Member Reviews

I read an eARC of this so thank you to Net Galley, the author and the publisher.

This was a delightful read, charming yet dark, whimsical yet constant sense of menace.

We follow the Everley family who are under a horrible curse. Violet’s mother disappeared one night in a bid to break the curse and now it falls to Violet to pay the price. We follow Violet as she tries desperately to break the curse to avoid paying a horrendous cost that was decided for her.

Violet is curious and determined, an excellent main character. She’s very brave in the face of a looming horror. We have a malicious and frightening villain. Who seems initially fairly benign but we soon learn that’s not the case.

The book has an interesting magic system linked to a fantastical metal and allowing instant travel. There are moments in this book that are quite horrifying and there is significant violence and cruelty.

The plot was fantastic and the writing was beautiful. I loved this author’s style and the pace was excellent. My only criticism is I wasn’t a fan of the romance. I felt there was too much harm in that relationship. Otherwise though this was a wonderful read.

Was this review helpful?

“We see the shadow behind you. We see the shadow ahead. From nothing, to nothing”

Thank you to Netgalley and Hopperscape for this e-arc!!

Review: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

The Positives
- magical worlds
- complex characters
- themes of belonging, family, pain and secrecy

Do I see myself in Violet? Yes! She’s a bookworm, who dreams of other worlds, and saw herself becoming a historian studying the arcane. The journey that Violet goes through is really inspiring, and I loved reading her development as a character!

If anyone is looking for a new dark haired male character with a tragic backstory, Aleksander is the one for you. He’s beautifully complex, with plenty of depth and intrigue. Together, Violet and Aleksander were tragically close, and were two very compelling characters.

This book is so beautifully written! Everything was so tangible, from the places to the emotions. The crafting of this world was perfect, with its whimsical magic and god-metal. On top of this, the mystery plot was so engaging and had me guessing what would happen next!

An incredibly divine and elegant standalone book, The City of Stardust publishes in 25th Jan 2024.

Was this review helpful?

I recently finished off a bunch of books either just before I went on holiday or while I was away, so I'm only now getting round to actually posting reviews. Sometimes it's a good thing to put a book to one side after you read it, to see what really sticks with you, but unfortunately for The City of Stardust that delay has mostly left me trying to remember it at all. Not a good sign.

The basic premise of the book is that our protagonist is part of a family who suffer under a curse, where one from each generation is taken away and she's the only candidate to be the next in line. As a result, she (Violet) is left somewhat vulnerable when, on heading out into the real world to work for a living, a handsome stranger takes an interest in her. He is, of course, both a boy she'd met as a child who'd revealed the existence of magic and also the minion of the ageless power that exacts the family curse - Violet is given a limited time to find her mother and set things straight, leading to her travels around the world. This is one of those classic 'things below the surface' type of fantasy novels, with secret societies and nothing being quite what it seems.

All in all, it's not a bad book but it suffers from some very uneven pacing and also too strong a focus on the main characters. In comparison, the supporting cast are fairly two-dimensional and that just shows even more how invested the author is in the main (romantic) relationship between Violet and Aleksander.

In some ways, this story could have been better served as the backbone of a duology or trilogy, where it wouldn't have felt quite so rushed and time could have been taken to explore some of the other characters rather than just making them exist for the purpose of driving the plot onwards. It's also not marketed as YA but Violet in particular feels very young and that sensation doesn't go away even as she gains more experience of the world.

I received a free copy of this book from the publishers, via Netgalley. This is my honest review of the book in question.

Was this review helpful?

*Thank you to NetGalley and Hodder & Stoughton, Hodderscape for providing me with this book in exchange for an honest review*

This book was SO good that I couldn't believe how it must be only a debut. It was amazing, it was one of those books you want to read them again for the first time. Fast paste, awesome characters and a wonderful world-building. I was immersed in the first page. Loved it.

Was this review helpful?

If you like an urban fantasy story with a twist, of secrets and keys, of blood and sacrifice, then this is a must-read for you.

This book follows the struggles of a young woman, abandoned into the care of her Uncles by her Mother, who begins to search for a way to save her life and end a curse of their family that leaves the brightest in a generation to the clutches of a mysterious woman called Penelope.

Violet has to learn her way through the world, who to trust and who to flee from. It is a story of love, loss, heartbreak and betrayal. But at the heart of it, it is about a young woman finding out who she is, and how she wants to live her life, if she can live it.

A wonderful story, with a rich setting and engaging characters. A must-read.

Was this review helpful?

