Unfortunately due to the current SMP boycott, I will not post my review until the concerns are addressed..

The synopsis, the author, and the cover of this book made it one of my most anticipated reads of 2024! Unfortunately it didn’t really hit for me. It was pretty slow and the dialogue felt very stilted and awkward. I enjoyed the first 25% but felt like there wasn’t enough going on in the story to keep me fully engaged.

A sweet young adult tale of forbidden love.

A nobleman and a commoner of a small town and she is dying because of her magic.

She’s making his wedding garb - his wedding to another woman that is definitely not in love with him.

I didn’t feel like it was “brimming” with longing like the book’s blurb claim, but there was this slow build of a relationship between two people who formed a friendship first.

I enjoyed most, the cast around them and wished that they would have been more forward. Especially Kit’s betrothed, Princess Rosa.

Overall, this was just a cute little book that I enjoyed reading. Thank you Netgalley and Wednesday books for the E-ARC in exchange for my review.

I really enjoyed this story! The regency inspired world was beautiful and rich and a great backdrop for Niamh’s adventures and character growth. Her journey touched my heart and I thought the magic really enhanced it. And the romance between her and Kurt was super sweet. Had a really good time with this one!

I love the concept of the book, and to be honest, was excited for another grumpy & sunshine trope after coming from Emily Wilde’s. But I failed to connect to the characters and therefore the magic of this cozy adventure. I am certain this book is a warm cup of tea for many, but with its slow start it felt like decaf on a day I needed caffeine.

Sweet and lovely and enchanting. A perfect fairytale and I loved it perfectly. Niamh was wonderful and I enjoyed the story.

A Fragile Enchantment was a whimsical regency romantic fantasy with a whole lot of heart, emotion and depth. Chalked full of scandal, political drama, and pining mixed in with some quiet tender moments, I found the story to be well paced and engaging.

The magic system was interesting, especially with Niamh, and I can definitely see the elements that have been compared to Bridgerton (though admittedly never watched the entire show or read the books so definitely surface knowledge).

There were a few heavier topics that the author attempted to tackle here which definitely made the story that more interesting.

Overall a fun read. This is my first book by this author but I would definitely read more of their work!

Beyond loved this book! Kept my attention the whole night! Yes the whole night I stayed up until 4am reading this and I have a preschooler 😂 definitely recommend this to everyone!

I have tried a couple of times to pick this one up and get into it, however, I think it is one of those books I need to read in physical form. From the chapters I have read, I am very interested in the world and Niamh's story, just sometimes you need a different format *shrug*. My bookstore has it and I will be happy to keep reading it soon.

I loved this book! I am normally not big on history, but this was well written. It was more of a romance than anything. I would definitely recommend this book.

thanks to netgalley and the publisher for access to the e-arc

I well and truly did not care for this in the slightest. I have been following the author and this book's journey for the better part of its pre-pub life, and was so incredibly excited for it. I am a strong lover of historical fiction, even more so when there are fantastical elements involved. So imagine my disappointment when this fell so completely flat for me.

This book was advertised as a slow burn regency fantasy romance, but by chapter 2 our main characters are already in love with each other. Well... at least she was. Listen, I understand the the main character is only 18-19 years old, and a certain degree of naivety is to be expected, but 18-19 in regency england is not like modern day 18-19 in terms of behaviour. She was annoying and whiny, and I don't know how any of the other characters could stand being around her. if you asked me her main personality trait, I would say it was stumbling and tripping. She trips over herself, her dress, the god forsaken floor at least once per chapter, and you bet each time she was landing straight into the chest or arms of the broody love interest.

Speaking of the main love interest, oh my god. Holly Black needs to sue for plagiarism bc that man was a knock off Cardan (who I didn't especially care for either) from the Cruel Prince, to the point where it was just laughable. I'd hate to be a citizen in his kingdom because that man was broody to the point of sounding like a petulant rich kid not getting his way and would often just dip out into the forest and ignore any responsibilities.

