4.5 stars
This was such a cute fantasy romance! I read the ebook and listened to the audio. I definitely recommend the experience either/both way(s)! There wasn’t a lot of world building in the story, which made it very accessible to just pick up and enjoy the story without worrying about having to keep track of something complicated or overrun with too many characters. The chemistry between the main characters was spot on. The storyline was top notch from start to finish. I hope there are more stories in this universe!!
*Thanks to MacMillan and NetGalley for the advance copy

This book was so good! Dreamy, captivating, full of fantasy, magic and romance! My brain had issues pronouncing the main characters name... so I googled it... then my brain just saw the English translation instead of the Irish/ Celtic pronunciation. I couldn't put this book down!!!

A sweet, fun, cozy, and adventurous read. Would absolutely recommend it to all Romantacy fans. I haven't read the Bridgerton series, but I think fans of that series would love this book. I am definitely interested in more from Allison Saft.

3.25/5 - A Fragile Enchantment is considered to be a Young Adult Fantasy Romance novel, though I consider it a YA romance with elements of magic because their is no substantial presence of fantasy in the story arc. It’s in a Regency-esque setting. The storyline is said to be reminiscent of Bridgerton and Howl’s Castle, I only saw faint traces of similarities between this story and those two.

Overall, this was decent. I liked the magical elements in the story especially Niamh’s abilities as a tailor and learning about the different dresses she’d worked on. The writing itself was good and I enjoyed the descriptions; the pacing of the plot was perfect.

I think the main drawback of this novel is that the author rarely explored or elaborated on any aspect of the story - keeping everything very surface level. The plot was simplistic, there were different (fictional) countries and kingdoms involved but we don’t delve too much into the history of them. I would’ve loved to learn more but it was understandable if the author chose not to in order to avoid diverging too far from the main story. Same goes for certain side characters who seemed interesting but ended up being quite flat due to the lack of characterization.

With regards to Kit and Niamh, I think more attention should have been given to their backstories along with their evolving relationship especially given the history of where they both came from etc. The author seemed to fall back on the cliches of a specific trope to explain their dynamic. Most of their scenes together seemed to be a pattern of banter and hyper-analyzing facial expressions. As a result, I found it hard to believe in their relationship or get invested in their story.

This story seems to be for a younger demographic but can be a cozy romance for older readers. I wasn’t the intended audience for this novel since I typically do not read Young Adult or Romance but I did not dislike this book. If you’re into either of those genres and are looking to read something that is quick and light then this is a great choice. Going into it with minimal expectations will also help. Once I accepted how simple this story intended to be, it was a satisfactory read. After reading more complex novels with heavier subjects and themes, this was a nice change.

For those who enjoy reading YA Romance, Romantasy or Regency-inspired romance then you will like this...perhaps even love it.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for giving me an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Thank you Net Galley for providing me an ARC of this novel.

Unfortunately, I didn’t enjoy the novel as much as I hoped. The premise of a seamstress able to weave magic and memory into her work and, of course, a regency romance is what interested me in the first place.

However, the story only touches on the surface of the process of bringing designs to life. I get that it might be boring to some people, but when sowing and creating together an outfit from scratch is basically a main part of Niamh’s identity, I want to see her work her magic, her entire creative process. But there’s no montage or anything, we start from the designs and skip directly to the end results. This greatly disappointed me.

Furthermore, in the first 20 pages of the novel, there was so much info dump that even halfway through the novel, I was still confused about the world building.

Moreover, the romance in the book feels random and forced. I feel like Kit being prickly for the sake of the “mean but soft on the inside” troupe. Also, Niamh, I understand she’s from Machland and so manners would be culturally different from Avaland, but she acts out of line too much. The opportunity to create outfits for Kit is one she desperately needs to take her family out of poverty and live a good life. It’s everything to her. Yet, she acts too friendly, and sometimes rude, to the royal family and it’s justify that since Kit is rude to her, she can be rude back. It makes me feel that despite the importance of the opportunity, Niamh doesn’t take it seriously enough.

One last thing, the conversation feels awkward. The main trio, Niamh, Kit and Gabriel, talk like they’re teenagers instead of adults. The bickering between Niamh and Kit feels like they’re ten years old fighting on the playground over a toy. Then there’re parts of the stories where I get thrown back into the modern era and it feels weird.

Overall, the premise of the book was really interesting. However, the execution was lacking in many ways.

I really couldn't get into this book. The main character seemed like a cookie-cutter mold of every other female main character out there.

I haven't been able to stop thinking about this book since I put it down. It's taken me forever to write this review because it was just so good!! What else is there to say?? 5/5 recommending this to everyone, Allison Saft you never disappoint!!

If the bisexual representation, chronic illness, mental health, grumpy x sunshine, regency inspired atmosphere isn't enough to draw you in, then maybe the tense political battle between the laborers and the monarchy will. Or maybe the forbidden love between a royal and a woman from the lower class? Ok if that still isn't good enough, then what about a gossip columnist spilling stories about the royal family in the newspaper???? AND THERE'S MAGIC!!!!

