Member Reviews

A terrific addition to the long running series that will be equally enjoyable as a standalone. Andy's sure Bobby isn't a murderer because he loves dogs. Among other things. Turns out the murder he's accused of has its roots in the gang Bobby used to run with - and testified against- but it also reaches into organized crime. Andy, his wife Laurie, and Marcus, along with other members of Andy's team find themselves working hard to untangle this one because it just doesn't make sense on the surface. It's a tricky twist plot and, as always, the courtroom scenes are terrific. Fans will remember how much Laurie likes Christmas and it's always a hoot when Andy meets with Junior. And there's a twist for Bobby. Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC. This is an easy read (although it's not an easy crime to solve) because it's quite genial and, well, dogs.

Was this review helpful?

he 28th installment of the Andy Carpenter Mystery series,'Twas the Bite Before Christmas: An Andy Carpenter Mysteryby bestselling author, David Rosenfelt, finds attorney Andy Carpenter at the annual Tara Foundation (a dog rescue organization) Christmas party. One of the foster volunteers, Derek Moore, who has two adopted dogs from the foundation, is arrested for a local murder. Derek, whose real name is Bobby, admits he had been in the state witness protection program and was previously a member of a gang, but didn’t commit the murder, and Andy believes him and agrees to represent him. Andy investigates, and uncovers plenty of damning evidence.

Although this is part of a thriller series, Rosenfelt is able to tell his story in a way that there is building suspense combined with satire and humor; it’s almost a farce, but is absolutely delightful. He does an excellent job of developing his characters. Andy Carpenter, the protagonist, is someone most of us want to know; he is not only a good attorney, but also a dog lover, which elevates him in most people’s eyes. Bobby is also likeable and well developed, as well as the other supporting characters. There are twists, turns and surprises, especially at the end where the dénouement is quite unexpected.

All told, reading this fun novel will keep most readers on the edge. Those who haven’t previously been acquainted with the series will want to start at the beginning and read them through. Rosenfelt is an excellent storyteller, and readers will certainly enjoy it.

Special thanks to NetGalley for supplying a review copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Solving crimes at Christmas with Andy, Laurie, Tara, and the gang - what could be better? Another great entry in the Andy Carpenter series. Twisty problems and gang violence kept me glued to my kindle until the final words! Grab it now!

Thank you to Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Andy Carpenter and his family and friends are celebrating Christmas at the Tara Foundation, his shelter for homeless dogs. Pete Stanton arrives with some officers to arrest Andy's friend, Derek Moore. Turns out Derek is really Bobby, a former gang member who turned state's evidence against some of the gang and went into state witness protection. The police in Patterson are arresting him for murdering a former gang member. Bobby tells Andy he didn't do it, he has a whole new life now, including adopting two dogs from Andy's rescue. Andy has little evidence to go on, but he believes Bobby is innocent and he is going to prove it one way or another. I really enjoy this light-hearted series; the characters are endearing and the dogs are important characters -- all I really want in a mystery!

Was this review helpful?

(4.5 / 5)

When the Christmas party at the Tara Foundation, a dog rescue organization co-founded by defense attorney Andy Carpenter, is interrupted when one of the foundation's dog foster volunteers is arrested for murder, Andy reluctantly takes his case. A witness in protective custody and a local crime family make this a Christmas to remember.

This is the 2nd book in this series that I've read now, the first being another Christmas-related book, and this has clinched my decision to start back at the beginning of this series soon. Though this book isn't a traditional type of mystery story, giving the reader clues as they try to solve it along with the main character, it did still have some intrigue that I had a prediction about (and turned out to be right about). Like an episode of an old detective show like Matlock, we are shown not only the investigation, but also the courtroom scenes as he defends his (presumably) innocent client. Though some of the dog love is lost on me, since I'm a cat person, I enjoy the characters. What really stands out to me, though, is the wit and snark of the main character. Rosenfelt manages to make his detective funny without overdoing it.

There was a bit of repetitiveness here and there, and the ending felt pretty rushed, especially a final reveal. Otherwise, though, it's easy to recommend it to fans of the mystery genre. The book isn't exactly a Christmas story—it just happens to take place at Christmas time, and you really don't need to have read the rest of the series to enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?

Andy is a criminal defense lawyer who doesn't want any clients. Because of the money his father left him and some lucrative cases, he is able to not work and spend his time with his friend, Willie, running the Tara Foundation, a dog rescue that he and Willie formed. He is married to Laurie, they have a young son, Ricky, three dogs and he is enjoying his life.

