Member Reviews

This was a really difficult book to review because I loved a lot of it. The setting of this dark tourism capital town where everyone’s life revolves around death and spirits is so interesting. I wish it were a real place! Love the spooky aesthetic and moments where characters just have knowledge that you would acquire living in a town like this like casually discussing the differences between shades and revenants or the finer points of mausoleums and catacombs. Very fun and a nice detail.

Loved the mystery elements and the adventures the characters would go on to unravel those mysteries which let us explore the town and its history more along the way and which provided some pretty great horror elements.The characters themselves were diverse and interesting and I wish we went deeper with them.

The weak point for me however was the character of Olive. I get that teens can be dramatic and am ok with that, but at times it felt she read much younger than teen with the way she reacts to some things and her behavior. Her personality is her trauma of surviving a shellfish allergy after being revived by paramedics. The existential death anxiety that follows takes over her whole life. Lifelong friends are abandoned, any aspirations for the future are abandoned. Only her constant thoughts of “the nothing” and occasionally her obsession with Mrs. H, an elderly woman at the care home she volunteered at who she forms a bond with but who passes away suddenly. And look, if this were mentioned once or twice or was shown in a more indirect way or if there were more to Olive’s character, it wouldn’t be a big issue. But we hear about it through Olives thoughts over and over and over again. However, once the story gets going and we have the other characters show up it’s really fun and interesting and there are some great twists and turns. It’s overall a fun read.

This book is a great fall read, it is spooky season personified. If you are looking for a quick and spooky read where you get to explore old abandoned asylums and graveyards and mausoleums this book has all those fall vibes covered.

I received an advance review copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I can confidently say I have not read a book like this and for that fact alone I enjoyed it. It is not often I read something that makes me feel like I am reading something new. This is a perfect book to add to a spooky reading list if you want something that wont scare you to death but will get you into the ghost spirit of things. I will say that if you are easily distracted you may have to reread certain parts more then once to understand what has happened as I had to do this many times having three kiddos running around while reading it. There were times I was completely lost but going back did help. (I will say this is not typically an issue with other books I read so maybe this was a writing style issue.) All in all A great book with characters I really enjoyed.

Was this review helpful?

"Here Lies Olive" is deliciously sarcastic with teenagers dealing with real-life issues, worries, and angst. It's hilarious, it's sappy, and everything in between. 10/10 will be reading again.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book. I honestly think this is the perfect YA "Spooky Season" book. It hit every box I wanted- eerie without being cheesy, writing that understood and leaned just enough into camp to make it fun, light romance without the typical YA drama (ie "do they like me, my world will end if they don't like me back," love triangles, etc) LGBT and Indigenous representation, ponderings of existential dread that a LOT of teens experience, and some really good reflections on friendships and family, and what it means to love someone even when it's hard.
There was so much going on with this book, and yet it didn't feel rushed or forced. All of it was delicately wound into a story about a girl who is so scared about the "Nothing" after death that she's cut herself off from her loved ones-- and who makes a last ditch attempt to contact a ghost to see if they can tell her anything more concrete about the afterlife (which goes very wrong and catapults her into the events of the book.) The book follows several characters, and each one is unique and well-rounded. I didn't ever get the sense that someone was written in as a prop or to further along the narrative.
I am honestly blown away that this is Anderson's first book. I am so excited to see what she comes up with next.

Was this review helpful?

Huge thank you to NetGalley and North Star Editions, Flux for allowing me to read this ARC!

This story was super interesting and I loved the characters! The vibes are perfect for spooky seasons. While this book seemed a bit young for me, I think this is a great book for the YA reader! Characters have great depth and development and deal with loss in a very understandable way. I loved the LGBTQ+ Rep!

Was this review helpful?

Wonderful coming of age, fall read! Its coming to that point of the year when cuddling up on the couch with a book is a whole vibe, and here we are with the perfect book for this. I loved the relatability to the FMC to the coming of age experience! It tackles so many existential ideas in an easy way that were just wonderful to experience.

Was this review helpful?

A spooky sapphic read with surprising emotional depth, HERE LIES OLIVE expertly balances lighthearted romance with serious topics like death and family trauma.

Our main character Olive is eDgY but self-aware; she wears dark lipstick and has a bit of an alternative style, but admits to being a basic white girl. She leans into the spooky vibes of her little hometown of White Haven, New Mexico, a dark tourism hotspot described as “a morbid Stars Hollow.”

Olive discovered she had a shellfish allergy in the worst possible way a few years ago, and technically died. She saw Nothing and her priorities shifted: Who cares about school and friends if when you die, you cease to exist?

Olive struggles constantly with her feelings around death and dying, which are exacerbated by the recent death of her surrogate grandmother, Mrs. Hernandez. She is haunted by the thought that Mrs. H is really gone, and the only thing keeping her going is the thought that she could be wrong–maybe she was somewhere in between.