While this seems like just a romance, this book has so many more layers. There is a war brewing in the kingdom of Avaland between the working class and the monarchy, where the laborers aren't getting paid their wages and the kingdom is turning a blind eye. On top of that, the main character, Niamh O'Conchobhair comes from an Ireland-inspired country and is discriminated against for her ethnicity, class, and accent. These topics being the forefront of the book along with the romance are what truly made the book one of my top reads of this year.

5/5 stars, please read this.

Let's start off with what I really enjoyed - the romance and the magic. For me, the romance storyline was strong, swoony, and full of all my favorite moments. There's plenty of yearning, romantic tension, and will-they-won't-they. In their romance, you can see them opening up and getting to know each other. This grumpy prince who has to realize that not everyone is out to hurt him, that he can open himself up and bloom. And then you have our magical seamstress who is fiercely protective and also just trying to provide for her family.

But I think where I struggled in A Fragile Enchantment was the world. At various points of the books, Saft is trying to introduce these political elements, but I had a hard time feeling the stakes. For Niamh there's this dichotomy between her identity and that of the nobility, but it only gets brought up when we are supposed to feel it and not in a lot of subtle ways. It feels very much a device for the plot in some instances.

I honestly DNF’d this book. The sentences read choppy, and it’s *nicely* put that the author hasn’t had an original idea. It’s like a Bridgerton spinoff involving young adults. Not my favorite. I read 10% into it and felt like I would be wasting my time to finish it.

I adored this book so much! It was as lovely and warm as a cup of tea on a chilly afternoon. I've had Saft on my radar for a while, but this was my first book of hers. She's a very charming and well, comfy, writer. It was just soothing to read her words. If you like Rebecca Ross' work, I'm sure you'll like Saft's. A FRAGILE ENCHANTMENT itself was perfect modern fantasy--great queer character rep, fun types of magical powers, dashes of BRIDGERTON and all the good tropes tossed in (enemies to lovers, grumpy x sunshine, slow burn Romantasy). What's not to love?

This is the second book I have read where seamstresses can affect people magically with their garments (please read THE CORSET by Laura Purcell for a decidedly darker tale!) and I really like fantasy books where the fantasy elements are primarily illustrated through such types of craftiness. A FRAGILE ENCHANTMENT is low stakes fantasy with high stakes passions, and I'm here for anything and everything Allison Saft from here on out!

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the ARC! Can't wait to get this for my library.

I've yet to read an Allison Saft book that I haven't enjoyed, but A Fragile Enchantment might just be my new favorite by her.

I absolutely adore the Regency England inspired setting, and I'm even more delighted that Saft didn't just borrow the aesthetics without addressing some of the social issues. Even though this is not technically our world, the class issues and relations between Avaland and Machland obviously mirror the fraught history between England and Ireland, while also allowing Saft a little bit more wiggle room with how her characters got to deal with these issues. I thought it was quite smart.

Niamh and Kit also had a fabulous dynamic. It's very much a classic 'getting off on the wrong foot, prickly/sunshiney' pair, but something about their romance just felt really tender and special. I got the sense that they really saw each other, and that can be difficult to pull off. These characters have layers, but they're each able to cut through the other with just a look, and that felt electric on the page.

I also quite enjoyed the supporting characters. Sinclair, Rosa, and Miriam rounded out the story quite nicely, and it felt like Niamh found a legitimate circle of friends to support her. I appreciated that Saft strayed away from the cliche cattiness that can occur between women in stories like this, and instead they actually talked through their issues and communicated like adults.

My only complaint is that it felt like everything wrapped up a bit too quickly/easily. Given that this is a standalone YA fantasy, and not a particularly long one at that, I'm not too surprised, but I wish the climax had been given a bit more time to play out.

This book was so charming and fun! Absolutely loved and recommend.

Thanks to NetGalley and Wednesday books for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Having read A Far Wilder Magic and fallen in love with Allison Saft's way with words, I was ecstatic to get my hands on a copy of her newest release, A Fragile Enchantment. And while her prose continues to touch me, this story did not grab my attention the way her previous two novels did. Granted, I'm not a huge fan of historical fiction, and this is a regency-era based fantasy, but I also just wanted a bit 'more' generally from this book. I loved the magic system in this novel, but I wish there was a bit more fantasy elements to it. And while I love Kit and Niamh, I wished they had a few more scenes of romantic development. All that being said, this is still a really strong story. I'm tough on the author because I know what she is capable of. Overall, I would recommend this to any "romantasy" reader.

oh my god!! this made me feel all kinds of emotions. i lost count of how many times my heart broke for Niamh, but also how many times my heart swelled for her. Niamh and Kit are such wonderful characters and i adore them both so much. best believe i’ll be preordering a physical copy of this book asap

Thank you so much to Allison Saft, St. Martin’s Press and Netgalley for allowing me to read and review this ARC.

A Fragile Enchantment is enemies to lovers, grumpy x sunshine, forbidden love and magical. Let's just say Bridgerton (Season 2) set in a fantasy world makes for an enchanting love story.

Saft has created a layered romance mixing nobles and lower class love interests who overcome to love each other fully. The whole vibe of this book, its tenderness between its characters and their worlds made this read divine. I need more of their story,..can I have an extended epilogue?