Andy is doling out eggnog at a Christmas party at the Tara Foundation when his friend, Pete, a police officer, asks him to send out Derek, one of the volunteers. Knowing it's not going to end well, Andy begrudging does and Derek is arrested for murder. It turns out that Derek is really Bobby and he had been placed in witness protection a couple years ago after he testified against fellow gang members. He has now been charged with the murder of one of the higher ups in the gang. Derek swears he didn't do it but the evidence says otherwise. Because he is dog lover, Andy believes in him and agrees to represent him.

This is the 28th in the Andy Carpenter series ... I've read them all and I'm still enjoying this series. Even though it is part of a series, it works as a stand alone (so you don't need to have read the ones before it to know what is going on). I like the writing style as it was funny, sarcastic and amusing. It was written mostly in first person perspective in Andy's voice.

I like Andy ... I think he would be a hoot to be around and he's quite generous with his time and money (he never charges for his services and he always picks up the tab for his friends at his favourite restaurant whether he is there or not). Andy admits he is a bit of a wimp so part of his team is the K-Team (Laurie, a former police officer and now an investigator; Marcus, an investigator with "persuasive" reasoning skills; Cory, a former police officer; and Simon Garfunkel, Cory's former canine partner). Sam is his accountant who is also a computer hack who wants to be part of the action.

Was this review helpful?

Twas the Bite Before Christmas by David Rosenfelt
Book 28 in the Andy Carpenter Series Pretty sure I have read or listened to all the books in this series. Always funny, not very serious even with multiple murders. I love Andy Carpenter as a character but I sure couldn’t live with him. Laurie deserves some kind of award for putting up with him. Christmas does get a couple of slight mentions but the story is not very Christmas oriented. However, the dogs play a bigger part in this book than in some of the recent books. And thank goodness, no FBI agents were needed to solve this case for a change. Although they were used as a threat once. It was a fun quick book with almost all the usual characters except Edna. No big loss. Also, Marcus communicates more and is becoming more of a regular guy, well sorta because he is still Marcus after all.

Was this review helpful?

This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
---
WHAT'S 'TWAS THE BITE BEFORE CHRISTMAST ABOUT?
On the night of the Tara Foundation's holiday party, Andy's friend Pete Stanton, of the homicide department, calls him to ask Andy to bring one of his volunteers outside, so the police don't have to cause a scene. Andy does so and immediately steps into the role of the volunteer's attorney. He doesn't know Derek Moore very well, but he likes Derek—and Derek's dogs (more importantly), and wants to protect him at least until they both know what's going on.

Andy quickly learns something about Derek—as he's arrested, it's revealed that his real name is Robert Klaster. Up until a couple of years ago, Bobby was in a gang in South Jersey. It was growing more and more violent, up to the point that Bobby was the wheelman for a murder. He went to the cops and turned in the men he drove—after their conviction, the state witness protection program moved him to Patterson with a new name.

Bobby's made the most of this second chance and has become an upstanding citizen and moderately successful business owner—in addition to a great dog shelter volunteer. But now one of the leaders of his old gang has been killed in Patterson, and a tip led Stanton's men straight to Bobby—with just enough evidence for them to make an arrest. The case is strong, but not air-tight. The question in front of Andy is can he take advantage of the weaknesses while finding the real killer?

And just why would someone bother setting Bobby up now?

THE RECURRING CAST
Almost the whole (and continually expanding) cast of regulars is around. Edna's traveling, but we still get a couple of jokes about her work habits. Eddie shows up, but barely gets any dialogue—and not one sports cliché!—I really enjoyed those (see also: Sam's song-talking), but the rest are about in their typical form.

Which is important—as much as these books are about the mystery/mysteries surrounding Andy's case, it's Andy and the crew we come back to spend time with. Including Tara, Sebastian, and Hunter—Sebastian particularly has some good moments in this book.

I do wonder if the supporting cast is getting too large, which is why Edna and Eddie get barely more than mentions. This makes sense, and it'd be good for Rosenfelt to rotate some of these in and out from book to book. It'd be better than cutting any of these for whatever reason—and better than just a token mention.

That said, Rosenfelt gave us some more than typical reflection on members of the cast. It was good to see Andy explain the specialization of work in his firm and for Andy to bring up the ethics of what he gets Sam to do in his narration. Cory's been good about that in the companion series, but it's not that frequent in this series.

