Member Reviews
Thanks, Kate Callaghan, for the arc!
MS. PERFECTLY FINE by Kate Callaghan was another book I’m sad I sat on because I really enjoyed it, but tbh, I think I read at the perfect time for me when I was having a bad flare-up of my health. I needed to read a story of a girl similar to me struggling through life with her chronic condition and knowing she had people there for her and that it’s okay to let new ones in. Plus, this is just a cute romance with a surprising bit of suspense!
Autumn is written with an excellent chronic pain representation. I really related to her and understood her feelings and insecurities. I felt seen, and I liked that. I appreciated how Elijah was written. Sure, he was a jerk initially, but once he realized she had real issues, he did what he could to adapt and help her. 🥹 (If only the whole world were this way…)
The forced proximity was great. I laughed a lot and loved how they fell into a relationship. And I was super surprised about the suspense! I did not expect it to be that suspenseful, and I felt like I was reading a thriller at some points. It made the book a lot of fun between the romance, comedy, and suspense!
I think this is a fun book for anyone, but I hope whoever reads it gives grace to Autumn and remembers that there are real people like her out there (Hi! It’s me!). I hope that you enjoy this book like I did because it was a lot of fun!
Content warnings: stalking, gaslighting, death, grief, chronic illness, medical trauma, ableism
This was pretty cute.
I liked the classical musician x gamer aspect and the fact that Autumn had chronical pains (which isn't something you encounter very often in a romance novel), so kudos to the author for that! Forced proximity is also one of my favorite trope so I liked that about this.
Other than that, this is being marketed as a romantic suspense/thriller, but that missed the mark a bit for me. The focus was more on the romance and I just didn't feel very threatened by someone leaving roses? Also, the reveal of the culprit didn't make a lot of sense to me somehow. But overall, a pretty cute read.
This is a captivating read for fans of romance, mystery, and suspense, particularly those who enjoy stories about overcoming adversity, healing, and the blossoming of love in the face of adversity, with a dash of humor and wit.
"Ms Perfectly Fine" was my second Kate Callaghan book and I was really excited for it, after reading the premise.
One of my favorite tropes is the Grumpy x Sunshine trope and I got really intrigued when I saw that Autumn is the grumpy in this story.
It took me a while to get into the story and sadly I couldn't really get attached to Autumn or Elijah. I did like the way they were portrayed but something was missing for me. In some moments the story went to fast for me and it was overall a lot of the story. It could have been a bit shorter at some moments or she could have made this book into a two-book-series.
I liked most about the story that the topic of chronic pain was addressed and how it was handled.
Thank you to NetGalley and CallaghanWriter for this EARC!
DNF @ ~25%
I really wanted to give this book a good chance, but I couldn’t get attached to it or the characters. Maybe one day, I could give this book another shot and rewrite my review :)
Thank you, Netgalley, for the ARC!
This was a cute read! Glad I got to read this--looking forward to more from this author.
Thank you NetGalley and Kate Callaghan!
Miss Perfectly Fine by Kate Callaghan is a fun and relatable read about the pressures of trying to be perfect. The story follows Frances, who looks like she’s got everything figured out but is actually struggling with her insecurities and the weight of expectations.
Overall, I really liked it and enjoyed the read.
I’d give this book 3 stars—it was cute but didn’t quite live up to its potential. Autumn Adler’s story as a concert pianist making a comeback sounded intriguing, and I liked the premise of her being forced to share her house with game designer Elijah Wells. Still, the execution fell a little flat for me. The characters were likable but felt one-dimensional, and I didn’t get the depth I hoped for. The enemies-to-lovers romance was rushed, and the switch from arguing to flirting happened too quickly to feel believable. That said, the banter between Autumn and Elijah was fun and one of my favorite parts, but the overall pacing of the story felt off. The side plots had promise, but they needed more time to develop, and I think the book would have been more substantial if it had just focused on the romance. On the plus side, Brinkley, the standout character, brought a lot of charm! It was an enjoyable read, but nothing that stood out for me.
Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC for an honest review.
i unfortunately just could not get into reading this book and it took me a while to finish. i found it quite overly descriptive and felt it could have been 2 books instead of 1. i did enjoy the romance between autumn and elijah though!
It wad good but it wasn’t great! I enjoyed the story and I liked the characters however it also feel kind of flat for me.
I expected a lot from reading the blurb so maybe it is partly ma fault for going in with high expectations but the characters and story sometimes didn’t feel developed enough.
But overall it was a fun read!
I could not put this book down! As someone with a chronic illness that leaves me in chronic pain it was really validating to read about a character who struggled with something similar and was still able to succeed in her life.
The chemistry between Autumn and Elijah was fantastic and as someone who typically flirts with my partner by bickering/teasing that was also nice to read about as well!
*I received a free ARC from Netgalley*
Ms Perfectly Fine follows the story of Autumn Adler, a famous pianist, who had an accident while she was performing. She crosses paths with Elijah, a man who designs games, and they fall in love as they are forced to live together in Autumn's house. This was my first book of Kate that I read and won't be the last. The writing reminded me of Ali Hazelwood and the characters were so good, especially Autumn and Elijah.
I wasn't expecting the plot twist to be so unexpected, as I was reading the book I thought it was something at first but it turned out to be another thing and I loved it, well done.
Overall, this was an amazing read that I would recommend to everyone who likes romance and forced proximity trope. Thank you to Independent Books Publishers Association for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
This was a fast burn that I was just okay with. I definitely think I am a slow burn reader for sure but I’m not saying g what was done was bad at all! They were very cute together and it was a fun popcorn read for sure
I've tried to read this multiple times, and it just isn't for me. I'm sure there will be some who can relate to the main character, but unfortunately I do not feel I am the intended audience for this story.
It’s a feel-good read with a mix of romance and self-discovery, perfect if you enjoy stories about finding love and being true to yourself.
**3.5 stars**
*Ms. Perfectly Fine* is an enjoyable, light romance with a touch of suspense that keeps you turning the pages. Autumn Adler, a determined concert pianist focused on her comeback, and Elijah Wells, a driven game designer, make for an entertaining pair as they clash over their shared living space. The dynamic between Autumn and Elijah is fun to watch, with plenty of witty banter and stubbornness on both sides. Their chemistry slowly builds as they move from adversaries to something more, and the tension between them is one of the highlights of the book. Elijah's relentless attempts to win Autumn over add a playful charm to the story, even as she tries to keep her distance. However, while the romance is sweet and the premise intriguing, some aspects of the story felt a bit underdeveloped. The suspense element, particularly the mysterious gift and its implications, could have been explored in more depth to create a stronger impact. Additionally, the pacing sometimes felt uneven, with certain parts dragging while others rushed by too quickly. Overall, *Ms. Perfectly Fine* is a charming read that balances romance with a hint of mystery. While it has its flaws, it's a solid choice for anyone looking for a story with endearing characters and a satisfying, if not entirely surprising, conclusion.
Such a cute romance! I loved every trope that was mixed into this story. It was so much fun getting to see Autumn evade Elijah's flirty personality. The build up and pranks were well integrated.
Tropes:
- reverse grumpy x sunshine
- forced proximity
- he falls first
- enemies to lovers
I really enjoyed this book, such a great feel good romance. Made me laugh and was a really enjoyable read, great for summer time!
This was not really what I thought it would be. I didn’t like the characters and found the story a bit far fetched. The cover is what drew me in but unfortunately wasn’t the one for me.
I actuallyy liked this book tbut I really wished people would stop writing books with Taylor swifts song tittles is not bad I am coming from a swiftie but this was cute and really lived up to the hyped!