Absolutely loved this book!

The authors writing style is amazing!

I look forward to reading more from them!

Making Her Theirs by Lily Manning - The story starts off with the reader meeting Georgia. After working hard at a Dallas Texas accounting firm, she finally received the promotion she has been working towards. This promotion lands her in Edinburgh, Scotland for a short stay to work on a project. After a long flight, lost luggage, and the discovery that her new furnished apartment is indeed anything but furnished, a drink at the pub downstairs from her is overdue. We are then introduced to Finn, Knox and Lachlan. From the authors description of these men, they will leave your mouth watering. When Georgia lays eyes on Knox and Finn, she knows it is over for her and she is not mad about it. Later that night she meets Lachlan when she is locked out of her apartment. Soon after she is surprised to find out not only do all three own the bar and rental, but they are also brothers. Each brother having their own personality makes you wonder if one is going to favor the other, but then you realize this is a why choose.

The Spice in this book is 4.5 out of 5. The author’s writing is very smooth, which makes this a fast read. Georgia lives out every girl's fantasy of going overseas and meeting mister tall, dark, and handsome, technically she meets 3. You get to watch the characters grow and it keeps you entertained throughout the story. And from what I can tell this may become a series. I cannot wait to read more from this author. If you like spicy books I would 100% recommend this book.

This novella length story is pure taboo smut with a smattering of plot. A reverse harem with plenty of spicy content to keep you occupied if that's what you're after.

I did enjoy this book to an extent, but I also prefer a tad more plot to my stories.

Check your trigger/content warnings and have fun with this short and incredibly spicy read.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5

Georgia arrives in Scotland and meet three brothers who she has an immediate connection with. Knox, Finn, and Lachlan. Each one fulfills a different need. What will happen when she has to go back home though?

This was a super quick and easy read and I was here for the spice! I really enjoyed it and you should definitely read this if you are looking for a why choose, reverse harem, that’s heavy on the spice!


📘: Making Her Theirs by Lily Manning
🗓️: August 23, 2023

Thank you to NetGalley, Lily Manning, and Innes Field LLC for this ARC!

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

*Reviewed on NetGalley and Goodreads.

Loved it! The characters are wonderful. It's sexy as hell. Steamy and full of heart. I was completely invested and hooked. And I want more! I'm excited for the next book and the characters it will feature.

This book was so good! It is steamy and romantic, and the ending was beautiful! I love why choose books, and I get so frustrated when the author chooses to end the book with the FMC picking one of them to spend her life with instead of continuing with all of them. Doesn't that negate the premise of "why choose"? This one wrapped everything up very nicely. My only question, is everyone comes to the wedding, and both of her parents and her brother are totally on board with her marrying 3 brothers and give a full go ahead with no questions? That was a little funny to me, but nothing book ruining. I also love the different connections she has with the brothers, but it could be a little repetitive in places, like: she laughed with one, felt protected by one, and felt safe and seen by the last one. I get how the relationships are by now, I'm sure it isn't going to change, lol but I didn't mind it.

I thought this was going to be a fun, quick read, but it was definitely not for me...
I love reverse harems, but this just did not tickle my fancy.

I received this Arc from Netgalley. Thank you for the chance to read this book early. My review is honest and 100% my own thoughts about the book.

I’m going to day this first. This was a spicy and “Hot & Bothered” type of book. Now some people don’t like RHs or Why Chooses, but if you do would enjoy this. I enjoyed reading this so much and will be suggesting it my other Why Choose reading friends. Let’s. Just say it’s a good thing that I have a poker face while reading any book. Especially out in public. I like that the Author’s about me states that this is their first try at RH or Why Choose. They originally started off as a Contemporary romance author. I think this was an amazing move. Because this was an amazing book. I had such a hard time putting it down. So thank you for the lovely friend that suggested to you to write a Why Choose.

This story is about Georgina, who goes to Scotland to try to climb the employment ladder. She goes to a pub and meets Knox and Finn. Later she meets Lachlan. These three men are brothers and have had a tough past. This makes it hard for them to except people into their circle. Now I know that the brothers Sharing Georgina could be controversial in the “real world” but as a fictional work it works well for the story. I loved that Georgina is the answer to these three brothers to heal their damaged souls.

I will say I wasn’t expecting that there was a bonus story about the business partner and his two partners finding their Angel. I would love to read more about their adventures and hope that the author continues with their story.

I love that the author shows the growth of the characters and that these men will do anything to keep that is theirs close. This is including doing what ever it takes to make their partners happy. I would love to read more from this author. I am excited to see what they come up with next.

