As someone who loved the first three Before the Coffee Gets Cold books, I jumped at the opportunity to read Before We Say Goodbye early. And to no one’s surprise, I cried just as much as I did while reading the first three books, if not more.

The Before the Coffee Gets Cold series takes place in a magical, time-traveling cafe in Tokyo, called Café Funiculi Funicula. While it appears to be an ordinary cafe, one seat is occupied by a ghost at all times — except for when she gets up to use the bathroom once a day. While she’s gone, visitors have the chance to travel in time to visit someone who has been to that very cafe before — with the caveat that they return before their coffee gets cold. If they return too late, then they’ll be cursed to be the next cafe ghost.

There are four short stories in Before We Say Goodbye. The first, titled “The Husband with Something Important Left To Say” follows a husband who is too caught up with work to spend time with his loved ones, until it’s too late. The second, “The Woman Who Couldn’t Bid Her Dog Farewell” is about a woman who feels immensely guilty for her dog passing away while she was asleep, and tries to travel back to apologize. The third story, “The Woman Who Couldn’t Answer a Proposal” is centered around a woman unable to commit to a proposal, only to realize later that she was too late. And lastly, “The Daughter Who Drove Her Father Away” is loosely based off of a real story.

To no one’s surprise, “The Woman Who Couldn’t Bid Her Dog Farewell” was the one that got to me the hardest — I was sobbing so hard that my dog woke up from his sleep and tried to comfort me. While most of the stories in the Before the Coffee Gets Cold series revolve around grief and loss, this was the first one where a pet was involved, and also was the one that hit me the hardest.

In all honesty, I’m pretty sure that I missed out on some minor links between all four books, just because it’s been so long since I’ve read the first three, but I don’t think that it detracted from my enjoyment of the book at all. If anything, I think I was able to enjoy Before We Say Goodbye even more, because I didn’t think the other stories were repetitive — whereas if I had read all four books back to back, I think the themes around grief and regret, and the stories could’ve gotten to be a little repetitive.

Overall, if you’re looking for a good cry, if you’d like to read more translated works, or if you just want to read some short stories, I couldn’t recommend Before We Say Goodbye more highly — just make sure you have some tissues on you!

"Before We Say Goodbye" by Toshikazu Kawaguchi presents a unique and intriguing concept that explores themes of time, memory, and the human connection. While the book has its moments of brilliance, it ultimately falls short of the high expectations set by its premise, warranting a rating of 3.5/5 stars.

Kawaguchi's storytelling style is undeniably imaginative, and the central idea of a cafe where patrons can revisit the past and make amends with their memories is a fascinating one. The book's structure, with multiple interconnected narratives, adds depth to the story and keeps readers engaged.

The characters in "Before We Say Goodbye" are well-drawn, each with their own emotional baggage and regrets to confront. The author's exploration of their journeys to reconcile with their pasts is both poignant and thought-provoking. However, there were instances where the characters felt underdeveloped, leaving some of their stories feeling less impactful.

While the concept is captivating, the pacing of the novel is inconsistent. At times, the narrative flows smoothly, drawing readers into the emotional dilemmas of the characters. However, there are moments where the plot seems to meander, leading to a lack of tension and urgency that should accompany such a unique premise.

The book's dialogue is reflective and contemplative, which fits the overall tone of the story. It delves into deep philosophical and existential questions, which may resonate with readers seeking a more introspective reading experience. However, this introspection may not appeal to those looking for a faster-paced or more plot-driven narrative.

The resolution of the central mystery surrounding the cafe and its enigmatic owner is handled satisfactorily, providing closure to the story's overarching questions. However, it is the emotional resolutions of the characters that take precedence, and these moments are where the novel truly shines.

In conclusion, "Before We Say Goodbye" by Toshikazu Kawaguchi is a novel with a compelling and imaginative premise, but it doesn't fully capitalize on its potential. While it offers moments of introspection and emotional depth, it struggles with pacing and character development. Fans of philosophical and contemplative fiction may find it to be a worthwhile read, but those seeking a more tightly plotted narrative may be left wanting. Overall, it's a commendable effort, but it falls short of achieving greatness, earning a rating of 3.5/5 stars.

I've absolutely loved following the characters that work in the cafe throughout the series. It is always comforting coming back to this cafe and these characters. I also enjoy the new ones that we meet and what we learn about them. Even though the stories deal with grief and regret, I appreciate that things are resolved in a heartwarming way by the end of it. I will keep coming back to this book and this series whenever I need a comfort read.

I’ve said before that grief can sometimes feel repetitive and I liked these books because while a little repetitive, they really help with that feeling of being stuck in a grief-filled rut. However, I do feel like this book felt pretty generic in the grand scheme of the series. There was only one story, the last one about the daughter, that really got me. And even though there was a story about someone losing their pet, it just didn’t hit as hard as I thought it would.

With that being said however, I do really like Kawaguchi’s writing style. It’s simple and a little understated, in the style of typical Japanese literature. Because of its unassuming style, it’s easy to be caught off guard by the heavy emotional impact. I didn’t even realize I was crying until I finished the last story in this book.

I think my issue with this book too, and why I didn’t like it as much, is the fact that some of these characters were a little unlikable. It was hard to feel sympathetic when some of these characters treated their loved ones really terribly. But I also see the point in making them unlikable - that everyone deserves a chance at redemption, and to be happy, so long as they change their ways.

i went into this book thinking i would really enjoy it. i like that the book is separated into four parts. however, i had a hard time remembering what character is who because of how many there were. i also found that i didn’t really care for the characters. after completing this book, i came to the conclusion that i won’t be reading another book from this author. thank you to NetGallery and the publishers for sending me an ARC of this book.

