Abbey and Leo's story deals with coming of age and coming out, finding queer community, and falling in love, all in the backdrop of New York City. The story is so sweet and vulnerable and also a little nerdy (former band kids will especially enjoy) - I loved it.

While yes this book book is YA, it very much lends to its younger YA audience - being an adult reader I can appreciate that, while also recognizing that it may have been too young for me personally to enjoy fully. For audiences 18 or younger, especially queer youth, this is such an excellent story.

Outside of how well this book offers rep - there were a few stylistic choices and subjective preferences I struggled with that ultimately landed me at a 3 star with this one:

While I loved how this was a short and sweet read - the insta-love feel of Leo and Abbey's romance made me feel a bit removed from it. While I felt the portrayals of their character growth was beautiful, it also felt very minimal - we didn’t get a ton of time to explore them as people or get to really know them deeply. I've read novellas where I could feel the weight and impact of a person's depth accomplished by the writer in a very short time. With this story, I kept feeling frustrated that so much time was being eaten up with content repetition.

I was not a huge fan of the ending - I won’t spoil anything but I felt more could have been done to really round the story out - it felt abrupt and I was not expecting to turn the page to find the acknowledgments. I would have loved an epilogue.

A massive thank you to — and NetGally for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

After reading Always the Almost, I was extremely excited to read Underhill's sophomore novel. I have to say that This Day Changes Everything did not disappoint! Leo and Abby are such lovable little queer teens getting ready to play with their respective schools at the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade. When they meet after accidentally getting on the wrong train, they set off on a magical journey across NYC. Leo is coming t terms with just hoe broad of a coming out he will have on national television, and Abby is reckoning with having feelings for her (maybe?) straight BFF. I absolutely adored how natural the pacing and characterization felt, and how Leo and Abby spoke so plainly about their hopes and fears. Edward Underhill's writing has continually charmed me, and I look forward reading whatever he writes next!

Thank you Netgalley for the ARC.
Overall entertaining read. My first by the author. I own another book, I should read it soon.
I loved that as readers we were taken through New York with these characters. I liked the setting and I liked the storytelling.

If you enjoy rom coms that are queer you will enjoy this book. I had a little bit of an issue with the pacing, especially with knowing that the main characters had a chance of being found out with what they were doing. I loved the discussions about being queer within the novel. This was an extremely wholesome novel and would definitely recommend it to younger audiences! 

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review!

Both Abby and Leo’s bands have been chosen to perform in the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. However, where Abby is excited about the opportunity, Leo isn’t as much. For Abby, New York is her chance to tell her best friend she’s in love with her with a huge romantic gesture–an annotated copy of their favorite book. She has it all planned out. On the other hand, Leo is afraid of getting outed as trans to his entire extended family and just wants the day to be over.

After they both get on the wrong train, Leo causes Abby to lose her book. Separated from their bands, they decide to spend the day in New York getting Abby souvenirs to give her best friend instead. But the more they spend time together, the more they realize that maybe there’s a spark.

Thanks to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for an advanced copy of This Day Changes Everything by Edward Underhill to review! Underhill’s debut, Always the Almost, was such a great read, so I was excited to pick this one up.

Let me start by saying: why didn’t this come out in November? I can think of very few YA books set around Thanksgiving, and I think a November release date makes so much more sense. I get that it’s a romance, so that’s probably why it’s coming out in February, but still. It would have made such a great November book!

Anyway, the characters in this are so well-rounded and realistic. Both of them come from smallish towns, trying to figure out how to best live their queer identities where they don’t know a lot of queer people. For Abby especially, getting to be in New York and see the possibilities gave her the confidence to come out to her friends. On the flipside, Leo is out, but has a lot of anxiety around his extended family seeing him and accepting him. They both work well as narrators, and Underhill creates distinct voices for both of them.

This book is being pitched as Ferris Bueller meets Dash and Lily, and honestly, what a great description. You get a bunch of fun adventures roaming around New York city, all the while you can tell that Abby and Leo are growing feelings for each other. It’s such a fun, lighthearted story, with a supporting cast that is there for their friends, no matter what.

With this and his debut, I think Underhill is carving out his place in the YA queer romance genre. I can’t wait to see what else he does next!

As a former marching band kid, this book was everything I wanted in a contemporary romance! When Leo and Abby get separated from their bands during a trip to NYC for the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, they form an unlikely friendship and decide to explore the city together. But when they start discovering romantic feelings for each other, what will it mean for their future? 👀

More than anything, I loved how unapologetically queer this book was! With a trans main character and another discovering their queerness, it’s an adorable exploration of what being queer means and how finding queer community can make a world of difference for teenagers. The characters deal with family issues surrounding their gender identity, living in places where being out isn’t popular or accepted, and understanding what “label”, if any, is the best fit for them.

