Member Reviews

This was an excellent character study and I haven’t been this enthralled with dorm living since Curtis Sittenfeld’s ”Prep.” The characters were so believable — reckless yet lovely, nice but mean, confident and immature. As someone who has been 19, 24, 30 and 38, I saw myself in each of the narratives. Would highly recommend, especially if you devour the Refinery’s money diaries. The specificity of every setting and situation was *chefs kiss*.

Also, this is not a thriller, but I was on the edge of my seat just waiting for the inevitable train to crash.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for the arc! Will recommend and preorder my little heart out.

One note about trigger warnings: suicidal thoughts/themes, death (human and pet)

Was this review helpful?

I loved Kiley Reid’s previous novel, Such a Fun Age, and have been eagerly awaiting her follow up. This did not disappoint! Reid is such a strong voice in realistic fiction writing.

Set in a college town, the novel centers on Millie, an RA at a southern public university, the group of residents who live next door, and Agatha, a visiting professor. The novel is character-driven, and extremely engaging. Characters are multidimensional and well-developed. They’re complex enough that no one in the novel is all good or bad. Reid really captures the nuances of all the personalities… of good people who justify making bad choices and people who make bad choices despite their best intentions. The novel feels timely and thought provoking in its portrayal of relationships, friendships, and online cultural and the dialogue about race and class.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC and the opportunity to review this wonderful new novel.

Was this review helpful?

It is hard to follow up with a debut like Such a Fun Age, but Kiley Reid has successfully written another beautiful novel. The writing in Come and Get It is different from her first book, but not a bad way. You can tell she is experimenting with her storytelling, while it still has her signature of telling people's stories and dramas in a nuanced funny way.
This was an engrossing story, I can see some people loving this and disliking this, but I loved this. I can't wait to continue to see what Kiley Reid does.

Was this review helpful?

So good! Adored her first ... this is entirely different, thoroughly enjoyed & could not wait to continue reading.
Such an incredibly talented writer & storyteller. The characters, plot, multiple themes & storylines were all so richly drawn & woven.
Highly recommend!
Tho I have to be honest--did not luv the cover art, tho understand the significance.

With great thanks to NetGalley & Penguin Group Putnam for this e-ARC!

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars rounded up to 3

I kept choosing to read something else rather than return to this one on my Kindle. It didn't pull me in and that surprised me since I was an R.A. in college. The author got a lot of those "dorm life/R.A. vibes" totally right, but the characters felt humdrum and there wasn't any real excitement for me to rush back to. It felt like I was slugging through it to the end. The writing style was easy to follow, but as some reviewers mentioned, it felt "flat". I wanted more drama and excitement.

I've never read anything by this author before, but apparently her first book is incredible. I think I need to check that one out instead.

Thank you to NetGalley and Putnam Books for an eARC so that I may share my honest feedback and review

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this, but had a few issues with it. While the writing style itself was readable and smart, the story itself didn't grab me right away. Still, I enjoy Kiley Reid's works and will keep coming back to this author.

Was this review helpful?

From the acclaimed author of the New York Times bestseller "Such a Fun Age" emerges an intriguing and thought-provoking narrative, delving into the complex web of relationships between a residential assistant, a professor, and three rebellious students. With her signature style, the author presents a captivating and engaging tale that explores the intricacies of human connection and the challenges that arise when boundaries blur.

Was this review helpful?

I really hoped to love this book because I think Reid is a talented author. This one just did not grab my attention. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC. Two stars is all I can give it. Perhaps some changes will be made?!

Was this review helpful?

I swear reading this book took my entire adult life. At best it was nonsensical, at its worst it was mind numbing dull. No one felt like a real person, it wasn’t clever enough to be satire or social commentary. Honestly, I haven’t read a book this poorly constructed in years,

Was this review helpful?

Agatha is a 38-year-old writer and professor. Millie is a 24-year-old resident advisor and student. When Agatha offers a way for Millie to make some extra cash, their acquaintance-ship slowly turns into something more.

I adored the author’s debut and but I ultimately didn’t connect with this Come and Get It. The writing is lovely for sure and the premise is interesting but I had issues keeping track of the various characters and wasn’t sure I cared about anyone beyond Agatha and Millie. Still, I would recommend this to fans of the author and those looking for a story set on a college campus exploring many themes including gender, race, poverty, and privilege.

Thank you very much to Putnam and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

⭐3/5

➡ Twenty-four year old college senior Millie Cousins is back at the University of Arkansas after spending the the previous year at home, working and taking care of her mother. This year, in what she hopes is truly her final year on campus, she's wrapping up classes, making memories with friends, working as an RA in the transfer/scholarship dorm and trying to save every penny she can to put a down payment on a house right out of college. When visiting professor and cultural author Agatha Paul offers her a unique albeit easy way to make a few dollars, she invites the professor into her dorm and subsequently, her life. What ensues begins as a small series of lies that quickly escalates to consume the lives of everyone involved.

🙏 Thank you to Netgalley and Putnam Books for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

🎯 What I loved: This book had a lot of potential. I was a big fan of Reid's debut Such a Fun Age and the way she layers her characters making them relatable, flawed, unlikeable and thought provoking. Come and Get It brought back Reid's dynamic characters and commentary on microaggressions, mundane relationships and power dynamics but it lacked the same follow thru that her debut had. was definitely drawn in by the relatable setting and the people she filled it- finding the way she juxtaposed a black RA, privileged residents, a professor facing professional success but personal turmoil and a resident with a streak of unfortunate luck fascinating.