I'm not sure if I had a point when I started this section, it's basically turned into "assorted thoughts on the use of the supporting characters." So let's see if I can summarize my take on them for this novel—I enjoyed seeing them all, and am glad we got to spend time with them. I do wonder, however, if more judicious use of some of them per book rather than all of them each time, would be a better experience for the reader.

THE HOLIDAY-NESS OF IT
So, this is the holiday-themed release for the series this year, as the title and cover image tell you. Very little in the book tells you that, however.

We don't even get the typical (and always enjoyable) rant about Laurie's months-long commemoration of Christmas. He gives a compressed version, but it's not the same. In its place, we get Andy's extended (and not favorable) review of egg nog. There are a few references to Christmas and a couple of the following holidays—but it's not focused on too much. Honestly, we spend more time on Ricky's soccer-fandom* than on any Federal or religious holiday.

* That was great to read about. Poor Andy. I get the same feeling when my kids prefer other SF franchises to Star Trek.

Do I care? Nope. I'll take any excuse to hang with Andy and the gang. But I figure since it's part of the theme of the book I should nod in it's direction.

SO, WHAT DID I THINK ABOUT 'TWAS THE BITE BEFORE CHRISTMAS?
This has nothing to do with anything, but Andy references the case in Flop Dead Gorgeous at one point in the book. It's been a long time since he's mentioned a previous case (outside of Willie Miller's, which gets mentioned from time to time). It's a nice touch to keep the series building on itself.

There were a couple of other things that stood out to me about this book compared to the rest of the series: Bobby's about as close to an unsympathetic client as Rosenfelt gives us anymore (maybe ever—this is the twenty-eighth book in the series, I don't remember the client in every one). And it's good that Rosenfelt gives us some characters that are hard to root for—although a reformed criminal is pretty easy to root for, come to think of it.

Secondly, Andy slips up (at least in his mind, although Laurie disagrees) and it leads to some tragic consequences. Now, no one's out there thinking that Andy's infallible by any means, but it's rare that a move on his part has such an obvious negative consequence. I'm not suggesting that we need to see major mistakes from our hero in every novel—but it's good to see that just because Andy Carpenter gets involved, not everything is going to be sunshine and roses.

That said, he's definitely at the point where I have to wonder why the DA keeps taking Andy's clients to trial—when will they learn? Also, Pete sounds far too convinced that Andy's client is guilty, you'd think he, in particular, would have more faith in his friend. This is a question countless readers have asked about Hamilton Burger and Lt. Tragg, as well, and the answer is simply: we wouldn't get to see Andy or Perry Mason do their thing otherwise.

'Twas the Bite Before Christmas delivered just what I expected—a good time with characters I enjoy, a clever whodunit, some fun moments with fictional dogs, and a satisfying resolution. Rosenfelt delivers that and more—there's a sweet bonus moment to the resolution that adds a little holiday glow to the book (that works equally well in mid-September as it will closer to the holiday, or at any point in the calendar year that you happen to read this in). You'd do well to pick it up, whether you're new to the series or a die-hard fan.

Disclaimer: I received this eARC from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley in exchange for this post—thanks to both for this.

Was this review helpful?

This is my first experience with the Andy Carpenter mystery, legal thriller series. Great, snappy inner dialogue by our main character, Andy, a criminal defense attorney and dog rescuer. This outing has Andy defending a twice-failed foster dog parent and friend, Bobby.
Bobby now under witness protection from the gang/mob he used to be associated with and who now seem set on framing him for a murder.
There is a whole team that works together to help Andy with his case. It was easy to read as a stand alone book, but I am sure reading previous books in the series would give all the back story to the multitude of side characters.

The cover art and title were the reasons I picked up 'Twas the Bite Before Christmas. As a Christmas-oriented mystery, it fell short for me. Basically, a holiday party got a small cameo in the overall plot. Nonetheless, the story was solid as a legal thriller.

Thank you to St. Martins/Minotaur Books for providing an e-copy via Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
3.5 stars rounded up to 4 based on being marketed as a Christmas story.

Was this review helpful?

Andy Carpenter books are always some of my favorite and ‘Twas the Bite Before Christmas is no different. Full of dogs, murder, mystery, and humor this book drew me in. Every person accused of a crime says they are not guilty, but is Bobby guilty? Did he get drawn back into gang life and murder? Twists and turns will keep you guessing because if he isn’t guilty, who is?

