Review: The City of Stardust by Georgia Summers

Based on the marketing, The City of Stardust seemed like a perfect fit for me, promising a blend of lyrical writing and a captivating plot. However, I found that the purple prose overshadowed the storytelling, making it difficult to fully engage with the narrative. While the world-building and premise had potential, the plot felt meandering and didn’t resonate with me as much as I’d hoped. Though beautifully written, it ultimately lacked the balance I look for in immersive fantasy. Fans of rich, poetic language might appreciate it more than I did.

This was an enjoyable read, but it didn’t quite hit the mark for me. The world-building is beautifully detailed, and I loved the concept of a city filled with magic and mystery. However, I found the pacing a bit slow at times, and I didn’t connect with the characters as much as I hoped. There were moments where the story really shined, especially with the magical elements, but overall it felt like it could have gone a bit deeper. Still, if you’re into whimsical, slow-burn fantasy, it’s worth a read!

If you like Erin Morgenstern's works (Starless Sea, The Night Circus), I would recommend you check out The City of Stardust. The City of Stardust is perfect for readers who prefer atmospheric worlds and enchanting writing, but is slightly weaker when it comes to plot.

The prose is absolutely stunning and really sucks you right into the world of The City of Stardust. The setting is fairytale like, with elements of wonder and beauty, but also of darkness. Summers's writing is immersive, putting you right into the head of Violet, our main character. The pacing is smooth and flows continuously, never getting bogged down in details. Summers did a great job building out the world beyond what was needed just for the main plot line.

Violet is a great main character for the fairytale story, although I did feel somewhat like she was just getting pulled around by the plot. Her development isn't that strong, but she was fun to follow and I really enjoyed how strong the theme of family was. The entire book revolves around family and loyalty, and Summers absolutely nails these aspects. I fully believe that Violet and her uncles are family and that they care for each other incredibly deeply. It's really interesting watching them struggle between their inherent love for their sister/Violet's mother and the anger or sadness caused by her abandonment.

One of my favorite things about The City of Stardust is how it handles the idea of a story. Throughout the book, while searching for her mother, Violet is told the same story from different people, each with a new perspective of view. And by the end, there is no clear true answer. No singular story that is the truth, because they all both are and aren't. It leaves a somewhat open ending, but I really like that Violet was able to move past and into her own story.

Unfortunately, other parts of the story are also left unanswered and not in an interesting way. No spoilers, but a large part of the plot felt unsatisfying by the end, since there was no wrap up. I usually like open ended endings, but this one didn't leave me thinking, it just left me disappointed. There's also a few elements of the plot that just felt like Violet jumping from point A to point B with a time skip, and I wish that we had been shown more of what actually happens between those points.

Overall, this was a really atmospheric and enchanting read, but not super memorable because of the weaker character and plot.

Thank you to NetGalley for sending me this.
I really enjoyed this book and I look forward to see what other books the author does. I liked the plot, character interactions, and worldbuilding.

I loved the world building on this. The myth and lore around it was beautifully crafted. I would recommend this to fans of The Starless Sea; it's a bit less complex but just as beautiful.

Thank you Netgalley and publisher for this ARC.

2.5 stars

The City of Stardust is a magical dark fantasy that does lack a little bit of character development. In my opinion, the main character is a little naïve and underdeveloped. I also felt like the story was rushed and the world building a little flat,

I do think this story had potential to be great, but it just wasn't quite there.

This was a very long book where not a whole lot happened. The writing was very pretty, felt a little like the flowery descriptive tone from The Starless Sea by Morganstern, but with no real plot to find up until the end. The concept of the story was very cool, but the execution was dragged out and boring and by the end of the story I was not engaged with the book at all, it was just a task to finish. There were some very great ideas of magic and world building, but not a lot to connect to the reader. On the positive, I am pretty sure this is a standalone

“The City of Stardust” by Georgia Summers is a beautifully written novel with an engaging premise. A generational family curse and a hidden doorways leading to a magical world! The prose is whimsical, using beautifully descriptive phrases as the characters engaging in conversation or when describing the setting. However, the characters fell flat for me. They seemed one-dimensional and forgettable. Despite the beautiful writing, the pacing was choppy and many storylines felt unfinished or rushed. I was often left wanting more.

Despite not being fully satisfied with the story, it is still an enjoyable read and I look forward to more from this author as she explores and grows her craft.

Thank you NetGallery and the publisher for allowing me to read this wonderful ARC and providing an unbiased and honest review.

I really tried to like this story. I tried starting it several times but it felt like it was a book you had to pay attention to every word on the page. I also sometimes grew bored of the writing style and felt like the characters felt two dimensional. I didn't really get an emotional connection with Violet and I honestly hated the love interest. I love the premise but it just felt like it was trying to be an epic story without any build up. I also grew confused with why the villain was going after the main character the more they tried to explain the plot. I then grew bored of her issues because parts where just redundant and characters never showed any growth. I appreciate the chance to read the story but wish there was more dimension in the character development.

The City of Stardust is a dark fantasy set in a magical underworld full of curses, monsters, love and revenge.

City of Stardust, by Georgia Summers
The cover art caught me eye but it was the synopsis that made me click the request button!

