Thank you so much St Martin's Press / Wednesday Books for the ARC!

This was utterly delightful!!! It was whimsical and cozy! Essentially a magical take on Bridgerton. Need I say more?

The romance and found family elements were SUBLIME. I was smiling and giddy all the way through.

4.25⭐️

Did I pick this book up because of that cover? Yes, yes I did. That cover is absolutely gorgeous so thank you to NetGalley for having this available to everyone for 48 hours so I could read and find out if the book matched its glorious cover. Overall, the book does and I really liked it.

Possible spoilers below.

I love any semblance of found family and I loved Niamh, Kit, Sinclair, Rosa, and Miriam. These are my children now. I really enjoyed Niamh's voice and watching the story unfold through her eyes. I loved that there wasn't a "villain" except for the king who was just a shadow figure at the edges of the story. It felt much truer to life where what you're fighting is not people being evil but people trying to protect and love others in their own destructive way. The end isn't everyone in a perfect place but everyone on a path to understanding.

I didn't like the gossip column. It ended up not making much sense and I don't think it was utilized to its full potential. We waited until 60% in to get the plot point on the blurb. That's too long in my opinion. It was also literally just there to cause tension between Kit and Niamh and Sinclair. No other point. So really kind of pointless. Also, I don't know how I feel about Kit and Niamh's relationship progression. It is very Darcy-Elizabeth and entertaining and sweet. But you go from mildly antagonistic to boom! love. Also, Niamh and her back and forth of if she liked him and if she should do these things. She'd do them and then suddenly feel guilty, but she didn't learn. It was a bit frustrating. I felt the plot toward the end unraveled a bit and she acted less like herself in her choices. I get the lesson is about allowing yourself to be selfish but in reality, sacrifice is necessary sometimes. But overall, it was definitely a sweet fun story with a wonderful cast of characters and I’m so glad I was able to read it.

Bridgerton vibe romantacy!!! Which is my holy grail so I knew I would just love it and I was not disappointed!! It also is forbidden love, enemies to lovers, & grumpy sunshine!!! So I clearly had the best time reading this book! 🫶🏼

Disclaimer: I appreciate NetGallery giving me an ARC in return for a honest evaluation.

A Fragile Enchantment is a romantic fantasy that reminds me of the Netflix's Bridgeton series in several ways. We have an unknown columnist and forbidden romance that includes a wedding. It is primarily about Niamh and Kit's relationship, with a dash of politics and magic thrown in for good measure.

I was really hoping to enjoy this book because I had previously read "A Far Wilder Magic" by the same author and had enjoyed it immensely and devoured it. However, there were a lot of things going on in this novel that I wished were explored more thoroughly. The political intrigue and magical system held my attention the entire time, and I was more interested in these topics than the romance. These elements, nevertheless, are more of a background motivation for these two lovers to get together.

What Niamh perceives in Kit eludes me. He strikes me as a very inept romantic partner who is also very rude. Niamh has a lot to lose, yet I got the impression that she was offering more in making the relationship work. Although it is said that Niamh is selfless, I don't believe this is true based on what I've read. Yes, she has made sacrifices by working for her family and doing this job solely to support them despite the danger, but she is suddenly quickly sidetracked by this man and gradually loses sight of her goals throughout the novel. They didn't even pay her on time.

I also didn't like how the Machlish's suffering was handled. The entire novel made me feel incredibly sorry for the working class, and all I wanted was for them to have justice.

I originally requested to read this book because of the cover and description. I dare say it, the book did live up to my expectations as a fantasy romance about a seamstress and a prince.

The book follows Niamh who is commissioned by the prince regent to design a wardrobe his brother's wedding. Niamh has the incredible ability to infuse her magic into her creations, expressing emotions and memories into the pieces themselves. She travels to the kingdom where she meets Kit, the groom, who automatically seems to dislike her and her talents. But as she gets to know him, it seems as if his emotions about her and the world are different then what he wants everyone to believe. Of course with any kingdom there political turmoil that gets mixed with the story as well.

The book was a great read with some Bridgerton vibes. There's an anonymous gossip columnist named Lovelace that publishes political and romantic scandal, mostly focusing on the royal family. That was a fun added bonus to the development of the story.

Overall, its a fun story to read especially if you like the Bridgerton books mixed with a little magic.

Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for an arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I don’t typically read historical romance but this fun Bridgerton-esque world filled with magic and romance was a delight. The magic in the story is more subtle, it doesn’t require complex world building, but it is the heart of the story for sure, and it’s fairly unique for a fantasy. This book delivers a grumpy sunshine romance between a magical seamstress and a grumpy prince. Unfortunately, I wasn’t the biggest fan of Kit, but it was still fun to read the romance between him and Niamh, even if it progressed a little too quickly for me. When I started this book I was intrigued and couldn’t put it down, the beginning definitely captured my interest. There were points along the way where I felt some strong emotions from the story and even ended up tearing up. In the end, not all of the plot resolved in ways I wanted it to and parts at the end felt more rushed. I feel like there was some untapped potential, but I’m still glad to have read the book.

Let me just start by saying that I absolutely LOVED this book! It was everything I had ever wanted in a historical fantasy romance: whimsical writing, period setting, a dreamy fairytale atmosphere, and a gorgeous romance.

I especially loved the characters of Niamh and Kit. Niamh is a kind and compassionate young woman with a love for magic, while Kit is a stubborn but charming Highlander with a hidden past. Their banter was hilarious and their chemistry was undeniable. I found myself rooting for them from the very beginning.

The plot was also well-paced and engaging. There was a good balance of romance, adventure, and magic, and I was never bored. I especially enjoyed the way the author incorporated chronic illness, LGBTQ+, and mental health representation into the story. It was refreshing to read a book with characters who felt so real and relatable.

Overall, I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves historical fantasy romances. It's a cozy and brilliant read that will leave you feeling satisfied and happy.

Here are some of the things I loved most about the book:

The writing was absolutely breathtaking and whimsical. I felt like I was in a dreamy fairytale, and I never wanted it to end.
The characters were complex and relatable. I especially loved the relationship between Niamh and Kit.
The plot was well-paced and engaging. There was a good balance of romance, adventure, and magic.
The author incorporated chronic illness, LGBTQ+, and mental health representation into the story in a way that felt both realistic and respectful.
I can't wait to see what Allison Saft has up her sleeve next!

First off I would like to thank netgalley for the ARC. Second I would like everyone to know that I gasped when I saw I got approved for this book.
read if you like:
enemies to lovers
grumpy x sunshine
bridgerton, regency inspired setting
forbidden love
TW: There is mention of a character battling alcohol addiction and possible suicidal thoughts.

I rated this book a 3/5 stars because it didn’t hook me as I thought it would. I typically finish books relatively quick however this read took me a bit longer. I did enjoy the book and there were some very cute moments throughout I just don’t see myself reading it again. The cover is gorgeous and I adored the friendship dynamic between the main characters.

This was beautiful with a good plot and wonderful characters. It was a cozy, Bridgerton like fantasy. I do wish some things were more explained, like the Fair Ones. I highly recommend to everyone!

Thank you to Netgalley, the publishing company, and the author for an ARC of this book. These are my honest opinions.

J'ai vraiment aimé ce livre. Je ne suis habituellement pas la plus grande fan des slowsburns, mais je dois dire que celui-ci ne m'a pas déçu. Ce livre a été écrit par l'auteure de La chasseuse et l'alchimiste qui était très populaire sur Booksta en français. Ce livre est parfait pour les fan de Bridgerton et de Red Queen! On suit l'histoire de Niamh, une jeune fille qui peut coudre des émotions dans les vêtements qu'elle fabrique. Elle est invitée à faire des vêtements pour le prince de la ville voisine, Kit. Kit est un prince mélancolique. C'est la définition de quelqu'un de grumpy. Il n'aime pas les autres et ne s'aime pas. Il est capable de contrôler la terre avec sa magie. Petit à petit, la bonne humeur de Niamh va venir briser la coquille de Kit. Mais plusieurs secrets vont être réveler et ceux-ci pourrait non seulement briser la relation entre nos deux personnages principaux, mais aussi la stabilité du royaume de Kit. Le premier 50% du livre était quand même long. Comme mentionner plus haut, il s'agit d'un slowburn. On apprend à connaitre nos personnages. C'était un peu long par moment. Cependant, le dernier 50% du livre est super bon! On voit la relation entre nos personnages grandir et il y a plus d'actions. J'ai beaucoup aimé nos deux personnages principaux, mais aussi les personnages secondaires. Ils sont tous attachant (sauf peut-être Jack, mais on comprend un peu pourquoi il est comme ça). J'ai aussi aimé l'univers. Il s'agit d'un bel univers fantaisie comme on le connait. Seul bémole, certaines side stories de l'histoire n'ont pas été assez exploités. Par exemple, on aurait pu enlever le fait que Niamh est malade parce qu'on en parle peut-être 3 fois dans le livre. Aussi, tout l'aspect avec les rebelles n'a pas vraiment été résolu. J'ai tout de même extrêmement appréciée ma lecture et je recommande totalement ce livre

I had the absolute privilege of being chosen to read an advanced readers copy of this book and I was absolutely delighted! This is the first time I've ever gotten to read an ARC and I will forever remember it. Allison Saft created an absolutely breathtaking story. I enjoyed how all of the lore was easy to follow. I do wish she could have gone into a bit more detail about how the powers worked and why some characters were more affected by the use of their powers than others but that little bit of intrigue could be something she could explain in a sequel (if she decided she wanted to write one).

