Member Reviews
Although this book is touted as a mystery, it has only a few mysterious elements, as the "mystery" is solved early on in the book and the remainder of the book deals with the characters' attempts to deal with the resulting problems. The regency era speech rings a bit false, as it is filled with a modern sense of humor, and although I want to appreciate the feminist twist on the prevailing attitudes of the time, it feels a bit heavy handed. There is a bit of romance that many readers will appreciate, but for me, the characters and plot let this book down.
I loved the start of this new historical fiction series. It was fresh, smart, snappy and extremely satisfying. It is 1815 and Lady Petra has recently caused a stir in society when she expressed her intention to stay single after the untimely death of her fiancé. Her father is a forward thinker who supports his daughter but her uncle is demanding that she marry. When Lady Petra's friends start disappearing to the country "for their health" and some are said to have died, Lady Petra becomes suspicious, especially after one of the footmen say that they saw their former employer, Lady Gwen, very much alive in London after her supposed death. But before Lady Petra can further question him, he is found stabbed to death. Soon Lady Petra learns more about the house in the country, run by Mr. Drysdale, where women are being sent by their husbands for "treatment." Some may truly need medical attention but most are just meddlesome to their husbands because they speak their mind or dare to seek independence. Lady Petra soon learns that her uncle plans to send her to the country but she has a secret ally to help her escape. Friends since childhood, Lady Petra and Duncan were inseparable until he was sent to oversee his families interests on the continent. He has returned to England and he is teaming up with Lady Petra, her lady's maid, Annie, and her best friend, Lady Caroline, to help save the women at Mr. Drysdale's asylum. I highly recommend and will definitely continue with the series. Thank you to NetGalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
After her fiance died three years ago, Lady Petra Forsyth proclaimed to society that she would live out her life as a spinster. Thanks to a supportive father and the rare gift of an inheritance from her mother, she can thankfully ignore the judgement and whispers from her peers. When she learns that one of her close female friends has mysteriously died from “melancholia”, she starts looking closer at the questionable physician her friend was seeing. What she discovers is numerous disappearances of ladies from high society, and an isolated asylum that they're all sent to. And, if her uncle has anything to say, Petra herself will soon be going there too.
Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Lord was a fun read. With a wide cast of female characters and an engaging plot, this felt almost like a Regency-period Nancy Drew, but with a touch more adult themes. An easy read with simple themes, it was exactly what I needed to read. The main character was definitely the highlight, with her friends coming close second.
The love interest wasn't very fleshed out and all the time we spent with him didn't feel like it was enough. The trope of estranged childhood best friend was interesting, but not overly so, and I think the relationship could have used some more development.
The setting felt slightly different from other Regency books I've read, possibly because Petra is a rare instance of “lady of independent means” in a society that usually doesn't allow women freedom. Her independence meant that the setting felt lighter or more modern, but the overall light tone of the book also meant that the switch to the discussions of gendered violence was swift and sometimes unexpected. This made it much more intense, which could be both a good and bad thing.
There were definitely parts of the book that could have been edited or rewritten, as some things felt underdeveloped or rushed, and the villain's were flat and washed out. But if you're looking for an easy read with a Regency girl gang and casual girlboss energy, this is definitely worth a read!
The first half of this book I was convinced I was going to DNF it. The second half I couldn’t put it down. It is very slow to start and has no sense of direction at first. Near the middle things do pick up and it becomes pretty predictable. There were a lot of names mentioned with not much background so it was hard to keep up everyone. The story finishes up pretty quickly and ends with a predictable cliff hanger.
I really wanted to love this book. I loved the idea of a regency mystery. The story was very long and wordy and convoluted, often hard to keep track of. There were so many characters to also keep track of and so much going on. It took me so long to read because I would get lost or Zoe out reading it. The asylum with the crazy evil doctor was a nice touch. But I really hated the cliffhanger at the end. This is a one off for me, I would not reread it and I’m not sure I would recommend it. I know some people loved it but it was too much for me. The only reason I would read the second book is to resolve the cliffhanger.
