Member Reviews

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: None

This was a cute clean romance novel. Sadie is having the worst year ever and as a result of a magical wish wakes up on January 1st but the year before! She has a chance to fix everything she did wrong including her ex that left her. But then there’s Jacob. Her brothers best friend who she was living with during her worst year. They kissed on NYE and she can’t get him out of her head. Sadie is conflicted between trying to right the wrong of the past and live her perfect dream life or realize she is missing out on amazing love story with Jacob. I enjoyed how the book went through the important moments of Sadie’s very bad year. The year went by at a good pace and we saw her grow as a person and learn some valuable life lessons she missed the first time around. I would have loved to see more romance between her and Jacob as well as watching her find herself and her place in the world. I was not a fan of major sexism and feminism that was written into the book but that’s just me. I took off a star for that and no spice at all but otherwise it was a lovely book!

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
This was such a cute novel about a woman named Sadie. On New Year’s Eve, she reflects on her horrible year- she and her boyfriend broke up, she lost her job as a pastry chef, she was living with her brother’s friend, and was working at a local coffee shop. At a NYE party, she comes across a fortune teller who lets her redo the last year as if it never happened. (Also, she kisses her brother’s friend/roommate at midnight). When Sadie wakes up, she remembers the last year, but it is starting over. The novel takes us through the months of the second chance year and compares what did or did not change.
I loved this story! I thought it was well-paced and was a unique storyline. The writing would occasionally be vague and some parts felt breezed over. Overall, I enjoyed this novel and the resolution at the end.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an advanced copy of The Second Chance Year. All views and thoughts are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This is the 5 star romance read I have been WAITING ON!! Massive thank you to NetGalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

For starters.. I was SO excited about the groundhog day concept... and I absolutely ATE THIS BOOK UP! I love how the writer jumped right into the story at the beginning, and we were given just enough information early on to connect with the FMC on not only WHY they wanted to have a do over year, but also how the do over year came to fruition. You follow Sadie who dreams of one day opening her own bakery, but things don't exactly go as she planned. She lost her job and her relationship and she would do anything to get a second chance at her really bad year... when she runs into a fortune teller on New Years Eve, her wish comes true. Reading as this "do over year" unfolded... The pacing was immaculate! Even though the book took place in the span of a year, it never dragged or got stuck in one moment in time too long. There was never any info dumping that muddied out the story. The characters were written in such a way that it was so easy to connect with them fast and I was actually able to visualize the story as I was reading. I think the concept worked so well and was beautifully written. It really put into perspective how one decision can change the course of your life. Should you conform yourself to the version of you that others think you should be to keep the peace, or is it better to follow your heart and be the version of you that you feel most comfortable and confident in? Would a second chance give you a better result, or is it true that what is meant to be, will be? If you're looking for a heartwarming story with romance, some found family, and a FMC who breaks the mold and learns to embrace herself and her journey, this is the one for you!

Was this review helpful?

A clown, a fortune teller and a pastry chef walk into a party...

Sadie (said pastry chef) has had a terrible, horrible, no good year. A lost job, lost love, and lost apartment have kicked a girl when she's down! But when faced with a cosmic do-over, will Sadie rise to the occasion and land on her feet like a perfectly executed macaron, or will she crumble and fall flatter than a gingerbread house in an earthquake?

I love baking and romance so this read was a no brainer for me! I enjoyed the time travel aspect to the book, and found the treatment of workplace harassment handled sensitively. In this book, the story was about Sadie and her journey of knowing and loving herself, as well as being able to shift focus from herself to others. While romance was there, it was not the only main focus of the novel. Baking references abounded which I thoroughly enjoyed!

There were a few instances of plot points not making sense that really pulled me out of the story. One example: the MC has to go help with something on her day off because she says it can't be made ahead of time. Then she proceeds to make the same item ahead of time for a different event...? Plus the phrase "Very Bad Year" was a bit overused.

All in all a fun read, that I would recommend! 3.5 stars, rounded up to 4!

My thanks to NetGalley and Forever for the chance to read this book. All opinions here are strictly my own.

Was this review helpful?

Sadie is having a bad year she lost her job, her boyfriend and her apartment. She is crashing with her brother's best friend. Her parents kind of suck. They reminded me of Ross & Monica where Ross can do no wrong and Monica can do no right. The same with Sadie and Owen. She meets a fortune teller and wishes for a redo of last year.

This book was so good. I could not put the book down. It sucked me in and I finished it the same day. I love when books just flow so well. The writing is fantastic. I loved the characters and the premise. We all wonder what would happen if we got a redo.

Was this review helpful?

When Sadie asked for a do-over, she got more than she bargained for. The chance at a re-do always sounds good, but is it always. This book shows that second chances aren't always for the best. This book posed some questions about the road not taken and sexism in the workplace. It was a quick, interesting, and fun read. I love that she got a second chance, but I also loved how it turned out in the end.

Was this review helpful?

