Member Reviews

Murderbot does it again. It has major feelings and major *redacted*. I loved the pace, what we uncovered, what the characters did and what they didn't. But above all I loved Murderbot as usual because there's no other character more relatable.
At the start of the book we are thrown right into the action and we don't know many things, one in particular is constantly redacted that my curiosity was screaming at me. Then we go back in time and see exactly how they got where they got and we see all range of emotions from our favourite murderbot. I want it to be safe and happy forever.
I will never get tired of these stories and I already can't wait to reread it all again and wait for more.

Was this review helpful?

Fantastic as all the others have been. I love Murderbot. They are real and they're my friend. Martha Wells always delivers.

Was this review helpful?

In this installment of The Murderbot Diaries, our favorite SecUnit is back, and this time it's out to stop the evil Barish-Estranza corporation from enslaving a planet. But something is wrong with Murderbot. It's not running at full capacity. So in addition to saving a planet, it also has to save itself.

This book picks up where Network Effect left off, but it's been a while since reading that book, and there's a whole other book in between, I was confused to say the least. Don't get me wrong. System Collapse still has those things we love about Murderbot: its witty quips, its love for Sanctuary Moon, its disdain for humans despite saving their butts time and again. I'm not sure why Wells put a whole book in between these two, but I kinda wish that wouldn't have happened.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC. I enjoyed this book, just not as much as other Murderbots.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book in the Murderbot diaries series that i didn't enjoy. Perhaps it was because it was a continuation of the story events in an earlier entry, I was somewhat confused for quite some time. Maybe it was because for most of the book SecUnit was not itself wallowing in some sort of crisis caused by REDACTED and not the usual action driven character we've come to know. Or could it be that for most of the book it was non stop negotiating and discussing with the various colonists or among the crew. For whatever reason, such an incredibly short book took a lot longer to complete than it should. It really wasn't until about the last third that the story picked up for me as SecUnit finally starting acting like himself. I almost wonder if this should have really been part of the the earlier entries story, but way shorter, and was instead fleshed out to make a new book. Either way very disappointing as I really look forward to the latest adventures of MurderBot. Hopefully the next outing will be a return to form.

Was this review helpful?

I am always going to be here for a new Murderbot book. I really enjoy these books. Do note that for this one, if it’s been a hot minute since you’ve read Network Effect, the only other full-length novel in this series, you should probably go re-read that first before starting this one.

This book ties in directly after the events of Network Effect and we’re still on the planet tying up loose ends. When I re-read the books in this series, I go by chronological order rather than publication order - so I start with All Systems Red (where we first meet Murderbot), Artificial Condition (where we first meet ART), Rogue Protocol (the book with poor Mickey), Exit Strategy (Murderbot meets back up with Preservation humans), Fugitive Telemetry (Murderbot tries living on Preservation and gets involved in a murder mystery), THEN Network Effect (aliens!! and we meet ART again), and now we’re here with System Collapse.

This is the first Murderbot book I got an e-ARC for and while I love the story, I did find it hard to read by text? I very much prefer this story on audiobook more and hearing Kevin R. Free deliver Murderbot’s dry humor. That’s just me though. I know there’s the full cast version of the Murderbot books and those aren’t really my thing since I listen at a speed that’s not entirely compatible with constant sound effects and music. So, my review here is going to be based off listening to the Kevin R. Free audiobook narration.

Content notes include violence, droids losing limbs, PTSD, depression, mentions of colonizing humans and their planets, and mentions of slave labor.

Murderbot is going through some things in this book. But a positive here is that we get a LOT of Murderbot and ART interactions and I’m always going to be here for that. Murderbot and ART’s crews are working to get the colonists on the planet established and give them options…and start doing trade with other planets? I think they’re working to help them be independent. There’s 2 factions that we already knew about in the last book, and they do not get along. Then there’s Barish-Estranza who are definitely the Bad Guys here and are looking to trick the colonists into leaving the planet entirely and shipping them off into essentially slave labor in the Corporation Rim (or at least that’s how Murderbot describes it).

In some aspects, the story felt like it dragged a bit but it was mostly because I didn’t care very much for the political stuff surrounding the colonists and I wanted something to HAPPEN. Luckily, before too long, it did. Even got a little creepy there. But at least we have the humans (Tarik, Ratthi, and Iris), Murderbot, and a small bot version of ART (it makes sense in the story) to keep me entertained purely from their existence alone. I do wish we saw some of Three in this, but Three is away doing its own thing while our favorite SecUnit has to figure out how to acclimate to life after the events of Network Effect.

I think in the end, this was an enjoyable book. It usually takes me another re-read on audio to really fully digest the stories? By the time this book came out, I’ll have already listened to the previous Murderbot stories four times each by audio. I’m glad to be able to add this to the rotation!

