Member Reviews

I could not finish this one. It started off strong, but it needs better editing. There is a lot of repeating information and some inconsistencies. And, there are too many story lines, just too much going on.

Was this review helpful?

This book is science fiction AND fantasy AND horror AND thriller AND....a lot. The book delivers a dystopian future where humans have discovered immortality by implanting their minds into different bodies, babies are grown outside the body in water wombs, and people are microchipped and monitored on a whole new level of e-carceration. The ideas that built this book were fascinating and thought-provoking. However, somewhere after the halfway mark, this story took so many wild turns that I had lingering whiplash. I almost did not have the mental energy to finish it. After taking some time to think about the story before writing my review, my opinion is that the author attempted to squeeze too much into a single book and the growth of the story may have benefited from being split up into multiple books. There are just too many concepts introduced and too much worldbuilding, where the finale felt like a chaotic sprint that was out of focus and anticlimactic. There is just too much shrouded in mystery through much of the book, and when it all comes to light in the end, it feels rushed. I can almost guarantee that if you read this, whatever you try to predict will happen will be wrong!

I received an advanced ebook by requesting a copy on NetGalley. Thank you to the publisher and author for allowing me this opportunity to read this whirlwind of a book!

Was this review helpful?

This novel is phenom! The academic prowess the literature possesses holds you captive with the turn of each page. The depth and layers to the characters represents itself to a fully developed plot that in fact would facilitate a collegiate academic discourse to evaluate the intricacies of crafted societal collapses that one so myopically challenged, believe it to be norms! If you are looking for a novel that weaves the many different fabrics of genre and lends itself to a cinematic aesthetic such as LoveCraft Country, Matrix , Memento, Handmaid's Tale, this novel is one you should pre order ASAP!!!!!
Well done Tlotlo Tsamaase!! Well Done!!!

Was this review helpful?

Womb City is a wild ride from beginning to end! This is a scifi horror book that also has some mystery and fantasy elements in it. In the blurb the books gets compared to The Handmaid's Tale and Get Out. I also want to add Black Mirror and Minority Report to that list. Especially towards the end I really felt like I was in Black Mirror episode (I love that show! It is one of the only ones I binge immediately when a new season comes out.).

I really enjoyed this book and it was a fast read that I couldn't put down. The beginning was a bit slow, but the world was interesting so I still wanted to keep reading. The thing that brought this book down to a 3.5 stars for me was that I felt like it wanted to do too much and wanted to tackle too many themes. Sometimes the writing style was also a bit jarring and I was confused about what was happening in the scene.

But all in all, a strong debut novel from an author I will definitely read more from in the future!

(If you want to read this book be aware that it is pretty dark. A list of trigger warnings is included in the book.)

Was this review helpful?

Really interesting premise and world-building, but some of the characters fell quite flat for me. I consistently found Nelah to be an unlikable protagonist, with behaviors that were inconsistent with her professed motivations. The scene where she attempts to steal?? a baby was confusing and felt out of left field. She is a woman who is monitored and under surveillance 24/7 and is very aware of this, so it made her seem incredibly stupid? Not sure what the intent was there, but it didn't work for me. Because the setting and sci-fi/horror tone was intriguing, I tried to look past it and enjoy those elements. I'd definitely be interested in reading more Tlotlo Tsamaase in the future.

Was this review helpful?

This book is best described as The Handmaid's Tale set in a dark sci-fi dystopia. It follows Nelah as she tries to past her trials to prove she is a worthy citizen. She is one the implanted ones, her husband can see days through her eyes, her thoughts are accessible to the authorities, she is watched because she has the potential to be a criminal. She must prove herself in order to exist in society and have a child. Things go wrong when her trials did not go as planned. Things spiral out of control and she is left in a circumstance where her very existence is on the line.
This book is riveting, and thoughtful. The plot moves at a steady pace, and you feel Nelah's pain and disassociation throughout the book. You see themes of power, corruption, sexism and greed throughout the book. I like that even though the story is futuristic, it still maintains ties to the African cultural myths.

Was this review helpful?

