Beautiful and heartbreaking, this book just blew me away! Erin Hahn writes a charming standalone YA book. Even if it Breaks Your Heart delves into loss and heartbreak in the most beautiful ways. This is a book I would recommend to any teenager who is experiencing their first bouts of loss or depression. I’m completely stunned by how much this book affected me. Winnie and Case are both dealing with loss but build a beautiful friendship that leads to young love. This has been my favorite Erin Hahn book so far and I can’t rave about it it enough.


Thank you to #Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Erin Hahn's YA vs. adult romances, obviously, vary quite a bit but are equally full of compelling language, stories with a heart and a downright adorable love story. And Even if It Breaks Your Heart fits right into that -- so perfectly. This opposites-attract romance, told in dual points of view, just draws me in and ends up reading quite quickly. Plus, Case and Winnie are like sickeningly sweet in love, I will admit. Succinctly put, this book is for the horse girlies IYKYK.

Even If It Breaks Your Heart by Erin Hahn is a wonderful, heartfelt YA novel about friendship, grief and love. I loved the character development for both Case and Winnie, it felt like they were completely different people by the end but in the best way! It was a sweet take on a cowboy romance where the FMC might be more of a cowboy than the MMC🤣🙌The story focused a lot on dealing with grief, building friendships and working through with real life challenges in a way that was very relatable and easy to fall into. It covers some pretty heavy emotions for youth but I think they were so well articulated and balanced out with a great HEA that I highly recommend this book!

ARC was provided by publisher via Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Oh this tugged on my heartstrings something fierce! At first, I had my doubts about Case. No way was Winnie going to have anything to do with him! But, then things were happening. Growth was happening. Change. And with each page I fell a little more in love with Case, with him and with his situation. And Winnie! I'm a sucker for the big sister who sacrifices for her family. I was cheering for her the whole way!

This was a great book. It's targeted towards YA but this adult was 100% pleased.

I think this is my favorite Erin Hahn book. I remember seeing her post on social media about the sad rodeo book and wow. Even better than I imagined. So good. 5 stars as always.

I loved the story, the world building and meeting the different characters. I felt completely immersed in the story and couldn't stop reading it.

This is hands down the best book Erin Hahn has written to date. Set in Texas on a horse ranch, it follows the lives of Case Michaels and Winnie Sutton. On the surface they have nothing in common. Case is the son of the ranch owner. Winnie is the girl who mucks the stalls and leads trail rides, all while trying to keep her siblings in line since her mom left and her dad is working or hanging out at the VFW. While Case seems like the privileged son who doesn't want for anything, deep down he's a mess. His best friend, Walker, died and Case has been lost ever since.

Hahn does a marvelous job of making these characters come to life. They feel like real teenagers - acting like kids one minute and adults the next. Their interactions with each other are sweet, but not saccharine. And the glimpse into the horse world is spot on! Never once does Hahn rely on manufactured drama for drama's sake. It's a beautiful story about two people figuring out who they are to the world and to each other, while experiencing grief and growing up.

Thank you to netgalley for the ARC!

Cute cowboy romance with a coming of age story. No steamy sex scenes. Some family drama but nothing too over the top. Quick read

Hahn is just an absolute expert at her craft. Her books are so atmospheric. They really sink you into a place where you feel the realities of this fictional text in such real ways. I adored Winnie and Case. Their journey toward each other was slow and sweet and paid off so well.

Erin Hahn's YA books are a breath of fresh air. Hard hitting and emotional, while also being relatable and fun. I recommend for anyone who enjoys YA, as Hahn has a great voice and characters.

After reading and loving Erin Hahn's adult titles I was excited to get my hands on her upcoming YA Romance release, 𝐄𝐯𝐞𝐧 𝐈𝐟 𝐈𝐭 𝐁𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐤𝐬 𝐘𝐨𝐮𝐫 𝐇𝐞𝐚𝐫𝐭 (PUB 01.01) It was just as wonderful as I'd hoped it would be. Thank you @wednesdaybooks

I swear I saw the author refer to this as her "sad rodeo, sad cowboy" book and that is spot on. Don't fret- while hard earned, the HEA is worth the trip. Both of the main characters, Chase and Winnie, are dealing with loss and heartache. There is a heft to their story. As they work towards unpacking some emotional baggage their relationship slowly grows from genuine friendship to more. It's been a long time since I was a teenager but it felt very emotional and authentic to me.

MORE: -Sweet slow burn. Closed door.- Case and Winnie are both post high school (18/19 yrs old)- Horses, rodeos, barrel racing

This is the story of two lost young adults dealing with very adult things.

Winnie has to keep it together and take care of her family while Case is trying to just survive day by day after loosing his best friend. As fate would have it Case and Winnie find each other at the right moment. That's all I'm going to say about the book because I don't want to spoil it and I think it's definitely worth the read.

This book flew by so fast I read it in a day. The writing was good enough that I could feel the atmosphere of the book and picture it as a film straight away. I loved the ranch/ cowboy vibes.

Case and Winnie's romance is slow burn, sweet and just perfect.

Erin Hahn did a good job of developing her characters and having them find their way and discover their true selves (in a wholesome, fulfilling kind of way)

The writing was a little too YA for me but overall I liked this book very much!
3.5 stars rounding up to 4!

Thank you to St. Martin's Press and #NetGAlley for the ARC. My opinions are my own.
Even If It Breaks Your Heart is out on 2/06/2024

Clean YA romance is here! This was a very different type of romance, where the main characters were both going through the stages of grief in their own way. Case was a wonderful view of how no matter your financial circumstances, grief will rear its ugly head and make you rethink how you live your life. Winnie, on the other hand, was in survival mode for so long, it was hard for her to understand that she could ask for help and truly pursue her dreams. Erin did a wonderful job of showing the rodeo industry, and the reader can truly imagine the world through the character's eyes. This book also shows that you never truly know what someone is going through so it's always better to be kind.

