Such a good book! This is a murder mystery set in a time before technology, which I really enjoy. I had figured out who the culprits were prior to the end of the book, but it did not diminish my enjoyment of it. The twists and turns and reveals were done well, leaving me quite excited for the future books in this series.

It has been a long time since I read a fantasy that brought so many aspects that kept my attention. This was a wonderful book with a gripping plot.

A fun romp and an interesting new world. Din and Ana reminded me of Berenice and Orso from Foundryside, both of whom I loved. The mystery was intriguing but the most interesting part to me is the Leviathans, I really look forward to learning more about them in future books. Achillean romance (g-rated) and only a tiiiiny part of the plot, though I'm sure we will see that develop as the book goes on. Just a short, fun, cute, funny, at times gorey magical mystery.

I have no idea what I was thinking when I requested this book - but I am so glad that I did. Monsters, and strange people operating under a weird government structure, a wet season and so many other things that were totally outside my sphere of comprehension, but when you boil it all down it is a murder mystery, told in the most ingenious and absorbing way.

So, if you are looking for an Agatha Christie, Hercules Poirot, Gregg Hurwitz, Anthony Tata, Nora Roberts, Daniel Silva, type of murder mystery, this is not going to be it. But if you are willing to put aside most of what you know and believe and stretch to unknown lands inhabited by transformed creatures, this is going to be a treat of immeasurable proportions.

The writing is great. The dialog contains substance and humor This was so clever it borders, no, it is brilliant. A million thanks to Del Rey and NetGalley for a copy.

I really enjoyed this fantasy murder mystery combo - the world building kept me engaged and the murder mystery was well-paced. I was able to actually predict the ending, but the journey to get there was full of the unexpected. I would definitely recommend this as an entry point to the fantasy genre.

Absolutely loved the humor, mystery, action, and... flippance? I haven't read this author before, but now I'm feverishly looking at what books my local library has. I can't wait for the second one.

Brilliant tale of a murder during an empire fantasy time period.
There is the detective with all of her eccentricities and her sidekick fresh out of training. Very much like a good Sherlock team, they find the clues that get the answers they need by various means including her sidekicks ability to remember everything and her use of a blindfold and refusal to leave her housing..
Fun read.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for allowing me this ARC.

The Tainted Cup was a really fun read and combined some of my favorite genres into a twisty story that kept me on the edge of my seat. I really enjoyed that is was like Sherlock Holmes but fantasy. The characters were interesting, the world building was immersive and the plot of the story kept me completely intrigued.

Bennett is a wonderful storyteller and I hope we get more adventures in this world!

Definitely check this one out.

A high imperial officer seemingly dead of contagion elicits an investigation from brilliant and eccentric master investigator Ana Dolabra. With the help of her new assistant Dinias Kol and his magically altered brain, she sets off to discover what truly happened to the officer and ends up stumbling upon a potential plot to take down the entire Empire.

Sherlock Holmes meets Benoit Blanc, but make it fantasy! Does it get any better than that? Well, it does if the world-building draws you into a magical new world with minimal disconnect and that is exactly what Bennett does with this story. It hits heavy in the beginning while establishing the rules of the world, so it took me a little bit to get into, but once the world is established, it was game on, rushing as fast as possible to get to the end because the story was so twisty, confusing (in the best way!), and compelling.

One of the best parts of characters like Sherlock Holmes and Benoit Blanc is that their minds are absolutely extraordinary, allowing them to process things in a way that a regular person does not. This is also true of Ana Dolabra and makes her quite an interesting character to follow. But this story centers more around her assistant, Dinias Kol, who has been magically altered to have a photographic memory—literally. He has perfect recall, though we find later in the story that there is one exception to this rule and it haunts him and makes him worry that Ana will find out and kick him to the curb. These little pieces that Bennett sprinkles upon the characters makes them feel more grounded even while visiting them in a fantasy world.

With expert ease, Bennett weaves together a story that keeps you guessing throughout. Each twist and turn leads the reader deeper into a world that is hard to untangle, but still manages to be compelling and intriguing. The plot of this story finds its resolution by the end, but also leaves us wanting more and ready to jump on the next book in the series upon its release.

Disclaimer: I received an advanced copy of this book from the publisher for free and have voluntarily written this review.

Review copy (eARC) provided via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review (which I apologize for providing late).

I was eager to read this based on highly Petrik Leo speaks of this author. And while I get why this book/author works for some, it just didn't click for me. It's a murder-mystery style adventure.

3.5 out of 5 stars, rounded up.

The Tainted Cup is a highly entertaining combination of historical fantasy and murder mystery, with wonderful central characters. The book starts with a brutal, strange death of a high-ranking individual, seemingly speared by a tree in his own home.

Enter the eccentric Ana Dolabra, a Sherlock-esque, reclusive investigator. Her newly employed assistant, Dinios Kol, is thrown headfirst into this strange case, using his powers as an engraver; a person who can remember everything they hear and experience.

Ana and Din begin to build a bond, and as a single death reveals many other wrongdoings, the reader is dragged into a weird society, with many other wonderful characters. Not to mention the literal leviathan that may break the city walls and destroy everything at any time.

