Member Reviews

I am so in love with this beautiful queernormative world that Jasmine Skye has crafted. Daughter of the Bone Forest is an epic fantasy full of politics, high stakes, complex characters, secrets, and betrayals with a gorgeous magic system. The main romance toes the line between enemies and lovers extremely well without it being overdone. The diversity and representation are super well done without them ever feeling forced. I only have good things to say about Daughter of the Bone Forest and I absolutely cannot wait for the next installment.

Was this review helpful?

Daughter of the Bone Forest by Jasmine Skye. Thank you, Macmillian Children’s Publishing Group and NetGalley for allowing me the chance to read this page gripping story.

I really loved this! From the start of the book I was pulled in by bone, magic, ice, etc. The characters were built s well that I understood their choices in the book and could sympathize with them. I soon found myself invested in their story and there were a few times I cried while reading.

Rosemund was by far my favorite character. Despite the challenges she faced or how her life changed, she stayed true to who she was. Too often characters change in the face of danger and allow it to impact who they are and what they stand for...not Rosemund.

I truly love this book and I hope to read more from the author in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book and need the sequel like yesterday! (seriously the plot twist at the end got me and I need to know more!) This book is set in a world where witches exist and have magic, and bond with human familiars that can shift into different types of animals. The story mainly follows Rosy, a familiar who can shift into bone animals, on her journey to save her grandmother. When Rosy saves Princess Shaw at the beginning of the story, she is taken to Witch Hall, a school for witches and familiars to learn and prepare for the impending war, where she must hide just how powerful she really is.

While the book was a little slow at the beginning, with having to settle into the world and figuring out how the system of witches and familiars worked, the book moved at a pretty fast pace after that. I couldn’t put it down! The school politics were interesting, especially seeing how Rosy defied the social “rules” and her sort-of-fake courtship with Shaw was great. I loved seeing their relationship develop over the course of the story. Though it’s an extremely slow burn (we don’t really see much romance between them in this book), we get to see Rosy become more and more comfortable with Shaw, despite not always agreeing with her.

Another major highlight of this book was all of the casual representation. The author stated it’s a queer-normative world, and that is definitely apparent. There are relationship pairings of all kinds (m/m, f/f, m/f), along with trans, nonbinary, and genderfluid characters. All of this is treated as normal and is simply a casual part of the story and who the characters are. I also loved how different kinds of relationships were emphasized, not just romantic ones. The friendships and other platonic relationships in this story were great.

If you enjoy fantasy stories with magic, politics, secrets and betrayals, and representation galore, definitely check out this book!

Was this review helpful?

Daughter of the Bone Forest follows Rosamund, a shapeshifter who only wishes to care for her imprisoned grandmother and the horses her family raises. By happenstance (or by nudging done by a friend with foresight) Rosamund meets Princess Shaw, saving her and her friends from an animal attack. To repay her, Shaw brings Rosamund to Witch Hall, a school for witches and familiars to learn how to control their magic and shifts. It's the last thing Rosamund wants, but she will do anything to help her grandmother and this may be the only way.

I really enjoyed this, even more than I thought I would. First and foremost because nearly every sapphic book I've read that claims to include horses only includes them at bare minimum. This book includes horses in many ways, from the ranch that Rosamund's family owns to her assignment working the stables at Witch Hall. Not to mention Rosamund's own shifter ability to turn into a horse (every horse girl's dream, or mine anyway).

Rosamund really sticks to her guns throughout the entire book, I feel like characters in this situation often change their points of view quickly. Rosamund was committed to keeping on the down low (admittedly not well, but the intent was there) and trying to find a way to help her grandmother be free of her imprisonment.

There was inclusion of a variety of gender identities and sexualities that were naturally included. This book also does not end with a romantic ending and I am so excited to see how it progresses through the rest of the series.

Thank you to NetGalley for making this available in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Rosy is a bone familiar, which means she has the power to shift into animals marked with exposed bone. We first get a feel of her shifting abilities as a wolf, and the magic and lore behind it are fascinating. Admittedly, I wasn't sure how to feel about her being able to shift. I usually don't gravitate towards books where characters are shifters, so this was a new experience for me. Rosy was still an interesting character to follow, nonetheless. I loved how caring she was of her grandma, and how in touch she was with her magic and the Forest itself. While others mainly viewed the Forest as untamed, it was home for Rosy.