The Everly family has been cursed for centuries. Every generation, the mysterious Penelope takes the most talented and brightest Everly, and they are never seen again.

Marianne doesn’t want to accept her fate, so she runs. But this means that Penelope wants her daughter, Violet.

A deal gives Violet and her uncles 10 years to find Marianne. The City of Stardust follows Violet as she sets out to find her mother while time runs out. Along the way she meets friends, enemies and people she is not sure she can trust, explores new worlds, and learns more of her fate if she doesn’t succeed in time.

Let me get this straight first, this book is beautifully written, and it’s amazing how this is a debut. The pacing could have used some work though, and that is a shame.

I had the feeling we were nearing endgame multiple times while we still had 40, 30 or 15% to go. This gave the book such a slow pace it didn’t feel like ‘only’ 350 pages. It also made the ending of this book highly dissapointing.

The world and magic system is very interesting and well thought out, no one character is truly good or evil and the belief system in this book makes you want to learn more every time it comes into play.

If you love scavenger hunts in books and don’t mind a slow pace, this book is for sure one you should pick up. If not, like me, you might want to skip this one.

Was this review helpful?

I think this book has a potential.. but some of the things don’t sit right with me.
Violet Everly lives with her uncle, Ambrosse and Gabriel who always travel and come back only on occasions. Her mom left her in the care of her uncle for travellong the world. But little did she know that Everly’s family has been cursed until Penelope come to her house with Aleksander then she starts questioning her life. Why her mom left her? Why she can’t go outside like normal people?
The story intrigue me, but like i said after i finished it, i’m questioning the book itself. Like, how come her mom left her without telling her anything? She said she left to find a way to break the curse, but nothing in the story tell us where or how to break the curse. And in one of the scene, it tell us that her mom left just because she can’t find the answer for the curse, i was like : how come a mom can be so selfish? Another thing is that it doesn’t explain why it need to have Marianne’s blood or Violet’s. The curse took so many Everlys before, but the curse still stands. And i feel like some of the characters don’t have a significant roles. Like you don’t care whether they’re there or not.
In the end, i’d say that this book did not meet my expectation. Thanks NetGalley & Hodder for granting me this e-ARC in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

The author's writing style is absolutely enchanting - the comparisons to The Starless Sea are merited. Unfortunately, the lyrical style doesn't really suit the story. The plot might have worked if written as a fast-paced romantasy, but in a whimsical and drawn-out style it was simply confusing.

Was this review helpful?

Violet Everly is cursed. Her mother was cursed too, but she left when Violet was a child and ran far away to where the curse couldn’t reach her. Raised by her uncles, Violet knows nothing of this. Their plan is to find her mother and make her face the curse before Violet has to, at the same time hoping that their runaway sister might have found a way to break it. But Marianne Everly is nowhere to be found: not in this world or any others that they can search.

The initial premise of this book was hugely intriguing, although it did get a bit convoluted nearer the end. As Violet learns more about the history of the curse, it just opened up more and more questions for me. Many of these questions remain unanswered, although I do like the philosophic approach that Violet takes towards this at the end of the book. She achieves what she set out to do, even if it wasn’t in quite the way she expected and even if she doesn’t fully understand the ‘what’ and ‘how’ of it all.

I enjoyed learning about the magical world of Fidelis alongside Violet and found it interesting that most of this knowledge is gained without ever having stepped foot on Fidelis soil. Because of this the geography of the world itself is fuzzy. Instead Violet’s, and the reader’s, understanding of Fidelis is built around its people and its politics. She certainly meets some interesting people on her journey. Unfortunately many of these people get a frustratingly small amount of page time. For example, we never really find out how Ambrose makes his living and the small glimpses into Caspian’s life only left me wanting more. In contrast the characters of Violet and Aleksander have been crafted with painstaking detail, including the clear trauma that lives in each of them.

Overall this book made for an easy read; it kept me absorbed whilst reading, but didn’t require too much brain power to follow the thread of events.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

The City of Stardust was an enchanting story, filled with magic, fairy tales and doors leading to other wolds. The beautiful, lyrical writing style will captivate you from the start and you'll be swept away in this adventure. Follow Violet in her journey and discover places beyond this world.

“What else is a curse but this? Love, stretched and warped beyond all meaning.”

Between curses and ancient gods, The City of Stardust will enrapture you until the very end.

Was this review helpful?

