Member Reviews

A string of women, including Lucy’s sister, Nicki, have disappeared. The Garda are stumped. Lucy decides to take things into her own hands by turning herself into bait. The twist did not quite work for me, but this was still solid. Thanks to NetGalley and Blackstone for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was really excited to read this thriller and I was not disappointed. I don't particularly love the sort of run run kill kill thrillers that are essentially races from killers, and I worried this had the potential to be that but thankfully it did not fall into those tropes and standards.

I also have always loved the missing sister/brother storyline with the vigilante or detective sibling that refuses to give up even when everyone else has and is out to find justice for their beloved sibling bc nobody else will do it but them, and this is one of those storylines. Lucy's sister Nicki disappeared many years past and Lucy has not been able to forget or move on, she is consumed with the need to bring her sister's murderer to justice. It was one of those glorious thriller endings where the author manages to weave together multiple storylines that had been moving along consecutively and twist them all up and bring them all together in one explosive finale. Those are my favorite and Catherine Ryan Howard delivered..

The writing was also above average writing for a thriller, I did not feel any of those cringey moments when you come across a very poorly constructed sentence, or else a very basic sentence or set of sentences that makes you feel the book was written by an eleven year old. I thought this was a solid reading experience that hooked me from the very beginning and kept me very engaged till the end, when I had no idea what was coming. There's nothing than a thriller that leaves you truly stunned by the twists and reveals, this book did that more than once for me. Solid 4 star thriller, a good one but not the GREATEST. Def recommend to anyone looking for a creepy fast paced read.

Was this review helpful?

Sometimes, you just have to bump a book straight to the top of your TBR pile…

An ex-boyfriend once told her that his favorite part of a night out, was walking home, just him and his thoughts on a deserted street. He didn’t need to walk to the front door with his keys squeezed between his fingers, ready to scratch or disable. He didn’t need to text a thumbs up before he went to sleep so that someone at the receiving end could sleep too. The part of the night HE loved, was the part that SHE had to survive.

And, yet, she sets a TRAP, night after night, walking the desolate streets where her sister was last seen, hoping to attract a monster.

And, that realistic, opening chapter when she voluntarily GETS INTO THE CAR-is TERRIFYING!! (Shout out to the Cover Art!)

Three women have disappeared, never to be seen again.

Tana Meehan, legally separated from her abusive husband was the first. Nicola (Nicki) Sullivan, who was last seen leaving a Pub after drinks with friends was next. And, 17 year old, Jennifer Gold vanished while out walking her dog, who returned home without her.

Operation Tide was formed when the girls were linked because their smashed cell phones were all found at the scenes where they were last seen.

When Angela Fitzgerald, a Gardai support staff member member for the Missing Persons Unit (MPU) receives some “physical evidence” brought in by a Charity Shop employee, she finds herself teamed up with a fast rising Detective, Denise Pope, who has been the Family Liaison Officer (FLO) for two of the families with missing women.

Could there be fourth Victim?

“You’re not being told everything. Call me, and I”ll tell you”

Lucy Sullivan, who is currently living with her sister’s boyfriend, Chris, has admittedly been RECKLESS as she searches for answers into her sister’s disappearance. So, when she gets that message from former tabloid correspondent, turned “True Crime Expert” Jack Keane, she bites.

She cannot move forward without answers, or stop herself from doing “stupid things”.

And, interspersed with the chapters of Lucy, and the two women who have teamed up to investigate the crimes outside of “Operation Tide”, are some from the first person POV of the ABDUCTOR-deemed “The Phantom” by that author who wrote the book, “The Nothing Man”.

He will CONFIDE to us, how he succeeds in getting his Victims into his car, AND how he chooses his VICTIMS, and you, yes YOU, might recognize yourself as a person he may have preyed on.

How CREEPY is that?

Catherine Ryan Howard, delivers YET AGAIN, with her latest, and I was thrilled to receive an early copy. No regrets on moving this one straight to the top of my TBR! It will make my favorites list for 2023.

I am still thinking about the ending!

Expected Publication Date: August 1, 2023-available to pre-order now.

Thank You to Blackstone for the gifted ARC provided through NetGalley. It was my pleasure to offer a candid review!

Was this review helpful?

This book was good. I was not expecting the twist with the main character. I enjoyed the perspective of the two different characters. It was interesting to see 'the other side' and the thoughts of the villain.

Was this review helpful?

This was HARROWING and twisty and upsetting and amazing. I don't want to say much about the plot, other than: it is dark AF and excellent. I love Catherine Ryan Howard with the fire of 1,000 suns, and The Trap is up there with 56 Days and The Nowhere Man as my favorites of hers. Read this!

Was this review helpful?

