Pay attention, listen, and refuse.

How did the book make me feel/think?

“Not Here” is an enthralling narrative that urges Canada to resist the American influence it has been subjected to since Confederation.

Canadians find themselves inundated with Americanization through various media, literature, and entertainment channels. America tantalizes us with its offerings, and we find ourselves yearning for more, while simultaneously witnessing the unsettling developments unfolding across the border.

Is America on the verge of collapse right in front of our eyes? Are values like decency and trust being eroded to an irreversible extent? Is authoritarianism vying for dominance?

To many Americans, Canadians are perceived as a polite annoyance, waiting for an opportunity to be used when needed. It is imperative that we reject the American model and stand against authoritarianism.
Goodman argues that Canadians must remove their blinders and abandon their self-righteousness because the afflictions plaguing America are not exclusive to them. We are not immune, nor can we claim innocence.
According to Goodman, Canada’s strength lies in its failures. The inability to unite as “one people” with a shared purpose has taught us valuable lessons.

Canadians must continue to learn and define who they aspire to be, and without a doubt, America currently serves as a cautionary example of what to avoid.

Goodman passionately implores all Canadians to pay attention, listen, and resist!

WRITTEN: 24 July 2023

As a Canadian, but ardent observer of American politics, this book was an absolute mix of the two. Goodman watched the rise of authoritarianism in the United States, but has since made Toronto his home. As a history teacher, I always start the course asking what makes up the Canadian identity? to which many students respond, "not American." This book provides a real discussion about what makes Canada different from the United States, especially in terms of democratic ideals. The book outlines the ways in which the eroding American democracy can impact Canada, and how Canada can act to preserve our democracy. He also ties in contemporary Canadian issues which I was glad to see, such as making meaningful mention to residential schools and the challenges Canada faces in reconciliation with Indigenous peoples. Really interesting book, strong writing, and would recommend!