Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. I also received a finished copy from Redhook as well.

This story was just confusing in so many ways. It might have been the point of having the reader feel as lost and confused about this world as the FMC, but it just was done in a way that also made me feel like I was not getting it. I explained that this book made me feel like I was expected to know something or pick up on something that was vague at or said unsaid, and very much the Autistic experience of just feeling confused at no context.

I still do my quite know what exactly I read, in all honesty. I feel like I missed so much context for what the ending is, where this whole world comes from and just know only gossip basics of it all. I think the story would have been better fleshed out and explained a bit more. I feel the author knew the information but the reader who doesn’t is left out.

This books was a lot of vibes. I enjoyed it but it was not particularly memorable. I struggled with the frequent time jumps, and there was a lot of telling and not showing. I was also disappointed by the character arc for the FMC's mother. It felt out of character based on the little information that we had about her.

This was such a wonderful read! I loved the writing - it flowed beautifully and was so descriptive. I kept finding I wanted to slow down and just savor the writing itself. I also really enjoyed the dialogue. I love stories that are built on character relationships and dialogue, so I quickly knew I would love this one!

I have to say the writing style was great. The author’s voice really was nicely portrayed and I’d read more of their work again. I liked the story as well. Not sure I loved it though, so that’s why it’s only 4 stars but I did like reading this. Interested in what more the author writes next.

Such a different story with really interesting characters! I felt like the first quarter of the book was a little bit on the slow side but I felt like it picked up after that. I also felt that the last quarter was a bit rushed. I really liked how cozy this book felt and loved the setting of an academic world.

Magical and dark at shocking turns, The City of Stardust is a solid fantasy debut, establishing Georgia Summers as one of the authors to watch out for. As I was reading this, it made me think of The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern and the beautiful prose and magical setting is evocative of Laini Taylor’s Strange the Dreamer duology. I am already excited for the author’s next work, The Bookshop Below!

THE CITY OF STARDUST is a wonderful, whimsical fairytale-esque YA fantasy with some of the evoking prose I have read to date.

This story follows Violet Everly, a sheltered but clever girl who's mother has been missing since she was young. Raised by both of her uncles, she's grown up with the distinct knowledge that there is more to her mother's dissapearance than they've let on. Eventually, this leads to her uncovering the hidden magical world that her mother may have dissapeared into, and that is after her next.

I'll start by stating that I connected more with this book in terms of plot than in it's characterwork. For a reason I can't quite articulate, I didn't really form any connection to Violet, Aleksander or even the unles. I was moreso invested in the mystery behind Marianne and the world of Fidelis.

I found that the actual plot by plot beats were done amazingly. Everything was put together in a way that flowed, but also held enough twists to keep me gripped to the book, waiting to see what our characters would discover next. Without giving too much away, I am 100% confident enough in this work to state that Summers' book IS a modern day fairytale.

There was a bit of an issue with pacing and the book sagging in the middle, but I managed to get over it because of how much I loved the actual prose. This book has such beautiful lines, I can't even get mad at it.

Summers' debut was a delight to read and I look forward to reading her future work!

Thank you to NetGalley, and RedHook, for providing me with an eArc copy of this novel.

I don't love naive FMCs, so this was a bit hard for me. That being said, this was a fun time and I enjoyed it. It could have been really great, but there were some flaws with the characters that kept it from a higher rating.

That being said, there is plenty of good here! The writing is great, the foundation of the story is really interesting, the romantic subplot was great, and it was just a whimsical fun read.

Well I had high hopes for this one--at first I was thinking it would be like Stardust by Neil Gaiman and The Starless Sea by Erin Morgenstern--but did not quite live up to those initial aspirations. This is a heavily plot driven novel, and at times so much so that I never quite latched on and felt attachment or fully empathetic any one character, they all actually got on my nerves, except for Caspian. Each time I thought we would go deeper and understand them more, it immediately skipped ahead in the plot or action would take place that cut it short.