[arc review]
Thank you to NetGalley for providing an arc in exchange for an honest review.
The Trap releases August 1, 2023

I am OBSESSED! Wow, this is the best thriller I read this year so far! Let me tell you, this is my first book from the author and I love her writing style! Smart, heart pounding, elaborate crime fiction with lots of references to true crime. I did not see the plot coming, yaaaay. Enjoyed the short crisp chapters, without cringy inner monologues. I connected with the two badass female detectives from the get go. Would love to read more stories featuring them, like a future series! Another plus....its funny, nice palette cleansers throughout the story!
Thank you NetGalles for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks @netgalley for read number 54 of 2023. I have some mixed feelings on this book. I’ve loved all of @cathryanhoward’s books that I’ve read, and this book is as fast-paced with as many twists as her previous ones. It’s as things all come together in the end that I struggled a bit. I’m still somewhat unclear on how part of the storyline was figured out, and the twist at the end, almost seems a bit much for me. It’s a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ book for holding my attention, but with a couple of areas that I wished were a bit more flushed out. Have others read this? What did you think?

Was this review helpful?

A young woman accepts a ride from a man in the middle of the night in a desolate area of Ireland. Catherine Ryan Howard begins The Trap with heart stopping tension and fear. Is he a nice stranger offering a ride, or is he the horrifying monster she hopes he is who took her sister and is accepting her bait?! The author references a time in Ireland when several women tragically went missing and the cases were never solved. This story starts with a fictional Lucy, whose life is unbearable not knowing what happened to her sister. There are several missing young women so the Garda create a task force called Operation Tide. Are all the cases connected? The tale is told in multiple POVs, including Detective Pope, Angela, a civilian volunteer in the Missing Person Unit, and the killer. Chapters by the killer are creepy and chilling. The author keeps you on the edge of your seat with unexpected twists and turns and a very clever ending. The Trap is a great read for readers of mysteries and thrillers! With thanks to Netgalley and Blackstone Publishing for this ARC. My opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The premise is fantastic but this moved a little too slow for me in the beginning. I stuck with it because of so many fabulous reviews and I'm glad I did. Once I hit around 50% it really picked up. The ending was really good. It's hard to surprise me but that got me.

Was this review helpful?

This book is written from several perspectives, not my favorite style, but it seriously works in this case. It broadens the viewpoints and helps to break a bit of tension…yes! Lots of tension and suspense!
It is very well written and a chiller- had my stomach in knots a few times!
Highly recommend for suspense/mystery thrill lovers

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this. It gave me a lot of tana french vibes and it worked so well. The gritty ambiance matched the moodiness of the setting and plot. I can’t wait to read more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Blackstone Publishing for an advanced review copy.

I was nervous going into this book because it was my most anticipated book of the year. I can just go ahead and identify myself as a CRH fangirl. This is my seventh read from Catherine Ryan Howard and.... I'm happy to report it might even be my favorite! That is saying a lot considering I've given all of her books 4-5 stars. I loved everything about this. She layers a compelling mystery with genuine tense thrills. I also loved the commentary on our consumption of true crime as a society. The writing was fantastic as usual with relatable characters I could root for. I was genuinely shocked at one point. Like completely floored which is so unusual for me these days. Typically, I see twists coming from a mile away, but I threw my iPad onto the couch in complete shock at one point and stared at this book like it was a white-hot poker in my hands because she GOT ME. Definitely worth it. Add it to your preorder list. Pub: 8/1 in the US.

Was this review helpful?

Wheewwwwww. <i>What.</i>

Full disclosure before I dive in, I received this book from NetGalley and Blackstone Publishing in exchange for an honest review. And that's what I'm going to deliver!

😳😳😳😳😳

Catherine Ryan Howard is one of my favourite authors, and <i>The Trap</i> is a banger. If the ending had been a smidge more satisfying, I think I would have enjoyed it that much more and bumped it up to a solid five stars.

<i>The Trap</i> alternates POVs. Between Lucy, who is doing increasingly dangerous things whilst searching for her missing sister, an unnamed killer, who compares hunting women to scaling Everest, another unnamed character who I won't discuss for spoilery reasons, and Angela, an aspiring Guard with the Gardai and probably the most likeable character of the bunch. Not hard, given one of them is a sociopath, but still. She's a treat.

From the synopsis, you've probably gathered that Lucy goes out in the night, trying to lure her sister's kidnapper to pick her up in his car and thereby lead her to the truth she's desperately searching for. What happened to Nicki? What happened to all the women who've vanished into the night, their phones broken skeletons on the ground, their memories blighted by the agony of not knowing?

I have very complicated feelings about this book, and about the ending. I won't discuss because Catherine Ryan Howard pulls a major wtf moment that could have gone wrong at the hands of a less skilled author. But what I <i>will</i> say is that I always grow sickened and very exhausted reading about women in distress, women being raped or held or cut into pieces. I remember feeling the same reading the brilliant [book:Exiles|60784359] - the final novel in the Falk series by Jane Harper. I just wanted the woman to prevail. I wanted her to turn around, stab the guy in the crotch and step away from the cliff of her own mortality. I just wanted a better end.

