imaginary problems. It really is a lot, bless his heart, and he's desperate to get out of this situation.

Star Shine Meadows is exactly how her name sounds – a free spirit with a glass-half-full attitude who never met a stranger and is kind to everyone she meets. Her parents are non-monogamous hippies and her best friends are two men and a woman in a polyamorous relationship. She and Rafe are complete opposites in every way, from upbringing and affluence to outlook and social circles. But she's just what he needs, and he’s everything she ever needed and never knew to look for.

This one has good bones and some truly hilarious scenes. The verbose narrative and introspection slowed me down and took me out of the story at times, and I’ll admit, Star was a lot. It took me a while to warm up to her, but I loved watching her grow and find herself with Rafe by her side. I’m a big fan of this gifted storyteller, and if you love her work you'll enjoy this one. Sweet, smexy, humorous, and heartfelt, this is sure to please romantic comedy lovers everywhere.

Was this review helpful?

I honestly loved this so so much!

This was a perfect grumpy sunshine romance and I had a great time reading it! Star and Rafe were the freaking cutest and I loved that they loved each other despite their imperfections.

It was heartbreaking to hear of Star's childhood and the abandonment that she received from her parents. It was beautiful to watch her character development throughout the novel! She deserved all the love and I'm so glad she was able to grow and become stable in the relationships she made with Rafe and her friends.

I loved the quirky aspects of this and it truly made for an enjoyable reading experience. The found family aspects made my heart so happy and the steam was immaculate!

That epilogue was the cutest thing i've ever read. That proposal was freaking adorable.

Overall a good time reading!

Thank you PRH Audio, Berkely Romance, Valentine PR, and Samantha Young for this arc and audiobook in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I love Samantha Young. So much. Every book I have read from her has been absolutely amazing. Cosmic Kind of Love is actually in my top 5 favorite romcoms. This was no different. I adored Star. I adored that she was her own person and did her own thing. I adored that she made her own happiness and Rafe came in and complimented it and didn’t take it over. I adored that they had such amazing chemistry and he didn’t want her to change anything about who she was, even if some of his stuffy family tried to change that. I adored how intense both characters were written. I loved that I hated Rafe in the beginning but ended up warming up to him. I loved that you could feel him falling more and more even if Star couldn’t. The only issue I had with this book was a scene in Rafe’s bathroom after they had a fight. It just felt weird to me but that’s just me. I will say that this book is 10/10 for spicy so if you’re not wanting spicy, steer clear. Personally, I thought the spicy added to it and made their relationship more real. This book was so freaking good. I can’t wait for her next one.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited to get this book before its publication date. I love everything Samantha Young writes and this did not disappoint. It’s got all the great tropes, grumpy/sunshine, fake dating, forced proximity, only one bed… I was also fortunate enough to get the audio copy from PRHaudio so I was able to bounce back and forth between audio and ebook and I loved both. It’s a really fun, feel good story, that has the spice and swoony moments we love to see.

Starr is hilarious and so bright, haha makes sense and her job as a character actor is perfect for her. Rafe is, well, a sexy vet and it’s another perfect pairing. I really enjoyed this book and would definitely recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

Happy-go-lucky, Star Shine Meadows hates being tied down which is why her two jobs--a costume character actor and professional line sitter--are the perfect gigs. They allow her the freedom a stifling career would not while simultaneously bringing joy to others. Rafe Whitman, sick of being set up by both his mother and sister-in-law, hires Star to play his fake girlfriend.

I loved this! The overall writing style and Star's voice drew me in from the very beginning. I loved seeing her journey as she grew and changed while learning to not compromise who she was deep down. I also thought the chemistry between Star and Rafe was fantastic (this is the grumpy/sunshine romance of my dreams!). Star's free spirit energy matched up perfectly with Rafe's more buttoned-up personality. However, the more we got to know the characters, the more their similarities came out and it was obvious why they worked.

Was this review helpful?

The Love Plot by Samantha Young is so entertaining and oh so swoony!!!!!

The Love Plot follows Star Shine Meadows, a bohemian free spirit that cares more about being happy than any traditional job or lifestyle can provide. She meets Rafe Whitman, a veterinarian who is tired of all the meddling his family is doing in trying to find him a wife, and he hires Star to be his fake girlfriend. Opposites attract, sparks fly, and welcome to your new favorite summer romance!

I thoroughly enjoyed the plot of this story and fell in love with Star and Rafe. Their grumpy/sunshine vibe with all the banter was so fun! I also love a good fake dating, close proximity, shared bed, steamy story!

I loved the character development in this story. Star is a professional line sitter and Disney princess character actor. She is quirky and wears her heart on her sleeve and I loved that. She is a lady you want to be your friend because she’ll jump in the ocean to save your dog or send you a care package after a rough day. She’s deathly afraid of commitment and I love the way Rafe handles that!

At first, Rafe is harsh, brooding, and cranky and really rubs you wrong but over time he became one of my favorite book boyfriends! He has a softness to him that is guarded from most but when you are in his heart, you are there to stay. I love how he loves people for who they are and doesn’t really care at all what his family thinks. He’s protective and loyal.

Both Star and Rafe have their own struggles but the way they communicate and break down one anothers walls was so tender and romantic. I love good communication in a love story!