Accompanied by a new girl who wants to be her best friend, the former best friend she abandoned, and an annoying type-A descendant of the man who owned the maybe-haunted asylum, Olive sets out on a mission to disprove what she thinks she saw when she died–Nothing. And the best person to ask about the afterlife is someone who’s in it.

I was so impressed with this book. I expected dark, I expected sapphic, but I did not expect the whirlwind of emotions I would experience with every page. Olive is an authentic teen with trauma who is just trying to figure things out. She doesn’t want anyone to get too close because loss is so painful, and her otherwise loving and supportive parents don’t talk about her experience so she doesn’t either. She is highly empathetic, quickly realizing that there is more to stuck-up Maren, who is just trying to get out from under the weight of her family’s dark past, and feeling an immediate flood of guilt when she realizes how she treated Davis when she went through her near-death experience.

The plot did dip a little bit in the middle, seemingly just to give them time to do regular teen things, but for a relatively short book this did not hurt my reading experience much. The prose is visual and descriptive, there is good LGBTQ+ and Indigenous rep, and I absolutely did not see that ending coming. A perfect first read for the start of spooky season. I highly recommend.

Thank you to NetGalley and North Star Editions for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Meet Olive. 2 years after she died and was brought back to life, shes still questioning what she saw in the hereafter. And was it the true hereafter.

Determined to find out she enlists the help of new friend Vanessa, an ex BFF Davis and Maren, her arch nemesis after she summons the spirit of Jay in the old Asylum. But not everything, or everyone is as it seems.

Dark YA with some heavy-ish themes. This was enjoyable & honestly there were a few parts were I was actually a bit afraid to turn the lights off after (I'm looking at you Shades. Actually, no I'm not 🫣)

Would definitely recommend as a spooky read, as well as a coming of age story with Indigenous and LGBTQ reps.

Was this review helpful?

Like
- Absolutely loved the strong start. It was new, it was a great idea and I was excited to continue with this book
- I loved the charm New Haven had and it was a perfect setting used
- It generated that fall/Halloween vibe that I really enjoyed and the descriptions used were really strong
- Very diverse set of characters as well

Dislike
- It became very repetitive after the half way mark and especially nearing the end of the book
- The plot felt dragged out and I wasn't really interested in it anymore
- There were some holes I felt like were missing throughout and some of the actions felt disoriented

Was this review helpful?

I'm not totally sure how I feel about this one. It felt a bit young for YA, reading more like a middle grade novel, except I don't think the horror elements would be appropriate for that age group. The plot and premise was interesting but the characters and their motives felt a bit flat. The humour was a bit corny for my taste. Appreciated the diversity and LGBTQ+ representation.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the supernatural aspects of this engaging YA horror read! The dark tourism aspects of the town were fun to read. I was immediately invested in Olive's story. I couldn't turn the pages fast enough to find out what would happen next. This is Kate Anderson's first book. I can't wait to read her next novel!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley for the ARC of Here Lies Olive in exchange for an honest review.

...and I'll be honest. I struggled quite a lot with this book.

**potential spoilers below**

The title, cover, and description all sounded right up my alley and drew me in to requesting (and ultimately reading) this book. Paranormal? Check. Cozy small town ala Gilmore Girls? Check. Creepy abandoned asylum? Check. Sapphic love? Check.

None of those, however, accounted for how annoying the main character is. She is incredibly two-dimensional for being a "not like the other girls" girl. She has one character trait and it's the fact that she died and came back. Maybe I'm being harsh, but like.... having a seafood allergy isn't special! I got nothing else from her, besides being completely obtuse to things going on around her. Most of the other characters were similar, with only one trait and not much else.

The plot had SO MUCH potential as well, but ultimately fell flat due to poor development. I didn't really understand Olive's motives, many of the scenes with paranormal activity were confusing to read, and as much as I love a sapphic love story, it was so forced I wanted to cringe. I really enjoyed reading the history of the asylum and getting into that aspect of it, but the plot line of what comes after death was not really cohesive across the story.

There were also moments in the narrative that nearly gave me whiplash. For instance, the first 4 chapters describe the small town and bring out a lot of Halloween vibes with no real nods to the "outside world", until in Chapter 5 there is seemingly random acknowledgements of school shootings, police brutality, and climate change. I did not see any of that coming, nor is it brought up anymore in the story.

After reading a few other reviews, I have to agree that I see this book fitting into the middle grade category, more than YA. If I were 10 years younger, I may have loved this.

Was this review helpful?

To begin, thank you to Netgalley and North Star Editions for the Advanced Reading Copy in exchange for an honest review

Set in America's Halloween tourist town, after Olive has a near death experience, she begins to question what happens after we die and fears that there is an endless expanse of Nothing waiting for her. Soon after, one of her closest friends dies, and it gives her hope that there is something happier in the afterlife. She then summons a ghost in hopes of asking him what happens after we die, but instead she brings to life a traumatized boy who doesn't know he's dead. so, olive and her friends work together to set his spirit free into whatever comes next.

