Member Reviews

This was a rough read. The kernel of the story was good but it needed a very strong editor. So much of the plot doesn’t make logical sense, and it’s obvious that certain actions were forced into the story to move the narrative along even though they don’t work. Even the basic idea of the school and the related hospital- none of it makes sense in the age of Instagram. The school “changes” the IGs for people when they need to erase memories of instances that happened but like, how? There’s a party with about 50 or so people there and not all of them go to the wacko school, so how did they miraculously delete everything and make everyone forget everything that happened? One of the main characters is an adult and just goes missing/is abducted and no one in his school/town/family notices or cares and it’s not even addressed. It would be one thing if all the students/patients were cut off from technology and their family, but they’re not, and the idea that NO one seems to notice any of the bonkers stuff happening is ridiculous. Especially because the school/hospital seems to be run by like 5 boomers with really bad villain caricatures for personalities. One of the villains wears Manolo Blahniks and whistles at her security guard henchmen. And I’m supposed to believe she is tapped in to the social life and digital footprint of high-schoolers? Just glaring, gaping plot holes throughout. I’m also not sure if the author and/or the story is British or American, because there are conflicting elements. The cover art was gorgeous, and again, the idea of the story was interesting, but this read like a first first draft.

Was this review helpful?

Alexandra Shaw is the new kid at a reform school and no one wants to be the new kid. She luckily has new friends and they are even the popular kids but she also has the trauma of having killed her father in a car accident. As the book progresses Alexandra has visions that seem like memories but they don't fit her current life, is she going crazy? When an encounter from someone that says they know her and that her name is not correct, that they used to date, and they were told she was dead she starts to spiral down a rabbit hole of what is really going on in her life. While I enjoyed the twist and turns however I never felt truly invested in any of these characters. 2.5 stars

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick and fun read. I enjoyed the characters and though it was a little predictable I really liked it. The twists and turns were good too!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and BooksGoSocial for allowing me to read this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

There are rumors and secrets found in most high schools. Popular crowds, bullies, and comic book nerds are all universal. Yet behind the gates of Pine Cliff Academy, the secrets are more sinister; there are rumors of children locked up in the basement, teenagers going wild and jumping off the cliff into the wild sea below. But is any of it real?

Alexandra Shaw is new to the Academy. Luckily popular girl, Kayla, swooped in and saved Alexandra from being a social pariah. Because with Kayla, and the thoughtful Hannah by her side, maybe no one will look too closely at Alexandra, since it's common knowledge that she killed her father. If only it were that easy. Alexandra knows that it was an accident, but still carries the guilt. She tries to be the perfect daughter, so her mother won't resent her. Won't look at her in that disappointed way anymore. And for awhile things were getting better. Until Alexandra started having visions of a boy.

Alexandra's body knows this mystery boy. Knows his touch, his heart. But she doesn't remember him. Until she does. Until she starts to remember a lot of things, things that don't make any sense.

This was a very quick read! There was a lot of action, and while I guessed a good majority of what was to come, I still enjoyed seeing how the author brought it all together. I enjoyed this book but really wish that the author had dove in deeper. I felt like a lot of the characters were one dimensional, and I didn't feel the chemistry between Alexandra and the MMC. To be honest, there wasn't a lot of time spent together before they were rushing off to the next thing. I think if the pacing of this slowed down a little and more time was spent developing the relationship between these characters it would have been a five star read.

Some trigger warnings: abuse, self-harm, eating disorders, family trauma, murder, death.

It does end on a cliffhanger (LOL) so there is more to come and be explored within this world. Most of the novel takes place at the Academy itself, so I hope the author decides to expand the world a little more and we can experience so much more from this world and the characters!

Was this review helpful?

this was a really good! I liked the characters, and they were super well-developed. the plot was super cool and fun to read, and the writing was also smooth and easy to understand
highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

Check for all TWs before reading this book!

The Unforgettable Alexandra Shaw is a very intriguing novel with unexpected twists and turns to a very mysterious story. I was fascinated with the unique title and beautiful cover of this book when I first saw it and it indeed has a promising, chilling thrill to it. Alexandra and the other characters in this book were the typical cliqué in every fictional highschool setting, but the plot was written quite well as it traversed through friendships, falling in love, redemption, and reclaiming one’s identity through remembering. The storytelling was incredibly fast-paced and it never fell flat. This author definitely knows how to write an exhilarating story. I felt gaslit throughout the entire book, which was perfect as it painted the atmosphere in such a dark manner and conveyed what the author really wanted. This book is perfect for Teen and YA readers seeking mystery and a riveting adventure. I can’t wait for the next book!

Was this review helpful?

This was such an exciting read! Full of twists and mystery! This book is a ya sci-fi thriller about a young girl who kills her father but that's not the end of the story. She goes on a journey to discover the truth. I love the cover too!

Was this review helpful?

#TheUnforgettableAlexandraShaw #NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an E-Arc copy of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

Where to start?…… I LOVED THIS BOOK.
This SF is very well written, we became completely addicted by all the plot-twist.
We follow Alexandra Shaw, who after a car crash killing her father, tried to have a normal life in her new school. She also tried to reconnect with her mother, whom she thinks ressent her for the accident. Sinking both of them into grief.
‘Til she « meets » Logan who claim to know her, leaving her confused an with doubts, not knowing if her sudden visions are only a trick of her mind or reel memories.
We also have really good characters, all with a different story, that we could think as typical high school character. The Queen Bee, Kayla with her more reserved friend Hannah the both of them always attached to the hip, Kyle the Bully, Scott the director’s son and of course, Kayla’s older friends who are in University. But in this, nothing is typical or normal, and everyone has reasons to be here. I only have one advise for you, Don’t trust everyone.