Was this review helpful?

This was an enjoyable listen, it was easy and fast. It wasn't my favorite of this series though. I didn't love the narrator to be honest, he didn't grab my attention fully.

It was nice to revisit the characters and get more doggies. Which is why I enjoyed the previous books I've read from this series, I've read a few. I just thought this one would have more of a Christmas feel.

There's also some parts that were very unbelievable and it just took away from the believability of the story. It was just okay for me.

✨️Thank you to @netgalley & @minotaurbooks for my free ARC & ALC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

David Rosenfelt's "‘Twas the Bite Before Christmas" brings a delightful blend of holiday cheer and mystery to the table, featuring everyone's favorite reluctant lawyer, Andy Carpenter. In this heartwarming tale, Andy finds himself entangled in a case that disrupts his Christmas plans but tugs at his heartstrings.

As the Tara Foundation's annual Christmas party gets underway, Andy is in his element. The dog rescue organization holds a special place in his heart, and the chance to celebrate with rescued dogs and their families is a tradition he cherishes. However, this year's festivities take an unexpected turn when homicide detectives crash the party and arrest Derek Moore, one of the foundation's devoted foster volunteers.

Derek, who is actually in witness protection under the alias Bobby, swears his innocence in the murder case, but the police are convinced otherwise. Andy is faced with a dilemma—he may not like the case, but he likes Bobby and is determined to help him clear his name.

With humor, wit, and an array of lovable canine characters, Rosenfelt crafts a heartwarming and intriguing mystery that will keep you guessing until the very end. Join Andy as he juggles legal battles, unearths the truth, and takes care of two new furry friends, all while trying to salvage his Christmas plans.

'Twas the Bite Before Christmas" is a must-read for fans of cozy mysteries and dog lovers alike. It's a tale of second chances, loyalty, and the enduring spirit of the holiday season that will warm your heart during the festive period.

Was this review helpful?

Twas the Bite Before Christmas is the 28th in the Andy Carpenter series. It’s got the same sardonic humor, fast paced and well thought out story as I’ve come to expect from David Rosenfelt. And for those worried that there might be a heavy Christmas theme to the story, fear not. Other than a few jokes about Andy’s hatred of eggnog and Brussels sprouts, the story could take place any time of the year.
This time, Andy takes on the case of a former gang member who’s gone into witness protection, only to be charged with the first degree homicide of a leader of his former gang. Rosenfelt has a bit of a formula - there seems to be irrefutable proof that Carpenter’s client is guilty, Carpenter finds proof he’s not but it’s not the kind of proof that can easily be included in a trial. It inevitably involves an investigation that Laurie, Marcus and Cory have to undertake while the court case is ongoing. But while there is a formula, each book comes across as fresh and complex.
This time, I actually could see two critical pieces of the puzzle, which is a first. I’m usually in the dark.
This book can all easily be read as stand-alone. It’s perfect for those that need a quick, entertaining read that doesn’t stint on humor or intelligence.
My thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin’s Press for an advance copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Honestly, I'm not altogether sure what Christmas has to do with the story here except that the events transpire over the holiday season, but it's a fun tale anyhow - especially since it's got plenty of the courtroom drama I love best. It does begin at an early holiday party at the Tara Foundation, a dog rescue organization founded and run by Andy, a canine lover who's also an attorney. Near the end of the evening, foster volunteer Derek Moore, a local businessman, is arrested for murder.

Needless to say, Moore vehemently denies he did the dirty deed. He does not deny, however, that he's in New Jersey's Witness Protection Program under his new name after having ratted on a nasty gang to which he admittedly once belonged. But the evidence against him is almost overwhelming - almost too much to be believable; but clearly, Moore (actually Robert "Bobby" Klaster) desperately needs a lawyer, so who better than his friend Andy?

Even though there's a real possibility that Bobby is being framed for the murder, Andy quickly realizes that proving it will be an uphill battle; the best he can do, most likely, is create reasonable doubt. As the investigation moves along - aided by Andy's wife, ex-cop Laurie Collins, and other familiar (this is the 28th book in the series) and likable team members Cory, Sam and Marcus (the latter a bruiser capable of giving anybody a bump in the night to remember), they may not be much closer to finding a motive - or who's out to get Bobby - but they do discover that a plan with far-reaching ramifications may be in the works.