The audiobook is a little funky at the beginning, or maybe it was just me? I generally do like Kevin R. Free narrating as Murderbot, and his take on the characters. But Ratthi and Tarik sounded strange at the beginning of this audiobook, as well as Murderbot. I think the voices got better after awhile, like the narrator finally found his footing with the characters again. But I have noticed that the voices don’t always match consistently from book to book when I’m listening to all of them in a row. I think I was most taken aback between Network Effect and Fugitive Telemetry the first time. But it’s fine. I’m not TOO bothered by it because it’s still a strong audiobook and very listenable. What are my other options? Reading with my EYES? Please.

Overall, I really liked this book and by the time the story was over, I wasn’t ready for it to end. This book is longer than the usual novellas but not as long as Network Effect. I’m always here for more Murderbot, and now it seems like future stories will give us more adventures with Murderbot and ART. Are there more Murderbot stories confirmed? I hope so! Because I will continue to read the series no matter how many new books there are.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars rounded up

I'm always happy to be back with Murderbot! I didn't realize though that this continued on from Network Effect and I might have done better following what was going on right away if I had re-read that one. Not one of my favorites of the series, but still fun and interesting. They're on a planet trying to get colonists to advocate for themselves and discover that an unreported colony also exists. Meanwhile, something strange is going on with Murderbot internally and they are dealing with that, while interacting with ART and other loved characters. If you like the series, this is definitely worth reading. I received a copy of this book for review from the publisher, all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Another phenomenal entry in the Murderbot Diaries series. System Collapse picks up where Network Effect left off (the order of the series is a bit odd due to the placement of the Fugitive Telemetry novella, which is out of chronological sequence with the rest). and begins to tie up some of the loose ends of the previous novel. Like the earlier entries, this one has a lot to say about mental health, relationships, and what it means to be a person with free will while also taking you on a breathless, futuristic space adventure. Murderbot is, perhaps, my favorite character I've ever encountered in SFF and I hope these books continue forever.

Was this review helpful?

System Collapse picks up almost immediately from the end of Network Effect which did initially throw me. I went back, reread Network Effect, gave myself like a month (I can't binge read) and then devoured System Collapse in two sittings. Murderbot is at their best (or their worst, depending on who you ask) in this new installment that might just be my favorite yet

Was this review helpful?

System Collapse the next highly anticipated Murderbot novella series delivers yet again. Being back in this world of corporations, of robots, and gun fights is a thrill. I loved being immersed in this action packed detailed world. It's these installments which advance how Muderbot realizes themselves especially with this recent problem. It operates on this larger plot level with Murderbot's problems, while also navigating the individual story.

Was this review helpful?

System Collapse was another fun foray into the world and mind of Murderbot. This is such a comforting series. Even when everyone is in peril you feel secure knowing that Murderbot will be there to save the day with both sass and warmth. What would the humans do without MB!? Also, I always love it when the character of ART is included in the story. I gave this one 3.5 stars but rounded up to 4 for NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I receive an advanced e-copy from the publisher via Netgalley though all thoughts are my own.

This was one of my most anticipated books of the year and it was well worth the wait. I enjoyed getting back into Murderbot's point of view which is equal parts snarky, hilarious and relatable particularly with some of the events that happen.

While there wasn't a lot of action that happened, there was a lot of banter between Murderbot and ART which is what I am very much here for and can't get enough.

I highly recommend reading this particularly if you have gotten this far in the series and enjoy reading more about character than adventure though there is some.

I will happily read any book involving Murderbot and that added bonus of ART making appearances.

Trigger warnings: violence, death, contract labor

Was this review helpful?

System Collapse by Martha Wells is the new Murderbot book. I won’t spoil anything here! I definitely recommend reviewing the previous volume (Network Effect) if you don’t remember details, as this book follows on directly with very little time interval; I feel the action is subordinate to Murderbot dealing with the personal fallout of those events. It was gripping! Also, Tarik rocks.

Was this review helpful?

Martha Wells’s Murderbot series has won both the Hugo and Nebula awards. The latest sends the independent secunit as part of a university to help a colony in System Collapse (hard from Tordotcom). The colonists had been fighting one another, one group had gone into hiding near the Terraforming device at one of the poles. Everything would have been fine except the Barish-Estranza corporation has sent ships hoping to grab what was left of the colony and indenture the surviving solonists. Murderbot eventually has to face several ecunits still under control, and help his humans and the colonists survive. Probably this will also be on the Hugo and Nebula lists.

Was this review helpful?

Martha Wells has captured so many of us with the Murderbot series. While I am most eager for another full length novel, I will never turn down another novella. Once more Murderbot is trying to save settlers and their own team. Our hero is dealing with a lot, keeping their humans safe, dealing with PTSD, trying to ignore their PTSD, working with ART who's snark is always on point, and still grappling with the past, plus the newest fear of an alien virus. I enjoy the duality of snark and humor intermixed with conversations about dealing with trauma. The series has always been about what really makes us or doesn't make us human and Martha continues to really make her readers think about it while having us follow a character we can all root for.

