I really enjoyed this one. I thought that it was a perfect autumnal read and really fit the dark academia sub-genre well. I enjoyed the overall plot and pacing, I felt like the characters were well drawn and the central romance was great but didn't detract from the central plot which I enjoyed immensely. Definitely recommend for anyone looking for a great spooky-season read.

No words,just vibes! Okay, maybe a few words since this is a review but the most noteworthy thing about A Stud in Drowning is the immaculate vibes Reid has woven.

Effy Sayre is a fairy tale aficionado and a reluctant architecture student. When the opportunity comes to design a home for her favorite late author she jumps at the chance. Hiraeth Manor has seen better days, as Effy starts to dive into the rubble she soon learns she isn't the only student who's come to the manor. Preston Héloury,a dashing and moody literature major becomes a fast rival to Effy but as they mysteries of the manor unravel they'll either have to work together or face unimaginable danger alone.

This isn't the first time Reid has delivered an evocative and ever present feeling of dread, she is a master of it! It works immaculately here, the crumbling manor and isolated location create a haunting location that our MC's thrive in. They are both multidimensional and intriguing, both a pleasure to read.

This is a read worthy of your autumnal TBR!

Absolutely incredible and stunning novel. Truly unique and beautifully told. It kept me guessing the entire time. I loved the mix of stark reality with eerie magical realism. I love that the author kept you guessing if the magic was real or not all the way up until the last line. The underlying message was done wonderfully. Truly deserves book of the year status. A modern classic.

I really truly wanted to love this book. After reading Juniper and Thorn I had such high hopes, but unfortunately this book just didn't live up to my exceptions. Ava discusses a lot of important themes in her stories, and this book is no exception. My main issue was with the main character and the enemies-to-lovers romance. Effy was just not very likeable, and while she has reasons for being the way she is, it made it really difficult to enjoy the story. Her interactions with Preston in the beginning felt almost forced, like the author was really trying to push the "enemies" part of their relationship. It wasn't until chapter 7/8 when I finally started to feel a little more invested in the story. Considering the book is 17 chapters long, that's pretty much the halfway mark. The romance made me roll my eyes a little, but that's definitely me. I think after reading Emily Wilde, my romance expectations were higher, and everything about Effy and Preston constantly touching annoyed me. Like at one point I just wanted to shake them and tell them to hurry up lol. I did kind of guess where things were headed, so the ending wasn't super shocking to me, and while the vibes were definitely there to an extent (I mostly mean spooky vibes, I don't know if I would personally classify this book as dark academia), it didn't improve my overall experience of reading this book.

“Survival is bravery too.”

On the surface, A Study in Drowning is a dark academia tale of mystery and fantasy, but there is so much more wrapped up in it. It’s about the relationship between authors and consumers, institutional sexism in academia, living in a world that dismisses anxiety and mental health, and ultimately reclaiming one’s voice.

I kind of loved the story-within-a-story format, even though it caused the plot to drag at points. Effy and Preston are academic rivals—and later enemies-to-lovers—who must work together to research Myrddin’s beloved epic and survive the haunted manor and the supernatural phenomena lurking in the area. Their discoveries unearth an array of cans of worms that confront the very facts and superstitions their warring nations are built on.

The language throughout is undoubtedly gorgeous. Reid’s writing style fits the gothic style exceptionally well and reflects careful research and worldbuilding on her part. However, the details of the worldbuilding didn’t hold up as well. Effy’s and Preston’s countries are at war, for instance, yet the cause of this war is unexplained. Preston faces prejudices for his heritage, but he is still easily able to enroll in the same university as Effy, travel between the two countries, etc., so the conflict seems like just another reason for Effy to initially resent him. Not to mention the division in folkloric beliefs between the north and south—again, this aspect seemed to serve as a way to heighten tensions between the characters, but it felt oversimplified.

Unfortunately, A Study in Drowning was not entirely to my liking, but it makes a great, gloomy novel to unravel as the season shifts to autumn.

I'm not sure what I expected going into this book, but it was definitely a surprise from start to finish. What began as a quiet, slow-building dark academia story quickly morphed into a maybe-fantasy-horror and "Me Too"-esque story about the women constantly shuffled to the background throughout history.

So often lately, "dark academia" tends to trend too far into "edgy" for my tastes, but A Study in Drowning handles so many deep topics deftly and through such an interesting lens of the redesign of a famous author's house and his story of The Fairy King. Effy is a lovely lead who forces you to question her own reliability at every turn, while Preston as her love interest is her equal in her way, and it's delightful watching them grow to tolerate and then love each other against increasingly weird and haunting odds.