Thank you Netgalley & Innes Field LLC for the ARC!

If you enjoy RH, this is a good book for you.

Georgia goes to Scotland for work for a few days and she meets three brothers. Needless to say the attraction is instant. As she gets to know the brothers she understands heach one of them fulfills particular needs she missed her entire life

The story is a quick read, the plot is very light, but every once in a while it's good to delve into pure smut and this one delivers... a lot.

Overall rating
4⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ out of 5

One of the spiciest books I’ve read and I absolutely loved it! It was a little too fast paced (relationship wise) for me and that’s the only reason it’s getting a 4 instead of a 5. I’m personally more of a slow burn reader but don’t let that discourage you from reading this book!

Spicy rating
5🌶️ out of 5

HOLY MOLY! The spice in this book is off the charts! The chemistry with all three brothers 🥵 if you love ✨spicy✨ books, you’ll absolutely love this one! Almost every single chapter had a spicy scene and we are here for it!


All opinions shared of are an expression of my own thoughts.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book.

Okay I'll give it to you straight, this is plain ass smut. No plot. So there is not much to review here, lol.
But if you are in the mood for that, definitely check this one out!

Bonus 1: It's a super quick read.
Bonus 2: The cover is so pretty.

Thanks NetGalley for this ARC, wow, just wow! Great book! This is my first RH book and it was very interesting!

Reverse harem erotic. This book is heavy on the smut which is good if you like this type of Genre. It’s fast paced love. 3 Scottish brothers and 1 lady who’s moved over.

The writing isn’t my preferred style but i believe others would enjoy it.

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for allowing me to Arc read this book

I’ve never read anything from this author, but I have read several series with this type of storyline. I’m still on the fence about this book. It wasn’t the greatest, but it also wasn’t the worst I’ve ever read. I would have liked more character development and story building. The book seemed a bit short in a novella type of way: slightly rushed and the plot seemed to have moved extremely fast. Despite that, the spicy level was an awesome. I’d say 4 out of 5. I was surprised at the added level of spiciness that you don’t normally read in this type of genres, but it was truly appreciated.

She hit the ground running from the very beginning. The characters met each other by the 2nd and 3rd chapters and then from there, things very fast. The characters met, got hot & heavy, and got their feelings involved very fast. I figuratively got whiplash from how fast things went. I wish there could have been a bit more getting to know each other while getting some problems resolved before the happily ever after. Therefore, I would say that this book is a solid 3 out of 5 with me having no interest in reading the other books in the series.

Lily Manning's "Making Her Theirs" is a fast-paced, steamy romance novel that, while delivering a passionate narrative, lacks essential character development. The plot suffers from multiple holes, resulting in an unrealistic storyline that could have been more thoughtfully developed. The book has the potential for a compelling story but falls short of fully realizing it. It's a one-time read for those seeking a brief, intense romance fix. While it offers a quick and heated narrative, it may not satisfy readers in search of a more comprehensive and well-rounded story.

Prepare to be seduced by three Scottish brothers in this new steamy novel. Through a captivating narrative that intricately weaves the perspectives of three men and one angel of a woman, this daring novel offers an exploration of desire, intimacy, and complexities of human connection. In this Dark why choose romance we follow Georgia, Lachlan, Knox, and Finn through their ten-day romance. The men are all Scottish and Georgia is from the great state of Texas. To top it off, each character affectionately gives her a special nickname, adding a playful layer of charm and intimacy to the story. Without a doubt, this provocative and passionate tale is a must-read.

I enjoyed reading this. I loved the characters and their personalities. I wasn’t sure how I would like this from the spicy scenes so soon in the beginning but I was so surprised to fall in love with the brothers.

I received this book from NetGalley and the publishers to read and review. All statements above are my true
opinions after fully reading this book. This was a quick & enjoyable read!

Thank you NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for granting me access to this book.

This is a quick and fun read for me. A lot of spice (as early as chapter 3) and an easy plot.

We have our FMC who is traveling for her work for 10 days met 3 brothers with varying personalities and damage past. They all click together.

This is a fast paced book and I enjoy reading it.

Georgia is ready to start the next chapter of her life, but will three mouth-watering brothers change her plans?

REVIEW: Making Her Theirs is a reverse harem quick read that dives right into spiciness. The book was mostly what I expected. I have to admit, the first chapter made me feel like the female protagonist was very immature and at times, annoying. This gets hand waved later in that she’s quirky and nerdy, but it didn’t land for me. The ending included a trope that I don’t particularly care for and it felt a little too easy to throw in there. 3 stars from me.