Member Reviews
ERASING THE FINISH LINE by Ana Homayoun is subtitled "The New Blueprint for Success Beyond Grades and College Admission." The only dispute I have with that is: is this really "new"? Homayoun points out the importance of developing a system, connections, perspective, and acceptance. She rightly stresses the importance and impact of executive functioning skills like organization, planning, and prioritizing, plus self-motivation (starting and completing tasks, meeting deadlines), adaptable thinking, and feeling comfortable with asking for help. These are all key life skills which we practice in high school again and again, particularly on a big, individual project like Junior Theme. Each chapter begins with an anecdote introducing a former student, like Nira, excited to be admitted to Notre Dame, who says, "the hardest part of college was learning to manage time and keep track of what I was responsible for and holding myself accountable when ... there was no one there to wake me up in the morning." Good advice from a peer of sorts, and at one point Homayoun also includes several strategies to "help children [emphasis added; why choose that term?] develop multiple circles of connection." Overall, however, her work is very text heavy and could benefit from more bullet points, checklists, and even sample exercises to further support the students she seeks to help. It seems likely that Homayoun has resisted this more directed guidance because she specifically states, "rather than doggedly pursuing the never-ending list of 'must dos' and 'should dos,' it's time for us to accept that there is not one 'perfect' way to find success." Yes, hard to argue with that; we have had Homayoun's earlier work (That Crumpled Paper Was Due Last Week) in our collection and will likely be adding ERASING THE FINISH LINE, also. Approximately ten percent of the book is devoted to references and notes which will interest researchers and those curious readers wishing to learn more. Also worth considering: 6 Super Skills for Executive Functioning by Lara Honos-Webb.
Erasing the Finish Line is a thought-provoking and inspiring book that offers a new vision for success. I think it would be a good read especially for students, parents, and educators who are looking for a new, unique, and different way to prepare young people for the future.