Member Reviews
Lisbeth Salander and Mikael Blomkvist return, with both heading to a small town in Sweden’s far north. Mikael is depressed at the end of the printed version of the Millennium magazine, which will now be a podcast. He’s going to see his estranged daughter, who is about to be married. He’s looking forward to spending time with his young grandson.
At the same time Lisbeth is also headed to the same town, unhappy to be named a guardian to Svalla, an unknown niece that she wants nothing to do with; but Lisbeth is her only living relative since Svalla’s mother has disappeared.
The thing that ties everything together is the plan to build a huge windfarm in the area. Mikael’s future son-in-law is an ambitious, somewhat shady local politician, who is under a lot of pressure. Svalla’s mother and step-father are in deep with a criminal developer who wants 90% of the project. Soon, Svalla is the target of criminals who want something from her.
I really liked Svalla, she was the most interesting character in this story. She’s 13, brilliant, and a savant when it comes to breaking into safes. I was way into the story before I became interested in Mikael and Lisbeth. Marcus Branco, the criminal mastermind, was a truly evil person. Still, it was Svalla who made the story interesting and tied everything together. Overall, I ended up enjoying the book, although I was disappointed with the characterization of Mikael and Lisbeth, they almost seemed secondary to the story.
I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley; this is my honest review.
The Girl in Eagle's Talons is the seventh of ten in the Millennium series, initially crafted by Steig Larsson. The first two books of this series gripped me, but the few books to follow putzed out a little for me.
In this rendition, Lisbeth Sanders is back; this time, her character takes on a new role as an aunt to her sister's daughter, Svala. Since other family members have also passed, Sanders is the next in line to be her caretaker. She struggles to accept a teenager into her life, but Svala shows signs of being brilliant. Though she is in danger, she is an intelligent girl able to use her resourcefulness to her advantage.
This series started as a great one for me, though I wish the plot line were more in-depth, like the first book. When comparing book one to book seven, though written by different authors, you can tell they are vastly different. This book was, sadly, not my favorite read.
I enjoyed the first 3 books in this series but did not read the next three by the second author. I was really looking forward to trying The Girl in the Eagle's Talons to see how the third writer would handle the series.
I think I was missing something in the translation from Swedish. I found it difficult to follow and had to go back and read to see if I had skipped something. I kept circling back but never could really get into the story or relate to the characters.
If you enjoy this series, I would say definitely give The Girl in the Eagle's Talons a try because it may have just been a difficult read for me.
I received and ARC of this book but this is my honest, voluntary opinion.
Lisbeth Salander is active again, but this time she’s an aunt trying to decide if she wants to take on the responsibility of a teenage girl. Lisbeth has been dark but still this is her sister’s daughter, and she eliminated the girl’s father. Mikael Blomkvist is involved as well, and his grandson is taken at his daughter’s wedding. Which causes him to take on issues as we usually does as a journalist.
The book looks at many environmental issues, but the number of characters and going by different names make the story confusing. As well Lisbeth doesn’t seem to be the usual strong persona who takes a head-on approach to matters. She seems indecisive, unsure, hesitant.
The Girl in the Eagle's Talons is the latest Millennium book, this written by Karin Smirnoff, the third author to take her hands at penning the eclectic suspense novels. Lisbeth has been named guardian to her niece, Svala. Lisbeth has no interest in caring for a child, but Svala is different. She’s brilliant and she’s in danger. Her grandmother has died and her mother has disappeared, so Lisbeth is next in line to be Svala’s guardian. Henry Salo, head of the municipality in Gasskas, is working to get a wind farm installed on acreage that is owned by others. #NETGALLEY #THEGIRLINTHEEAGLE"STALONS
Thanks to net galley providing me with this ARC. Lisbeth Salander returns to gather up her thirteen year old niece, whose mother is missing. Lisbeth is the only family left even though she has never met the girl and has no interest in being a child minder. Svala turns out to be a bright resourceful girl who knows what’s going on and has great survival skills. Mikael Blomquist also comes to the town, following a story about the impact of a large windmill farm on this remote quiet community. The characters lack of edginess of Stieg Larssen’s depiction, but there’s non stop action. .
Unlike most of the previous books about the character Lisbeth Salander, this one seems to focus most of the story on a new character, Lisbeth’s niece, Svala, daughter of the man Lisbeth killed earlier, who could not feel pain but loved administering it. Svala, who also cannot feel physical pain, and who happens to be genius with special skills at opening safes, joins forces with Lisbeth to put things right in this typically complex story of criminal intrigue and underestimation of key characters by the bad guys, to their ultimate displeasure.