Though this book is told through two POVs, I much preferred Rosy's to Shaw's. I couldn't connect to Shaw at all, which made their moments together lackluster to me. I also didn't enjoy how there was a shift in their chapters where Rosy's were in first person while Shaw's were in third. It just felt confusing to me and brought me out of the book. Usually, when I read dual POV books, they are both in 1st-person or both in 3rd-person, and it took a while for me to get used to it. I usually enjoy 3rd-person more, but I felt like this book would have worked better if it were all in 1st-person.

The magic system and worldbuilding were captivating. I loved the idea of a farm setting and a magic school setting in one book. I also loved how much animals were involved and brought up because I love it when fantasy books include them as companions or just for appreciation.

Was this review helpful?

This epic lgbtqia fantasy is absolutely everything I wanted! The descriptions, the politics, the characters, and the representation are incredible.

Rosy is a shifter who winds up going to a very prestigious school. For Rosy, this is a different experience than what she is used to, tending horses with her grandmother. With this huge change, Rosy finds herself even getting attention from the princess. This story takes some interesting twists and turns that leave me anticipating the next book bc yes (!!!!) This is a series!!!

I'm so excited about this one and recommend it.

Out February 27, 2024!

Thank you, Netgalley and Publisher, for this Arc!

Was this review helpful?

I read an eARC of Daughter of the Bone Forest by Jasmine Skye. Thank you, Macmillian Children’s Publishing Group and NetGalley.

I am so glad I read this. I was starting to wonder if I was resenting all the ebooks I was reading because I just didn’t want to be forced to read them. But this book changed my mind.

Not that this book was perfect. There were a few pacing issues, and it felt like some parts weren’t given enough time to really get into the emotions or even explore the politics of the moment.

But overall, the story was really fun. I liked the main characters, and the “villains” of the story were dynamic and angering in just the right place.

I definitely am looking forward to the sequel!

Was this review helpful?

I’d like to start this review off by thanking NetGalley and the publisher for access to this eARC. I received it in exchange for an honest review.

Now that that’s out of the way, this will probably be a short review. I DNF’d this book at 47%.

From the beginning, it never really grabbed me. I liked the magic well enough but I just didn’t care much for the characters. I liked that this society is queer normative . There was no homophobia and that was amazing. It didn’t matter the gender of a person’s partner. Just their social status.

The main character has a cousin of color (weird way to describe her but I’m not sure I can call her Black or any other brown race. She has dark skin, somewhat curly hair. So yeah, cousin of color).

I liked the way the society was built. That the Queen or King’s familiar would also be a King or Queen. It was an interesting twist on the way a King or Queen’s partner is usually seen. Sure they get a title but all the power tends to only be with one of them, not both.

The writing was competent enough. It wasn’t awful but nothing pulled me in. I was a bit bored, even with something interesting was happening. I tried changing the time of day I read, reading in small bursts to leave myself wanting more. Nothing really helped.

But the biggest reason I DNF’d is because of the romance. It’s supposed to be a sweet fake dating situation. I saw other reviews calling it a sweet romance.

No.

Here’s the thing. Shaw, the princess gets Rosamunde, the familiar she’s interested in, to agree to a FAKE courtship. That’s important. Fake.

Shaw then decides to go back on it. Thinking to herself that she wanted Rosamunde “entranced enough by it [her society and station in it] that she wouldn’t realize the courtship was real until it was too late.”

Direct quote.

That’s disgusting to me. This girl agreed to fake date. And yes, I know fake dating leads to real emotions. I’ve read my fare share of fake dating romances. It’s one thing when they both agree to a fake relationship and start falling for each other as time goes on.

It’s another thing entirely when the rules are set, a fake relationship, and one of them decides to manipulate the other into a position that they can’t get out of.

Shaw knows that Rosamunde does NOT want to be in a relationship with her. She’s doing this fake relationship out of necessity. It isn’t something she wants. And Shaw is aware of that. The girl literally told her to her face. Shaw even has a girl who can see the future in some capacity, still not sure how, who tells her that Rosamunde isn’t into her.