I really loved the characters of this novel. I was invested in each and every one of them. I like that every single one of them had both their good and bad traits highlighted. No one was a complete paragon of morality but I think that's what made them so likeable.

I really loved the romance in this book I wish I could go into more detail but I don't want to go into spoiler territory, especially considering the book hasn't even been released yet. I will say that anyone who likes the grumpy/sunshine trope will like the main couple quite a bit.

This book is one I'd recommend to fans of Bridgerton and Pride and Prejudice. Definitely has those vibes with a hint of magic. All I could say is I found this story to be very, very heartwarming and it makes me want to go and read Allison's other books. I will definitely be picking up a copy of this novel in January and I'd encourage everyone else to as well.

This just might be my favorite book of the year. Niamh has been hired by the King of her neighboring kingdom as the seamstress for the upcoming wedding of the Prince. With the money and exposure that comes from this job, she will be able to provide for her family and make their lives easier.

Things start out bumpy but soon she finds herself coming to enjoy the moments she spends with Kit. But Niamh has a job to do. She can't allow her developing feelings for Kit get in the way of her goals.

This book was filled with longing, magic, court politics, fights for equality and lessons on putting yourself first and not giving up on the things you want. One of the things I especially enjoyed was the character growth in the side characters. They weren't just there for the sake of the main characters. They had their own issues to deal with as well.

I loved Kit. He allowed people to see him a certain way and had given up on fighting for the things he truly wanted. He was a sensitive kid who was told from a young age that that wasn't ok and so as an adult he tries to hide that side of himself. Niamh is great because she forces him to be himself and he in turn helps her to realize that she can't continue to live her life to please others.

3.5 stars rounded up

Spice: 2/5 (one somewhat steamy scene followed by fade to black)
TW: alcoholism, some anti-queer sentiments towards supporting characters by their families.

I loved how this story started. The writing drew me in, the world was fantastic, and I thought the magic system was very creative. I would love my own embroidered and enchanted garment from Niamh!

Ultimately though my suspension is disbelief can only go so much before I just can't suspend anymore. Why would the Prince Regent (Jack) allow Niamh to go to all of these functions, as basically a servant? And how does she have anything to wear, which would have to be made with expensive fabrics for it to be remotely acceptable, but it's been drilled into us that Niamh and her family are so utterly poor? How is Jack allowing this group of five, which includes the princess Rosa, and prince Kit but also the glorified seamstress to go galavanting around? How does she have time to sew all these pieces? How is Jack chill with these very strange enchantments in the garments?

There's just so many questions that were popping up and the ending felt pretty rushed overall.

But yes, the cover is beautiful. I wish the story inside lived up to it. It was good, I'm glad I read it, but not great.

I liked this book a lot and the atmosphere of it! It was very romantic and regency-vibes.
I do think that Kit could've been more compelling as a love interest, and the main character annoyed me sometimes. She got in so much trouble and seemed so naive that it made things cringey at times. I found myself feeling frustrated with her.
Overall, a good book, but I think the second half was very slow.

Bridgerton meets fantasy in this enchanting novel, bursting at the seams with magical dresses, forbidden love, and scandals.

Niamh has one chance to make a better life for her mother and grandmother. A rare seamstress with the ability to enchant clothes, Nimah is invited to Avaland to create a wedding cloak for Prince Kit and his arranged bride, Princess Rose. But everything is not as enchanting and perfect as Niamh imagined. Prince Kit is grumpy and has no interest in the marriage, and his bride seems even less thrilled. The working class is fed up and revolting against unfair wages, with help from a scandal sheet that exposes the noble’s hypocrisies and secrets. As Niamh and Kit work together to solve the unrest growing in Avaland, they fall for each other. But when the scandal sheet starts writing about the sparks between the two, Nimah is given the choice to spy on the royal family or send the arraigned marriage up in flames, causing even more political turmoil.

Niamh is sunshine personified, a girl obsessed with pretty things and hopelessly romantic. Unfortunately, her whimsical notions have been kept under lock and key after years of scoldings by her mother and grandmother. They constantly belittle Niamh and make her feel poorly for having dreams and goals for herself. Even though Nimah never dealt with the war between Avaland and Machland firsthand, her grandmother will not let her forget it. Niamh is overly giving, wearing herself down to the bone for the sake of others. She sees moments of rest as selfish, never mind her chronic pain and fatigue. Despite the burdens placed on her, she still remains cheerful and genuinely kind. She can’t help but look through Kit's prickliness and see the good inside. No matter how hard she resists, she falls for him, despite the catastrophe that spells out.