So carefully, Andy and the crew follow clues, with the primary objective of keeping Bobby out of jail for the rest of his life. As I mentioned before, much of the story - narrated by Andy - takes place in the courtroom, where Andy can show off his considerable chops and humorous asides. It's a very entertaining addition to the series, and I thank the publisher, via NetGalley, for the opportunity to read and review a pre-release copy.

Was this review helpful?

David Rosenfelt does it again. He combines dogs, mystery, Christmas, and lots of humor into a wonderfully readable story. Andy Carpenter is a terrific character, a reluctant lawyer who does his best not to work. He finds himself involved in a murder case involving one of the people who fosters dogs from the shelter Andy helps run. The arrested man turns out to be in the witness protection program. Andy believes in his innocence and takes the case. I love all the recurring characters and these stories are always intriguing and fun to read. I will always recommend this series to patrons who love mysteries with a dose of humor. I give this one five stars. Thank you NetGalley for allowing me to read this book for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Andy Carpenter's next case comes to him at the Tara Foundation Christmas party when one of the best fosterers is arrested for murder. Derek Moore whose real name is Bobby is in the Witness Protection Program after turning in two of his fellow gang members for murdering a convenience store owner and a customer who was there. Bobby has built a new life for himself which includes adopting two dogs. He tells Andy that he didn't kill anyone and asks for help.

The case doesn't look good. The victim's blood is found in Bobby's trunk and the murder weapon in a cabinet in Bobby's home. But there are still a number of questions that need to be answered before Andy can prove that someone is framing his client not least of which is why someone would want to frame him.

As Andy and his team of investigators including his wife Laurie and accountant Sam have lots of trails to travel down to find the answers. For quite a while it looks like Andy and company have discovered another crime that is still on-going which is great but doesn't get Bobby off the hook.

I enjoyed this 28th episode in the Andy Carpenter series. I really like Andy's sarcastic and self-deprecating viewpoint. The story has a nice assortment of dogs too between Andy's three and Bobby's two.

Was this review helpful?

For those that don’t know Andy Carpenter is a New Jersey attorney who is independently wealthy and doesn’t take cases unless he believes the person is innocent and it seems loves dogs. Andy is part owner of a dog rescue foundation and the story begins here during a Christmas party. That’s about all this book has to do with Christmas.

I have enjoyed all the Andy Carpenter stories to date, but feel after twenty eight outings, he has mellowed and is not as snarky as he’s been in the past. Also, the plots seem to follow the same formula. And with this one, I guessed the antagonist right away.

Still fun to read and I won’t stop reading these books, but this was not one of the best.

Was this review helpful?

Once again, Andy Carpenter wins the day. And it is just as enjoyable and funny as all the books proceeding it. If I ever commit a crime, he would be the lawyer I would want. Not only does he prove you are innocent, but he saves the world from disasters at the same time. In the need for a dog sitter while you are in jail? No problem, the more the merrier. And that is the reason that I hope Mr. Rosenfelt continues with this series for a good long time. It feels like family, whenever I read one of his books, although I have to admit that I missed Edna's scenes in this one, Thanks, Netgalley and Minotaur Books for the chance to read it.

Was this review helpful?

witness-protection, gangs, dogs, courtroom-drama, law-enforcement, lawyers, teamwork, animal-rescue, animal-shelter, laugh-out-loud, murder-investigation, verbal-humor, snark-fest, friendship, family, thriller, suspense, suspicion, framed, organized-crime*****

Another amazing yet funny by Andy Carpenter and cohorts. A valuable volunteer at Carpenter's dog rescue is charged with murder and it is found that he has been living under New Jersey Witness Protection. Of course Andy takes the case and it turns into an incredibly convoluted mess involving more than one organized crime operation. Fast paced and full of red herrings, but the biggest plot twist comes at the very end!
This series can easily be read out of order or just drop in anywhere and have a good read while laughing your sox off! This is NOT an unbiased review! I love the Andy Carpenter and K-Team books! The stories are imaginative, somewhat plausible, totally engaging, and off-set reality.
Andy Carpenter is a wise-mouthed lawyer who can afford to take semi-retirement by only representing innocent clients while supporting an animal shelter. Add in that his wife is no longer law enforcement but works as his private investigator and more and you have the baseline for these convoluted mysteries. There are many other people who help Andy find out what the truth really is and make it courtroom admissible (The K-Team). The mysteries are always intriguing, and I cackled my way through the whole thing (again)!
I requested and received an EARC from St. Martin's Press/Minotaur Books via NetGalley. Thank you!
I will definitely get the audio when it comes out.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

In this 28th book in the 'Andy Carpenter' series, the Paterson, New Jersey defense attorney represents a man in the state's witness protection program.

