Forgotten Sisters takes a unique direction by incorporating horror, crime, and fairy tales together. The story follows sisters Anna and Jennie in their historic bungalow along the Chicago River. After their parents are killed in a tragic accident, the sisters are left alone, tethered together by their haunted past. Eldest sister Jennie is now a troubled recluse, spending days in her bedroom, only leaving the house for nightly walks. While Anna is reserved to care for her sister and the house. In her loneliness, Anna works on a podcast and recounts the ghostly tales of Chicago. At the same time, a series of disappearances casts unease over the town, raising questions about the mysteries of the river.

At the start of the book, I was inclined to give a rating of 4 or 5 because of the intriguing premise. However, as I reached the end I began to shift towards a 3. The story presents an abundance of new ideas and leaves room for the reader to uncover the mysteries, but I also found myself confused by the multitude of events happening. Is it a story about a haunted house? Or is it a story about a vengeful serial killer? The storylines eventually converge, but the journey to that point left me somewhat disoriented. Admittedly, I was most drawn to the police procedural aspect of the story and I was hoping for more of a focus on the investigation itself. I appreciate that the story challenged my expectations and offered a blend of intertwining themes, but ultimately I wasn't the right audience for this book.

Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for the e-ARC.

One of the best books I’ve read all year. No seriously. I mean that. I loved this book. This may be my new fav author. Thank you.

Forgotten Sisters is a very different sort of book, kind of a horror novel and a fairy tale and a police procedural and a fever dream all rolled up into one.

Chicago is a city near and dear to my heart and Ravenswood is a great neighborhood, so the setting is fantastic. I'd never heard the stories of the SS Eastland or the Union Stockyards before, so I really enjoyed learning more about the city's dark history through Anna's podcast.

The chapters involving the two police detectives, Kowalski and Rodriguez, were also entertaining and I wish there had been more of them. They aren't really the main focus of the story, so you only glimpse bits and pieces of their investigation … which is too bad, because I would happily read a book that focused entirely on the two of them.

Oh, and Clover and Thistle were the best part of the book, because … dogs! And, in case you were wondering, they do survive.

The rest of the book, which revolves around sisters Anna and Jennie (and later, Anna's boyfriend Peter), is just … weird. None of them talk like normal people – the dialogue is stilted and they all speak as if they're giving some sort of modern day Shakespearean soliloquy, Jennie in particular. The romance between Anna and Peter doesn't seem at all authentic, perhaps because the book skips over most of the beginning of their relationship, but also because you never learn much about Peter other than that Anna's obsessed with him. And, really, other than at the very end, nothing really happens plotwise. The police investigate a bit, Jennie waxes poetic a whole bunch, the house throws temper tantrums when it doesn't get its way, and that's about it.

The ending did surprise me, though. I'd already guessed who the killer was, but I hadn't guessed *who* the killer was (which I realize makes no sense, but I'm trying to avoid spoilers). The ending actually would have been pretty good if it hadn't been bogged down by all the weirdness that permeates this book, but the twist gets kind of watered down by all of the … *gesticulates wildly* … rest of it.

Overall, this book had its interesting moments but it just wasn't really my thing. If you like your books to read like a Shakespearean fever dream, you'll probably love this one, but it was just kind of “meh” for me. 2.75 stars, rounded up.

Many thanks to Netgalley and Thomas & Mercer for providing me with an advance copy of this book to review.