Ad Pr Product
🇧🇼Womb City -Tlotlo Tsamaase

This is definitely not my normal genre of book, it's kind of futurist handmaids tale esque. From the outside Nelah has it all but she's stuck in a loveless marriage with a husband whose able to examine her every move through a microchip and has body switched into the body which previously created a crime. . After a drug fueled evening Nelah accidentally hits a women with her car, her and the man she's having an affair with then decide to bury the body. The ghost of said victim then starts to haunt Nelah and begins killing her loved ones off, which will culminate with the death of her unborn child. As they fight against this ghost they realise that the biggest enemy isn't the one killing their family in a gruesome way.

Although not my normal genre is really enjoyed this book. In a dystopian way it examined what it means to be a women in a man controlled world. I thought the concept of this book was really incredible and I would not have worked out the ending. However, I did feel some parts of the books were a bit repetitive. That could have been because it was an arc copy and the final version will have been edited to remove this. However because the concept was so good I don't feel it retracted from the book and I still loved it.

Was this review helpful?

If you ever enjoyed watching The Matrix, Lovecraft Country, Memento, & Handmaid’s Tale before…Womb City is the book for you. This story takes you down a rabbit hole of adultery, intrigue, family secrets, with a dash or murder. I very rarely reread books once I’m finished with them but this is a story I will happily read again.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for providing a review copy.
This book has a LOT going on. I would put it firmly in the sci fi horror category. I enjoyed it quite a bit, but I felt like there was so much happening that I couldn't keep up. This could also be a me problem, as I was in the middle of moving to another state. I almost DNF'd a couple of times, but I'm so glad I stuck it out. This is a very important, empowering story. 4.25 stars

Was this review helpful?

Thank You to NetGalley for the Arc
Womb City by Tlotlo Tsamaase, in which far-future women live and are controlled by chips implanted in them that monitor their every move. This novel is everything a patriarchal dystopia should be; an exploration of power and the way that gender shapes one's relationship with it. In this version of the world, the chips implanted in women are used to keep them "perfect." The protagonist Nelah finds herself torn between the life she has always known and the realization that the world around her is something much darker than she originally thought.

Personally, I loved this novel and thought it was a wonderfully in-depth look at modern womanhood and the realization that the system is built against you. Where I struggled was in the marketing of the novel as, like most patriarchal dystopias, it is marketed as a version of The Handmaid's Tale; however, Womb City is a story that stands on its own without the backbone of Margeret Atwood's novel.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the start of this book. It led with a sci fi / dystopian setting with quite strong commentary on inequity, gender, and justice. It took me a little while to understand the context and worldbuilding but was super intrigued by it and was looking forward to learning more about how the system worked.

At about 40% it felt like the book really veered off into another genre, bringing in more paranormal elements than I was expecting. Despite this I enjoyed the book and found the whole premise really intriguing. Would make a great movie

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved Womb City by Tlotlo Tsamaase!
I was so excited to read this book as it sounded amazing, and I'm a big fan of sci-fi horror books, and this one did not disappoint!
It ended up being an amazing and unique read!

The world building was a little difficult for a bit, but once I understood it, it was amazing!
I thought Nelah was a great main character, and I really loved the ending.

I definitely highly recommend this book!
Thank you so much for giving me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This review was made possible view an ARC through NetGalley.

Wow, wow, wow. I was drawn in from the first page. The voice and prose really worked for me as did the cyberpunk and Queer elements. Tlotlo Tsamaase has a real talent for making you feel close to xer characters and world. The Motswana mythology elements were woven in naturally and really made Womb City feel specific and unique.

The twist really worked for me as did the ending, but I can see why it might read as conspiracy theory for some and be a turnoff. Everything felt like it was leading up to the big reveal and it tied in with the themes. Nelah's drive to become a mother and her pain from multiple miscarriages plus her affair with Jan all felt tangible and natural. Nelah is probably one of my favorite MCs so far this year and I ached for her more than once. I also loved the details of the bodyswapping worldbuilding in an Africanfuturism Botswana.