**I received a pre-release copy of this book from Netgalley for an honest review**

The Everly family is cursed, and every generation their best, brightest, and most talents is taken by the mysterious woman Penelope. A woman who never ages, never forgets, and never forgives a debt. When Violets mother vanishes, the curse falls on her, unless she can break it first.

There is always that worry when you hear of a book with a really interesting premise, from an author that you don't know. Will they be able to live up to this idea, this potential?

The City of Stardust didn't disappoint. I absolutely loved this book.

There was beautiful imagery, and magical scenery, all tempered with a dark evil undercurrent. Characters had internal conflicts of interest; weighing up their ambition, their moral values, and their self-preservation. Which all made the world so much more believable.

I will definitely be keeping an eye out for more works written by this author.

Was this review helpful?

A really great and intriguing read. I loved the characters and the story. Will look out for more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

I honestly have no idea what to say about The City of Stardust . It's the first time in a while that I've been left so stunned by a book. I knew this would be a book that I would like, but I did not expect to enjoy it as much as I did. The worldbuilding in this was one of the most unique that I have read recently. It's a dark world, full of intrigue and mystery. And the way Georgia Summers writes about this world feels very immersive, almost as though you are there with Violet as she goes on a dangerous journey to find her mother and break a devastating curse. Summers' writing is really what made this book for me; it flowed perfectly and the pacing was impeccable.

At its heart, The City of Stardust is a story about family and about love; and Violet's determined journey to find her mother and break a devastating curse. Her character growth throughout the book is incredible and she is, by far, my favourite character in the book. I also quite like Aleksander and how we get to see him struggle with grasping with what he has been told through his whole life (with it all being a lie). Summers did a damn good job at showing this and that's another amazing thing about this book.

The City of Stardust ends in a way that feels like the closure of an important journey, and at the same time, it leaves you wanting more. I don't know if there will be another book set in this world, but if there is, I will definitely be reading it.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to like this one after the first couple of pages but sadly, the last part of the book put me off a little bit. I enjoyed the initial mystery and intrigue, the first meeting of the two protagonists and the concept of the reveurite/star-metal, but it lacked some serious worldbuilding to really pull me in. Overall, this book could have used some more pages to cement its' world and magic, to shed some more light on the different characters and their motives. The whole conflict was resolved rather abruptly and in a way that felt somewhat unsatisfying. The prose was great though! 'Whimsical' is the most fitting word for the lyrical writing style and I enjoyed it greatly!

Was this review helpful?

A stunning, magnificent fantasy. It was complex, mysterious, and brimming immense jeopardy via the Everly curse. Violet is a wonderful heroine, and Aleksander is great, even though, I personally was confused by the instantaneous romance between them. It’ is such a rich, world building story and I really hope there’s a follow up, Huge thanks to the publisher for this gorgeous ARC. P.S. This book contains my favourite villain and twist ever.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this novel. The villain is truly a villain and written expertly. The mystery surrounding her family curse is what made this story enticing and addictive. I thoroughly enjoyed it and will be recommending this to my students after summer. Perfect for autumn and winter reads!

Was this review helpful?

"The City of Stardust" by Georgia Summers sounds like an engaging fantasy novel with a unique blend of magic, politics, and romance. The concept of a hidden curse tied to the protagonist's lineage, along with the suspense of a looming deadline, adds an intriguing layer to the story. The slow burn romance and themes of betrayal and second chances promise to keep readers invested in the characters' journeys. Overall, it appears to be a promising read for those who enjoy fantasy tales with a mix of mystery and romance.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this book. The world created by Georgia Summers had echoes of The Night Circus for me, and it was a really immersive read. Violet Everly's mother has abandoned her, and now it falls to Violet to break the family curse. But this is much more than a story about a curse, it's a story about love, and about how far people are willing to go to get the things they think they want. I devoured it!

Was this review helpful?

This is a book about adventures, fairytales, dreaming of getting to be in other worlds, family, betrayal, and so much more.

Violets family is Cursed, and once every generation, one Everly is taken, and they disappear. Since her mother has disappeared, it's now Violet's turn. She either needs to find her mother or a way to stop the curse. This sends her on a journey she never could have expected.

I liked the book, and it was interesting to follow. At the same time, i wish more would be happening. The writing was a little bit confusing in the beginning, but once i got used to the style, it was easier.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book from start to finish. The title drew me in, the summary made me excited and then I couldn’t put the book down.
Fans of The Invisible Library, Genevieve Cogman and The Starless Sea, Erin Morgentern will fall in love with this book. It was all the right levels of whimsical with the added spice of deception, horror and adventure.

Was this review helpful?