Thank you Wednesday Books for the complimentary copy.

I was so excited to read this book! It was my first book that I received an early copy of to review, so it will be a very special part of my reading journey.
A Fragile Enchantment follows Niamh, a seamstress who enchants her work with feelings and magic. She is brought to the kingdom of Avaland to make the royal wardrobe for the crowned prince, Kit, and his future bride. Not only is Niamh a talented seamstress but she is also Machlish. The Machlish people have been wrong by the Avaland Kingdom and a group of rioters have been trying to get the prince to listen to their requests. All the while there is a rumor column written by Lovelace. Lovelace always seems to be in the know about the royal family and taunting the Machlish rioters all the while keeping their true identity a secret. Through an unlike friendship Niamh, Kit, and Kit’s best friend Sinclair, try their best to free Kit from his engagement to Rosa and help the Machlish people.
Overall the book was pretty good, I liked the world building and magic system but I struggled getting through the first half of the book. I found the second half much more exciting and easier to follow. At times I got annoyed with Niamh and the way she would like life and opportunities pass her but in the end she learned to stand up for herself and truly take the reins on her life. Kit was also difficult to like at times with his extreme stubbornness and sometimes arrogance. My favorite character in the book was Sinclair. I loved his humor and sarcasm and dedication to his friends.

Thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Books for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

A Fragile Enchantment was a beautiful Regency-England influenced romance novel with a touch of magic and fantasy. This book truly had everything - there was an almost entirely queer cast, a very slow burn romance (with TRUE grumpy x sunshine), a unique form of magic in the hands of our main character, and an extremely charming world and characters.

If you’re a fan of Bridgerton, especially Anthony and Kate’s story, trust me when I say: you will eat this up! There were many connections between that series and A Fragile Enchantment, even including “The Tattler,” Allison Saft’s version of the scandalous gossip columnist (reminiscent of “Lady Whistledown” in Bridgerton). I don’t know what it is about these Regency era romances, but I was giddy and kicking my feet at almost every moment!

In my opinion, this really was the perfect little magical romance story. I’m truly looking forward to reading more of the author’s works in the future.

Upon further reflection after finishing this book, I have to update my review and my rating. This book was 5 stars for me. I absolutely loved this book. I am a sucker for fluffy regency fantasy romance. I greatly wish more books like this one existed. It gave me that same feeling I got when reading fairytales as a young girl, that hope for an epic, all-consuming love.

For me, what shined most about this book, apart from the love story, were the side characters. I loved each and every one of them, from Sinclair to Sophia to Rosa to Mariam to Jack. All flawed in their own way, but also likable. I would read a sequel about Sinclair falling in love in a heartbeat (hint hint).

I hope Allison Saft continues to write more books of a similar vein.

I think readers will love this book but it wasn't really for me. I felt like the author, rather than come up with something unique, just borrowed from various other novels (invisibility cloak, divine colored blood, silver-streaked hair, etc. for example). There was even some Robert Frost thrown in for good measure. The romance itself seemed to start out on the right track for an enemies to lovers and I was feeling the chemistry, but then it veered into instalove and I lost interest. I couldn't wrap my head around the magic Niamh possessed, although Jack and Kit's was pretty cool. If she could weave feelings into clothes, did that make her actions at the end (during the wedding) manipulative? Also, these were the worst-depicted royals I've ever encountered in a book. Jack seemed completely incompetent and the workings of the royal court really didn't make any sense. There were also dropped plots. Erin was mentioned as a friend/potential ex of Niamh who "left the palace quickly" (why? it wasn't explained) and her past with Niamh seemed to be thrown in just for a diversity mention. What did the turbulent history between Macland (Ireland) and Aveland (England) have to do with the rest of the plot? The rebel was thrown in for just one more plot point in a book already oversaturated. Why was Niamh the only one dying from using her powers? Regardless, I do think this will be very popular and others will enjoy it a lot more than I did so I would still recommend to the right audience. I will say, the cover is gorgeous. 3 stars. Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for the DRC in exchange for an honest review.

I loved this !!! I didn’t think I was going to like it as much as I did because it’s written in 3rd person but it didn’t bother me as much.

The beginning was slow but the it picked up for sure.

I’m definitely thinking about getting a copy to reread 🥹

A Fragile Enchantment is a Bridgerton-esk story with a magical spin. Niamh is invited to Sootham by the prince regent to create the wedding dress and cloaks needed for the upcoming wedding of Prince Kit and Princess Rosa. Niamh is divine blooded and possesses the power to enchant fabric with memories for the user and feelings for those who view the garment. Niamh hopes this opportunity will allow her to take better care and create a better life for her mother and grandmother who live in a land shunned by high society. Her dreams however take a different turn when love comes into play.

I adored the book, it had me wishing for spring and dreaming of beautiful dresses in faraway lands. I have been looking for a regency novel that felt whimsical while also keeping the style of a classic regency romance and this did not disappoint. I highly recommend A Fragile Entanglement to any fan of Bridgerton and magic,

Thank you to Netgalley, St. Martin's Press, and Wednesday Books for the ARC!