And tells Shaw that she’s only interested in her because the girl tells her no. And Shaw calls it “playing hard to get”.

This would be disgusting if adults did it. It would be disgusting if it was a heterosexual couple or any flavor of queer couple.

When I read this is made me squirm. A relationship that starts on disrespecting someone’s boundaries “this is a fake relationship” cannot be one that is healthy in the end.

So that’s why I DNF’d this book. If I had to give it a review, I’d give it a 2 for solid writing ability and that’s all.

Was this review helpful?

A sprawling fantasy with unique worldbuilding and a queernorm cast makes DAUGHTER OF THE BONE FOREST a book to remember.

Was this review helpful?

Daughter of the Bone Forest is a stunning debut. This queer normative bone and transformation magic story is my latest obsession. Let's just begin the emotional roller coaster of my love. Firstly, I loved how the forest is almost like it's own sentient character. The secrets, motivations, and darkness it hides. From the beginning, Rosy only agrees to go to the school to find a cure for her grandmother and to never be dragged into the war which ended in her grandmother's feral state and her grandfather's death. But we all know how intentions end.

What ends up ensuing in Daughter of the Bone Forest is a story about coming into our own power. About the ways royalty and nobility might use our powers as fodder, but also the very real people, friends, and loved ones who are lost in the crossfire. This dual POV story is about what we will do with our power. How much we will witness without saying a word.

Was this review helpful?

“We’ll need it, for what is to come.” OKAYYY I was absolutely shocked by this book, I loved the dialogue and action. I felt as if I were watching this through a movie, and since it’s been freezing outside it’s very topical to temperature. I loved the characters and the way they stayed together!

Was this review helpful?

this book was such an absolute delight. I'm not gonna lie, once I saw it was queer I requested it from NetGalley just bc of the cover, and I really went in knowing next to nothing about this title or the author. I was so pleased when I ended up genuinely loving it!


are you looking for...
- a magic school setting with minimal classwork?
- an mc who can shapeshift into a plethora of different animals?
- a whole cast of folks who can shapeshift into all sorts of cool critters??
- a gentle, non-specific sort of worldbuilding you can just relax into?
- lots of horses?
- the kind of political intrigue that's just big explosions in the bg?
then try this book! ✨


Daughter of the Bone Forest follows Rosy, a young bone familiar who is long-used to hiding the extent of her natural abilities. she's declined going to Witch Hall (aka magic boarding school) for years, and she's largely happy living with her extended family on their well-established bone horse ranch. she especially loves taking care of her grandma, who lives in the Forest (capital F required) unwillingly.

you see, many years ago, grandpa died in an ,,, avalanche. kinda. grandma naturally found this whole thing wildly suspicious and ended up trying to jump her late husband's controlling officer, called a thane. when she's pried off him, she's sentenced to life in the Forest bc she went quote, mad with grief. (I guess this was considered a somewhat generous sentencing by the witches, in repayment for grandma and grandpa's exceptional military service.)

that being said! the military is still hard-pressed to find wolf familiars, as they are by far some of the best fighters, and are not above forcefully conscripting people. life in the Cursed Kingdom is pretty wilding since it seems like a huge majority of the world outside hates magic-users, and there's constant rumblings of war and spooky foreshadowing of widespread death.

Rosy doesn't want to fight in a war. Rosy kinda lowkey hates the Witch King, as he was involved in her grandma's sentencing, and she kinda highkey hates everybody who is rich and/or hoity-toity bc they treat her and her family like garbage. this is all very valid imho. Rosy is a natural bone wolf familiar (as in, the first time she shifted it was to a bone wolf) but she's never told anyone apart from her grandma. she's determined to keep her head down, keep her grandma and family safe, and avoid the looming war at all costs.

unfortunately, Princess Shaw Colchuk, daughter of the Witch King, heir apparent to the Cursed Throne, stops by Rosy's hometown on her way back to Witch Hall. Rosy ends up kind of accidentally saving her (she inadvertently saves Shaw by saving her cousin, Toketie "Tokey") and Shaw clocks how skilled of a shifter Rosy is. she personally invites Rosy to Witch Hall, even offering to pay for her attendance, and Rosy ends up begrudgingly agreeing to go. she's got high hopes that she can get her sticky fingers on this new medicine that's being experimented with that can recall familiars from going 'feral', which is a problem her grandma Struggles with.

