Member Reviews

Thank you to Random House Children's | Delacorte Press and NetGalley for an electronic advanced readers copy of this novel.

Her Dark Wings by Melinda Salisbury is a YA retelling of the Hades and Persephone story, except with 2 teenagers as the main characters. Bree and Corey were best friends until Corey's boyfriend cheated on her with Bree. Angry with what happened, Corey is thrown for a loop when Bree dies. With mixed emotions, Corey tries to grieve her friend, yet she is still furious about Bree's betrayal. Then the gods get involved.

I don't want to go more into it due to spoilers, but I thought it was an interesting retelling of the myth.

Was this review helpful?

It was beautifully written, had that thriller edge to it but the characters go had more depth. Love the world but needed more detail in my opinion. Overall great book but just need a little more like.

Was this review helpful?

I really adored this retelling. It was interesting and creative in a way that other Persephone stories haven't yet been told.

Was this review helpful?

Her Dark Wings by Melinda Salisbury offers a fresh and captivating YA retelling of the Hades and Persephone myth. Salisbury truly excels in her vivid descriptions and the depth of her characters' personalities, adding layers of richness to the narrative.

This retelling stands out for its immersive storytelling, where every detail enhances the experience. The dynamic between the characters is compelling, drawing readers into their world and making their journey unforgettable. If you’re a fan of mythology reimagined with flair, Her Dark Wings is a must-read that will leave a lasting impression.

Was this review helpful?

I’m left wanting more.. the length of the story was great, but I’m thinking the pages could have been filled with more substance. Much of the storyline felt like it was dragging and waiting to get to the next scene.

A multiple point of view could have worked very well here. Bree was likable enough, but added POVs could have helped her out a bit.

Overall, I would have liked to see more characters POVs and more world building.

Was this review helpful?

I was excited about this one but it was archived before I got fully invested, so sadly it's a DNF for me.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this was a DNF at 18%. I just really didn’t jive with the writing style. It was difficult for me to blend the poetic writing with the angsty teenager narrative.

Have no doubts many teens will like it. Just wasn’t for me.

Was this review helpful?

Holy moly this cover is gorgeous!!! I really love the Persephone and Hades myth and I really enjoyed Melinda's take on it.

Was this review helpful?

Retellings, especially ones as epic as Melinda Salisbury’s latest, will always end up on my TBR. This Persephone myth retelling about childhood best friends was an easy add to our best books of December list. Read it as soon as it comes out to find out why.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this Persephone x Hades retelling and thought it was done really well and different from what's currently in the book market right now. I thought Corey and Bree's relationship added this element to the story that set it apart. Corey's mental process of working through her anger, grief, vindictiveness, and the darkest parts of her human nature was interesting to work through, relatable to the readers, and made her character development by the end, just that much more satisfying.
I'm looking forward to reading more from Melinda Salisbury.

Was this review helpful?

Corey was inseparable with her best friend Bree -- until Corey's boyfriend cheated on her with Bree. Corey hates both of them for what they did to her, even when Bree suddenly dies. Things get more complicated when she realizes that she's gotten the attention of Hades, lord of the death, and Bree's death might have resulted from Corey's hatred of her. Corey finds herself in the underworld getting to know both Hades and the Furies, who want Corey to embrace the rage she feels at the betrayal she experienced. The more time she spends in the underworld, the more she learns and her powers grow.

I haven't read very many Hades and Persephone stories, but I love Greek mythology, so I was excited to give this one a try. I wanted to like this book more than I did. While I thought it had some interesting ideas for retelling this story in a modern way, it was hard to connect to the characters, and I think I would have struggled to finish it if I hadn't read it on an airplane flight.

Corey is hard to like. While her rage and feelings of betrayal are understandable, it's hard to like her when she spends the whole time feeling so angry and doing things that don't make her look like a good person. Even as angry as she is, it's hard to justify her actions or even how destructive she is willing to be in her life before she goes to the underworld. Although I enjoyed a character who is dark and angry, it's also just difficult to root for her.

The furies are more interesting as characters. I don't think I've ever seen such an interesting take. Usually, the furies are just general bad guys or all the same. I liked their different personalities and how they are both incredibly protective of Corey while being vicious.

The setting was a little confusing. It's hard to tell what kind of time period it was when they were using cell phones but also still actively worshipping the Greek gods. There aren't any answers to this. Why do these people still believe in Greek gods? What does worshipping them actually look like in the day-to-day, and if she actively worships the gods, why wasn't she a LOT more freaked out when they started showing up in her life? The underworld was also difficult to picture for the most part. When the entire world is described as gray and boring, it's, well, boring to picture.

The "romance" also falls flat. It feels more like Hades is more interested in her for a science experiment than anything else. Corey doesn't even think he's particularly attractive. The romance is less about her wanting to love him and more about deciding which side of the fight she will take. Unfortunately, that makes the book's ending feel flat. It's less about her choosing him and more about her not choosing the other option.

