Member Reviews

RUINED is a grafic novel perfect for wild fans - like me - of Bridgerton. Ruined by Sarah Vaughn tells of the relationship between Catherine Benson and the enigmatic and charming Andrew.

The whole town is whispering about how Catherine Benson lost her virtue, though they can never agree on the details. Was it in the public garden? Or a moving carriage?

Only a truly desperate man would want her now―and that’s exactly what Andrew Davener is. His family’s estate is in disrepair, but Catherine’s sizeable dowry could set it to rights.

After the two wed, Catherine finds herself inexplicably drawn to Andrew. but could falling in love with her husband tear her marriage apart? In this richly detailed Regency romance, duty and passion collide in a slow-burn tale of intertwined fates.


I found the story extremely cute and flowing. The drawings, despite their simplicity, are really very tender and the color palette is sensational.

Bridgerton's influence can be felt from the very first page but this aspect did not bother me at all.

An extremely cute and enjoyable graphic novel. Perfect for lovers of the world created by Julia Quinn and for lovers of the genre.

Thank you so much to NetGalley. the editor and Sarah Vaughn for providing me with this ARC copy inchange of an honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

This was a nice regency graphic, pretty much what is expected. Nothing new or different but I still enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this one missed the mark for me. I wasn’t the biggest fan of the art style, especially when the characters were drawn with certain expressions (it didn’t look good to me) and for it being a graphic novel, the art is the main focus really.
For a romance, I really couldn’t get behind it. I guess this type isn’t for me but the marriage of convenience and romance arc felt more awkward than swoon-worthy.

Was this review helpful?

Ruined is a Regency-era graphic novel. It follows Catherine and Andrew.

Catherine has turned away every suitor, but this year after a scandal, her father made arrangements to marry her off to Andrew Davaner. He desperately needs the money and she needs a husband to shut off the rumours.

It was just supposed to be a marriage of convenience, but as they got to know each other, the sparks flew between them.

It's a slow-burn romance, but a good one. I liked the story but didn't like the artwork all that much.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and First Second for the ARC!

I was very excited by the premise of Ruined but ended up spending a lot of my time reading it slightly confused. It kept feeling like I was missing something, especially when it came to the side characters. As if there was backstory for them that got cut for time and they hoped we'd manage to figure it out.

This could be solved in publication for all I know, but the transition between scenes was very jarring a lot of the time. There were a few moments where it felt like a page was missing, then suddenly we're in a new scene. Perhaps the final version will have chapter transitions that could make this easier. But as it was it was confusing.

I also don't know if I really buy the transition in their love story. He comforted her once when she needed it and I see how it could've opened them up to each other more. But after that their time together was told in a montage and I didn't really get to see them fall in love. I wish we had gotten to see more of those moments. Dude literally falls down a hill and realizes he had fallen in love with her? Yeah, ok.

Unfortunately, not a fan of this one. Hopefully others will enjoy it more than I did.

Was this review helpful?

I love a historical romance, and this might be the first graphic novel one that I’ve read. Ruined is a quick and heart wrenching story. After Catherine and Andrew are labeled “ruined” by society, each for their own reasons, they wed mostly as a way to save themselves and their families from disgrace. While a marriage of convenience helps them both, Catherine is still looking for love and hesitates to get close to Andrew. Over time these two learn to help each other while love starts to blossom, even if they’re not great at communicating that to one another. I really enjoyed watching these two eventually stumble into love and all of the side characters in the story were really great as well.

Was this review helpful?

Ruined was a fun and quick read. However, it lacked a full depth to the characters which made them interesting but a little flat. Overall it was enjoyable but that was all.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a cute graphic novel! I gotta admit, when I first saw the cover, I expected a different artstyle but that is just because the cover was so small on my laptop screen, it does fit!
I think storywise, this one could have been a bit longer so the readers could see more of the characters and especially I would have liked to see more of Gemma and how she overcomes her fears and not just her going outside at some point to comfort her brother. I think there were just a bit too many different storylines that were put out here to be really executed properly. I mean I liked all of it, but since there were so many different storylines to follow, I would have wished for more information on them all.
The artstyle was very cute, but I had some difficulties with imagining and understanding especially how old the characters are. It was kind of plain (which is not a bad thing!) so I would have hoped for a few more details on the characters. Sometimes the pages were also really fuzzy, but only the drawings and not the lines of the characters which made me a bit confused because that meant, that the fuzziness did not come from my phone but from the page itself.
All in all, still a very cute graphic novel, especially since it is completly in colour!

Was this review helpful?

An easy and angsty read for fans of regency graphic novels! The storyline was simple and predictable of others in the genre but the author and illustrator truly depicted the conveyed the sadness, longing, and love of the characters throughout the book. My only wish was for more character expansion with the Catherine's past relationship and that of Andrew's family trauma (and his relationship with his sister). Otherwise, a great storyline and artwork.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first graphic novel and I was completely smitten! Of course we know the P&P story and this retelling in GN format was so well done.

Was this review helpful?

"Ruined" by Sarah Vaughn is a captivating blend of historical fiction and romance. The book's compelling storyline and vivid art kept me engrossed, offering a unique take on history and romance.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!

I enjoyed the artistry of this graphic novel, but unfortunately it wasn't my cup of tea personally. While I typically enjoy a great romance, I just felt like this story wasn't for me and I couldn't push through to finish it.

Was this review helpful?

The setting and setup of this comic is very familiar to anyone who has read Jane Austen or Julia Quinn, that should draw readers in. I stayed because of all the little modern sensibilities this title had, such as the diverse cast. Seriously, do you know how refreshing it is in a title like this that the lead couple actually talk to each other about their wants, needs and fears? They may not love, but they work well together and that's fine. The rest of the cast also show that there can be plenty of interpersonal drama that can be had and it's just as engaging when you like the characters it's happening to. Regency romance fans, and people curious about what appeals to said romance fans, should give this a look!

Was this review helpful?

The art is well done and the concept is fantastic. It’s a short, easy read, but the plot is a little shallow.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publishing team for this ARC!

This is a fun read for those who love historical romance with Pride & Prejudice vibes. It's my first time seeing a HR as a graphic novel so I was really intrigued by it. While I didn't love the art style, the story was easy to follow and sweet. I enjoyed reading it!

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun and steamy historical romance graphic novel that is perfect for fans of Bridgerton and regency romance. I liked the art style a lot! The color palate felt cozy and I loved seeing the fashion from that time period. The romance was really great to follow. Marriage of convenience is one of my favorite tropes when it’s done well and this story definitely hit the mark. Even though it’s a graphic novel, it didn’t hold back on the spice, so just be aware that it does get, well, a bit graphic for lack of a better word.
This was an easy and quick read and I really enjoyed the story.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author/illustrators and the publisher for providing me an early copy in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This was a really quick read. The art was nice. I just felt the plot wasn’t as flushed out as I would have wanted. It felt a bit too easy with not enough conflict or anything

Was this review helpful?

From the gorgeous cover to the absolute romance and chemistry in this book, I was hooked. I finished it in a day while at work (oops). I loved the book!

Was this review helpful?

Perfect for fans of Bridgerton, this book filled the regency romance genre to a T. Illustrations were more graphic then anticipated, definitely for an adult graphic novel audience rather than YA.

Was this review helpful?

My first time trying graphic novel regency romance and I probably won't do it again. I found the story to be boring and the graphics could have been a lot better since this is supposed to be sexy and romantic, not look like something for kids.

Was this review helpful?