Member Reviews
The Forest Grimm was interesting and a bit unexpected. I was expecting the whole red riding hood tale from the cover, but I wasn't expecting any of the other Grimm fairy tales and I thoroughly enjoyed that there were others but it felt like way too much at times.
The characters were okay, it's a slow burn so obviously it takes time for the 2 main characters to admit their feelings to each other but for some reason this slow burn just didn’t do it for me. It just seemed like from the start she was oogling over him. My favourite character would have to be Grandmere! I loved the fact she reads cards and tells futures, she was just a super enjoyable character.
It did feel like there was some plot holes, which I hope will be solved in book two ( especially after that ending ). And I’m hoping everything comes together and answers the tons of questions I have. I even have a feeling we’ll meet more Grimm fairy tale characters.
Thank you Netgalley and ST. Martins Press for an e-arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I was really looking forward to this. I've enjoyed Kathryn Purdie's books in the past, but this just fell incredibly short for me. I love retellings, and I love Grimm Fairytale retellings - especially when they're dark, moody and atmospheric - but I really didn't care for the ways in which they were altered. The whole plot felt a bit jumbled and messy. I didn't really care for the FMC or the love interest.
I had high hopes for this, and unfortunately it didn't meet them.
This was a clever book with a twist on the classic Grimm fairy tales blended into the storyline. Main character, Clara is obsessed with finding her missing mother in the Forest Grimm. When the opportunity presents itself, she ventures into it along with her close childhood friend, Axel. But things definitely aren't always as they appear in the woods here and they are constantly rearranging themselves. You'll be lucky to find your way out when the time comes.
Yet, Clara and Axel each have their own reasons for being there - - their own burdens so to speak. And then another friend finds her way to them as well and their search gets even more complicated.
In addition to looking to rescue other people, Clara is desperately trying to resist the pull she feels to Axel. She tells herself that he isn't meant for her but for another. But is that really true? And how does Axel feel?
Of course, you have a big wolf, a red cape, some other scary fairy tale characters and some that aren't supposed to be scary. It all blends together to be a twisty and fun read.
Apparently this is the first book of a duology. I could have been very content with this being a standalone. I hope that the second book doesn't take away from the nice feeling of completion that I had when I wrapped up this first book.
AUDIOBOOK REVIEW: I toggled back and forth between the audiobook and the ebook. I didn't mind the narrator's voices, but I did struggle to keep up with the storyline when I was listening to it as opposed to reading it. I'm not sure what made this book different from others for me, but I found myself reading it to finish because it was easier for me. 4 stars
Thank you to NetGalley for ARC's of both the ebook and audiobook. I voluntarily chose to read/listen to and review both of them.
Thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for the Advanced Readers Copy in exchange for my review.
I will admit I went into this book with lower expectations because I had seen reviews saying it leaned towards the younger scale of YA. However I ended up finding myself easily lost in the story, and I tore through the last 200 pages.
Does it feel younger sometimes? Yes, mostly in that it feels like innocent young love, the no I can't like him that's crazy sort of cliché, as well as the main characters single minded focus on finding her mother. However I never found it detracted from the story, and well I am reading YA I cant get mad for a YA book having YA things in it lol.
The best selling point is the reimagined fairy tales are fantastically creepy, but not in the ways I thought they were going to be. They were unique enough that they kept me on my toes unsure how the solution was going to play out. Which to me is very important in a reimagining, you want it to be familiar but not tired and overdone, this hit that balance nicely.
Ultimately I liked this book better than other more lauded books I've read this year. And far better than other reimagining's I've read. I believe the physical copy is coming to me in a book box next month, and I will be excited to display the special edition on my shelf. I hope many others will give it a chance.
Thank you to NetGalley for giving this ARC, and this doesn't influence my review. This was a unique take on fairytales, and I enjoyed all of it! The romance was swoon-worthy, and I am obsessed with the forbidden love trope. Overall, I suggest reading it!!!
The forest is Grimm, as Grimm as the brothers and as twisted as their tales. This is a marvelous retelling of several Grimm tales while Clara, Axel, and friend Henni head off on a quest to save others lost in the woods and return them while to their village. Clara is ostensibly Little Red Riding Hood, and she does rescue a few others, Rapunzel, Cinderella, and Hansel and Gretel, along with the Big Bad Wolf. But others remain and it is likely a sequel is brewing. Absolutely a delightfully noirish deep dive into childhood folk tales by an author with a vivid imagination.
I received an eARC of this book for review from St. Martin’s Press via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.
• The Brief: Clara is eager to make a wish… one carefully crafted to free her mother and her town. She will have to journey through a vindictive magic forest with her best friend to get the opportunity.
• If you liked Once Upon a Time, this YA novel featuring characters from familiar tales by the Brothers Grimm may just be up your alley.
This fairy tale mashup features Little Red Riding Hood along with numerous other recognizable characters. Told in 3rd person past-tense, this is a coming of age fantasy romance with a heavy emphasis on the fantasy. There is disability representation, the protagonist Clara has scoliosis. I can’t speak to the quality of the disability rep, but it was present throughout her travels in the forest.