I do love a spellbinding, curse ridden, family drama, and I absolutely love the name Violet!

This year-long mission to lift the family curse was less rushed than I anticipated but still managed to keep my attention. That said, I would have loved to have had more - more character depth (maybe a dash of spice in the tortured romance department) and more world building. There is a lot that could be mined from this author’s concept and storyline.

Thank you to Netgalley and Redhook Books for my advanced digital copy to read and review.

I love a standalone fantasy! They’re not daunting and I love how concise they are.

I liked this, but I can’t say it was a standout. The premise is right up my alley and I liked the writing- it was very pretty.

It did feel a bit disjointed though. There was a lot to keep track of and I feel like not everything came together but also came together too easily?

The City of Stardust by Georgia Summers is a spellbinding standalone portal fantasy and the author's debut.

The Everly family has been cursed for so long they are unsure why it started. The best and brightest in every generation disappears as punishment for a for a crime nobody remembers, and a purpose nobody understands.

I initially picked this book up because it was blurbed by Sangu Mandanna and was compared to other authors with dark worldbuilding whom I have enjoyed in the past. Also, this cover is phenomenal, and the naked hardcover is really pretty as well.

It does really feel like a dark fairy tale; that vibe came through very strongly to me. The author's prose is lush and lyrical, which is optimal for me for these kinds of stories. I appreciated the thorough plot line though I think the first half especially could have been tightened up a bit more in editing. It does lean a little more in the New Adult direction, as our main characters are in their early 20s.

The worldbuilding was really interesting to me, with magic doors and even more magical keys, oaths signed in blood, and gods who survive by eating human souls. There's a tinge of dark academia here, as one of the main factions are power-hungry scholars. I did greatly appreciate the casual queerness that was briefly mentioned early on in the book.

If you're a fan of dreamy books with lushly written prose, you should check this out!

CW: violence, violence towards children

fascinating and unique fantasy, loved the world building and the complexity of the characters. Also loved that it did not over explain itself to its readers

I was granted a pre-release copy of the city of stardust by Georgia Summers. Through net gallery. All opinions written here are my own. I did not receive compensation either monetarily or otherwise to write this review.
I just finished reading the city of stardust by Georgia Summers and I have to say it reminds me a lot of several books and series of books, namely The Lion, the witch and the wardrobe and, The Golden compass series. It only reminds me of these books in the ways that I love. Best bringing together fantasy with just enough of reality to make it just maybe believable why hell also being able to transport the reader to a whole other world. I really appreciate the author's use of descriptions in the scenery and in the character's emotions. In the beginning this book was a little bit hard to follow as I thought that there were holes that maybe the author should have filled in for the reader, but by the end I was glad of the way it came out. Thank you Georgia summer for letting us have just a little glimpse into this wonderful imaginary little world. I look forward to the privilege of reading your next book. Thank you very much

This was a dnf at 70 percent for me. I just did not connect with the characters or anything that was going on. I really wanted to love this story.

honestly this is sitting somewhere between a 3.5 stars and 3.75 stars for me. I really enjoyed the story and how whimsical and magical this was, while also having such a dark and sinister underlying quality to the world. It’s the embodiment of all “all that glitters is not gold.” our mc Violet Everly has been raised by her two uncles ever since her mother mysteriously disappeared as a child. No one knows where Marianne has gone or whether she’ll return, but there’s a confidence shared by all that she’s out there SOMEWHERE. We quickly learn that this family is unlike others, cursed to pay a debt each generation, owed to an ageless and powerful woman named Penelope, who shows no remorse for the devastation she’s wrought on their lives over the years. After a bargain is struck between one of her uncles and this woman, Violet is given ten years of freedom while her family searches for her mother to help break this curse, but she was left in the dark for most of this time, unaware of her magical potential and the looming deadline.

When she does discover it, she dives headfirst into the world, hellbent finding her mother and saving them both. She was such an interesting character to explore, curious and fearless in her endeavor. The premise of infinite worlds and god-like beings accessible by magical keys isn’t necessarily unique, but again the almost horror like elements added to their underbelly was so compelling. She makes allies along the way, Penelope’s apprentice Aleksander at the forefront of this, and with their help, she digs deep into the mysteries of the key holders and sheds light on some of their darkest secrets, ones that choose to willfully ignore to maintain that illusion of mystical splendor.

My biggest qualms were the timeline, which I struggled occasionally to wrap my head around, as well as the lack of real conclusion to the disappearance of Violet’s mother. I did enjoy the ending, but feel like this story feels just slightly unresolved leaving those questions hanging open. I don’t need everything answered, because I do appreciate the idea that these other worlds are unfathomable for mortals, but I think Violet herself deserved some closure for the years of abandonment she suffered through.

I really enjoyed this book. The story grabbed me immediately and kept me reading well into the night. I loved Violet and Aleksander. Their characters were great together. Overall, I loved the plot and characters and this was a magical read!

Unfortunately this story, plot, and characters just did not interest me. Will not be continuing with future books.

I wanted to love this book. The premise was great but the delivery did not work for me. I tried several times to get immersed in the story and it never fully hooked me.