Here is a specific example: (Spoiler alert)

Why did Violet stab herself through the hear to open the door in the dungeon of the Scholars tower instead of just slicing open her hand? And then, how does her mystically preserved ancestor save her from a stab wound to the heart? Your guess is as good as mine, because it is never actually explained.

Also felt like the one semi-steamy scene at the end was written by a man for a YA novel. It did not spark joy [or any kind of arousal]. Probably because once again, almost all of the major characters felt two dimensional and unlikeable.

Overall, it was not a bad read, but I don't feel especially inspired to recommend it to anyone else unless they are specifically looking for "Stars as Gods folklore".

This was a slow and painful read. The characters were flat, boring, and far too numerous. The premise was certainly interesting and at the end I found that I wanted the book to be framed from Penelope’s and Ever’s perspective because that would have been far more interesting than reading about Violet trying to find her mom. That potential is what saved this from being a one star in the end. Overall, disappointing.

City of Stardust is a fantasy novel with splashes of mystery and intrigue as we follow in the footsteps of Violet Everly. The Everly line has been cursed for generations and after the disappearance of her mother, Violet is next in line to suffer the fate of her predecessors — the price? Her life.

The story begins with Violet discovering the nature of the curse, realizing how sheltered she’s been her whole life thanks to efforts of her uncles who have kept it a secret. From there, characters are introduced and the mystery begins to build and unravel, but it still took me about 50% of the book to feel like the plot began to have a stronger footing and I was able to be pulled in. And even longer for me to connect to the characters. I don’t think I fully engaged until Violet’s character development began to take shape and she finally sets out to fix the curse. There’s also a bit of a romantic subplot, though at the start Aleksander and Violet’s connection felt a bit rough and forced. That changes later on, and not entirely in a good way. The villain of the story, Penelope, adds the most intriguing elements to the plot as it unfurls, providing some depth that was lacking in the prior story progression.

Overall the writing is very descriptive and creates an interesting magical world beyond the ordinary, which I enjoyed and was intrigued by. But the pacing tended to jump around and the third person narrative switched in the middle of the chapters, which left me feeling rather confused and disconnected at times. And as we neared the ending it felt like the crescendo was within reach, the culmination of all that transpired in the latter half coming to a conclusion, and it fell completely silent. There were implications that worlds and lives were at stake throughout the entirety of the story and then it just ended. The lack of payoff was quite a surprise. It gives off that open ended air but left me feeling rather unsatisfied. Like a sip of wine… I enjoyed the initial taste, savored it a bit in the middle, but the after taste burns.

Such an intriguing premise and magical world but lacked the depth and execution to fully bring it to life for me.

Thank you to NetGalley and Redhook books for the chance to read a review this eARC.

This was a really cool and fun story. I feel like it was pretty unique. It was a little slow because of the world building but once you got into the action it was super fun. I loved learning about and getting to know the characters. I liked seeing them interact with one another as well. I would definitely recommend this book and want to read more by the author/series for sure!

I really wanted this to be more exciting than it was. I feel like it falls into a growing category of books that masquerade as really cool fantasy, but don't explore the concepts in the ways that they should. I would comp it more to When Women Were Dragons, The Lost Book of Eleanor Dare, and The Book Eaters, rather than The Starless Sea or Addie Larue. It just felt a little flat and I would have loved to have explored the world and magic way more than the family drama that drove the story.

For a debut author, holy moley!

I’m one for hating the dread of impending surprises within my novels, it’s why I reread favorites, because I know what’ll happen. If you ALSO need this, pick up this book— you go into the book and continue to read, obtaining and knowing more than the FMC. I felt more at peace while reading because of this and it allowed me to fully immerse myself into the story. While the plot thrills & the romance hides deep within the subplot, this third-person narrative intertwines fantasy with urban legends, allowing something new to be born.

The City of Stardust is a fantasy novel about Violet Everly, born into the family of magical Everlys who report to the mysterious, unaging Penelope. After her mother's disappearance, Violet decides to try to break her family's curse.

