This story continues where Leaving Lancaster ends. It follows Esther and Holly as they continue to discern if they will remain in Lancaster. Esther has been asked to enter a courting relationship with her next door neighbor who is a widower of 15 years. Nathaniel's wife left him and is rumored to have committed suicide. Holly is being pursued by three different men. Zach the area's veterinarian. Aaron, Nathaniel's younger brother. Larry a business man from Seattle. She has to make the decision whether she will return to Seattle or become Amish. Will she leave behind her cell phone and computer?