Member Reviews
I came to Nell Painter via The History of White People, which I found fascinating and informative. There are gems in this collection, as well, but there is also a lot of autobiographical diversion. I was unable to fully grasp the unifying thread or thesis. And I did not find the writing itself very good- both structural challenges with the sentences and poor word choice at times. So, a reasonable book for the range of topics, some interesting, but not on a level with previous work.
A collection of essays that simply confirms the brilliance and high intellect of Nell Irvin Painter. I read the essays and always felt like I was gaining some new insights and knowledge. This experience for me was surprising on some levels, because I tend to drift if I’m reading about subjects that are of little personal interest, but I stayed with Ms. Irvin throughout the text, and I feel smarter for having done so. If your aim is to spend time with a multi-hyphenate scholar and experience the bright and vibrant prose she presents on the page, then this intelligent collection of essays is your guide. So keep talking Nell Irvin Painter, I’ll be right here listening and learning. Special thanks to Netgalley and Doubleday for an advanced DRC.
Let Painter keep talking. Perhaps the greatest anti-thesis to the way states like Texas and Florida are responding to US history by censoring all the bloodshed. But Painter asks, what of the beauty?
Names unknown to me, this was an incredibly informative read. It's black history you didn't know. It's history made new. It's history still so important. Because blood continues to spill and we certainly cannot try to cover that up.
"I Just Keep Talking: A Life in Essays," by Nell Irvin Painter is a captivating exploration of her intellectual journey, intertwining her roles as a historian, scholar, and artist. As a therapist specializing in bibliotherapy, I found this collection to be a powerful tool for healing, weaving together personal narratives and academic insights with an unapologetic honesty that invites readers to reflect on the complexities of race, politics, and identity.
One of the book's standout features is Painter's transparency regarding her own challenges within academia and her eventual embrace of her calling as an artist. This candid approach adds a layer of authenticity to her work, making it not only a scholarly endeavor but also a deeply personal and relatable narrative. As a black woman navigating the academic landscape, Painter's willingness to share her struggles is an empowering testament to being in pursuit of one's true calling no matter the challenges.
The collection spans a wide array of subjects, showcasing Painter's versatility in addressing historical figures such as Sojourner Truth, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and Malcolm X. Through her unique vantage point on American history, she challenges readers to reconsider preconceived notions about race and politics, urging us to confront the uncomfortable truths embedded in our nation's past. Her perspective on violence in southern society, both pre and post-emancipation, offers a nuanced understanding of the deep-seated roots of institutionalized hatred.
One of the book's strengths lies in its examination of racism as an ideology rather than a mere personal flaw. Painter adeptly dissects the historical evolution of this ideology, providing a pro-black historian lens that reframes our understanding. By delving into the intricate layers of racism, she encourages readers to move beyond simplistic narratives, fostering a more comprehensive comprehension of the societal forces at play.
The inclusion of Painter's original artwork throughout the collection adds a visual dimension to her already rich narrative. Drawing from newspapers, personal records, and original sketches, her art serves as a poignant counterpoint and emphasis, capturing the tragedy and humor inherent in her subjects. This interdisciplinary approach enriches the reader's experience, offering a holistic engagement with the material.
"I Just Keep Talking" stands as a testament to Nell Irvin Painter's enduring legacy as a preeminent critic and writer. Her essays resist easy answers, embracing complexity and challenging readers to confront the paradoxes within American history. Thank you to the author and publisher for the e-arc copy!