I typically shy away from contemporary romances unless I'm pulled in by the storyline and this book delivered. I enjoyed the character development of Sadie and how she goes from wanting to the course of her decisions to finally accepting that she will never fit into any other person's ideal image of her. The friends-to-lovers arc was fun to read and Jacob is adorable. Weisner does a fantastic job of laying out the plot in a cohesive manner and the pacing never lagged. I would read more from this author!

Was this review helpful?

DNF. I really liked the premise but the writing did not work for me at all. It wouldn't be fair to the book if I finished reading and gave it a low rating.

Was this review helpful?

Everyone wishes for a second chance at something, and for Sadie it’s for the past year of her life. After losing her job and her boyfriend, she desperately wants a do-over. And thanks to an encounter with a fortune teller, her wish comes true.

Getting a second chance at the last year of her life, Sadie is careful to do and say the opposite of everything the first time around. She’s determined to get the things she believes she wants. But sometimes no matter how hard you try to change your fate, you learn that what’s meant to be will always find a way.

I loved the messages in this book. First, no matter how hard we try, we can’t change fate. I’ve always been a firm believer of “everything happens for a reason” and this story really drives that home. Second, we should never suppress who we truly are. Sadie worked so hard to be the opposite of who she truly was and eventually she couldn’t even recognize herself anymore.

I adored Jacob. He was such a good-hearted man, and despite his inner struggles with admitting his feelings for Sadie, he continued to always be there for her in whatever way she needed.

There were a few points when it was hard to tell what was actually occurring and what she was recalling from the first time around. I also kept forgetting that the characters were in their 30’s. Their life circumstances, and even the way they acted at times, gave off younger vibes. I didn’t necessarily mind it, but I did struggle to relate to the characters at time.

Overall, this was a sweet yet meaningful story. I’m typically not one for supernatural plots, but this was one was well written in a way that left me struggling to put the book down.

I received a copy of this book through NetGalley. Thank you to the publisher and author for a chance to read and review this book!

Was this review helpful?

This is a cute book with a "Big" feel! I wasn't sure about the 'back in time' aspect at first, because it can be overdone, but this combined a light-heartedness with tackling some big issues. Sadie has a terrible year and wishes, on New Year's Eve, to go back in time and get a do-over...and who hasn't wished for that at one point or another? She has chance, and learns that the grass isn't always greener on the other side, and sometimes the best stuff is right in front of you. There are elements of sexual harassment, though nothing truly terrible or graphic, which is one of the bigger topics the book addresses.

Was this review helpful?

Looooved this book. Such a cute premise...the FMC Sadie has been dumped and has lost her job. On New Year's Eve she wishes for a do over - and the next morning she wakes up and is able to change her fate. But is this what she really wants?

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

A great book by this author. The main female character, Sadie has had an awful year, her boyfriend dumped her and she also lost her job. At a NYE party she wishes she could redo everything in her life. She wakes up the next morning being able to - but is getting everything back the best for her? I loved the FMC Sadie....she's strong, bad ass, and a loyal friend. Will she find her 'ideal' life?

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

The book was a solid three stars. The story centers around Sadie, a 30-something baker still trying to make it big in the upscale restaurant she works at. The story was simple and followed the usual rom-com pattern, but the plot kept me reading until the end, waiting for the happy ending.

My biggest wish/suggestion is the story dialed back the character's ages. In my opinion, the target audience for this book would be 17-26 years old. Yes, I understand that the fictional elements about going back in time are part of the story, but as a 30-something reader, I couldn't see myself relating the characters or their conversations and problems. After awhile the bakery-analogies were starting to wear me down. However, 19-year-old me would have gobbled this story up: it has all the right elements of cute and 'freedom' of being 'grownup' (these characters could easily still be in college) that works well with a younger audience.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet, tender, story and swoony romance! One of the best closed-door romances I’ve read and the MMC has resurrected #teamjacob for me. Set in NYC with restaurant/cafe backdrops, Sadie, a pastry chef, is presented with a chance to do over her Very Bad Year. I had my doubts about a “do-over” centered story but was pleasantly surprised with how well this element suited the story and wasn't used as a last-act cop-out. It gave reverse “13 going on 30” through the lens of a one-year time difference rather than 17.

Hands down the best part of the book was Jacob. He is a precious gem of a man to be protected at all costs. I cherished every scene he was included in and only wish there were more of them. A close second best part of this book is Sadie’s character arc. Even after a chance to re-do her Very Bad Year, she is still faced with awful parents, a horrific work environment, and a stifling relationship with a finance bro. Over the course of the year, you follow her very satisfying journey as she learns who she is and what really matters. Even though I was screaming at her to see the bigger picture, I was captivated by her growth and progression.

Also very enjoyable was the cast of characters that Sadie begins surrounding herself with. They were all very endearing and balanced the negativity of her parents, injecting joy, humor, hope, and positivity into the story.

A very satisfying read overall and the only thing I could have used a little more of would have been more of a resolution for her finance bro boyfriend and for the next-door neighbor, Paige. Seeing as how they were instrumental to Jacob and Sadie’s story I thought they deserved a little more redemption.