I’ve read this author’s entire series with the time traveling cafe, and will continue to read them, hoping they come out with more! These books are about getting a chance to relive a situation in order to say the thing one should have said the first time. The author takes situations we’ve all been in and shows us how we can take charge of those situations and say the right thing so we won’t need a time traveling cafe to live our best lives. These stories bring tears and laughs, and all the feels we experience in life, to life right here in this little series of books. There is always something to learn about life, and that’s why I love this series. Each story touches a whole new part of life and you just can’t wait to get to the next part.

Love this series this is another wonderful story a cozy lovely story.I have recommended these books they are a charming tale.#netgalley #harlequinbooks.

What a cozy read, just like a cup of coffee! Kawaguchi has a brilliant concept of if you could visit someone in the past, knowing it would change nothing, what would you do? Another brilliant installment to the series that explores closure, grief, and overcoming regret. The fact that each story feels pretty quick and explores their journey into the past similar to how fast a cup of coffee cools reinforces how precious time with our loved ones is. At the same time, I still managed to get choked up twice in this book. Kawaguchi exploring grief with pets and the Japan earthquake and tsunami of 2011 was a very grounded and welcome expansion to the series. I'm excited to see what Kawaguchi has in store next for readers. Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing for the galley in return for an honest review.

I love these books. There is just something so refreshing about them being so cozy. They are stories not just grabs at attention.

I'm always excited when another installment of the Before the Coffee Gets Cold is released. This one follows our familiar cafe but it definitely focuses more on the individuals that come in rather than on the staff and their various connections with each other and the people who visit the cafe. Although the stories were interesting, the only criticism I have for this volume was the repetitive nature of the storytelling. We're told in every single story how the time travel works and what the risks are as well as the same descriptions of the staff and ghost. Each story kind of had a predictable ending as well. Not my favorite volume in the series, but I of course will continue reading the series because they are such comfort reads at this point.

I drink coffee all the time and recently learned about the concept of this series. It asks the question who would you visit if you could go back in time but only have enough of it until the coffee gets cold... Love the idea surrounding it but couldn't totally get immersed in the short stories. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.

3.5/5

To put it succinctly, my experience with this book was genuinely enjoyable, with each storyline proving to be a captivating journey in its own right. The brevity of the book, a deliberate choice by the author, made it a seamlessly digestible read—a factor I deem significant, particularly given the weightier themes tackled within.

3.5 out of 4 stars.

This is my first book by Toshikazu Kawaguchi, so I went in with an open mind. I was excited to read the book as the premise is really interesting and I have been meaning to read “Before the Coffee Gets Cold.” I really enjoy the message the series has that time is finite, to make the most of every opportunity with the people in your life, and learning to live with your regret. There were some very beautiful aspects of seeing your regret in a new light, obtaining closure, and growing as a person in uncomfortable situations.

At the same time, I wish there was more to the story. Although I appreciate the multiple short stories, I wish there was more included. For example, I would have liked to have the story told from alternating perspectives of the manager, waitress, and customers.

I also wish there was even a slightly longer time period before the coffee cools. I understand the meaning of a brief period to prevent the novelty from wearing off on the characters. Also, I feel the brief period highlights the flaws in our humanity where, while characters know this is still the last moment of time with someone who meant something to them, they still cannot make the most of the moment. Even so, I wish the book gave the readers a bit more of a chance to have a more meaningful conversation, even if by a few more minutes.

At one point the author references the earthquake and tsunamis that occurred in Japan in 2011. The reference to this real life tragedy brings deeper meaning to the storyline and draws the audience back to the eerie reality of life.

In sum, I enjoyed the book and found each storyline interesting. I appreciated how brief the book was as it made it an easy and accessible read which I think is important in regards to the heavier subject matter. At the same time, I think there should be more included to the storyline to build upon the points the author makes about life, love, and time.

This is my 1st of the series. In hindsight maybe I should have read the others first....having said that what a beautiful read. The book's message is such a thought provoking takeaway.

This was my first time reading one of Toshikazu Kawaguchi’s books and it did not disappoint. I’ve heard only good things about the series and that you will be crying by the end, and the rumors were true. I am not an annotator, but I found myself often highlighting just beautifully articulated sentences. Kawaguchi is able to tell several different, heart wrenching stories within one book. Each story had such different characters and themes. I expected the book to be good but it truly exceeded my expectations. It was an easy read and is one of those books you can finish in a night. Would recommend 1000 times over.

4 stars
Another amazing installation to this series. It will make you feel all of the feelings. It is pretty important to read the previous books first though. It’s like visiting an old friend. I love this series.

Didn't realize this couldn't standalone—quite hard to follow. It might be the translation, but I also struggled with the rhythm of the writing.

This is the 4th book in this short, sentimental, and moving series-and I enjoyed reading all 4! I wonder if there will be a 5th book…

Notable lines:

“There are many crossroads in life. All regrets stem from what happened at one moment we never imagined would happen to us. When our own action brings about an unexpected result, how can we not experience huge regret? After all, do we ever get another shot?”

Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ARC of this book for an honest review!

The fourth book in the before the coffee gets cold series. The customers get back with old flames, make amends with estranged family....etc. It's emotional, touching, poignant and sweet. A little magical and a lot of great story-telling. One of the best series!

Thanks to the publisher for the arc.

Each story goes straight to the heart and warms it with a shiny blanket. I wish the writer would publish at least one a month <3