Grumpy, socially awkward Kit has been called back to court for an arranged marriage. His four years away from the political scene have only served to sharpen him, making him even more rude and unfeeling than before. Few people know about the abuse he dealt with at the hands of his father and the worthlessness he felt when he couldn’t help his brother. Despite his rough exterior, he is chivalrous and very concerned about potentially harming others. No matter how hard he tries, he can’t seem to stop himself from falling for a clumsy seamstress who gives him headaches from her optimism.

Niamh and Kit are my new favorite couple. Despite presenting as complete opposites, they are very similar. Having dealt with family trauma and feeling worthless outside of what one can perform, the two slowly come together in the love story of a lifetime. Despite the very rough start, thanks to Kit being rude, Niamh slowly worms her way past his defenses with her unerring good cheer and love for others. Niamh comes to realize that Kit’s rudeness is a guard, and his instinct is to protect and care, even if he has a funny way of showing it.

This book is a romantic fantasy. The tension between Avaland's nobles and Machland's lower class is technically the “plot”, but Niamh and Kit take precedence. The focus is on what Niamh and Kit overcome in order to love each other fully, which isn’t usually my cup of tea. Yet, Saft has created such layered and nuanced characters that a more complex plot would have gotten in the way of fully fleshing out their harmful pasts and brilliant future.

Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’ll be rereading this. Add this to your TBR and thank me later.

Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and Wednesday Books for the advance copy! All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.

Thank you NetGalley and the publishing company for giving me an advanced readers copy in exchange for my honest review.

This book was truly a delight and I will be reading this book again in the spring since it brought me so much joy! Between the world building and whimsical writing I was hooked!

A Fragile Enchantment is a whimsically fun fantasy romance with a regency era setting and a cast of morally gray, complex characters. I loved everything about this book. Niamh is an extremely talented tailor who can sew magical enchantments into her designs. When she is hired to design the wardrobe for the royal wedding, she can't believe her luck. Her family desperately needs the money and support. However, this task will be much more challenging than she expected, since the groom is a brooding, angry, uncooperative individual who could care less about both fashion and this wedding. The development of Niamh and Kit's relationship is perfectly executed. In fact, the author does a great job with all of the characters. I especially loved Kit, Sinclair, and Jack. They are all facing their own personal obstacles and, at times, are their own worst enemies. The author also does a fantastic job of demonstrating that there are many types of love and that love can be portrayed through many different actions (not just through hugs and kisses).

I have read Allison Saft's other books and loved them as well. She is definitely one of my must-read authors. I will be recommending A Fragile Enchantment to everyone I know. Easy 5 stars!

I really wanted to love A Fragile Enchantment, but sadly I found myself frustrated with the story overall! The premise really drew me in: the book is set in a whimsical Regency-esque world with touches of magical realism (the protagonist Niamh is a seamstress who can imbue her designs with particular feelings and memories), contains undercurrents of political intrigue and tension as well as forbidden romance with a prickly prince.

Saft has a lyrical writing quality that I always enjoy; it was present in her previous novel A Far Wilder Magic, and is on full display here as well. The allegorical element seen in her previous book is also present here: Saft seems to explore some of the historical tensions between the English and Irish during the 18th-19th centuries. Despite having fantasy undertones, it feels more grounded as a result and the allegory (even if handled a bit simplistically) gives the novel some complexity.

I just couldn’t get behind the relationships between all the characters. They’re all meant to be a bit unlikeable, (or at least, that’s how I ended up feeling about them) apart from Niamh– who is supposed to be a ray of sunshine. But I really couldn’t understand what Niamh saw in her love interest; it was “insta-love” frustratingly executed as their subsequent interactions didn’t really improve. Additionally, the plot ended up feeling quite messy in its balance of romance and court/political intrigue; it never seemed to find its footing enough to succeed from either angle for me. I wish the magical realism element had been played up a bit more, as I really liked the concept of Niamh’s talent with needle and thread and felt that was overshadowed.

Thank you to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for an advance copy in exchange for an honest review!

Allison Saft has quickly become one of my must buy authors. Her writing is divinely whimsical and effortless in its narrative. One of the highlights of this book’s many dynamics was the emergence of found family. If you’re into enemies to lovers, regency romance, grumpyxsunshine this is the book for you. Thank you for the e-arc I can’t wait for other readers to fall in love with this novel.

Some very sweet moments! Loved the whimsy in the magic and the friendships/ found family vibes. Didn't always love the characters, but still a fun read!!