My Thoughts
A beautifully poignant tale about dealing with family, friendships, grief, loss, growing up too soon and so much more it is a long laundry list you have to experience for yourself along with Case and Winnie as they go through it within this story.

More than just for the young adult crowd of readers this slow burn modern day romance takes readers on a journey they will not soon forget and introduces them to the world of Rodeo competition along the way.

Both Case and Winnie come from stereotypical rich boy/poor girl backgrounds but what they find in common far outweighs their different life circumstances.

No major drama ensues which was a huge bonus for me and the friends to lovers’ romance evolved naturally between our MC’s.

Dual POV allowed equal opportunity to get to know both Case and Winnie, and in my case to also fall in love with a horse.

Queen Mab may have four legs but she <i>speaks</i> to my childhood preference to spend more time with my horse than with people.

Plus, her ability as a barrel horse in competitive barrel racing with Winnie as her partner/rider is a magnificent fictional pairing.

As for this books’ actual message, the title says it all.
[EArc from Netgalley]
On every book read as soon as it is done and written up for review it is posted on Goodreads and Netgalley, once released then posted on Amazon, Barnes and Nobles as well.

I read 2 Erin Hahn books in a row that are releasing soon, and they both were amazing. This book had so much going on, but so much to love. The characters were everything and I even enjoyed learning more about rodeo. I highly recommend this!

Nobody does YA romance quite like Erin Hahn. Her chokehold on wayward, misunderstood, hurting but intensely sweet, charming young men is staggering, and Case Micheals did not disappoint. He feels so real, so fully fleshed out that I could reach out and hug him. Which is pretty much what I wanted to do to that poor, grieving bull rider throughout the entire book. And Winnie is the perfect take no BS, Fiona Gallagher, "Look I'm really busy with REAL WORLD SHIT," horse girl, and she must be protected at all costs.

Even If It Breaks Your Heart is a beautiful, brilliant reimagining of a friends to lovers story. Hahn wasn't telling lies either, this story will break your heart, but only so it can put it back together again in the most touching, heartfelt, unflinching way. I loved every second of this story, and I can't thank the author, NetGalley, and St Martin's Press enough for this advanced copy.

As always I love Erin Hahns books. She has a great way of capturing what it's like to be a young person that's trying to deal with life.

Case is trying to live his life after losing his best friend and Winnie is trying to be a leader for her family. They need each other to help see where they're future leads. Though you may not have personally gone through what the MC's are dealing with, Hahn is able to express their emotions in a way that helps you understand and cheer for them. I couldn't help but think about Case and Winnie when I wasn't reading. I would love to see where their life leads.

This book is perfect for YA Contemporary lovers and you don't even have to be into rodeos. Thought it made me want to go horseback riding.

Even if it Breaks Your Heart is Erin Hahn’s magnum opus. A beautiful study in grief and longing, her teenage characters fight to find their way out of the darkness- one spiraling after losing his friend, the other scrambling to keep her family together despite her parent’s neglect- and their pain and frustration is viscerally palpable.

There’s a fury and immediacy in Hahn’s writing, every line gorgeous and heartbreakingly beautiful, as if she’s grabbing the reader by the collar and telling them to pay attention to these kids. As if she’s demanding we take time to listen to an entire generation of teenagers traumatized by violence, and disease, and loss.

But it isn’t how honest, or sad, or visceral this book is that makes it great, though it is all of those things. What makes this novel truly gorgeous is that flickering beneath the grief and trauma, there is an ever-growing ember of hope. Despite impossible circumstances, these two beautifully complicated and flawed teenagers stumble and scrape and fight to give the people they love a better life, even if they believe they should sacrifice their own potential happiness to do so. What ultimately unfolds is a story of grace and healing, as Hahn shows her characters, and her readers, that hope isn’t only possible, it’s necessary, and that while happily ever afters might be for fairytales, there is light in the darkness, even if we can’t see it yet, and joy and peace can be found with the people we love and the families we make.

3.5 stars rounded up to 4 stars.

Even If It Breaks Your Heart by Erin Hahn is a contemporary young adult book about Winnie Sutton, a girl who just graduated from high school is working to take care of her siblings and keep her family together. When she meets Case Michaels, the wealthy and famous rodeo star, it seems like they have nothing in common at all. But as they get to know each other, they find a connection that helps them both to find their way.

This was a cute and fun read! I did not know anything about rodeo before reading this book, so it was interesting to learn more about that world. It's a slow burn/slow build kind of story and maybe it was a little too slow for me at times. I wanted more to happen, and I wanted a little more interaction between Case and Winnie.

But overall, it was an enjoyable story and one that I would recommend if you like this genre!

This book was sweet, the cowboy backdrop was fun, and it explored more somber emotions like grief and recovery relatively well. It felt very YA - and it is! so I can't fault it for that, but it's worth noting. Some YA books have younger characters but a wider appeal, and some YA books seem to be fairly exclusively for a younger readership, and I felt that this was the latter.

I found the plot a little stilted, probably at least in part due to the dual POV. I felt that I didn't really gain much from a second POV and it prevented significant plot development as we were constantly rehashing the same events twice. I'd maybe have preferred it to have leaned more into being character driven to make all the POVs worth it, or remain slightly more plot focused and drop the second POV.

Overall a quick and entertaining read, but nothing particularly memorable or moving for me.