Keep in mind that if you have ever dealt with any form of sexism, workplace harassment, and/or sexual harassment this may be something to be wary of because it is a main feature in this book but in my opinion Melissa Wiesner does it justice.

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an arc!

Was this review helpful?

Truly enjoyed this book by Melissa Wiesner. The characters and chemistry were strong and I loved the foundation of friendship and the theme of perception not always being reality. We've all thought about do overs and I'm so happy it worked out for these characters.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks so much to Forever(Grand Central Publishing) and NetGalley.

Sadie is having a horrible year. Her boyfriend has dumped her and she lost her job. At a New Year's Eve party, she wishes she could redo everything. She wakes up the next day being able to. However, is what she wants back really right for her?

Sadie is a bad ass. I was a little sad reading about her trying to change herself to fit into certain norms because I cheered hard when she spoke up or spoke her mind. She is the hype woman you need. She is bold and fierce. She is loyal and loves her friends. Everyone else in the book is kind of a side character. I loved the pastries Sadie created and thought the book had a good message about letting people in who love you for who you are.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own. Thank you, Net Galley!

I loved the FMC, Sadie! She's a badass and I loved her story of finding herself and navigating life. I feel like in real life she and I would be great friends!

Also, can I say that I'd love to hang out at the coffee shop Sadie works at, what a fantastic place along with the most amazing human beings!

This is a lovely, sweet, heartwarming romance that shows you how one decision can impact several turns of events in your life. I'm sure we all feel like we'd love a second chance or do over in our lives, I know that I can, and in that, it's completely relatable.

I definitely recommend this book for a great, quick, read! Also, Wiesner is now on my radar to read more of her novels!

Was this review helpful?

Things aren't going so well for Sadie. In the span of a few months, she lost a boyfriend, her job, and her apartment. A chance meeting at a New Year's Eve party leads her to wish for a do-over of the past year. Of course, she is skeptical, but the next morning she wakes up, and the year had started over. Will this make a difference in the way Sadie's life plays out?
I so loved this book. Sadie is a smart, vibrant woman who speaks her mind. This book was about more than just Sadie. Women so often think we have to change who we are to fit some expected mold. I loved Sadie's journey in the book. She found herself and what made her happy. And I was so happy for her!
Please read this book! It's fun and engaging and so darn good!


I received an e-arc from NetGalley and Forever (Grand Central Publishing) in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

Sadie Thatcher is in a major slump after losing her job, apartment, and boyfriend - all in one year! When presented with the opportunity to make a wish from an untrustworthy psychic, Sadie asks for a redo of the past year. When she wakes up on New Years Day a year prior, she vows to make all of the necessary changes to get her life back on track. However, by playing it safe and making these changes, Sadie learns both the consequences of not being her authentic self, but also the amazing things that come from from seeing people and opportunities with fresh eyes.

The Second Chance Year was an absolutely delight to read! There was a great balance between the romantic storyline and Sadie's growth as a person, and the retelling of what happened the first go-round wasn't repetitive. Sadie was such a likable MC, and Jacob, the quirky coffeeshop crew, and other characters were so charming and genuine. Four wonderful stars!

Thank you to the publisher for providing me the ARC through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

OMG. OMG. OMG. I think I found one of my new favorite stories! I was so, so skeptical when I read the synopsis of this story, but boy did it blow my expectations out of the water!

Where do I even start? I loved the "original" Sadie, the spitfire who's unafraid to stand up for what's right and speak out against what's wrong. It was refreshing to read about such a strong, confident FMC. Regardless of where her life is at the beginning of the book, you can't help but admire her for the difficult decisions that led her to that point.

And then there's Jacob. Sweet, sweet Jacob. His quiet and consistent love for Sadie made me tear up on several occasions. My heart broke a little for him every single time that he second-guessed himself. But, when he decided to take a chance and put himself out there, I cheered him on. Because, why wouldn't I?

The CD from High School was Jacob's equivalent of the John Cusack boombox and it almost made me cry like a baby. It was the sweetest thing in the world and it made me want to give young Jacob a hug. And while you can wonder why he and Sadie couldn't have made it work much earlier in life, there's something to be said for timing. I'm pretty sure that that's what the author would like for us to take home. 😉

If I have anything negative to say about this story it would be Owen's involvement in the whole Jacob and Sadie dynamic. He did overstep on a few occasions. But, I can't say that I blame him because Jacob must be protected at all costs. 😍

I'm so glad that there was an age gap of only one year. Anything else is likely to give me creepy little bro vibes. Also, the whole supernatural element is not something that I ever really seek out voluntarily, mostly because authors tend to leave loopholes in the plot. But, in this case, it was tackled so well that it was quite believable.

This is absolutely one of the sweetest stories that I've read all year! But, it also tackles some incredibly important subjects such as sexual harassment in the workplace and emotional gaslighting. These subjects are handled so masterfully that they never take away from the actual plot, but only enhance it further.

4.5 ⭐️

NOTE: ARC received in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?