Woven into the story is a detailed tale of one criminal’s fascination with sea eagles and his care and feeding of them during his self-imposed isolation deep in the woods of Scandinavia, from which he plies his craft of problem and people elimination.
The story wraps up very quickly after a long and twisting reveal of the motives driving the main characters, including Mikael Blomqvist’s daughter and her fiancée, the main character in the plot to turn forest land into money. A new evil mastermind is also introduced, who’s extreme evil and depravity made this reader cringe.
Not as well presented as the originals by Stieg Larsson, but still very entertaining with good character portrayal and development.
Big thank you NetGalley and to the publisher for the chance to review this book pre-release. I really enjoyed this addition to Lisbeth's story, however I agree with the other reviewers that a second look should be given to the translation into English. A more formal review will be available on my IG/TikTok and Goodreads.
Thanks so much to NetGalley and Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor for this advance readers copy, in exchange for an honest review. The Girl in the Eagles Talon is the continued story of Lisbeth Salander and Mikael Blomkvist and the first book of a new trilogy, from a brand new author, in this world. This is a thriller with the converging stories/paths of Lisbeth and Mikael, involving large corporations, advantageous/untapped wealth in natural resources, and a tangled web of familial connections throughout all of it. I think it’s best to jump in without much more information, since it’s so easy to fall back into this world.
This was a solid continuation of the Millennium series. I was initially hesitant with a new author coming into play and I think the style was definitely a bit different but, it was still enjoyable to read. I do think it took a while to get into the story and there was a fair amount of backstories and discussion on other characters that I just couldn’t wait to just get to see more of Lisbeth/Mikael. I tried to just push through to get to those parts of the story, which was a little tough, but once the story got really involved, I could finish it out.
I do think the settings and descriptions in this book really helped put the reader into this world and I thought that was a plus in this book. If you’ve enjoyed other books in the Millennium series, you may enjoy this one and may enjoy the nostalgia of it all. It is definitely a fresh take and was fun to revisit some favorite characters.
This felt so different from the other books in the series that it was a little bit jarring for me. Not my favorite read.
I love this series and Lizbeth Salander is one of my favorite characters. This was a well written book but I had some issues with the plot. It was just “eh” at times. And, of course, it needed more Lizbeth Salander.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/75523433
Just 3 stars for the Seventh outing of Lisbeth Salader, now with her third (female) writer. Having read them all, I was really rather underwhelmed by this installment "Girl in the Eagle's Talons". There seemed to be translation issues here and in addition, both of the MC's seemed somewhat diminished from their former selves (I get they're older, but still). There was plenty of action & I did like the addition of Lisbeth's niece, but something was just off here. My sincere thanks to Net Galley & the publisher for the "read now" complimentary DRC - opinions my own.
I've always like Lisbeth Salander's character, and I struggled with the previous iterations that attempted to revive her. I'm not familiar with Smirnoff's other work, so I have nothing with which to compare her writing. As much as I wanted to enjoy this latest reimagining of Salander, I could not get into this novel. The first half was downright painful, not to mention confusing due to intermittent flashbacks, men with no names, and a myriad of characters that really had no relevance up to that point. The redeeming quality of this novel, and perhaps the only thing that kept me reading, was Svala. While only thirteen, she seems worthy of her own set of novels - maybe for a YA audience, but she deserves to be the lead protagonist, either way.
Some of the story may have also been lost in translation. There was a great deal that seemed to go beyond the usual geographical challenges that arise when reading a novel set outside the reader's country. (What is the deal with Santa and Finland? That whole part of the book was bizarre.) I love a good Swedish police procedural, but even Lisbeth couldn't save this one for me.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for letting me get my hands on this one early. After a disappointing second trilogy that treated Lisbeth as a side character, I was excited to revisit these characters with a female author. The plot was fun and I enjoyed the introduction of Svala, Lisbeth’s niece. However, the translation was just awful. Very stilted with jarring jumps in time/setting/dialogue that made me wonder if I had missed something-I finally gave up on rereading confusing passages and just plowed through. I’m sure the original is a lot of fun but this translation is not quite ready for English-speaking audiences.
This is one I’m going to have to think about for a while because, truthfully, I’m not sure how I feel about it. It felt like a very mixed bag to me. Of course I loved getting to live with Mikael Blomkvist and Lisbeth Salander, one of my all time favorite fictional characters, once again. And Svala Hirak, Lisbeth’s niece, was also a welcome addition and entertaining foil to Lisbeth.
One of my biggest complaints is that there are just too many new characters who ultimately serve no real purpose within the story, as well as far too many subplots that could be removed without affecting the book at all.