A Study in Drowning is the perfect fall read if you're looking for something vaguely spooky and chilling for those dark autumn nights!

***4.0 Stars***

Overall,
This was a great fall read. The setting and ambiance were very gothic and chilly (made me think of sweater weather). The story is interesting and keeps you engaged. With the main plot centering around Effy a girl with a darkish past who is studying architecture but truly loves literature more, however women are not allowed to study it. She finds her self called to her deceased favorite authors home on the cliffs of a town and slowly uncovers not all things are as they seem. With the help of literature student Preston they gradually discover the history of some of their favorite works. I did find the world building a bit lacking, mainly because I wanted more. This story is very narrow in scope, and because of that the limited world building works just fine, but I am a nerd and wanted to know all about the history of the world and what certain things really mean.

Cover,
This cover is perfect and I love it.

Recommendation,
This is Ava Reid's first foray into young adult and its well done, if you like her other works then I think you would like this. It is perfect to read on a cold rainy day in fall.

***Thank You Netgalley and Harper Teen for the chance to read an eArc of this book in exchange for my free and honest review***

loved the eerie, spooky vibes. preston, the love interest, was such a nice change from cocky love interests. i liked that they were both on equal standing grounds. i breezed through this book so fast. it's the perfect autumn book to add to your tbr. i'm really satisfied with how it ended, it wrapped up so nicely. sometimes i think "that's it?" to the big reveal at the end of a book but this one was perfect !!

Thanks to NetGalley & HarperCollins Children's Books for the copy in exchange for an honest review.

Wow, wow, what a fantastic gothic mystery! It was raining the whole time I was reading and it really added to the cold and wet atmosphere of the book.

I absolutely loved reading the themes Reid brings up in the book--it's dark, but it's not...edgy, in a way. It's all presented very well and is integrated into the mystery and I won't say more in case I spoil it.

I can't say the characters were all my favorite, but I like how retrospective Effy is and acknowledges her flaws and works on them throughout the book. Fantastic story!

A Study in Drowning is a beautiful dark academia novel that encapsulates what it meant and means to be a woman in a male dominated world. I would say that it is a historical fantasy, though no specific time period is mentioned (e.g. Effy uses a payphone to call her mother). I don't enjoy realistic fiction, but I thoroughly enjoyed how Reid combined the genres. I loved this book and Reid's writing style.

A dilapidated (and possible haunted) house on a cliff by the sea? An evil Fairy King who may or may not be real? Academic rivals to lovers? A Study in Drowning has it all. But more than that, it has Effy Sayre. Effy who is smart and scared and strong in her own way. Effy who has survived through her books and escaping into stories. Effy whose story is all too familiar. Ava Reid handles Effy's story with care and compassion, allowing her to grow and find her voice in a way that feels earned and authentic.
I have to mention the romance as well. It unfolds in such a tender way, growing out of mural respect and shared interests. Reid (and Preston) make consent sexy.
Also, the long suffering English major in me is very vindicated that in this world studying literature is the most prestigious of all the arts!
The only note I have is that I was slightly confused by Angharad's appearance at the end of the book because I thought she was a ghost but then she got an apartment outside of the house so I guess she was real?? It wasn't very clear.

A Study in Drowning is a gorgeous gothic fantasy with academic rivals, haunted houses, devious schemes, and fairy kings in a Welsh-inspired war torn world. Perfect for fans of Divine Rivals or A Far Wilder Magic, ASID dives into mental health discussions that rarely receive this level of attention in young adult books. Protagonist Effy faces doubt and distrust from all sides, including her own mind, but she never loses sight of what she wants.

I wasn't expecting this story to take my breath away with slow-burn horrors and empathy. Effy has long dealt with nightmares of the Fairy King coming to her. She has always wanted a chance to study the author Emrys Myrrdin up close, since she believes his epic Angharad saved her. The story features how the title character evaded the Fairy King's seductions.

The chance soon comes when she wins a contest to renovate Emrys's crumbling house. A rival student who wants to prove Emrys is a fraud also comes, and they enter a tentative alliance to uncover a big mystery. Effy starts to worry that Preston is right, that her hero has a tainted legacy.

It brings up the question about how a lot of women and minorities have white male heroes in creative fields because those are more likely the stories that receive acclaim and awareness. We also get a sense of Gothic literature, and a love letter to legacies.

Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Reid possesses a writing style that is lush and all-encompassing. A Study in Drowning weaved together folklore and gothic themes, highlighting the harm of patriarchy and the expectations for women, both in academic settings and outside of them. I found the narrative both offensive and so incredibly important, as I’m sure the author wanted. The atmosphere was spot on, and while there were threads that I felt could be smoothed out a little, overall the story was captivating and compelling. Also, I loved Preston and the dynamic between him and Effy throughout the manuscript.

Thank you, Netgalley and the publisher, for an eARC version of this novel. Opinions are my own.

Moody, atmospheric with lyrical prose, at times ominous, A Study in Drowning is a beguiling dark academia fairy tale. The story centers around two college students investigating a literary mystery, holed up in a gothic house belonging to the late writer, Emrys Myrddin.

The fantasy element of the story is fairly light. Part of the intrigue is not quite knowing what is real or not, from Effy’s unreliable perspective: does the Fairy King she’s dreamed of since childhood really exist, or is she simply suffering from hallucinations as she’s been told? The question regarding the existence of the fae is one that everyone grapples with in this world: one of the strongest features is how writer Ava Reid creates and defines different geographic regions in this world (Llyr vs. Arganta, north vs. south), creating a rich tapestry of folklore inspired by Welsh tales; they are areas with varying political and spiritual beliefs, which adds a degree of reality to the world. While I wasn’t caught off guard by some of the latter twists, as the story barreled toward its ending, there were still some unexpected pay-offs and resolutions.

I was able to ask Reid if she was inspired a bit by A.S. Byatt’s Possession (which I read earlier this year), and while she had the idea for this book before she read Possession, she did say that reading helped inform some of the writing. Thematically, this book covers similar ideas regarding the feeling of ownership in scholarship/academia. But I also loved how this book reflects on additional ideas regarding women in male-dominated spaces. It’s hard to say more without dropping spoilers, but the constant presence of decay and nightmare that seem to envelop the story help to advance some of what is suggested regarding authorship and academia.

As characters, Effy and Preston are a strong rivals-to-lovers pairing. How they end up finding a home in one another is beautifully developed. I sort of wish we had more time with them in the end, to see Effy continue to develop, but I also appreciate where this one ended and that it’s a standalone.

(I do wonder if the YA rating is a bit of a stretch; I feel it’s more aptly New Adult since Effy and Preston are college-aged? It’s one I wouldn’t feel entirely comfortable recommending to all of my high school students given allusions to SA (though this is never explicitly described) and how at times it can feel quite dark.)

Thank you to HarperTeen and NetGalley for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review!

First off, let me say, that the concept of this story was a win for me. The silencing of voices, of women, the pervasive control exerted by men, married to the telling of fairy tales, of myth, and the differing opinions on what to believe or disbelieve.. it was all really enthralling. Helped, too, by the dreary and eerie setting, coated in danger and dampness, with an impending feeling of the world around you about to wash away in an instant.. yes, that was all very to the good.

It was everything else I disliked. As in, the characters. For all that they were a vehicle to move the story, to unravel the mysteries (which, let’s be real, I knew exactly how this was all going to go down almost right from the get-go) I felt they actually worked in opposition of my enjoyment and instead muddled it all up instead. And maybe it’s because I knew what was to come? It normally doesn’t impact my enjoying, the knowing, but when I’m struggling with an element of a story (again, the characters) maybe it did. Because it spilled over into the pacing, too. So maybe it was a two-fold thing.

But regardless, I do still think this is a story worth picking up. It may not be the most enjoyable experience — Reid is doing a lot with her narrative and it’s not all pleasant but a lot of it is important — but I’m not mad I gave this author a second go. Even though, looking back, it seems I had the same issues with THE WOLF AND THE WOODSMAN that I did with this one (spoiler alert : characters and romance) so time will tell if there’s ever a third attempt.

I liked the cozy, atmospheric vibes, perfect for a rainy day. It had an interesting premise and I appreciated how it handled heavy topics with care.

My biggest grievance was, I didn’t feel invested in their characters or their connection to each other. I didn’t understand what to root for. and that really took me out of it.

thank you to NetGalley and HarperTeen for this arc in exchange for an honest review!

I'm so sorry my review is late! I absolutely loved this book. This YA dark academia fantasy treat is beautifully written, with a rivals to lovers romance and a dash of Fae lore. But more importantly, it’s a story about survivial, mental health and believing women and marginalized genders, about agency and finding your voice in a world that consistently silences you.

Plus, as I was reading this, I was imagining myself on a cliffside in Cornwall, wind whipping through my hair and coat, the Atlantic raging below.

Happy sigh. 5 ecstatic, desirous stars.

Thank you to Harper Collins for an e-arc of this book in exchange for an honest review!