*****

Ever since he inherited a large fortune, defense lawyer Andy Carpenter takes very few cases. Instead, Andy likes to hang out with his wife, son, and dogs; watch sports; schmooze with his friends; help run a canine rescue operation called 'The Tara Foundation'; and so on.

The story takes place during Christmas season, and The Tara Foundation is hosting a holiday party for dog adopters and their canine kids. Andy is there with his wife Laurie, their son Ricky, and their threes dogs: golden retriever Tara; basset hound Sebastian; and pug Hunter.

During the party, Andy gets a call from his friend, Homicide Captain Pete Stanton. To avoid disturbing the festivities, Pete asks Andy to bring out dog daddy Derek Moore, who's adopted golden retriever Jake and dalmatian Sasha. It seems Derek's real name is Robert Klaster, and he's being arrested for murder. Andy signs on to defend Klaster and to take in Klaster's dogs while the accused is in custody.

At the police precinct, Klaster - who wants to be called Bobby - tells Andy his story. Bobby grew up in Camden, New Jersey and belonged to a gang called the Camden Cobras. The Cobras were involved in running numbers, prostitution, robbery, protection rackets, and other non-violent crimes. Then Bobby saw two Cobra members, Johnny Luko and Donnie Briggs, shoot and kill a convenience store owner and one of the store's customers. This horrified Bobby, and he turned state's evidence against the killers.

To protect Bobby, New Jersey put him in the witness protection program and gave him the name Derek Moore. As Moore, Bobby started a business called 'Davis and Moore Flooring' with his partner Jalen Davis, and the enterprise has been very successful.

Now, a Camden Cobra member named Roland Banks has been murdered, and the police have evidence that points to Bobby as the perpetrator. Andy is convinced Bobby is being framed and sets out to prove it. To do this, Andy employs a private detective agency called the K Team, whose investigators are Andy's wife Laurie - a former police officer; Corey Douglas - a retired cop; Simon Garfunkel - a K-9 German shepherd who worked with Corey at the Paterson Police Department; and Marcus Clark - the toughest, scariest guy on the planet.

Andy also calls in his law partner Eddie Dowd - a former football player who's especially good with paperwork; and accountant Sam Willis, who can hack into any computer anywhere. For Bobby's case, Sam collects phone records that are especially helpful in identifying alternate suspects. Sam usually likes to deliver his reports in person at Andy's house, where useful information earns him a big plate of Laurie's pancakes.

As Andy tries to clear Bobby of killing Roland Banks, he runs across a dangerous Cobra gang leader and his thugs; crime lords in Philadelphia and New Jersey; and a scheme involving shipping and explosives.

When confronting dangerous people, Andy - who admits he's not brave - is protected by Corey, Laurie, and ESPECIALLY Marcus. With Corey and Marcus as backup in a tricky situation, Andy observes, "I'm not scared anymore either...Marcus seems to have taken the lead in this; Corey stands a bit farther away. They've probably done it this way because Marcus is the scarier of the two. If Marcus and Godzilla were partners, Marcus would be the scarier of the two."

As always, Andy shines in the courtroom scenes, where he's up against prosecutor Stan Godfrey, "a talented attorney [whose] skills are only exceeded by his ambition; and trying the case before Judge Gettner, "who's been in a bad mood for thirty years."

I always enjoy Andy's sarcastic quips and wisecracks, which add a touch of humor to the book. For instance, talking about not having to call his secretary/office manager Edna, Andy notes, "Edna got engaged two years ago to David Devine, a wealthy owner of fast food restaurants, and since then she has become a professional engag-ee. They are going to have a destination wedding, and to decide where it will be, they have apparently decided that they have to personally check out every place on earth. Right now they are in Slovakia, or maybe it's Slovenia....I always get the confused."

The plot gets a little over-convoluted, and Andy is a bit off his game in this book, because I figured out the bad guy long before Andy did. Still, it's all good fun.

There isn't a lot of Christmas vibe in the book, but Laurie does put up a huge Christmas tree, play Christmas music, and buy Christmas presents for the family - including one for herself from Andy.

This is an enjoyable cozy mystery, recommended to fans of the series.

Thanks to Netgalley, David Rosenfelt, and Minotaur Books for a copy of the manuscript.

Was this review helpful?