I must admit, I was pretty hesitant to read The Tainted Cup, as I’m not a huge fan of epic fantasy. But I was so pleased to find that this book is incredibly character focused, and all the world building is done through natural, well-written dialogue.

A great example of Bennett’s character focus comes towards the end of the book. There is an opportunity for the author to create a huge, epic scene to close the book with a literal bang. Instead, he creates a gorgeous, intimate scene between Din and Ana, which I highly appreciated, and was one of the most memorable moments.

I opted for the audiobook reading, and Andrew Fallaize delivers a flawless performance. He effortlessly creates the huge cast of characters; he took an already impressive book to a whole other level.

I’m so glad this is part of a planned series, as I was genuinely bereft when the book was over. I would recommend this book to anyone looking for a “gateway drug” to fantasy.

A great fantasy mystery. Set in an empire where great sea walls are all that separate civilization from annihilation at the hands (claws, fins, etc.) of the titans beyond, Dinios Kol is assigned to assist investigator Ana Dolabra in looking in to some strange and mysterious deaths…which may put the very existence of the empire in peril. Din is an engraver, one who has been magically augmented to have a perfect memory, and Ana is an eccentric if brilliant detective who wears a blindfold. This was my first book by Bennet and it was compelling, if sometimes confusing. I loved the world building and character development (Ana is amazing), although I sometimes felt a bit lost in the names and norms of the world. Overall I’m looking forward to the sequel as well as trying other books from this author.

I am going to be honest. I am ruined. Who let me go this long without having started any Robert Jackson Bennett books? Who let me start with a new series? How am I to keep going knowing that mystery is afoot and I want to be back in this world stat?

“So instead of committing robbery, I made tea.”

A strange murder has occurred and Ana is called in to investigate. Ana is known not only for her brilliance but also her quirks and with her is her new assistant Din, an engraver with his own secrets. Din's job is quite literally to observe and report, as Ana insists on wearing a blindfold and avoids leaving her home. As an engraver, Din has been magically altered to possess perfect recall of the things he observes, suiting Ana's purposes perfectly. The two utilize their unique skills to work toward uncovering a scheme that could threaten the entire empire.

I really enjoyed this one. It was a tad difficult for me to get into in the beginning, but once I was in it, I began to appreciate it's uniqueness and became very curious to see how it all played out. This book mixed a murder mystery with a fantasy world with a splash of Sherlock Holmes level detective work. Bennett has always had a knack for building a unique and fascinating world to be immersed in and I found he did the same here. I am surprisingly satisfied with this novel and excited for the next one.

3.5 stars rounded up. It took me a little bit to understand the world of Daretana, so it was a slow start. The different roles and the fear of the sea creatures was also a little confusing.- they somehow destroyed everything and also their blood provided the magic for human modifications. I enjoyed Ana and Din. And these two characters helped me stay with the story as the mystery unfolded.

Thank you to NetGalley and Del Ray for an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

Beautifully written engaging fantasy mystery. Once I started it I has a hard time putting it down. The world building was immense. Definitely putting on my recommendation shelf

I’m in love y’all! This is my first book by my this author (how?!) and, bang the gavel, I’m sold. A fantasy mystery with laugh out loud moments, incredible world building, and a bit of a Sherlock and Watson vibe, this was a lot of fun to read. It’s quite complex and I’m definitely going to reread it before the next installment comes out. It’s really cool that this is the first in series but stands alone; that’s so rare! This is one of my best reads for 2024

Before reading this book, I was about to give up on murder mysteries. I haven't enjoyed the last few I read and thought that I just didn't like the genre any more. I'm so glad I gave it one more try! My love for the murder mystery is now revived with The Tainted Cup.

Besides the clever clues and the well-crafted mystery, what I liked was
* The fantasy setting with giant walls, killer plants, and dangerous leviathans
* The unique characters with all their abilities and grafts
* The neurodivergent main characters of Ana and Din
* The adorable romance sub-plot. This is not a romance book. This was a very small but sweet part of the book.

If you like your murder mysteries with a hefty dose of fun and fantasy, this is the book for you.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Ballantine for a digital ARC of the book in return for my honest opinion.

Middle ground for me on this book. I LOVED so many things. A murder mystery fantasy ? Sherlock vibes? 100% here for that. The world building was great and so thoroughly fleshed out. But there was just something missing to me. I cannot put my finger on it but I didn’t connect with the characters. It was a good book! Just not a 5 star for me.

I'm sorry to say this is a DNF at 42%. I held on as long as I could, but I just didn't like this. It shouldn't take more than 40% to get into a world or whatever's going on in the plot, so I'm bailing. This could be a me problem because most reviews are 4 or 5 stars, but that's just not the experience I'm having.

The first 15% was great. I loved the setup of the mystery, the dynamic between Din and Ana (I agree it's reminiscent of Sherlock and Watson's dynamic), and the things that were revealed about the world. However, after that point, it starts to go at a slower-than-snail pace and it feels like nothing is happening at all. The dynamic between the characters and the worldbuilding just wasn't good enough to hold my interest and I found myself counting the minutes for the chapters to end.

I wanted to love this because I've heard such good things and I was excited to get to it, but I could barely get to 42%.