The romance between the two was so cute. Grumpy trans boy meets sunshine queer girl on an epic quest over the course of a single day. They follow the plot of her favorite book around the city. The magic of New York during the holidays was vividly described—I really felt like I was there. ❄️

I highly recommend adding this to your tbr and preordering it! The book releases on February 12, 2024. I wish I’d had this book as a teenager! ❤️ A huge thanks to the publisher and author for giving access to a digital copy in exchange for my honest review.

I wanted to like this, a rare book where a trans guy gets a girlfriend but the author is clearly so concerned that writing trans m/f is not "queer enough" that the characters drip with his own insecurities. But since they both lack a backbone or a personality this insecurity make up most of who they are during the book.

I'd buy kids falling in love in a day because they're extra like that but older teenagers? Especially one who already start the day madly in love with someone else?

This book is a disappointing combo of undeveloped themes. Leo being "too much" is genuinely interesting to explore

another absolutely beautiful YA novel from Edward Underhill! I absolutely love the writing style, dialogue, and settings of his books, as well, of course, as the beautiful stories. Leo and Abby have the most magical day together in New York City. both of these beautiful, lonely characters find some peace in each other, even if they have a bit of a tumultuous first meet. Being a New York City nerd, I loved following them all over the city, collecting Momentos, but what really made the story special is seeing Leo and Abby find comfort, peace, acceptance, love in each other as well as themselves. The story does not gloss over the realities of queer peoples existence in closed minded parts of this country, and New York City acts as the safe bubble of magic, freedom, friendship, and possibility where Abby and Leo don’t have the scary aspects of their normal lives weighing them down so much, overall, this was another story from Edward Underhill, I always love reading his books to get a lovely, unique, deep and heartfelt perspective of queer YA love stories ❤️
thank you for the arc :)

Super cute 24-hour romance set in bustling New York City between two queer kids figuring themselves and their feelings out. What a perfect November read, as it takes place the day before Thanksgiving !

Thank you both NetGalley and the publisher for the Arc of this novel.

"I’m . . . not with her, either, actually."... “She’s my best friend.” Ida gives me a knowing nod. “We’ve all been there.” Oh? “We have?” She grins. “Pretty sure falling in love with your best friend is, like, a queer rite of passage.” It is?

This Day Changes Everything is a sensational and beautifully queer novel that is a take on Ferris Bullers Day off and What if its Us. This book gave me so much anxiety! I was so anxious to see if Leo and Abby were going to be found out and get in trouble. It was super entertaining and cute. I loved following their journey and wanted to see where the day took them. I found Leo to be a little aggravating at points but I think that is a more of a personal thing.

This review is also posted on Goodreads and Instagram!

If you love queer rom-coms this is your book. I didn't quite get the high stakes-ness of the book but I can appreciate the story. I'm a sucker for books set in New York, so that is what kept me interested. The entire story is set over the course of one day and that is what took me out of the premise, I understand you can like someone within one day of knowing them—but loving??? I'll never believe in that trope. All in all, really great story and good read.

I really liked this book. I have a soft spot for books set in New York, so this was no exception. It's very fast paced, fun, and fluffy romance if you want a short cozy read. The main characters were both very lovable, and even though it is set in a day, i found myself rooting for their relationship. If you liked Dash and Lily, you will probably love this.

This Day Changes Everything is as wholesome, sweet, and good-for-your soul as...(pausing to think of something appropriately Thanksgiving themed) buttered biscuits? Pumpkin pie? Sage stuffing? ...you get my drift.

But truly. I really enjoyed Underhill's writing; both Leo and Abby were very well-written characters, and the romance felt stumbling and realistic. I appreciated how gently but earnestly Underhill wrote about both of their struggles as queer teens, but never verged into melodrama or overwrought emotions.

While I thought the latter half of the book dragged and was a bit unnecessarily convoluted, I did appreciate how much of New York City Underhill took us, as readers through. And getting to see it through non-jaded eyes was *chef's kiss.*

Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press, Wednesday Books for the ebook ARC. All opinions are mine alone.

When fate throws Abby and Leo together on the wrong subway train, they soon find themselves lost in the middle of Manhattan. Even worse, Leo accidentally causes Abby to lose her Epic Gift for Kat. So to salvage the day, they come up with a new mission: find a souvenir from every location mentioned in the book for Abby to give Kat instead. But as Leo and Abby traverse the city, from the streets of Chinatown to the halls of Grand Central Station and the top of the Empire State Building, their initial expectations for the trip—and of each other—begin to shift. Maybe, if they let it, this could be the day that changes everything, for both of them.