I want to preface by saying: I am not a paranormal fan. I don't read horror. so, I am biased. But the reason I didn't like this book was not the genre.

To start: Olive.
She was predictable and a huge stereotype. She's characterized as just... "different", but she's nothing of the sort. Her entire character is wanting to know what happens after life and liking dark lipstick. She has no complexity.
Plus, Olive was INCREDIBLY dense. Not once did she have a revelation that was shocking to the reader. Instead, for someone who seems to have such authority over the events occurring, it took Olive an insane amount of time to understand everything.
I did enjoy that we also watch her gain friendships back after losing them, but... that was it. Her love story was such a stereotype. It was expected and forced for her to fall in love. I didn't see any spark between the two. Instead, it felt like "oh, well, of course she's going to fall in love because that's just something she would do" instead of watching the story form naturally.

One thing I did like was the complexity of the conflict (although some parts were hard to read because it doesn't align with my beliefs, but I won't get into that). Death is one thing that people don't usually talk about seriously. Today, people dissect and question everything in life, but death is left untouched. Death is the one thing people say "well, you can have your own beliefs about that". it's invigorating to read a book about teenagers dealing with these issues. Teenagers who, evidently, feel almost invincible.
---
The conflicts in the novel that Olive faces, give us an insight on the craziness, yet also ingenuous manner of her town. Her town simply ignores that Olive died, and they like to glamorize death in a cute, spooky way, but also won't discuss it with anyone. This highlights the differing sides of her town, which I found interesting.

The author has an incredible talent with writing. She uses beautiful, flowery language and has thousands of hidden messages in a seemingly cute, fun book. I could talk about the meaning of her words for hours, but, I just wish the plot and characters were developed better. Anderson had amazing writing and an amazing idea. It was just executed poorly. I will certainly read more of her books in the future.
---
Overall, it's a 3.5 star book rounded down. I really wish I could rate it higher, but, I just think plot and character hold more significance than the writing and message.
If Olive had a better character, and some plot holes were fixed, then this would be a five star from me.
I recommend this to people who love spooky season and anybody who likes beautiful writing. This is probably not something I would recommend to any of my friends, just because it's not usually my thing, but I did enjoy it.

Was this review helpful?

3.25 Wow, this was a debut novel- it’s great for a debut for sure, not exactly my genre though. Maren is my favorite character I love her sm, I only guessed part of the “plot twist”? Spoilers; Vanessa being a ghost or whatever but not her being related to the Seymour’s and the ribbon I thought was holding her head up in a headless type of way nkt tieing her to her victims at all. The “closure” for the book and Olive felt great.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks so much to the publisher and to Netgalley for providing me with an e-ARC copy of this book! My reviewing & platforms information is linked in my profile.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was such a cute book. Dark, and obviously themes of death & dying, but that is right up my alley and just in time for Spooky Season.

I did spend the first half of the book wishing that Olive would go to therapy, but it really helped build into the character growth that she had throughout the book.

I was able to figure out the majority of the plot twist, but I don't think that was a problem, I think it goes to show how good the foreshadowing was by the author that I had an idea of what was happening so when it did I had a "I KNEW IT" moment, and we all love those.

I loved the dark parts of the book, but just as much I loved the parts that focused on friendships and relationships. They were written well, and added to the story, instead of feeling like a separate piece of the story.

Was this review helpful?

I LOVED IT!
At first it was a bit boring for me because it started slowly, but as the pages turned the story began to take action. The plot twist that happened in the story I didn't expect it to happen. I saw something coming related to "that person" but not THAT, I loved that twist. I liked that the protagonist could heal it was really beautiful, not only her relationship with death but with her loves one. I loved that little rivalry that went on between Maren and Olive, how at the end of the day they are very similar but different at the same time. I love this "hate to love" trope.

Was this review helpful?

3.5! this book was really interesting and a really good debut. i especially loved the setting, the way the town was described was so cool. i enjoyed this!

Was this review helpful?

This book plunges you headfirst into autumn vibes and doesn't let up. It brings together an unlikely group of friends on a supernatural journey that starts out secretive and selfish, and ends up bringing them together in ways they couldn't have predicted.

I appreciated the way the characters all start out feeling like caricatures, but quickly develop their own personalities and flaws and idiosyncrasies as the story develops. I also really enjoyed the way it tackles the question of what comes after death, something anyone who's experienced loss has grappled with.

At almost exactly the halfway point, I developed my own hypothesis about the mystery within the story and, as someone not particularly into mysteries or predictions, enjoyed watching the story play out to see if I was right. It turned out to be mostly correct, but I questioned it plenty of times along the way and still enjoyed the story even after I'd confirmed (most of) my theory.

In the end, this was spooky and creepy and weird, and also a sweet love story and a lesson about really living.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A perfect spooky read. Just in time for spooky season, I love Olives character.

Thank you Netgalley and North Stars Editions for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?