I had a really hard time with this book, although I'm not really sure why. It reminded me a lot of the Starless Sea by Erin Morgenstern (love letter to writing/books, magical hidden worlds), which I liked fine. I just had a very hard time getting into it. I had no idea that this was at least partially set in the modern day until someone mentioned a cell phone like 40% in. I had been picturing Victorian adjacent the whole book. I wasn't very compelled by any of the characters. At around 60%, I realized that I had no idea what was going on and that I didn't really care to find out. I ended up DNFing at this point. Which is sad!!! I really wanted to like this one. I generally struggle with fantasy plots (here for the vibes) but those weren't enough to keep me interested. This might have been a wrong-place-wrong-time situation as I just read a bunch of fantasy books back to back and maybe I'm just fantasy fatigued. However, I also think that the plot/characters were not compelling enough for my liking and it was very slow to get through for me.

I recommend this book if you absolutely loved The Starless Sea OR really like love letters to literature, reading, etc. This one wasn't for me. 2.5 stars rounded down to 2. Thank you to Redhook Books and NetGalley for the eARC of this book, my thoughts are my own!

This book was nothing like what I was expecting it to be but in a good way. From the very first scene with the uncles talking about the girl I knew I was in for a beautiful ride of twists and turns in this world where things clearly weren't quite right under the surface.

Packed with beautiful writing this book was really enjoyable from the moment I started the ARC until the moment I finished it on audiobook (It came out before I could finish the ARC but if you were wondering the audiobook narrator was wonderful also). Overall it was a great read that kept me engaged with twists I wasn't expecting and characters that kept me on my toes.

This story was great. It was well written and had a lot of feeling behind it. The world was original and you could tell

Went into this blindly and I’m glad I did as I was not sure what to expect with this one. Fun read. It started off strong and towards the middle pacing was off to me but picked up again at the end. 😲

"The City of Stardust" by Georgia Summers is a standalone fantasy novel (hoping for more) that follows the story of Violet Everly, a young woman on a mission to break a family curse that has seen the brightest and best of her family line disappear generation after generation. The curse is tied to a crime forgotten by time, with their tormentor, Penelope, a figure who never ages or forgives a debt. Violet's journey takes her into a magical underworld filled with power-hungry scholars, fickle gods, and revengeful monsters. Very different world created here. She is driven by the ultimatum issued by Penelope to find her mother, Marianne, who left years ago to break the curse and never returned. Violet's quest is not only to find her mother but to discover the key to the city of stardust, where the Everly story began, and break the curse once and for all.

Family curses and quest for identity are the main themes here which is fun to play with in a magical world. The consequences of seeking power is explored well here.

Huge thanks for this enchanting read NetGalley and Redhook Books! ✨

Georgia Summers is a new author to me. I really enjoyed this fantasy/romance! The book was a satisfying, enthralling read. Violet, the main character, was complex and didn't fall into the many tropes that plague romance. Her evaluations of people while sometimes slow in coming rang true and as she traveled the world to solve her mystery she grew independent, strong and true to herself. I highly recommend! Georgia Summers, the author is definitely one to watch! I look forward to her next book!

4.5 stars.

For centuries the Everly family has been cursed; a family member from each generation is stolen away to another world for repayment of something that they don’t remember anymore.

That time is quickly approaching for Violet Everly, the youngest of her family. Terrified, yet determined to break the mysterious curse and avoid death, she begins the search for her mother, who vanished in the middle of a stormy night when Violet was a child.

Violet uncovers a world full of secrets, power-hungry scholars, monsters and gods - and the key to the mystery surrounding the Everly family’s curse. But will she be able to save herself and her family?

I really enjoyed this book - very reminiscent of The Starless Sea which I loved and had hoped to find something similar for years. Summers has written a great debut fantasy novel full of beautiful prose and excellent world building - full of adventure, diverse settings and landscapes. The sense of urgency by the impending deadline keeps the reader engaged throughout the story. This is one that I would pick up again in the future.