I'd recommend this to people who love cyberpunk and are open to themes around motherhood, infertility, abuse, and more. Womb City deals with a lot of uncomfortable themes but it never feels like it's for shock value; it feels purposeful and is there to make you consider what is being said. This is Tlotlo Tsamaase's adult debut novel and I'm beyond excited to see more from xem. The cyberpunk elements with the horror elements in a Queer Africanfuturism framework worked for me in ways I genuinely wasn't expecting.

Was this review helpful?

DNF @ 6%, the earliest I have ever DNFed something. Unfortunately, I've been trying to get into this for ten days now, and have had to accept that it is just not for me.

As has been noted by other reviewers, Womb City makes use of many, many futuristic technologies (including, but not limited to, body-swapping and behaviour-monitoring microchips) to explore race, gender, corruption, and power, among other things. The result is discordant: it feels sort of like watching every episode of Black Mirror simultaneously, rather than engaging with a single, thoughtful, considered narrative that delves deeply into any one of these concepts.

I'd also like to note that, at this point in the book, my experience (including my dissatisfaction) is limited to its sci-fi elements - the horror has not yet been introduced. I would still like to thank NetGalley and Erewhon Books books for providing me with a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Take one part Minority Report, one part The Handmaid's Tale, and one part Altered Carbon, shake well and start a science fiction novel. When half baked, add a good ghost story and turn it into a horror novel. That's the best I can do to describe this amazing novel without giving anything away.

Was this review helpful?

The premise of this book is SO interesting. I loved that it's a fantasy smashed into a scifi world. That being said, for at least the first 60% of the book I found myself continually having to reread entire passages because the heavy handed world building kept losing me. And when I say heavy, I mean HEAVY. There was so much going on that it felt almost convoluted at times. I felt like I was sludging through the first half and then being whiplashed and flying through the last half at hyperspeed.

That being said, Womb City was truly gripping. The action -packed last portion of the book was fun to read. I definitely reccomend if your jam is dystopian horror that throws an entire world on your head and doesn't allow you even a moment to grab your bearings. I would've rated it 4 stars but by the end the story just felt like TOO much.

Was this review helpful?

This book started out so promising. The story was different and I could see a whole world unfurling in front of my eyes. But then the author tried to fill an entire book series on one book. It was just to many ideas and it simply became to hard to follow the different ideas presented. I would have loved for this to be a series rather than a single book. I feel like the author could have allowed the different plot points to breath and developed on their own.
It wasn't a bad book, the prose was right up my alley and as stated, the ideas were great. Just to condensed.
Thank you to netgalley and Kensington for this eArc

Was this review helpful?

I can easily see this being a fan fav. The drama, the sci-fi, the love triangle was all perfectly done. I finished wanted more from the characters. Great job to the author.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

Nelah lives in Africa in a futuristic dystopian society where consciousness can be uploaded and transferred into other bodies. Naturally, this leads to a hierarchy where the rich are basically immortal and eternally young while the less fortunate live short and often miserable lives. Society is also very patriarchal and women are heavily monitored to ensure a domestic supply of infants (future bodies for the rich to use.) Nelah’s status is middle-class, and she gained her wealth from her successful architecture business. But due to various circumstances, her consciousness was placed into a former criminal’s body, which means she must have a microchip implanted to make sure she stays in line and doesn’t display signs of criminal tendencies. Her mind must be regularly reviewed by her husband and she must perfectly pass his and the government’s mandated reviews if she wants any chance at getting that microchip removed and her freedom back.
But after a nightly rendezvous with the wealthy man she’s having an affair with goes wrong, passing the exam is the least of her worries. With both the government and the spiritual world after her, surviving will be hard enough.
This was an interesting novel that sparks some thought about various topics, but I felt it could’ve benefited from more editing. There was a lot going on and it didn’t feel very cohesive. The supernatural element was suddenly introduced and took the story in a completely different direction, which was jarring.
If edited more, I think this would be a great, thought-provoking sci-fi novel.

Was this review helpful?

Womb City was a fascinatingly original story with such an interesting technological and governance system that sparks the imagination. Nelah is a compelling character facing such relatable struggles and dilemmas, and it was an exhilarating (albeit harrowing) ride to follow her on her journey throughout the book.

Was this review helpful?