The world-building is interesting – linking the mostly mundane village with the dark fae-inspired magic filling the unknown magical woods and all those inhabiting it. The blending of new ideas modifying familiar tales was the best aspect of this book for me.
The plot was interesting if somewhat convoluted. Still, the author did a good job twisting the familiar in interesting and entertaining ways.
3.5 Stars rounded up
This story was much creepier than I anticipated! The forest was home to some very sinister villains - the murderous Cinderella and her menagerie of dead animals comes to mind. It was fun to see the twists on classic Grimm characters like Red Riding Hood and Rapunzel.
These weren’t some of my favorite characters I’ve ever read, but I think a lot of that has more to do with me being a 32 year old lady reading books about 17 year olds than the characters themselves. They felt young and naïve to me, but they ARE young and naïve. I admired Clara’s courage and Axel’s optimism. Henni is who I struggled with the most - her complaints annoyed me, especially since she forced herself into this entire situation.
I thought the writing was a bit simple and the story could have benefited from a more descriptive style. The conclusion left me slightly confused, and I’m hoping that maybe in the second book of this duology we’ll get a bit more of a clear understanding of the curse and how Clara’s magic works.
Thank you NetGalley for an advanced copy of THE FOREST GRIMM by Kathryn Purdie.
Things I liked:
1. The creepy, twisted take on the more innocent characters from fairy tales. Just so, so great.
2. The romance once it really got going and was sweet and even kind of hot at a few points.
Main thing I didn't like as much:
It took too long to get to the good parts. I'll be honest that I ended up skimming a bit. Once it got to the creepy fairy tale people, I got more into it, but still kind of had to skim to get to the real good parts. I kind of wish the atmosphere of the whole book had fit with the creepy parts. A lot of it felt a little too much like overdone YA fairy tale retellings or YA fantasy in general, and not enough like the cool, different, twisty stuff. I just wanted more of that.
Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin’s Press for an ARC of The Forest Grimm!
This was such a unique story about a girl willing to risk everything to save the people she loves, with some twisted fairytales added in! I loved the concept of this book, but the overall plot and writing style were not for me. I found certain elements to be very repetitive and cheesy, but it was an intriguing story.
One of the things that most intrigued me about this story was the idea of a magical forest filled with twisted versions of well-known fairy tales. I was just talking with someone the other day about how many of the versions we’re most familiar with are very different from the darker original versions. I liked the idea of including references to those darker stories in a new tale.
And that’s one of the elements I enjoyed most about reading this book. I really liked the forest, too. It felt old and dark and filled with deadly magic. The story centers around Clara and her developing relationship with Axel, a plotline that I also followed with interest. I think I would have enjoyed a little bit more focus on Henni’s relationship with Clara. The way the story ends left me hopeful that Henni would be a critical character in a follow-up tale. All I can say to that is, yes, please!
On the whole, I think readers who enjoy reimagined fairy tales or books like THE GREYMIST FAIR by Francesca Zappia will definitely want to give this one a read.
Note: I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Thoroughly enjoyed the book. This book is Little Red Riding Hood meets The Grimms Fairytales (hence the Forest Grimm). Our main girl Clara lives in a small village on the outskirts of the forest where magic runs wild. Thanks to the magic of the forest her village was blessed with a magical book called Sortes Fortunae. Once a villager turns 16 they are given the opportunity to make one wish using the book, but when someone uses their wish and it results in someone’s death the forest becomes angry and curses the village. The curse results in people wandering into the forest never to be seen again. When her mother becomes the first lost one Clara vows to bring her home, and now she finally has her chance when she discovers a way to enter the forest. Now Clara and her friends must find all the lost ones who believe they are characters from Grimms Fairytales (including Rapunzel, Hansel & Greek, and more..). But entering the forest comes to save her mother comes at a great cost, because Clara’s fate says she will die in the forest.
This book was filled with all the dark fantasies! Cinderella, little red, Rapunzel, sleeping beauty and Hansel and Gretel, with all the little twists and turns. I really enjoyed reading this book. This reminded me of the brothers Grimm, and it kept me in ruptured in the story from start to finish.
Going into this book, I knew it was going to be a fairy tale mashup and that actually worked better for me as a reader. I didn't try to figure out what parts of the story were going to be part of a strict retelling and I just turned off my brain and let it all go. The beginning was a little slow, but once I was about 25% of the way in, the story picked up and I was ready to find out what stories Purdie would use.
One jarring moment was Clara using a character's name despite never having met the character or the character introducing themselves. Hopefully this issue is caught in final edits.
I did not know this book was pitched as Grimm's fairy tales meets The Village, but I picked up on The Village aspect quite early. Clara's grandmother speaks French, but no one in their village knows this language. The setting seems to be a forest, but no country or economy is given. It's like this little village just exists beside the forest, which gave some wonderfully creepy vibes.