The reason im giving this two stars is because 1.) i managed to finish it (skimmed most of the last 40%) and 2.) because of a single side character. Kitt's brother (honestly cant even remember his name) but he was the only character who acted like a real person, who behaved as one would expect someone too in this kind of setting, and really the only character who has more than two active braincells in communication with each other.

Thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the ARC of this!

This gave me The Cruel Prince vibes, and I was there for it. Enemies-to-lovers, magic, and royalty? Yes, please. I loved the way her clothing magic was described.

This book was built around some interesting concepts, but just didn't work for me. Niamh is a poor seamstress from Machland (a stand-in for Ireland?), which has been subjugated and systematically stripped of resources and impoverished by the royal family of Avaland (England?) for generations. Niamh's magical gift is that she can sew feelings and emotions into the clothes that she makes. Additionally, there are rumblings of a rebellion amongst the Machlish who live in Avaland. I was intrigued and was excited to read Niamh's story. But ultimately, I didn't feel like the story hung together very well. The romance between the main characters wasn't well developed (or, frankly, believable); the stirrings of rebellion didn't really go anywhere; and Niamh was supposedly dying from her use of magic, but this thread didn't really go anywhere either. I was also puzzled by the implication that several characters were gay or bisexual, when this wasn't further developed and didn't really contribute to the overall story. Additionally, it didn't make sense to me that Niamh was treated as an honored guest at the palace when she was basically a servant from a country the Avlish looked down on. Finally, the use of modern profanity in a historical setting was jarring. I really liked the idea of this book, but ultimately, I found it an unsatisfying read.

I really liked the characters in this book. I liked the magic system and thought the dynamics of the different relationships was interesting.

I really, REALLY enjoyed Saft's 'A Far Wilder Magic,' so I was super excited when I was approved for this!

'A Fragile Enchantment,' was just delightful. I don't usually love a historical time period, but this gave Bridgerton Vibes which I will always enjoy.

The characters were fun, but the magic system had space to be a little more thoroughly explained.

ARC Review: I don’t know why I had such high hopes going into this book, but I was thoroughly disappointed.

A Fragile Enchantment by Allison Saft is a hate-to-love romance story following Niamh, a magical seamstress from a different country who can imbue her projects with emotions, who gets brought to the palace for a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to create the garments for the prince and his betrothed for their upcoming wedding. However, when she slowly falls for the prince her feelings become more complicated. Simply put, I had issues with this book. I think this book was trying to do a bit too much, and the anonymous gossip writer gave me too much Lady Whistledown vibes. It was attempting to comment on racism and homophobia with the underlying political plot in addition to providing the actual romance plot line and because of that, the love aspects fell a little bit flat. Much of the in-between times and mundane tasks that could’ve been elaborated on (like working on the clothing, growing flowers, etc.) were skipped over, which I think was a missed opportunity for character development. Also, there were a few times when the plot was a little bit messy to the point that I was confused about the ordering of events. Ultimately, the main thing for me is that I wanted more of the cozy romance with a hint of magic vibes and instead got politics.

Spoilers ahead, tread with caution:
One of the biggest issues I had with the book is that nothing really gets resolved besides the main romance plot. The country is still homophobic and racist. There is still an economic crisis going on. And the country’s international relations are by no means promising. I feel like it was just kind of a sloppy ending. Also, the prince and the protagonist don’t spend that much quality time with one another; it just seems fast. Unrelated, but I am not a fan of the fade-to-black scenes in this book. I’m not opposed to them as a concept, but I don’t understand why the author would choose to show fingering in detail and her *climaxing* but not the intercourse. It just seemed funky. Needless to say, I wouldn’t recommend spending your time on this book.

This ARC was received courtesy of NetGalley and was published on January 2, 2024.

This book combined two of my favorite things; magic and regency themes. Niamh Ó Conchobhair is a magical seamstress, who can see her emotions and memories into the very pieces she creates. She is summoned to the country of Avaland, to create wedding wardrobe and jumps at the chance to give her family a better life. An unlikely friendship blooms between herself and Kit, the groom of the upcoming wedding. But nothing is like the fairy tails. She is constantly reminded that she is part of the working class and her people are currently fighting for their rights. And top it off she is being blackmailed to soon the very royals she is growing closer to. Is she willing to risk it all?