This was such a sweet and uplifting book. This coming of age story is so different from every other book you read yet it was so perfect in every way.

This Day Changes Everything by Edward Underhill was a beautiful story about love and accepting yourself.
This was such a sweet and heartfelt book.
I really enjoyed this story and found the characters adorable and engaging.
I loved the relationship between Leo and Abby.
Leo and Abby are spectacular characters trying to find their place in this world.
The affection and emotions were very raw and real feeling.
I could feel every single emotion and it was just endearing.
I also adored the side characters. They are so realistic and flawed.
Edward Underhill’s writing is the best and can write the most stunning YA romance stories.
This Day Changes Everything is about finding yourself and being true to yourself.
Underhill, keep these stories coming because I for one am absolutely obsessed with them.

"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own."

Thank You NetGalley and Wednesday Books for your generosity and gifting me a copy of this amazing eARC!

Giggling and kicking my legs, "This Day Changes Everything" was such a cute little queer romp. I had an absolutely wonderful time and I would recommend this book 100 times over!

This book just ticked off all of my boxes and contained so many things that scratch the good part of my brain. I grew up reading spiritual predecessors to this book, like the apt comp title Dash & Lily, but as a late-ish in life queer woman there has always been a bit of a hole in this space for me (even though Levithan’s work does include several gay boys!!).

This day changes everything was such a perfect balance of fun, adventure, and thoughtful exploration of identity. It featured the romanticized exploration of New York while still being grounded (things cost money! and it was acknowledged). The love story was sweet, and it had the requisite beats of a romcom without ever getting too frustrating or dark.

I really loved the time spent in both PoVs as well. Abby and Leo were a classic sunshine grump pairing with some really thoughtful depth. I appreciated the nuanced representation of queerness, especially around labels (and the fact that sometimes we can put too much weight into them!). It was fun to read a story with a transmasc read since there is still not much representation for trans people in romance, especially in YA.

A fun book! Would recommend for sure!

Thanks to NetGalley and St Martin’s Press for the early read. Can’t wait for others to get to check this out!

(posted on storygraph - https://app.thestorygraph.com/reviews/ca266e8b-1790-4a36-b5e2-1e8ab2c2514d)

Okay, this was super cute and I honestly can’t wait to get my hands on a physical copy early next year!

If you are looking for a cute whirlwind young romance with lgbtqia representation that has an inadvertent day of playing hooky with a newfound friend in NYC days before the Thanksgiving parade, look no further! If you want a story about transversing the complicated world of finding out who you are, who you love and how to set healthy boundaries, this book is for you. Overall it’s just a cute love story from a perspective that needs to be heard from more voices.

This novel includes great discussions about being queer. The author encapsulates relationships of all kinds with the inclusiveness of being queer. All in all? it is a good coming of age and is a wholesome YA novel.

It sucks believing in the Universe, but someone has to.
But what does it mean to believe in the Universe? I like to think that whatever you look like, whatever you think about yourself, whatever you feel about yourself, if you want, out there, a person is waiting for you.

In other words, we're also called hopeless romantics, and this story, which directly came out from a winter rom-com, is the perfect example of how delusional we are.
But please, don't judge us; there are days we also have difficulties in believing in the biggest scheme of our lives, and those days are tough.

Before explaining the many reasons why you should read this book right now, I clarify it’s a fall story. It’s set during Thanksgiving and there's already a Christmas vibe, so don't ruin the atmosphere before even starting and read it during the right season.
It's important to point that out because this story is also, among many other things, a love letter to New York from the eyes of who can truly appreciate its details: someone who's never been there.

First things first, there's “Queer” written all over it: on the cover, on the spine, on every page; characters have the word “Queer” written on their foreheads.
And those characters feel so real: they talk about gender and labels and topics that aren't usually discussed out loud for unknown reasons, they’re starting to know each other and are confused about themselves. But what truly makes you see them as real people is that even after a big apology from his mom, Leo doesn't just forgive her.
Would you forgive someone for whatever reason the moment they apologize? I wouldn't, but I usually don't forgive at all. But in movies and books is common sense to do so, otherwise, the story can’t end with its happily ever after.
Well, it's bullshit and “This Day Changes Everything” shows how you can accept someone's apologies because they fucked up, but that doesn't mean you are healed on the spot. It can take time, it can take nothing, the only right answer is the one that makes you feel good about it.

Thanks to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley, who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest opinion.