The book's tone is distinctly YA (this is a good thing) and I feel that it is appropriate for younger teens. It was nice to read a YA book that felt geared towards teens both in content and story structure.
The book is the first in a series, but I felt that it could have been a standalone. The main story was done, and it felt like the epilogue was tacked on to make a duology. I'm not sure if I'll read a second book because the story did feel completed.
Thank you to St Martin's Press and Netgalley for the arc for review purposes.
The moment that I read the synopsis for this book I knew I was going to absolutely love it, and it held up to that expectation. I'm a sucker for a fairytale kind of vibe or retelling. It's always drawn me in, and snares my attention and interest real quick.
Page after page I never wanted to put this down. It's so good, and I've heard so many great things about this author. I own some of her other books, but haven't had the chance to read them yet. I definitely want to soon. I love the way she tells a story, and how she creates and builds the world within the story and the characters.
Thank you NetGalley for an arc of this book.
I think this book had some good ideas, but at times the plot seemed to slow to a crawl.
I liked the interesting dark twists on some of the classic fairy tale characters. Cinderella was especially creepy.
Thought that the relationship between Axel and Clara was sweet.
Unfortunately I had major problems with the plot. It meandered all over the place, and had some sections that didn’t seem to propel the story forward. I also really didn’t like the cliffhanger and the tease of the next book at the end. It was so obvious I felt like I was hit over the head with it.
Overall, this was just an ok read for me.
Thank you to St. Martins Press and Netgalley for providing me with an ARC of this book.
The Forest Grimm is a fantasy romance—with a twist on the Grimm’s fairytales. I thought the way the different tales were worked into the Little Red Riding Hood inspired main story was really clever and well done. The fantastical with an edge of creepy definitely lives up to the original Grimm’s vibe.
I liked the main characters and their interactions with each other and I found the writing style and world building really easy to get into which made for a quick, enjoyable read. I’m really looking forward to the next book after that cliffhanger epilogue!
I love this, spooky forest is one of my favorite tropes, love the old fairytale inspiration, feels like a dark fairytale with cameos of beloved characters like Rapunzel, Hansel & Gretel but made them creepy.
Clara is sure that she knows how and when she is going to die, as the cards have told her, and when The Forest Girmm begins to enchant people, Clara looks for a way to enter it, recover the magical book, and break the curse.
She lives in a special town because they have the Book of Fortunes, the residents can make a single wish, and the book will help them fulfill it; someone used their wish to kill someone, but now the book disappeared and the forest cries out for revenge and lore people to enter and never return. The town sends people to appease the forest but they have no success in entering it until Clara finds a way, using a rare flower. She will not go alone, Axel and Hanni accompany her. They have someone lost, Clara her mother, Axel his fiancée and Hanni her sister (who is Axel's fiancée)
Love the setting, it's creepy, the forest is not what it used to be, the trees have a life of their own, the roots attack you, everything moves from place, there are also poisonous mushrooms and berries, a wolf that does not stop following them and when they find the lost people, they are no longer what they were, now they are murderers; what an adventure.
The characters are likable, the friendship is sweet and the romance is a slow burn. The ending is not completely closed, but it does not have a shocking cliffhanger, it can be enjoyed alone. This was atmospheric and perfect for autumn if you want something with fairytale vibes, romance, mystery, and spooky. Also, this is a Young Adult and feels younger than adult.
Read it if you want:
• Creepy Forest
• Dark Fairytale inspiration
• Cursed town
This is a dark re-imagining of the Grimm fairy tales. I likes how the story weaves some of the popular Brothers Grimm's fairy tales like: Little Red Riding Hood; Hansel and Gretel and Rapunzel. This dark story focuses on Clara who travels into the forest with Axel in search of something that will help her village that is cursed. By going into the Forest Grimm, Clara tries to find out the secrets of the Garden in hopes that she will be able to help her village.
This book is a Duo logy series, and I am looking forward to book two of this series. I'm a fan of dark YA tales when they are done right.
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the opportunity to review this book.
The Forest Grimm takes those familiar fairy tales you know and turns them upside down. Hansel and Gretel, Rapunzel, Sleeping Beauty, Cinderella and Little Red Riding Hood all make an appearance, and they’re all delightfully dark and twisted.
At the center of the story is Clara, a young woman who is desperate to find her mother. Clara’s only thoughts have been about taking on this monumental task. But when she finds herself alone with Axel, she realizes there’s more to her fate than just saving her mother. Clara’s fairly single-minded when it comes to her destiny. She’s thought things through. But she’s only been looking at them one way. With Axel comes a new way of thinking and a future Clara never dared to dream about.
Author Kathryn Purdie deftly intermixes familiar tales with her own imagining, creating something entirely new. Her pacing is solid and there are some nice surprises in store
The Forest Grimm is a fast-moving adventure, mystery, fantasy and romance all mixed into one. The book ends with a big twist, and I’m excited to see where Purdie takes the story next.