Lady Petra Forsyth is flung into a whodunit when she learns a friend may -- or may not -- have died mysteriously.
This book was marketed as "Bridgerton meets Agatha Christie," which piqued my interest, as I am a lover of both (as well as Jane Austen).
I will start by saying I do have a fondness for the main character. I love women (fictional and real) who buck societal expectations. I also enjoy her relationships with other characters.
Having said all that, I'm afraid this book left me disappointed. On the mystery side of things, there weren't enough red herrings and not enough potential suspects to really make Petra do any real deducing. Things seemed to be neatly -- or very coincidentally -- handed to her in a bow. Even the climax seemed to end with too many coincidences in Peter's favor.
In terms of writing style, I felt the story relied heavily on exposition. In other words, a lot of ink was used to describe events not shown in the book. While this was used heavily in Austen's time, it makes for boring reading by today's standards. There are for sure some things described that would make for enjoyable scenes to read.
I started this story and wasn't 100% sure what I was getting into. I loved the protagonist and her drive and foolhardiness, especially against the background of regency England and the social expectations of the ton. She and her friends were very entertaining and their friendships and support of each other contrasted well with the stereotypical infighting and teardowns that are common in other regency era novels. I also appreciated the grain of realism planted in the drama at the end (no spoilers!) I enjoyed this novel as, essentially a cozy mystery/beach read and I was satisfied by the end, but it wasn't my favorite read. To begin with, this was a little out of my depth in terms of what I normally read and I didn't enjoy some of the twists and turns. They felt out of the blue and random at points, but I enjoyed the experience and the end result.
I enjoyed this book and look forward to the series. Lady Petra is an interesting protagonist. She is single by choice, unusual in the Regency era, and has money and property in her own right, which encourages her natural independence, in a time when female independence is unacceptable. When she uncovers a scheme meant to keep the women of her class very dependent, she’s feisty enough to take on the villains and the social norms that make it easy for them to commit such a crime. I’m eager to see what comes next.
Historical intrigue romance
Ms. Connally brings a tale of romance and intrigue to the table. Petra and Duncan played together as youngsters, but circumstances created a parting of the ways and she resented his lack of connection.
She became aware of sinister happenings and set out to find out who was responsible.
I liked the story, it flows well and does create emotions, although I thought Petra’s disappearance didn’t match her portrayal. Just sayin’. I recommend to fans of historical intrigue.
I requested and received a NetGalley ARC to peruse gratis and offer my opinion in the same.
This was so convoluted that I had a hard time (1) getting into it and (2) understanding what was going on. And then it ended it what I thought was a cliff-hanger. But then I may have misunderstood a lot more than I thought I understood. Grammar errors bothered me (well, consider the title). I can't recommend it, but then I can't say someone else wouldn't enjoy it. I give it two stars for effort, but I doubt I will read the sequel, if there is one to resolve the last line of the book. I just ended up confused. #ActLikeALadyThinkLikeALord #NetGalley
If Enola Holmes were little older and more jaded.
When Lady Petra Forsyth’s fiancé and love match dies just weeks ahead of their wedding, she makes the shocking public proclamation that she will never remarry. A woman of independent means, thanks to an inheritance from her late mother, Petra sees no reason to give up her freedom to marriage. Instead, she uses her title to gain access to elite spaces and enjoy the best of society without expectations.
But when gossip suggests that a longtime friend has died of “melancholia” while in the care of an asylum, Petra vows to use her social status to dig deeper. But will diving headfirst into this investigation cost Petra her freedom and independence. And how does her childhood confidant, Duncan’s, return to London fit into all this?
I think the premise and the set-up is quite enjoyable. I also think the ending is intriguing and left me feeling content for now. Frankly, the idea of wealthy men throwing their wives and daughters, who became too hard to control or too much of a nuance to bother trying, into an asylum under the care of a shifty physician has historical merit. And I love a feminist spin on a period piece. It’s an easy, fun read. And I would gladly read another story in this universe.