🙅‍♀️ What I didn't: Ultimately, this fell flat for me. The characters had potential, the setting had potential and it felt like there was build-up but that the characters weren't fully developed and the 'big event' didn't feel suspenseful enough to me. More than that, the resolution felt way too much like a 'drive away into the sunset' type of thing for me to really pull a message from the story. There was something there- it just didn't have the same pull as Such a Fun Age for me.

Read if you love:
*college dorm settings
*racially & socio-economically diverse characters w/ a focus on microaggressions and hierarchies
*financial variability on college campuses

See also: What's Mine and Yours, Maame, Americanah

Was this review helpful?

I was super excited to read this book after reading this author's debut novel, "Such a Fun Age." That book was 5/5 stars, and I would give this one 4/5 stars. This book has similar insightful observations regarding class, race and gender which makes this another thought-provoking novel. The insights provided on these heavier topics are done with humor and intellect so it didn't feel like too heavy of a read. While I didn't particularly find any of the characters super likeable, I do think this was an important story to tell and ultimately will be a book I remember for years to come.

I hope Reid continues to write more thought provoking novels as it is clear she can execute them well.

Thank you to NetGalley and Putnam Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Highly Recommended!

Kiley Reid can hit you where it hurts, and I am all here for it! Her debut novel, Such a Fun Age drew attention to multiple issue of race in America, teasing out the nuances and highlighting the micro aggressions. Her beautiful writing leads you slowly down a path that you fear can only lead to a disaster.

In her sophomore effort Reid takes on a midwestern college campus. There are college students - transfers in student housing and seniors acting as Resident Advisors as well as a visiting professor. How they all interact is fascinating and Reid easily pulls you into the thought process of each character as they make choices that will effect the rest of the year and maybe their lives. If you like contemporary culture novels, Shakespearean characters, campus stories or are just ready for Kiley Reid's next great book, Come and Get It is for you!
#penguingroup #KileyReid #comeandgetit

Was this review helpful?

A grand follow up to the NYT bestseller and Reese's Hello Sunshine Book Club pick, SUCH A FUN AGE, COME AND GET IT is a fresh and provocative novel about a residential assistant and her messy entanglement with a professor and three unruly students. The book is full of sharp wit and insightful observations about race, class, and gender. Reid's writing is clear and engaging, and her characters are complex and relatable. Come and Get It is a must-read for anyone who enjoys smart, funny, and thought-provoking fiction.

Here are some specific things that I enjoyed about the book:

The characters are well-developed and relatable. I found myself rooting for Millie, the protagonist, even when she made mistakes.
The book is full of sharp wit and insightful observations about race, class, and gender. Reid does not shy away from difficult topics, and she tackles them with intelligence and humor.
The book is absolutely engaging! I found myself flying through the pages, eager to find out what happened next.
Overall, I highly recommend Come and Get It to anyone who enjoys smart, funny, and thought-provoking fiction. It is a book that will stay with you long after you finish reading it.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a great read! It was my first title from this author and I cant wait to dive into other titles. This book was really character based and driven so if you enjoy that, then you will like this! I really got attached to these characters and enjoyed reading their story. It was also really enjoyable to read about a college group of girls and remember what those dynamics were like for me!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks so much for the review copy. I liked this book better than Such a Fun Age. I enjoyed the character development and how the characters were connected throughout the book.

Was this review helpful?

This is a story about a college dorm and college age girls and their roles and dynamics within a group. Sounds great, right? Hmm, just didn't work for me this time. I felt like the author jumped around quite a bit and every character fit one or two stereotypes, like she had to include race, sexual orientation, wealth . . . but then never quite developed them to tell me why it mattered, or why someone acted the way they did because of it or in spite of it.

The story is set in 2017 at the University of Arkansas and centers around Millie Cousins, a 24-year-old senior who is ready to graduate, get a job, and buy her first home. Millie is a resident assistant at a dorm that primarily houses scholarship and transfer students. This book also follows Kennedy, Tyler, and Peyton, who live in the suite next door to Millie, and Agatha, a visiting professor and writer.

Millie is a complicated, layered character but ultimately so compelling that you never consider not rooting for her, and Reid has such an ear for dialogue. I enjoyed reading about Millie and her dormmates and reminiscing about my own college days. While some parts were a bit over-dramatized, I felt that the author accurately captured life as a female collegian. Overall, this was a fun and quick read, and I am excited to see what Kiley Reid does next.

Thank you to NetGalley and Putnam Books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Life is messy and we are all flawed. Kiley Reid's latest explores college life and the personalities encountered. There is a student with a sense of entitlement, everything they want they deserve and can justify regardless of its impact on others. There is the college professor who should know better but takes advantage of a student who is easily manipulated. The same student has her goals in life and while she has a moral code it frays when faced with money that can help her achieve her priority of buying a house. Then there is the very vulnerable student who loses her sense of who she is after a trauma.

Kiley Reid's books can read at a superficial level like fluff. You need to peel back layer by layer to see the vulnerabilities and micro aggressions about power, money and race in her books. She holds up a mirror and dares us to take a good look.

Many thanks to Netgalley and Penguin Putnam for this advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

Didn’t connect with any of the characters. I may return to it closer to publication- one of those books where I’d like to see how it is framed in the NYT Book Review. As Reid’s debut was smash hit, I will be watching to see how this book is handled. Not a favorite for me.

Was this review helpful?

Reid does it again with this masterful coming-of-age story. Set at a mid-western university, this book follows a Professor, RA, and group of students in a dorm. With much of the plot taking place on a typical American dorm floor, Reid examines class, gender, and sexual orientation in an incredibly fresh and unique way. Reid takes typical power dynamics in academia and flips them on their head to show them in a new light. The characters shine and feel as if they could walk off the page. The chapters could have used more transition between them as the flow felt clunky at times, but overall this book is a great success.

Was this review helpful?