Was this review helpful?

Included as a top pick in weekly November New Releases post, which highlights and promotes upcoming releases of the month (link attached)

Was this review helpful?

In SYSTEM COLLAPSE, everyone's favorite cranky SecUnit is stuck on a planet again, working with ART's crew to protect some colonists from the evil corporate overlords, Barish-Estranza.

Honestly, despite being one of my most anticipated reads for the year, this was not my favorite -- it felt low on the snark factor, and I think I need to re-read all of the prior books because I was having a hard time keeping everyone straight. That said, it was still super enjoyable and a must-read for existing fans. I will happily read any and all future Murderbot books because Murderbot is the best.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely enjoy reading these stories. I like that we get a full length novel.from time to time because the novellas tend to be to short and there.is such a long time between them that it makes it hard to remember all the details for the next book.

Was this review helpful?

Officially known as a Security Unit, or SecUnit for short, it refers to itself as Murderbot. And it's just about the most identifiable Murderbot you're ever going to meet! System Collapse picks up after the events of Network Effect. The Barish-Estranza Corporation has sent rescue ships to a lost colony planet in trouble due to alien contamination.
Anyone who knows Barish-Estranza, or most corporations, knows that they are up to no good. They've also brought along a contingent of SecUnits of their own. Normally this wouldn't be much of a problem for Murderbot, especially with ART on its side. But something's wrong with Murderbot and if it doesn't figure out what that is quickly, things could go sideways in a hurry.

The stranded colonists are so long removed from the wider universe, that they are unaware of the corporations' reputation, and have no reason to trust one set of humans over the other. Murderbot and ART must work with their human crews to come up with a compelling way to convince the colonists or risk seeing them hauled away as slave labor.

Martha Wells has created a fascinating universe with corporation-heavy governance, built on top of a little-understood pre-corporation settlement system, with a sprinkle of very poorly understood alien influence. This creates fertile ground for interesting politics and exploration. Add a sarcastic killer robot who just wants time to watch soap operas and you have an unbeatable combination.

Murderbot is the driving force and for all its sarcasm, the humanity it is coming to find within itself gives tremendous heart to this story. Murderbot knows it is not operating correctly, and furthermore realizes that the lives of the colonists and the humans that it has come to care about are in danger unless it figures out how to repair itself. Fortunately, ART is there to offer assistance and understanding that maybe nothing and no one else is equipped for. Murderbot and ART is one of my favorite buddy pairings. (A Murderbot/ART buddy cop movie is something I'd pay to see). Hopefully, it's enough to let them figure a way out of this mess.

Martha Wells delivers again with another outstanding story with my favorite character.

I was provided a copy of this book by the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

Murderbot is not itself and its people are concerned, which...yuck. Dealing with trauma, alien contamination, colonists and corporate baddies makes watching entertainment media even more enticing, but...
The start of this one was slow for me, because I didn't remember what had happened previously. It took me a while to realize that I was reading how Murderbot was processing, or not, its trauma and the insecurities it was dealing with in respect to keeping its people alive and how things were changing for it. Happily, by the end Murderbot is finding its feet again, kicking butt, solving problems and dealing out snark. I loved it, and of course am already looking forward to the next installment.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars rounded down for the middiest of mid reads I can remember. I became a somewhat enthusiastic fan of Murderbot after binging the first 4 novellas, but the series kinda lost its luster and momentum with me with the full-sized novel in Network Effect. Then we went back in time strangely with the next novella that has left very little trace in my memory before returning to the present time directly after Network Effect with this one.

And what an awkward transition it was into the new story -- the beginning of System Collapse is one of the clunkiest starts to a sequel I've ever experienced with just way too many human names bandied about for characters that are basically indistinguishable. But thankfully it didn't take overly long before we set off on a new mission that got me settled in more comfortably and feeling like I was reading something closer to a Murderbot plot from the earlier books. I still enjoy the way Wells writes Murderbot's POV, with lots of sardonic inner monologue and copious use of parentheticals, which is a fantastic touch that so few writers do.

We also got plenty of Murderbot interacting with other non-human intelligences, and that also continues to be engaging for me. However, I just wasn't really engaged by this particular plot, and I found everything pretty hard to visualize. The humans continue to feel un-compelling, and so I don't really care if Murderbot can keep them alive, and I can't muster emotion to care about Murderbot's own emotional investment in keeping them alive. For such a short book it took me 5 days to get through it since I rarely found myself eager to pick it up.

I do think this short-novel length of 240 (slim) pages seems like possibly an ideal size for a full Murderbot adventure to play out without overstaying its welcome. It was ok and besides the beginning I generally enjoyed my time with it, but I fear it will be yet another book from the series that leaves barely any kind of mark in my memory. I guess Murderbot is just kind of drifting away from being something that holds my interest.

Was this review helpful?