Gelato and Lies. Not a big fan of this one. I don’t like the hidden identity trope, just not for me.

I truly loved this story for so many reasons. The budding romance between Iris and Gio is a beautiful slow burn, intertwined with the magic of New York's Little Italy and their shared love for gelato. Their relationship feels authentic and heartwarming, developing naturally as they work together to save Gio's family gelateria. I enjoyed how their connection deepens over time, marked by small, meaningful moments rather than grand gestures, making their love story both believable and endearing.

The secret gelato recipe plays a crucial role in the plot, serving as a link between Iris's past and her new life in New York. The mystery behind how Iris's mother came to possess the recipe adds a layer of intrigue, while the process of recreating the gelato symbolizes Iris’s journey of self-discovery and healing. I appreciated how the recipe was more than just a plot device; it represented family, heritage, and the bond between Iris and Gio, adding depth to the story.

Iris's evolution throughout the novel is compelling. Moving to New York to escape her past, she finds herself rediscovering her passion and purpose through unexpected connections and challenges. I liked how her character grows stronger and more confident as she embraces her new life and the people in it, particularly the close-knit community of the gelateria. This journey of personal growth, coupled with the love story and the enchanting backdrop of New York, made the book a delightful read.

I have read a few of Josie's novels before this one and was so excited to get a chance to read this one! I really enjoyed the scenery and characters and it's definitely a comforting cozy read! Thank you!

A Winter in New York follows main character Iris in her move to New York for a fresh start and to find some connection to her late mother. Not only does she find clues around the city that unfold some of her mother's life, but she finds her own corners of the hustling city to make her own. This wintery tale turns the Big Apple into a quaint and cozy place, letting the reader get lost in the story.

I truly loved the small-town feel that was pulled out of the setting. It was done in such a way that New York City still felt vast, but emphasized the routines and habits that you fall into in big city life. The shops you regular at and the streets you pass through every day. There is a great family element to this story, that only made it more and more cozy. I really did enjoy this story and it is perfect for a seasonal read.

I absolutely loved this captivating book! The characters are great, the development of the story is wonderful, and I can’t wait to read more by this author!

I was hoping for the same magic of One Day in December but I did not connect with these characters. It was fun to read a book based in NYC but it felt like the author just had a list of NYC spots she wanted to mention.

✨Book Review✨
A Winter in New York
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
.
This book was a low 4 for me. I did read it in two days and kept wanting to go back, but the main character's decisions drove me nuts. Stop keeping secrets!!!! I wanted to scream at her for most of the book.
.
That being said, it was a super cute love story. I love how much it centered around family and friendship. The gelato plot line was adorable, although I could see some poeple finding it too cheesy. I do think it could have been a lot shorter. Rom coms at 400 pages are just a little too much. Overall, would definitely recommend for a cute romance.
.
I listened to the audiobook and had a very hard time listening to this narrator.

This cozy read is perfect for a winter day or when you're just looking for something cozy and heartwarming. This book celebrates the love and comfort found in chosen families and great friendships through the main characters journey of starting over and grief. I would recommend this book to anyone looking to be swept off their feet by a family business and growing relationship between two passionate chefs.

A deliciously sweet winter romance centered around family and gelato. I did struggle to get through this one at times, as it felt a bit slower paced than the author’s previous book, but it was an enjoyable holiday diversion nonetheless. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for making a copy of this book available for my review.

DNF. The book was kind of slow, though I appreciated the dual perspective between mother and daughter.

Really enjoyed this sweet love story. It wasn’t super holiday focused so if you aren’t looking for a Christmas romance necessarily, don’t be afraid to pick this one up! I loved the main characters. The author does an amazing job of making them feel real

One day in December is one of my fave winter reads. I was hoping to feel similarly about this title but it felt very dry and in need of a spark. The intimate scenes were odd and I could not ground myself in the story.

Josie Silver is an automatic read for me! She did not disappoint yet again. I will say this one took me a bit to get into, but once I was hooked I was in! It's a sweet story about Iris and Gio. Two people who are struggling coming together for their love of vanilla gelato. All the winter vibes and cozy feels from this book.

Thank you so much for my ARC of this book!

I loved the relationship that developed between the FMC and the MMC. And his whole family really. I really struggled with her not telling him about the recipe. I understood her reasonings but it still didn't sit well with me throughout the whole book. I gotta say that one of my favorite scenes was when the ex BF came back and the whole family showed up to put him out. best part for sure! That might have been because I was wanting to do that myself throughout the whole book soooo.

Josie Silver is a must-read author for me. This book was sweet and charming with picture perfect romance. I loved their connection and bater over all...and some great slow burn tension that makes it all worth it!! Great family dynamic throughout and you will crave gelato after you read this! Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC. All thoughts and options are my own.

thank you to netgalley for the advanced reading copy. I really enjoyed this and will be getting copies for my shop.

This was a cute story about Iris' adventure in New York. It made me really want some gelato while I was reading.

I loooooooooooooooooooooved this book. So fun, and it's was such a great read to get into the holiday spirit. Iris and Gio were a delightful couple, with real world problems that affect their lives. Iris' BFF Bobby was also a hoot.

The romance was perfection. A slow-burn, well-executed, makes-your-knees-turn-to-Jello kind of romance. I adored Gio.

I would have loved to see a little more depth to him, but the romance in general? Their banter, tension, and overall connection? Definitely a 10/10.

I mean, the fact that he affectionally calls her “little spoon” in Italian? Are you kidding? Too cute for words.

Looooooved this one! The characters in this book are so charming and lovely. I want to be adopted by a big Italian family! This was a sweet story with many layers. It felt homey and comfortable, just what you want in a good holiday book.