Rafe’s family really wanted Star to be more practical, more in tune with reliability like working a nine to five job and dressing more professional. It really had me thinking about how much you should have to change yourself for someone you love? I think so many people are searching for love and it gets exhausting! Slowly people start to settle or think they have to change things about themselves to find their perfect match. I love how this is examined in this story and I think there need to be more men like Rafe out there!

Smanatha Young’s writing is phenomenal! She has such an incredible backlist and I can’t wait to dive back into it! I read On Dublin Street many years ago and loved it!

Was this review helpful?

Spice? Check.
Sizzling attraction? Check.
A HEA, after we get the fake dating and grumpy x sunshine trope? Also, check!

I really really enjoyed this book. I thought the characters were so funny and perfect one another. Rafe is so calm and cool while Star is like looking into the sun. She is so cheery and I smirked several times at her antics. Their chemistry was off the charts and I loved to see it. If you like a sweet, but smutty, read I'd recommend trying it out!

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
🔥🔥🔥

Quick Breakdown

Opposites Attract
Grumpy x Sunshine
Fake Dating
Only One Bed
He Falls First
Cinnamon Roll Hero
Found Family
No 3rd Act Breakup
Single POV
Open Door - Moderate Detail

I LOVED this. It’s my first Samantha Young, but it definitely won’t be my last!

Let me tell you, I fell HARD for Star & Rafe. I
might be bias since I’m a total simp for anything grumpy x sunshine, but I quickly found myself ADDICTED. Nothing gets me like the banter you get with a opposites attract romance. It literally gave me life & finally broke me out of my reading slump.

Star is this content, bohemian woman & unabashedly herself. I loved her for it. There were moments of self doubt, but it humanized her for me & I found it refreshingly relatable.

Rafe, the hot vet, 1000% stole the show for me. I was gone on him from the start. He played the part of the lovable cinnamon roll, disguised as a grump perfectly. He was occasionally quick to judge but could easily admit when he was wrong. How he clearly flirts with Star under the guise of “fake dating,” obviously falling first. Knowing she’s scared to commit, he pushes her the right amount. Comfortable to play the long game, knowing she’s worth it. And the way he stood up for & defended Star from his family, SWOON!

Was this review helpful?

I fell in love with Samantha writing with a kind of cosmic love and since then I've been in a hype trying to put all her books together on my tbr
.
It was hard for me to get into this plot, I missed that it wasn't dual pov, but as Rafe and Star interacted, the dynamics made more sense and I got hooked on the story, on Star's conflict of wanting to belong to someone after having grown into a free and independent person
.
Star has two jobs, one as an actor at events and the other as a line sitter, at one of those events she meets Rafe, the little birthday girl's uncle, and after having a strange conversation, their cross paths again and she doesn't miss the opportunity to answer him
.
But when Rafe offers her to work for him, posing as his girlfriend to get rid of his matchmaking family, there is no way to she can refuse, Not only is Rafe attractive, but he also offers her the amount that can make her dream of traveling across the country come true.
.
But as they spend more time together and she gets to know his family and spends more time with Rafe, she begins to wonder if she's really living the way she wants or how she learned from her hippie parents.
.
I love this type of characters who are there to support and accompany the heroine in her process . The pace of this history that kept me turning page after page and it was a delicious slow burn with a perfect grumpy sunshine
.
Thanks to Samantha young and Berkley publishing group for give a copy of this beautiful book in exchange for my honest and voluntary opinion

Was this review helpful?

If Samantha Young writes it, I know I’m going to love it. “The Love Plot” is light hearted, fun, swoony and so much fun to read.

Star Shine Meadows is a sunshine girl trying to live her best life in NYC. She works as a professional line sitter and also character for parties. When dressed as a character, she meets Rafe Whitman when she overhears him making some not so nice comments on her acting skills. Fast forward to a couple days, she sees him while in line for a job and publicly embarrasses him with some comments to match his energy from the party. Rafe is a veterinarian who owns his own clinic which is thriving. But his family is constantly trying to set him up on dates that he doesn’t want so he offers Star 10k a month to be his fake girlfriend. But as the two spend time together, the attraction both were feeling starts to surface.

I love a grumpy/sunshine and add in opposites attract and I’m a happy reader. I loved Star from the first chapter and my affection for her grew each chapter. Star is kind, genuine and just overall an amazing person. Her heart is big despite growing up with parents who always put themselves first. Rafe is a classic grump who just wants to live his life and not have his family meddle in his personal life. But hanging out with Star helps break those grumpy walls down and we get to see the real guy underneath. And I loved him so much. He’s also kind, caring and thoughtful. I love how protective of Star he is when his family doesn’t give her the warmest first greeting. And how he had no problem admitting he was wrong and apologizing for his words before he really met her. Their banter had me laughing out loud so many times and I just loved reading about them going from strangers to friends and then to lovers. It was a natural progression and just felt right. The ending was so sweet and I enjoyed this book so much.

Was this review helpful?

I really loved this story, not just for the romance & steaminess, but for the messages it gave. While this is a cute grumpy/sunshine, fake relationship romance, it also deals with some important topics, like being and loving yourself & being happy, however that looks for you. This one gave me butterflies, while also making me tear up at parts, and I honestly did not want to stop listening.

Melli’s Book Breakdown
🤍Grumpy/Sunshine
🤍Fake Relationship
🤍Hate to Love
🤍Steamy
🤍Found Family

Was this review helpful?

Loved The Love Plot! The fun cover matches the insides. The story and character were additive and right on point with everything I except from a Samantha Young story.

Was this review helpful?