I’m waiting now for the second books this fall ;)

PS: this cover is absolutely SUBLIME

Was this review helpful?

Oh my stars, what a cliffhanger! I can't wait until the second book comes out…
I loved Alexandra's character; she is a realistic teen, thinking about school and friends but similar to Trueman in the Trueman Show, people keep giving her hints about what is really going on and she repeatedly doesn’t pick up on it ,but you do 😉 she’s preoccupied with other things, like her guilt about her dad and her difficult relationship with her mom. Eventually, she works out that things in her life are not what they seem and that people are constantly lying to her and something more sinister is going on. You keep rooting for her to connect the dots and do something about it, before it’s too late. Really enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

A very enjoyable fast-paced YA read with multiple twists. This was easy and quick to read but kept me engaged and wanting to read the next book in the series.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun book that kind of reminded me of Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. I look forward to reading the sequel. I don’t want to write any spoilers but I enjoyed the pace of the book and the surprise twists. I received a free copy of this book from netgalley and the publisher in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book, I didn’t guess the twists and had a good time. It won’t be one I reread in the future but I’m glad I read it when I did

Was this review helpful?

I was really excited going into this book. It was such an interesting concept. There was just something about it that missed the mark for me. I haven’t quite figured it out yet but unfortunately, this book wasn’t fully for me.

Was this review helpful?

Big thank you NetGalley and to the publisher for the chance to review this book pre-release. Yes yes yes. I loved this book SO much. It brought me on a ride, and I was hanging on the whole time in anticipation of the adventure. A more formal review will be available on my IG/TikTok and Goodreads, but I already purchased a copy for friends!

Was this review helpful?

Alexandra is seventeen and trying to make sense of her life after accidentally killing her father. She just wants to find her place in a new school, mend things with her mom, but nothing is that simple. Enter Logan, who claims that not only does he know her, but she herself was killed in the accident. Together they start digging up a terrifying truth about her school and events quickly spiral out of control for Alexandra and those around her. With no one to trust, she races to piece her life together before it's too late. The Unforgettable Alexandra Shaw is an exciting debut novel full of twists and turns - I'm usually good at guessing endings but this one caught me off guard which I loved. With its captivating story and gripping suspense, this book was definitely a page-turner! Thank you Netgalley for the ARC in exchange of this honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Love that spectacular cover; the deftly done mix of mystery, sci-fi, and fantasy; the amazing worldbuilding; plus the twisty plot that kept me rapt. Teen and YA readers will especially enjoy THE UNFORGETTABLE ALEXANDRA SHAW, and wait as excitedly, as I am, for the sequel slated for fall. Recommended!

Was this review helpful?

Review in progress and to come.

I received a free copy of this book via NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving a review

Was this review helpful?

The Unforgettable Alexandra Shaw is an easy to read teen mystery with some science-fiction/thriller undertones. Readers followed a 17 year old girl, Alexandra, as she tried to fit into a new school after having to completely relocate after losing her father in a car accident. Alexandra doesn't know who to trust as she uncovers some secrets about her identity throughout the book whilst also having strange visions about a boy she hadn't yet met. Plot-wise, I felt that the premise of the book was extremely interesting and did keep me intrigued as to what would happen next - I was able to read this in two sittings as it was difficult to put down - however, I feel that the book could have been executed slightly differently as everything seemed a little too easy for the main characters and there didn't seem to be any true consequences for their actions. It was obvious that everything would turn out well for the main characters as nothing really seemed at stake - especially as it was mentioned that the memory-wiping procedures could fail and forgotten memories could be re-triggered. Alexandra was a very difficult character to like as, throughout the book, she didn't seem to stay true to her character and appeared to make wild decisions that didn't seem realistic. I also didn't care too much for her friends or her love interest as we, the readers, didn't actually know much about them - they were just there in Alexandra's story.
Overall this book was a quick and easy read but may have more suited towards a reader closer to the protagonists age (although I am only 23...?). While I won't be checking out the sequel, there is already a good mystery being set-up which I can see other people enjoying.

Was this review helpful?

Alexandra Shaw is your typical teenager from the outside, she attends a private high school, has friends that she adores, and can sometimes struggle to get along with her mom. But Alexandra was in a car accident that killed her father, and she was the one driving... At least, that's what she was told. Until she meets Logan, who tells her that her father wasn't the only one who died in the crash, she had too. While Alexandra struggles through the grief and guilt of killing her father and the confusion that Logan adds to the equation, we follow as she attempts to find out more about her life <i>before</i>.

Overall, I found this book to be pretty enjoyable. It was an easy read but at times i found the writing to be kind of slow and repetitive. That being said, the story kept my attention and I really found myself speeding through the pages, wanting to find out what would happen next. This book really gave me <i>Wilder Girls</i> by Rory Power vibes. Though the premise isn't exactly the same, I found myself almost getting the storylines intertwined. I ultimately decided to rate this three stars because while I did enjoy it, there was just something missing for me and I can't quite put my finger on it. However, I am really looking forward to checking out the final book in this series when it comes out in the fall. The ending of this book was very intriguing and I'll definitely be thinking about it for a while to come.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ebook ARC of this book!

Was this review helpful?