And this might be me being picky, but I don’t think the Millenium saga needs the random meta moments sprinkled throughout. Lisbeth actually referring to herself as the girl either the dragon tattoo and the girl who played with fire, as well as Svala telling her aunt “You look like Noomi Rapace” just felt really cringe-y to me.
The central mystery is good enough that it really doesn’t need those extra subplots, and Lisbeth’s continued determination to take down men who hurt women is especially welcome in 2023.
Overall, the nostalgia factor of Mikael and Lisbeth is strong, but the novel itself felt very middling. Here’s hoping the next one is a true return to form for my favorite duo.
It pains me to give a two star review, especially when I appreciate the immense effort it takes to write, publish and translate a book. This series of books is one I have followed over the years and I was looking forward to this latest installment. However, I found the narrative choppy and with little transition between topics and characters. While some of the characters' inner thoughts were italicized it was not always clear if the thoughts were past, present or future or whose thoughts they were. Blomqvists is angst-ridden due to the demise of his beloved Millennium. His future looks bleak filled with blog, vlogs and podcasts. On top of professional worries he is asked to travel to Norrland for his daughter Pernilla's wedding and to see his nine year old grandson.
Coincidentally, Salander travels to Norrland at the same time, also for family-related business. Her twin (dead) brother's daughter needs a guardian and she is the only option available. The story line becomes exquisitely twisted from this point on. The bad guys are over-the-top evil and vile, more coincidences occur and the plot gets more and more tangled. And though this series has always been graphic I found this installment more graphic than necessary at times.
Perhaps the translation of the book enters into the awkwardness I found while reading but I am not sure that is totally responsible for the less than smooth writing.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-galley.
I really enjoyed "The Girl In The Eagle's Talons." It was great to be reintroduced to some of the characters, especially Lisbeth Salander and Mikael Blomkvist. It was a wonderful page-turner and kept me excited & engaged while reading. I would recommend this book to anyone that likes mysteries and thrillers. If readers enjoyed the first three books in the Millennium Trilogy by Stieg Larsson, they will also love this book. It was very cinematic and would make an excellent movie.
The small Swedish town of Gasskas is under pressure. A consortium plans a forest of wind turbines, a direct conflict with the pristine beauty of the surrounding mountains and its needed tourism. Michael Blomkvist, alienated by Millennium magazine going totally digital, arrives for his daughter’s marriage. The groom, a city manager, has a dark past and perhaps a darker future, which strains the father-daughter relationship even further. Added pressure comes from the kidnapping of her son, Blomkvist’s grandson. Lisbeth Salander, despite her reluctance, has been named caretaker of her gifted teenage niece, and arrives in the town to discover that the 13-year-old might be in danger. The mounting tension threatens the town, strains damaged relationships, and ultimately explodes into violence. An excellent addition to this remarkable series.
DP Lyle, award-winning author of the Jake Longly and Cain/Harper thriller series
After seven books, I’m sad to report that this new Millennium novel was highly disappointing. Larsson set the bar so high, that it’s unfair to compare the rest of the volumes to the original trilogy, but Lagercrantz’s books were fun. The Girl in the Eagle's Talons is the first of a planned three by Karin Smirnoff, who actually lives close to where Larsson grew up. I really liked Lisbeth’s niece, a new character who has a lot in common with her aunt. As for the rest, I’m afraid that I found it boring. There is too much information about mining, wind energy, reindeer husbandry and, most of all, politics. Larsson didn’t shy away from this, but this book is too localized to appeal to me. For instance, there are too many dialogues about the political parties in Sweden, about which I know nothing. My problem is, I wasn’t invested enough to even Google it, and in the end it didn’t matter. The baddie sounds like a Bond villain, but instead of cheesy fun, he gives long speeches about the state of the environment (I think, to be honest, I’m not sure). The plot takes a long time to set up characters and situations that don’t pan out, or fall by the wayside. Maybe some will become important in the sequels, but it distracted from the plot. I was looking forward to reading this book so much that I feel let down. I hope other readers enjoy it more.
I chose to read this book and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased. Thank you, #NetGalley/#Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor, Knopf!
I read all of the other books in this series years ago so I was very excited to get an ACR of this book from NetGalley and the publisher. It was great to jump back into the story of Lisbeth and Mikael. The beginning of the story was hard to get into. There were many characters with unfamiliar names and places which made it hard for me to keep track of who was who and what they were doing. Once I got about halfway in, it was good. I liked the new character, Svala, who is Lisbeth's niece that she is guardian of. Svala is in trouble with the wrong people and Lisbeth and Mikael have to come to her rescue. The book was a bit graphic but so were the others. It was somewhat farfetched that Savla was able to do all that she did but I was happy with the ending and would probable read another book in the series.