This was a quick read, in the cozy mystery genre. I enjoyed parts of the book but found that there were a lot of characters to keep up with. I really wasn't into the strong feminist vibe either, felt inorganic. I felt like the plot moved along at a nice pace and was easy to follow but that ending was a bit rush. Overall a good storyline though. I would actually give it 3.5 stars
Thanks to Netgalley for the ebook to review. The opinions are my own.
I enjoyed reading Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Lord. Thanks to NetGalley and publisher for the ARC.
Always look forward to reading a new author. I particularly look forward to a Regency period setting. This book was weighed down by ponderous dialog. Because of that, it took too long to get into the plot which wandered and became unclear. I received a copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Kindle Copy for Review from Net Galley, St. Martin Press and Minotaur Books.
I received a free, advance copy of this book and this is my unbiased and voluntary review.
Regency era comes a new mystery series that gives you a new and exciting read. A time when ladies are not expected to act prim and proper and not meddle into murders. A charming series that have the potential to be another favourite.
We meet Lady Petra who was toe be married until her fiancé suddenly passes away. She begins to become an outcast in society ass rumors are saying that she’ll never marry.
Her friend suddenly disappears and is presumed, Petra will find herself seeking answers. An entertaining story of a head strong female who does not conform to the time. A promising start to a new series.
This one eased quite slowly into the mystery. It really set the historical stage, which made for a slow start, but a good foundation.
I enjoyed watching this character fight to make her own path, despite societal and familial expectations. The mystery itself was quite delayed and then quite slow, and I wish it had been a bigger focus to the story.
That being said, it was a good read, with building suspense, disturbing elements based on history, and an overall enjoyable read!
I didn't like the last chapter and how it left off. I m assuming it's to set up for a second book, but I still didn't like that little tweak.
Thank you to NETGALLEY and MINOTAUR BOOKS for the ARC!
I'm not sure if this book wanted to be a romance or a mystery or social commentary. Petra was an enjoyable protagonist, but the narrative dragged and the writing style was cumbersome. The mystery resolved well and with a satisfying end for the evildoers, but the romance ended with a rather clunky cliffhanger. I don't think I'll look up the sequel.
Bridgerton vibes? Sign me up. Throw in some Agatha Christie vibes too? Even better.
Immediate dislike of Uncle Tobias, whose comparisons of Petra to a horse were infuriating, not to mention his gaslighting later on.
But wait, the gaslighting!!! It’s so sad how easy it was for men to gaslight women and then be believed in earlier times. Shoot, it still happens today. The fact that evil men such as Uncle Tobias and Drysdale exist! Bellingham too! And to think her father so easily believed these other men… The hatred that men had for independent women…is had my blood boiling.
But the ending?! What?! There has to be a sequel, I’m hoping. Ultimately, I loved this book. It had me hooked very early on, just how I like it
Big thanks to NetGalley and the author for approving me for this ARC!
I found this historical romantic mystery to be precisely what I needed when I needed it.
It wasn't a stuffy and slow-moving historical, it had wit and candour and levity, relatable characters and modern struggles in a Regency-era period. It was mystery-forward with a slight romantic subplot. Remember that if you come to this book for a primarily romantic story, you will risk being disappointed. It is primarily a mystery, which is why I enjoyed it so much.
It combined cozy mystery with a Regency-era setting, added a cup of feminism, a dash of romance and a sprinkle of spinster pride. As a happily childfree and unmarried person, I felt a connection to the FMC and was invested in her chosen lifestyle.
I didn't realize until the 90% point of this book (when I started looking at other reviews) that it is actually the start of a series. I cannot wait until November 2023 when this book is released and I can start widely recommending it to family and friends. And the even longer wait until the next in the series is released...
You will think it will be an easy wait for the next in the series until you read the very.... last.... sentence...
When I read the blurb that said Act Like A Lady, Think Like A Lord was "Bridgerton meets Status Christie" I knew all I needed to know. This was wonderful I and I'm glad to know this will be a series. it reads fast (which I love) and has a good mystery.
Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced digital review copy.