And it's very hard to find that in these books. Because of course, it's not based in reality. Women go missing. Women are murdered in untold numbers. While jogging. While going to the shops. While walking down a laneway. While being married. While working. While having sex. While vacationing. While driving. While daring to be happy, spoiled, selfish, angry. While having an opinion. While existing. Women are murdered and murdered and murdered, and I think I am just absolutely sick of it.

So while <i>The Trap</i> was ridiculously good, and while Catherine Ryan Howard is exceedingly talented, sometimes, the reality of the world in which we live - brought to raw and depressing light by her Acknowledgements and explanation for the Vanishing Triangle that inspired the book - is too much for me to bear.

Still, I highly recommend this for any thriller fans. You won't be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

Whoa the beginning is absolutely insane, and it just keeps going full throttle from there! The pacing is strong, just enough procedural woven in to let you catch your breath. Well crafted twists and turns, keeps you guessing. I think there are places where the character development lacks a little something, but it is all forgiven by the plot and pace!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a good read , it had the usual, suspense, intrigue, action, murder, and a great who done it! The storyline was interesting and flowed nicely! I would recommend reading this book as it was well worth reading but it wasn't one of my top favorites! Still a decent read! Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for sharing this book with me!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Blackstone Publishing for sending me an arc in exchange for review.


This is probably one of the most interesting thrillers I’ve ever read. The different povs. It was fast paced however the timeline kind of confused me a bit with the writing but in the end I ended up really enjoying this.

Was this review helpful?

There were too many perspectives in this twisty story for me. I found the timelines confusing and had a hard time keeping the overlapping stories straight. This could be in part because of the formatting of the ARC, where stories blended together from one paragraph to the next with no warning. Also, what was happening with that ending? It needed a bit more of a wrap up for me...

Was this review helpful?

I did not realize what I was getting into with this book. The synopsis was so clever and strange that I had to read it, but it was darker and more disturbing to me than the suspense/mysteries I usually read. Hard to shake off and let go off -- which makes this a well-written, plotted, and genuinely disturbing story. Yikes! I can't share more without giving too much away, but definitely read this is you enjoy more dark, twisted mysteries, and if you enjoy being inside the mind of a killer. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC. #TheTrap #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Lucy O’Sullivan is on a mission to find her sister Nicki who went missing… at any cost. Nicki, along with several other women in the area, has gone missing with absolutely no trace and the Gardai has a man in question but no real leads. So Lucy decides to take the case on in her own way by dangerously seeking out the man who is behind the kidnappings. She starts going out late at night to try and get approached by him hoping he will lead her to her sister. Detective Denise Pope is on the case and pairs up with Angela from the Missing Persons Unit who happened upon a major clue in the investigation. Throughout the novel, there are additional excerpts told in the killers voice. So the reader is privy to his thoughts and actions. This was such a crazy, edge of your seat, unputdownable read! I loved everything about this novel: the plot, the characters and the excellent writing. I highly recommend this five star read!

Was this review helpful?

Wow! I think I fell into a trap by not seeing the last shocking twists of the book until they hit me in the face! Catherine Ryan Howard writes unputdownable, highly heart-throbbing, and smart psychological thrillers that keep you on the edge of your seat. The short and captivating chapters, well-executed mystery, and strong heroines who risk their lives to catch the psychopath are the main strengths of this book that kept my eyes and hands glued to the pages for hours, canceling my entire schedule to fix my entire attention to this wild ride!

There’s a psychopath riding his car in the middle of the night to lure women into his car. "Tana Meehan, Nicki O' Sullivan, and Jennifer Gold are the missing women. They disappeared in December, June, and then December again from Kildare town, Dublin city center, and the Enniskerry Road, around 10 p.m., around midnight, and in broad daylight just after three.

When Jennifer disappears, the three cases are linked, and Operation Tide is established.

Nicki’s sister, Lucy Sullivan, looks for the man who captivated her sister by using herself as prey, lurking around the place she’s taken in the middle of the night. She can do anything to bring her sister back home, including teaming up with a notorious anchor man.

Angela, who works as a civilian paper-pusher in the Missing Person Unit, finally has a chance to work with Detective Denise Pope after her recent discovery from a thrift store, which leads them to an important clue about the missing women cases.

Tana Meehan’s husband, Roland Kearns, is one of the suspects in their investigation. But there’s no reason to think that he may be involved in the other missing women cases.

One of the other narrators of this book, along with these women, is the killer. He is married, living a double life, and thinks hunting women in the middle of the night is as exciting as climbing Mount Everest. The narration parts that belong to him are definitely irritating, making your blood run cold!

The entire characters’ stories intercede at the conclusion in a very satisfying and dark-twisty way.

I devoured this book in one sitting. It’s riveting and luring. You may also catch smart references to the author’s previous books as well. I absolutely recommend it if you’re keen on reading something fascinatingly mind-blowing.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Blackstone Publishing for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange for my honest thoughts.

Was this review helpful?