Shaw, meanwhile, is intrigued by Rosy's standoffish nature and general disinclination to kiss her ass. (this is one of my favorite couple dynamics, I'm not gonna lie.) there's a witch-familiar bond that improves the magic abilities of both parties involved that everybody and their dog is trying to get in on, and Shaw ends up with her eye on Rosy for that. this school year promises to be an exciting one for poor Rosy lol.


I really loved the characters in this book! all of Rosy's enormous family, Shaw's high-class and infallibly loyal entourage, the colorful cast that makes up Witch Hall's professors and students; they were a delight. the magic system is new and interesting without being needlessly complicated, and is even helpfully color-coded for folks who aren't looking for a high fantasy romp lol. I think I'll be recommending this book pretty broadly to any reader who has even a passing interest in YA fantasy.


rep - sapphic mc, sapphic love interest, trans sc, achillean scs, nonbinary (they/them) sc, misc queer scs
thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc ✨

Was this review helpful?

What an awesome queer-normative fantasy debut. The stakes are higher than ever as war looms ever closer and two girls (Rosy and Shaw) are thrown into a dangerous courtship (one that has been prophesied and fated). I really enjoyed the writing style that this author has--it was really accessible and compelling. I love a grumpy/sunshine fated love story, and when you add a creepy forest? I'm immediately sold, take my money. The magic system was unique and fun, and getting to watch the characters interact with it and the world at large made for such a fun story. I can't believe I got cliffhanger'd at the end there because I absolutely need the next book immediately.

Was this review helpful?

Two girls reluctantly bound by fate must weather a dangerous courtship as a prophesied war grows ever closer in Jasmine Skye's high-stakes, queer-normative dark fantasy debut, Daughter of the Bone Forest.

Beautiful and haunting. Loved the prose, the world-building, and the characters. Gorgeous!

Was this review helpful?

It is 4am and I should have been asleep hours ago. Daughter of the Bone Forest had me in a chokehold and I could not put it down. Fifty-two hours into the new year and I’ve read the book all other books are going to be compared to.

From the first page, I was hooked. I love creepy, sentient forests, and this book DELIVERS.

The magic system is so unique and even though Rosy literally delivers a class presentation on bone magic, it never feels info dumpy.

Rosy is prickly and defensive and has her thorny shields up so high it’s a wonder she hasn’t poked out her own eye with them. And Shaw? Shaw the badass terrifying bone witch princess? She is the golden retriever girlfriend. She is smitten. She’s going to tell you that she’s totally a serious person and this just makes sense. But she took one look at the snarling feral grump Rosy and went “yes, this one.”

Five million stars. It would have been six million, but I’m mad about the cliffhanger.

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Feiwel & Friends for the ARC. I’m so glad I didn’t have to wait until next month to read this!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this one! I loved the magic system, which was unique and interesting, and I enjoyed the magic school setting. There was much less romance than I was expecting (which was fine by me). I liked how queerness was normalized in this world, though sometimes I felt that the author over-explained it instead of just letting it exist. Because this is a YA book, I understand that choice somewhat because it might be the first time some teens encounter people who are gender fluid, but it still sometimes felt clunky.

In the last couple chapters, some of Rosy’s decisions didn’t always make sense to me. I also would’ve liked to see more of the world’s politics, but it seems like we will get a lot more of that in book 2. Overall it was a strong debut and I’m interested to read more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

Daughter of the Bone Forest is a strongly crafted world of magic and hierarchy that bends and breaks all of its habitants. Rosy has had to hide her true power in the Bone Forest not just for safety but everyone she loves. A chance of fate brings her to the attention of Death’s heir, Shaw, and everything Rosy has know is changed.

Was this review helpful?

Why did the book have to end?! I was not ready for it to end! I want the sequel now!
What is the story that the ghost of Pops/General Holt has to tell Shaw? I think I have an idea of what scheme he uncovered and the motivation behind it; though I will have to wait for the sequel to know for sure.