A lot of my fellow mutuals and reviewers bring up great points about potential shortcomings in the book — specifically concerning the romance, worldbuilding, and the characters themselves. Whether or not these aspects land or not will ultimately depend on the reader’s tastes, especially considering this is an Ava Reid novel where readers are oftentimes divided.

Hearing these concerns, I was admittedly worried that I wouldn’t end up enjoying the book because these are important points that I believe an author should hit in some ways for me to enjoy. However, I don’t think the sparse worldbuilding is too sparse that it unequivocally undermines what the book sets out to do. I think whether the worldbuilding completely falls flat or not will depend on the reader’s tastes and expectations. Because so many of my mutuals pointed this out, I was already expecting it so this never ended up bothering me. (Though I do think there was still a great opportunity to expand and delve deeper into this if the book was longer!)

I also actually thought the romance in this book was quite beautifully done. It was subtle and tender in a way that can easily be mistaken for underdeveloped though I think this once again is highly dependent on the reader’s expectations and even perhaps our expectations of what constitutes a worthwhile, “highly” developed romance. If you’re looking for a “rivals to lovers” that hits all the typical beats traditionally seen within the YA space (two highly contrasting personalities, high tension, drawn-out animosity, etc), then I think this will let you down. I believe this depiction of the romance is quite appropriate considering the plot which is situated within a larger context of injustice, trauma, and the unwavering determination to survive amidst it all. Seeing two soft characters fall in love in contrast to the harsh, unforgiving world around them was a strong point personally.

Reid is also masterfully skillful at prose that is both raw, hard-hitting and symbolic of the wider plot at hand — it personally never crosses over into territory where it reads fanciful or overly embellished. This is the third book of theirs that I have read and I can securely say that their style of writing is for me — there is something so emotionally evoking and tender about their writing style that drew me to tears by the end of the book for no concrete reason.

All of this is wrapped up in a broader critique of academia that in part pulls from Reid’s personal experiences — they absolutely nailed enfolding this within themes of survival, sexism, and systemic oppression. What I also think Reid does skillfully is incorporating the “story within a story” theme here, often seen in their previous books but reworked to tackle and explore different themes that fringe reality and imagination.

Overall, as Reid’s debut YA, I think they utterly shine here in a way that differs from their adult books, in a way that I think I ultimately prefer more.

Effy Sayre has been an ardent fan of Emyrs Myrrdin ever since she was a child, holding close to her heart the story of Angharad which she finds a deep connection with. Despite her deep love of literature, she is a woman and women are not allowed in the literature college so she settles for the next highest college - the architecture college. When an opportunity arises for an architecture student to design Hiraeth Manor, the late Myrrdin’s home, Effy enters her name for the opportunity - and is chosen!

But designing Hiraeth Manor is an impossible task: it is literally crumbling into the sea. On top of that, when Effy arrives at Hiraeth, she finds literature student Preston Héloury there to study Myrrdin’s papers, determined to prove that he was a fraud. Despite their initial animosity, the two work together to investigate Myrrdin’s legacy - one trying to discredit him and the other hoping to redeem him - and find that Hiraeth’s foundation may not be the only thing that can’t be trusted.

It’s the season for dark academia and this story is the perfect addition to any TBR seeking those vibes. In this breathtakingly atmospheric tale, we follow a young woman who is doing everything she can to just survive in the world. From a young age, Effy has been spoken down to and her experiences discounted simply because she is a woman. Effy is heartbreakingly relatable, a character who is lost and struggles with her mental health but still finds a way to stick around.

An entire generation (looking at you fellow millennials!) is going to find themselves relating to Effy’s struggles while reading this story. With Preston’s digging into Myrrdin’s history, Effy faces the potentiality of the fall of her biggest hero and idol. A work that she has found comfort in for the majority of her life gets called into question due to the muddy waters that the author ends up in. If you grew up entranced by a certain wizard and his world only to find that the author is an utter and complete bigot, you know exactly how this feels.

This story will leave you aching, for Effy and everyone involved. It is a beautiful story that causes you to question things you know and hold close the ones that mean something to you. Following Effy’s journey from the start to end, though it hurts at times, also brings hope - that one person can make a difference and can make changes happen. It's also a reminder that social stigma can (and should) be fought against, especially when it comes to mental health struggles.

Some content warnings for those who need them: sexual assault, abuse of power imbalance, sexism, parental rejection, parental death, amputation, child abandonment, discussion of child sacrifice, potential for drowning, and mental health stigma.

Disclaimer: I received an advanced copy of this book from the publisher for free and have voluntarily written this review.