This was such a fun quick read! From the moment Niamh set foot on Avaland, she is caught up in the whirl world of court life and political intrigue. She is a complicated character in by working her gift to create a better life for herself, she is slowly killing herself. And the chemistry between herself and Kit is off the charts from their first meeting. All the characters introduced have their own unique gifts and issues that just add to the storyline.

This concept and story was absolutely delightful and intriguing. I loved the court politics and the class-war happening in these kingdoms that loosely resemble the UK, Ireland, Spain and Scandinavia. However that class war is complicated by our naive little Niamh who is a commoner with “divine blood” that the noble families value and selectively breed for with arranged marriages. Sweet, hardworking and self-sacrificing Niamh just wants to help provide for her mother and grandmother and try to give them a better life in a world still living in the shadows of a devastating war of rebellion and freedom. But the sweet innocent seamstress can’t quite help but falling for the broody, troubled Prince, despite his arranged engagement to another. Duty to family is the driving force for many of the character’s actions and intentions, though thankfully our friends that duty to self is just a worthy of an endeavor.

I loved the friendship our young group develops as the wedding day approaches and the book does a wonderful job of showing when and where emotions come into play with the aristocracy, their families and their futures. Let’s not mention the LGBTQ+ representation that is there but never eclipses any of our characters personalities. We have characters that being gay/bi is just a single facet of their persona, not the entire thing which is, obviously, true to real life. Having characters dealing with current and past stigmatization and prejudice over sexual orientation, past substance abuse and generational trauma is handled in a respectful way that again, simply because one of many facets of a character rather than all encompassing.

However, there were times that I felt perhaps too much was trying to be covered at once and we only got snippets of each important plot point. We got brief pieces of Niamh at work, imbuing magic into her creations, brief moments of familial strife and reconnection after trauma, brief moments of political intrigue and building unrest and rebellion, and many other brief examinations of various character relationships. Sometimes the trouble with standalones is having so much to explore, and not enough space to do it in, especially using third person narration. Sometimes our narrator felt omniscient and sometimes felt limited.

Overall, the story was fun, intriguing and gave me the grumpy x sunshine slow burn I love. A Fragile Enchantment is an easy to read, easy to understand and easy to love young adult fantasy.

What an incredibly beautiful story! I was blown away by the quality of the writing. Allison Saft has a real talent for description in particular visual imagery.

I was immediately drawn into Jack and Niamh's story. They understood and supported each other in a way that I adored. I liked that Niamh was always honest with Jack, including calling him out for being entitled at the beginning of the story.

I also loved reading about the magic in this book. Niamh's gowns and other sewed creations were so fun to read about! I also really like Jack's magic and how it sometimes reflected his moods. I would love to see the movie version of this because some of the scenes described were truly cinematic!

I have seen this book compared to Bridgerton with magic and there are definitely similarities. I was reminded of the beautiful decorations for the events in the tv show as well as the importance of the gossip column. I was also reminded of Olivia Atwater's Half a Soul with the quality of magic and the alternative regency setting. There is also a similarity in the heroes and their disdain for society and desire to change it.

I cannot recommend this book highly enough! I think fans of all types of romance will love this one as well as fans of YA fantasy. I would also encourage fans of historical romance to give this one a try. It may not be a traditional historical, but you will recognize familiar elements. For example, that scene where something happens to the heroine and the hero paces in the hall even though it could cause a scandal. The one group I might not actually recommend this book to is younger YA readers. These characters are adults dealing with adult problems and while the content is not inappropriate, I do think it was written with an older audience in mind.

🌶️ - This is a YA book so it is pretty much closed door. However, there is slightly more than kissing going on (though it is not described in any detail). It may go over the heads of younger readers but older readers will be aware of what is going on.

Allison Saft has a lovely way with prose and her covers are always unique and lovely. I enjoyed this romantic fantasy and excited to rec it to my target high schooler audience. I am always happy to find a stand alone romance for them that is of a reasonable length. This one is all the better with Saft's fun banter and whimsical magic. The world building is just right and doesn't bog the reader down.
Thank you so much for the ARC!