The most vivid aspect of this book is Corey's rage and betrayal. It is dark and strong. I did like the closure of their relationship and how Corey has to come to terms with what her best friend and her boyfriend did. Corey and Bree's relationship alone is the book's best part. While a lot of other things were lackluster, and while I don't even like either of the girls, the relationship is raw and complex and real. That and the furies made me give this book three stars.

If you're looking for a great Hades and Persephone romance, this isn't it. But if you're looking for a story about the complications of friendship and betrayal with a Greek mythology backdrop, this might be more your kind of thing.

Was this review helpful?

Her Dark Wings is a young adult contemporary fantasy inspired by the Hades and Persephone myth.

Corey is a teenage year old girl living on an island with her dad and step-mom. The summer she was seventeen she had her heart broken when she was betrayed by her best friend (Bree) and her boyfriend (Ali). When at a party she kisses a stranger and wishes her former friend dead she is horrified to find that her wish came true and that Bree drowned. Her confusion, grief and rage will thin the barrier between worlds and make her able to see Hades and the entrance to the underworld. As she finds herself entangled in his world she is forced to face her own darkness and where she really belongs.

Her Dark Wings is a well-paced and enjoyable read. It didn’t talk down to the young adult audience but also didn’t turn Hades into a campy god of seduction or Corey into a naive heroine in need of rescuing. I wish they had more scenes together (with less of the Furies) but I also enjoyed the appearances of Hermes who was sly and brought fresh air to all his scenes.

Overall, this was an enjoyable read and I highly recommend it.

4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

“Her Dark Wings” by Melinda Salisbury is a modern day Persephone telling. This book was very fast paced and keeps you engaged until the very end! Corey is a heart broken teenager with a green thumb, living in a community with a deep worship for the Greek Gods.

Corey is such an interesting and well rounded character and I loved reading about her! This is truly a coming of age story with greek mythology sprinkled through it! Salisbury has a wonderful writing style and I loved reading about how she imaged this greek story!

If you are looking for a greek mythology inspired coming of age story this is definitely the story for you!

This review is left voluntarily, and thank you to the publisher and netgalley for an ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Corey and Bree were the best of friends and thick as thieves until Bree committed the ultimate betrayal: she slept with Corey’s boyfriend, Ali. Corey is heartbroken and wishes Bree dead the same night that Bree drowns. Consumed by her guilt but also her anger, Corey mysteriously finds herself in the Underworld. The Furies can sense her darkness and take Corey under their wings to teach her their ways. Hades sees something else inside Corey and wants her to join him. Corey must decide whether she wants to harness her power in the Underworld or go back to her mortal home to resume her normal life.

I am not a big fantasy reader, but I really enjoyed this. You don’t need an extensive knowledge of Greek mythology to follow the story, though there are terms and characters introduced that the author assumes the reader knows. I think it’s inaccurate to label this a modern retelling of Persephone and Hades. I feel it was much more about Corey and Bree’s friendship and how Corey was able to come into her own as a young adult, but I liked that spin. It’s a powerful message that many people can relate to. I think the story dragged a bit in the middle with the Furies, though. Even though I liked their characters, especially Alecto, not much happened when Corey was with them that advanced the plot. I really liked the ending, though, and think Corey’s story wrapped up nicely. Thanks to NetGalley, Random House Children’s Books, and Melinda Salisbury for this free ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

"Turns out, the legends are real. But Hades is different from what Corey imagined—and so are the Furies, terrifying and beautiful creatures who encourage Corey to embrace her rage. The more Corey discovers about the Underworld, the more her own power stirs. But can she resist the lure of the darkness within?"

A modernized hades and persophone??
SING ME UPPPPP

Was this review helpful?

A modern day Persephone/Hades-esque story (very very loose). The story follows Corey and Bree, two best friends who's friendship is destroyed when Bree betrays Corey with Corey's boyfriend. Corey is angry and vicious now, and Bree sudden;y dies.... without explaining anything and Corey can't let her go. Corey see's Bree's spirit leaving and decides to follow it leading her to the Underworld where she meets Hades and is taken in under the wings of the Furies. The story focuses on friendship and betrayal with Greek Mythology woven in,

Was this review helpful?

This was one of those books where the hype was more than the story was good. It was very bland and just didn't live up to the hype. One other aspect that I think really bumped me out is that I know that this was a young adult novel for Hades/Persephone but I was still hoping for it to be a tad darker. So for this one I think if you want to check it out you should probably try grabbing it from the library. One good thing about this was that it was a stand alone.

Was this review helpful?

Corey wishes for her ex best friend to be dead. The same night she kisses a masked guy.
When her bf ends up drowned she gets sucked into a world of gods.
Retelling of Persephone and hades

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the e-ARC! I am very grateful and happy to explore everything this author will write in the future as well!

Was this review helpful?

This story is a very angry tale. The main character is filled with hate over losing her best friend. First in life and then to death. I like how all of the mythology was intertwined throughout the story.

Was this review helpful?