The story is very intricate and clever. The concept of four types of magical abilities, and with each type at its strongest during the most consequential day of the season - Beltane, Samhain, etc. -- is not a new one. Nor is the concept of witches and familiars bonding together. However, the author has taken these concepts and crafted them in a way that feels unique. The major characters are great, even those cast in more of a "villain" role. I enjoyed Rosamund's unconventional nature and how her words and actions imbue some characters with greater confidence (Oluk) and force other characters to reconsider their prejudices and assumptions, especially about those who come from lesser circumstances. Also, for all her fear and anger, and how it forces her to hide much of herself from others, there are also a playfulness and joy to Rosamund when she shifts into animals, especially a new animal for the first time. I also like the way that the author handles gender -- there are characters who are clearly male and clearly female, but also characters who are gender fluid or who are transgender -- and it is what it is, a non-issue.

Was this review helpful?

Rosy is a bone familiar, able to shift into different animals, something she's been hiding to avoid conscription in the army and having to bond with a bone witch. When her secret is partially revealed, she's thrown into the world of Witch Hall, learning to control her powers but also navigate a web of political intrigue as her fate becomes tangled up with Princess Shaw.

I absolutely devoured this. This is a fabulous example of queer YA fantasy. The queer-normative society is a breath of fresh air - there's queer folks of all types and ages, including nonbinary, trans, and genderfluid representation. The author was clearly intentional about having diverse characters and went about it in a really thoughtful way.

The fantasy elements were a great mix of familiar and new - it was a fun twist on the classic magic school and prophesied war. The witch-familiar relationships and different branches of magic were clever, interesting, and well-developed. I loved that the four elements here were bone, glass, flowers, and ice and the unexpected ways that those powers manifested.

The romance was also so well done - the tension between Rosy and Shaw had me kicking my feet and giggling out loud at times. Rosy's prickly and headstrong nature meshes so well with Shaw's steadiness, but their disparate feelings about war - one who's been raised knowing that it's her destiny, one who's been raised seeing the devastating consequences - threaten to tear them apart despite their undeniable chemistry and bond.

But in the midst of all this, there's also some great humor and light moments. I'd reread this book again purely for the scene where she shifts into a raccoon to claw the face off of a jerk because like... same. Wish that was me. Also, there's a horse with An Attitude Problem who's nicknamed Cow and I love her. And it ends on a cliffhanger.... so this is me impatiently tapping my feet because I cannot WAIT for the sequel! I'll read it the second it comes out.

Strongly recommend to any queer YA fantasy fans, especially if you like political intrigue, horse girls, feral raccoon vibes, a smidgen of fake dating with a side of magical bonding, and sapphic witches. A fabulous debut by Jasmine Skye.

Was this review helpful?

OMFG!!! This book is what every LGBTQ+ YA Fantasy reader is looking for!! This series follows the two main characters who identify as women, Rosy and Shaw. A child of a simple horse rancher and a princess bound by fate to save their country. Rosy is a powerful and gifted bone familiar. Rosy spends most her days tending to the horses and spending time with her exiled grandma in the Bone Forest. This peaceful routine and life is interrupted by a visit to their town by none other than Princess Shaw. The Princess’s visit was anything less than eventful and Rosy was forced to save her life. As Rosy’s reward Shaw offered Rosy free tuition to the Witch Hall. The Witch Hall is the most prestigious school in the Cursed Kingdom , it is where the upper class Witches and Familiars attend to train and ultimately prepare for service to their country. Within Witch Hall, Rosy faced political games and a fake courtship with Death’s Heir. Rosy is faced with the impending change of who she once was and who she is becoming and what that means for her future and ultimately her destiny.

This book was slow to start but was 10/10. The tropes were so well written and I felt that the yearning for each other was done perfectly. This books has:
-LGBTQ+ representation
-forced proximity
-fated bonded pair
-fake relationship
-secrets/betrayal
-political maneuverings
-SUPER unique magic system
-prophecies

The normalization of LGBTQ+ that Skye created in this world was utter perfection. It flowed perfectly. There were characters who were they/them and the conversation about pronouns was so effortless. I struggle to find the right representation in fantasy that doesn’t feel like forced diversity. This is up there with The Hollow Star Saga. The only downside of this book is that is it sort of ends in a cliffhanger which I hate. But I will 100% be reading the next book!!

I want to thank MacMillan Children’s Publishing Group- Fiewel & Friends and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?